Subject: S7-04-23: Webform Comments from John MacNamara
From: John MacNamara
Affiliation: Specialist

Oct. 30, 2023

Addressing Securities and Exchange Commission,

I am writing to provide my comments on the proposed rule
"Safeguarding Advisory Client Assets." While I appreciate
the SEC's efforts to enhance investor protections and address
gaps in the custody rule, I have concerns regarding the potential
overreach of the regulatory authority. It is important to ensure that
the SEC's jurisdiction does not encroach on areas that should be
regulated by other agencies.

One area of concern is the regulation of digital assets or crypto.
Digital assets, such as cryptocurrency, have emerged as transformative
technologies in the financial industry. However, the regulatory
uncertainties surrounding these assets pose significant challenges. It
is crucial for the SEC to consider the unique characteristics of
digital assets and strike an appropriate balance between investor
protection and innovation.

Furthermore, I value my privacy and freedom to make independent
decisions about my investments. While the proposed rule seeks to
enhance oversight and safeguard client assets, there must also be a
recognition of the importance of individual autonomy and privacy. It
is essential to ensure that regulations do not overly burden investors
or inhibit their ability to make informed financial decisions.

In conclusion, I urge the SEC to carefully consider the potential
overreach of regulatory authority and the unique challenges posed by
digital assets. Additionally, I emphasize the importance of preserving
investors' privacy and autonomy. These concerns should be
appropriately addressed in the final rule to ensure a balanced
regulatory framework.

Thank you for considering my comments.

Sincerely,

John MacNamara