XML 39 R16.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.22.4
Insurance Regulatory Restrictions (Notes)
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2022
Regulatory Assets and Liabilities Disclosure [Abstract]  
Insurance Regulatory Restrictions
9.    INSURANCE REGULATORY RESTRICTIONS
United States
AAC is domiciled in the State of Wisconsin and, as such, it is subject to the insurance laws and regulations of the State of Wisconsin (the “Wisconsin Insurance Laws”) and is regulated by the OCI as a domestic insurer. Everspan Indemnity and its wholly owned subsidiary, Everspan Insurance Company ("Everspan Insurance"), are domiciled in Arizona and are subject to the insurance laws and regulations of Arizona (the “Arizona Insurance Laws”) and are regulated by the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions as domestic insurers. The other subsidiaries of Everspan Insurance are domiciled in various States and are therefore subject to the insurance laws and regulations of their respective States of domicile (together with the Wisconsin Insurance Laws and the Arizona Insurance Laws, the “State Insurance Laws”) and regulated by the insurance departments of those States as domestic insurers. In addition, AAC, Everspan Insurance and its subsidiaries are subject to the insurance laws and regulations of the other jurisdictions in which they are licensed and operate as foreign insurers.
Insurance laws and regulations applicable to insurers vary by jurisdiction, but the insurance laws and regulations applicable to our insurance carriers generally require them to maintain minimum standards of business conduct and solvency; to meet
certain financial tests; and to file policy forms, premium rate schedules and certain reports with regulatory authorities, including information concerning capital structure, ownership, financial condition (such as risk-based capital), corporate governance and enterprise risk. AAC, because it is a financial guarantee insurer, is not subject to risk-based capital requirements. As a run-off financial guarantor, AAC has been operating under the Stipulation and Order required by OCI. OCI is developing OCI's Runoff Capital Framework to assist with decisioning related to capital and liquidity management at AAC.
Regulated insurance companies are also required to file quarterly and annual statutory financial statements in each jurisdiction in which they are licensed. The State Insurance Laws also require prior approval (or non-disapproval) of certain transactions between an insurance carrier and its affiliates. The level of supervisory authority that may be exercised by non-domiciliary insurance regulators varies by jurisdiction. Generally, however, non-domiciliary regulators are authorized to suspend or revoke the insurance license they issued and to impose restrictions on that license in the event that laws or regulations are breached by a regulated insurance company or in the event that continued or unrestricted licensing of the regulated insurance company constitutes a “hazardous condition” (or meets a similar standard) in the opinion of the non-domiciliary regulator.
The domiciliary regulators have primary regulatory authority, including with respect to the initiation and administration of rehabilitation or liquidation proceedings. Additionally, the accounts and operations of AAC and Everspan are subject to individual periodic comprehensive financial examinations by their domestic regulators, and may be examined collectively by the lead regulator of the affiliated insurance company group.
In December 2020, Everspan Insurance completed its re-domestication from Wisconsin to Arizona and obtained broad authority to write property and casualty insurance (while contemporaneously surrendering its authority to write financial guaranty insurance) in Arizona. Everspan Insurance thereafter sought similar amendments to its certificates of authority in all other states. Everspan Insurance and its subsidiaries (Providence Washington Insurance Company, Greenwood Insurance Company, Consolidated National Insurance Company and 21st Century Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey) are subject to risk-based capital requirements.
Everspan Indemnity was formed in 2020 as a domestic surplus lines insurer in Arizona and, accordingly, is eligible to write property and casualty insurance as an excess and surplus lines insurance in all states by virtue of the U.S. Nonadmitted and Reinsurance Reform Act of 2010. Everspan Indemnity owns 100% of Everspan Insurance. Everspan Indemnity issued its first policies in May 2021.
All of Ambac's insurance subsidiaries are in compliance with the minimum capital and surplus levels required under the State Insurance Laws required to transact all business written to date.
Our Insurance Distribution businesses, like some other managing general agents, brokerages and program
administrators, may be subject to licensing requirements and regulation by insurance regulators in various states in which they conduct business.
