Subject: File No. S7-08-09
From: William C Beck
Affiliation: Long-time Investor

May 6, 2009

If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck maybe it's a duck.

PLEASE REINSTATE THE UPTICK RULE. IT WORKED.

For goodness sakes, we had no problems with "pig-piles" before the UPTICK rule was eliminated. Without the rule inplace, the speculators drove weak stocks down WAY BELOW THEIR TRUE VALUE and caused $ billions in losses for REAL INVESTORS.

The speculators can give you a million reasons not to reinstate the rule, but they are the greedy ones who caused the "meltdown" in the first place.

Eliminate all short and ultra-short ETFs.