Subject: SR 33-11176
From: Peter Neal
Affiliation:

Jun. 13, 2023

Summary: 


Banning cryptocurrencies in the United States would have several detrimental effects. It would hinder economic growth and innovation, jeopardize the country's technological leadership, impede financial inclusion efforts, stifle entrepreneurship, and undermine global competitiveness. Additionally, banning crypto could lead to a loss of tax revenues, create national security risks, and push transactions into unregulated black markets. Instead, a balanced approach that combines regulation and innovation can address concerns while harnessing the potential benefits of cryptocurrencies. 


1. Economic Impact: Cryptocurrencies have emerged as a significant driver of economic growth and innovation. By banning crypto, the United States would miss out on a tremendous opportunity to foster a thriving digital economy. Numerous industries, such as finance, technology, and entrepreneurship, have benefited from the growth of cryptocurrencies, creating jobs and attracting investments. 


2. Technological Leadership: Embracing cryptocurrencies allows the United States to maintain its position as a global technology leader. Blockchain technology, which underlies cryptocurrencies, has the potential to revolutionize various sectors, including finance, supply chain management, healthcare, and voting systems. By banning crypto, the U.S. risks losing its competitive edge in this transformative field. 


3. Financial Inclusion: Cryptocurrencies provide financial services to the unbanked and underbanked populations worldwide. Banning crypto would hinder financial inclusion efforts, depriving millions of people of access to secure and affordable financial services. By supporting the crypto market, the U.S. can demonstrate its commitment to inclusive economic growth and empower individuals who have been traditionally excluded from the financial system. 


4. Innovation and Entrepreneurship: The crypto market has become a breeding ground for innovation and entrepreneurial endeavors. By fostering an environment that supports cryptocurrencies, the U.S. encourages risk-taking, creativity, and technological advancements. Many successful startups and groundbreaking projects have emerged from the crypto space, contributing to job creation and economic prosperity. 


5. Global Competitiveness: Several countries have embraced cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology, positioning themselves as attractive destinations for crypto-related businesses and investments. If the United States were to ban crypto, it would risk losing talent, businesses, and investment opportunities to more crypto-friendly jurisdictions. To remain globally competitive, the U.S. needs to embrace the potential of cryptocurrencies and provide a conducive regulatory environment. 


6. Tax Revenues: Cryptocurrencies, when properly regulated, can contribute to increased tax revenues for the government. By implementing appropriate taxation policies and ensuring compliance, the U.S. can benefit from the growing crypto market and use the additional funds to invest in infrastructure, education, healthcare, and other important sectors. 


7. National Security: Banning cryptocurrencies might inadvertently push transactions into the unregulated black market, making it harder for law enforcement agencies to track and combat illicit activities. Embracing cryptocurrencies with appropriate regulations enables better oversight and enhances national security efforts. 


It's important to note that while cryptocurrencies have their challenges and concerns, a balanced and thoughtful approach that combines regulation and innovation can address these issues effectively, rather than an outright ban. 


By embracing cryptocurrencies, the United States can seize the numerous opportunities they offer, fostering economic growth, innovation, financial inclusion, and global competitiveness. It is crucial for policymakers to carefully consider the potential long-term benefits and implications before making any hasty decisions. 


I hope this information helps you present a more sophisticated argument against banning crypto.