In addition to the legal restrictions applicable to AAC as described herein, pursuant to the terms of the Settlement Agreement and the Stipulation and Order, AAC must seek prior approval by OCI of certain corporate actions. The Settlement Agreement and Stipulation and Order include covenants which restrict the operations of AAC. The Settlement Agreement will remain in force until the surplus notes that were issued pursuant to the Settlement Agreement have been redeemed, repurchased or repaid in full. The Stipulation and Order will remain in force for so long as OCI determines it to be necessary. Certain of the restrictions in the Settlement Agreement may be waived with the approval of the OCI and/or the requisite percentage of holders of AAC's surplus notes.
OCI's Runoff Capital Framework, when implemented, will assist OCI with making decisions related to capital and liquidity management at AAC. OCI's Runoff Capital Framework is not yet complete and therefore we are not able to predict the results of such and what it may mean for our Legacy Financial Guarantee strategy, particularly as it relates to deleveraging AAC and distributing capital to AFG. Nevertheless, in the event that the OCI Runoff Capital Framework were to indicate that AAC is in a capital deficit position, OCI cannot require AFG or any other Ambac entity to contribute capital to or otherwise support AAC.
Although not domiciled in New York, AAC is nevertheless subject to the New York insurance law governing financial guarantee insurers. New York’s comprehensive financial guarantee insurance law defines the scope of permitted financial guarantee insurance and governs the conduct of business of all financial guarantors licensed to do business in New York, including AAC. The New York financial guarantee insurance law also establishes single and aggregate risk limits with respect to insured obligations insured by financial guarantee insurers. Such single risk limits are specific to the type of insured obligation (for example, municipal or asset-backed). Under the aggregate limits, policyholders’ surplus and contingency reserves must at least equal a percentage of aggregate net liability that is equal to the sum of various percentages of aggregate net liability for various categories of specified obligations. At December 31, 2022, AAC is in compliance with applicable aggregate risk limits and applicable single risk limits.
The financial statements of AAC and Everspan are prepared on the basis of accounting practices prescribed or permitted by the State Insurance Laws and the actions of regulatory authorities thereunder. AAC and Everspan use such statutory accounting practices prescribed or permitted by the applicable regulatory authorities for determining and reporting their financial condition and results of operations, including for determining solvency under the State Insurance Laws. The States in which AAC and Everspan are domiciled have adopted the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (“NAIC”) accounting practices and procedures manual (“NAIC SAP”) as a component of prescribed practices as codified in each State’s applicable law or regulation.
Statutory policyholder surplus differs from stockholder's equity determined under GAAP principally due to statutory accounting rules that treat financial guarantee premiums and loss reserves, investments, consolidation of subsidiaries or variable interest entities and surplus notes differently.
The following are details of statutory surplus for AAC and Everspan Indemnity:
AAC’s statutory policyholder surplus was $598 at December 31, 2022, as compared to $757 as of December 31, 2021.
Everspan Indemnity has statutory policyholder surplus of $107 as of December 31, 2022 as compared to $106 as of December 31, 2021.
The OCI has prescribed additional practices and has permitted accounting practices for AAC. As a result of the prescribed and permitted practices discussed below, AAC’s statutory surplus at December 31, 2022 and 2021 was higher by $90 and lower by $5, respectively, than if AAC had reported such amounts in accordance with NAIC SAP.
Everspan Indemnity and its subsidiaries do not have permitted or additional prescribed practices at December 31, 2022. The Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions has permitted accounting practices for Everspan Indemnity and Everspan Insurance at December 31, 2021 As a result of the permitted practice discussed below, Everspan Indemnity's statutory surplus at December 31, 2021 was higher by $18 than if Everspan had reported such amounts with NAIC SAP. Everspan had no additional prescribed practices as at December 31, 2021.
