Subject: SR-OCC-2024-001
From: Jesse Marb
Affiliation:

Feb. 28, 2024

In a hypothetical scenario mirroring the 2008 financial crisis, imagine a future where a regulatory body has the power to decide which financial institutions receive emergency support and which do not. During the crisis of 2008, certain banks and financial entities were bailed out by government funds to prevent a complete economic collapse, sparked by a massive downturn in the housing market and risky investment practices. 


Fast forward to a scenario where the financial system faces a similar threat. A program designed to provide loans to struggling financial entities is about to end, and there's a proposal on the table from a regulatory body (OCC) that suggests changing the rules to make it easier for some institutions to survive the impending financial drought. 


The OCC's proposal involves adjusting the financial requirements, effectively allowing some institutions to receive a critical lifeline through reduced regulatory demands. This move could dictate which entities can navigate through the financial turmoil and which might falter without support. This selective assistance raises concerns about fairness and transparency in the financial system, echoing the debates from 2008 over which institutions deserved to be saved. 


This imagined scenario serves to highlight the complexities and potential ethical dilemmas of regulatory decisions in financial crises. The idea of a regulatory body wielding the power to pick winners and losers in the financial sector brings forward questions about accountability, the criteria used for such decisions, and the impact on the broader economy and public trust in financial systems. 


The key lesson here parallels concerns from the past: the importance of ensuring that decisions made during financial emergencies are transparent, equitable, and based on clear criteria to maintain faith in the financial system and avoid perceptions of favoritism or a "rigged" market. 


Best regards 
Jesse 


Household investor