Additional Prescribed Accounting Practices
AAC:
OCI has prescribed the following accounting practices that differ from NAIC SAP for AAC:
Paragraph 8 of Statement of Statutory Accounting Principles No. 60 “Financial Guaranty Insurance” allows for a deduction from loss reserves for the time value of money by application of a discount rate equal to the average rate of return on the admitted assets of the financial guaranty insurer as of the date of the computation of the reserve. The discount rate shall be adjusted at the end of each calendar year. Additionally, in accordance with paragraph 13.e of Statutory Accounting Principles No. 97 "Investments in Subsidiary, Controlled and Affiliated Entities" and paragraph 8 of Statutory Accounting Principles No. 5R “Liabilities, Contingencies and Impairments of Assets - Revised”, AAC records probable losses on its subsidiaries for which it guarantees their obligations. AAC also discounts probable losses on guarantees of subsidiary obligations using a discount rate equal to the average rate of return on its admitted assets. AAC’s average rates of return on its admitted assets at December 31, 2022 and 2021 were 3.22% and 5.28%, respectively. OCI has directed AAC to utilize a prescribed discount rate of 5.10% for the purpose of discounting both
its loss reserves and its probable losses on subsidiary guarantees.
Paragraph 4 of Statement of Statutory Accounting Principles No. 41 “Surplus Notes” (“SSAP 41”) states that proceeds received by the issuer of surplus notes must be in the form of cash or other admitted assets having readily determinable values and liquidity satisfactory to the commissioner of the state of domicile. Under statutory accounting principles, surplus notes issued in conjunction with commutations or the settlement of obligations would be valued at zero upon issuance pursuant to paragraph 4, SSAP 41. OCI has directed the Company to record surplus notes issued in connection with commutations or the settlement of obligations at full par value upon issuance. The surplus notes issued have a claim against surplus senior to the preferred and common shareholders.
Paragraph 35 of Statement of Statutory Accounting Principles No. 43R ”Loan-backed and Structured Securities” states that when an other-than-temporary impairment ("OTTI") has occurred, the amount of the OTTI recognized as a realized loss shall equal the difference between the investment’s amortized cost basis and the present value of cash flows expected to be collected, discounted at the loan-backed or structured security’s effective interest rate. From June 11, 2014 to February 12, 2018, OCI had directed AAC to not evaluate for OTTI investments in AAC insured securities with designated policies that were allocated to a segregated account of AAC in rehabilitation overseen by OCI, and required all such investments be reported at amortized cost regardless of its NAIC risk designation.
Permitted Accounting Practices
AAC:
OCI has allowed the following permitted practice for AAC:
Wisconsin accounting practices for changes to contingency reserves differ from NAIC SAP. Under NAIC SAP, contributions to and releases from the contingency reserve are recorded via a direct charge or credit to surplus. Under the Wisconsin Administrative Code, contributions to and releases from the contingency reserve are to be recorded through underwriting income. AAC received permission from OCI to record contributions to and releases from the contingency reserve, in accordance with NAIC SAP.
Everspan:
The Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions has allowed the following permitted practice for Everspan:
Paragraph 8 of Statement of Statutory Accounting Principles No. 97 “Investment in Subsidiary, Controlled and Affiliated Entities” (“SSAP 97”) states Investments in US insurance Subsidiary, Controlled and Affiliated entities shall be recorded based on the underlying audited statutory equity of the respective entity's financial statements adjusted for any unamortized goodwill. Everspan has received permission from the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions to admit its investment
at December 31, 2021 of its wholly owned subsidiary, Providence Washington Insurance Company. Providence Washington Insurance Company received a waiver from its regulator to file a statutory audit report issued for the year ended December 31, 2021.
United Kingdom
The Prudential Regulatory Authority (“PRA”) and Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) (and their predecessor regulator the Financial Services Authority (“FSA”)) are the dual statutory regulator responsible for regulating the financial services industry in the United Kingdom, with the purpose of maintaining confidence in the U.K. financial system, providing public understanding of the system, securing the proper degree of protection for consumers and helping to reduce financial crime.
These regulators have exercised significant oversight of Ambac UK since 2008, after Ambac, AAC and Ambac UK began experiencing financial stress. In 2009, Ambac UK’s license to write new business was curtailed by the FSA and the insurance license was limited to undertaking only run-off related activity. As such, Ambac UK is authorized to run-off its credit, suretyship and financial guarantee insurance portfolio in the United Kingdom.
The PRA requires that non-life insurance companies such as Ambac UK maintain a margin of solvency at all times in respect of the liabilities of the insurance company, the calculation of which depends on the type and amount of insurance business a company writes. These solvency requirements were amended on January 1, 2016, in order to implement the European Union's "Solvency II" directive on risk-based capital. Ambac UK had previously been in a capital shortfall position as compared to these solvency capital requirements, but has met the requirements since December 31, 2021.
Dividend Restrictions, Including Contractual Restrictions
State Insurance Regulators prescribe rules that determine if AAC and Everspan may declare dividends. In addition, AAC and Everspan are subject to certain restrictions in their respective articles of incorporation with regards to the payment of dividends. Board action authorizing a distribution by an insurance company must generally be reported to the applicable domiciliary regulator prior to payment. In addition, State Insurance Laws generally require regulatory approval for the payment of extraordinary dividends, which are distributions in amounts that would exceed certain thresholds, such as a percentage of surplus or net income for the prior year or number of years.
Everspan does not have sufficient earned surplus at this time to pay ordinary dividends under the State Insurance Laws. Furthermore, certain subsidiaries of Everspan Insurance are restricted from paying dividends to Everspan Insurance until 2025 or later pursuant to the regulatory orders approving the acquisition of those subsidiaries, unless specifically approved by the applicable domiciliary regulator.
Due to losses experienced by AAC, it has been unable to pay ordinary dividends to AFG since 2008 and will be unable to pay common dividends in 2023 without the prior consent of the OCI, which is extremely unlikely. AAC’s ability to pay dividends is further restricted by the Settlement Agreement (as described below), by the terms of its AMPS (as described below) and by the Stipulation and Order, and may be affected by OCI's Runoff Capital Framework, although OCI's Runoff Capital Framework has not yet been implemented and we cannot predict the results or implications thereof. See Note 1. Background and Business Description for further information. Accordingly, AAC's ability to pay dividends to AFG and the timing thereof remain subject to substantial uncertainty.
Pursuant to the Settlement Agreement, AAC may not make any “Restricted Payment” (which includes dividends from AAC to Ambac) in excess of $5 in the aggregate per annum, other than Restricted Payments from AAC to Ambac in an amount up to $8 per annum solely to pay operating expenses of Ambac. Concurrent with making any such Restricted Payment, a pro rata amount of AAC's surplus notes would also need to be redeemed at par.
Under the terms of AAC’s AMPS, dividends may not be paid on the common stock of AAC unless all accrued and unpaid dividends on the AMPS for the then current dividend period have been paid, provided, that dividends on the common stock may be made at all times for the purpose of, and only in such amounts as are necessary for, enabling Ambac (i) to service its indebtedness for borrowed money as such payments become due or (ii) to pay its operating expenses. If dividends are paid on the common stock as provided in the prior sentence, dividends on the AMPS become cumulative until the date that all accumulated and unpaid dividends have been paid on the AMPS.
The Stipulation and Order requires OCI approval for the payment of any dividend or distribution on the common stock of AAC.
OCI's Runoff Capital Framework may be implemented in the near term. While OCI's Runoff Capital Framework is not complete and we cannot predict the results and implications thereof, it is possible that OCI's Runoff Capital Framework and decisions based thereon may affect AAC's ability to reduce financial leverage or to pay dividends to AFG. Nevertheless, in the event that the OCI Runoff Capital Framework were to indicate that AAC is in a capital deficit position, OCI cannot require AFG or any other Ambac entity to contribute capital to or otherwise support AAC.
UK law prohibits Ambac UK from declaring a dividend to its shareholders unless it has “profits available for distribution.” The determination of whether a company has profits available for distribution is based on its accumulated realized profits less its accumulated realized losses. While the UK insurance regulatory laws impose no statutory restrictions on a general insurer’s ability to declare a dividend, the PRA’s and FCA’s rules governing capital extraction by insurance firms in run off require Ambac UK to consider its future capital requirements over a 3 to 5 year period in both base case and downside stress scenarios before declaring a dividend. Further, the FSA
amended Ambac UK’s license in 2010 such that the PRA must specifically approve (“non-objection”) any transfer of value and/or assets from Ambac UK to AAC or any other Ambac group company, other than in respect of certain disclosed contracts between the two parties (such as in respect of a management services agreement between AAC and Ambac UK). Ambac UK is not expected to pay any dividends to AAC in the near future.