XML 33 R12.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.3.1.900
Note 5 - Loans
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2015
Receivables [Abstract]  
Loans, Notes, Trade and Other Receivables Disclosure [Text Block]

5.     Loans


      Most of the Company’s business activity is predominately with Asian customers located in Southern and Northern California; New York City; Houston and Dallas, Texas; Seattle, Washington; Boston, Massachusetts; Chicago, Illinois; Edison, New Jersey; Rockville, Maryland; Nevada; and Hong Kong. The Company has no specific industry concentration, and generally its loans are collateralized with real property or other pledged collateral of the borrowers. Loans are generally expected to be paid off from the operating profits of the borrowers, refinancing by another lender, or through sale by the borrowers of the secured collateral.


The components of loans in the Consolidated Balance Sheets as of December 31, 2015, and December 31, 2014, were as follows:


   

As of December 31,

 
   

2015

   

2014

 
   

(In thousands)

 

Type of Loans:

               

Commercial loans

  $ 2,316,863     $ 2,382,493  

Real estate construction loans

    441,543       298,654  

Commercial mortgage loans

    5,301,218       4,486,443  

Residential mortgage loans

    1,932,355       1,570,059  

Equity lines

    168,980       172,879  

Installment and other loans

    2,493       3,552  

Gross loans

    10,163,452       8,914,080  

Less:

               

Allowance for loan losses

    (138,963 )     (161,420 )

Unamortized deferred loan fees

    (8,262 )     (12,392 )

Total loans and leases, net

  $ 10,016,227     $ 8,740,268  

Loans held for sale

  $ 6,676     $ 973  

The Company pledged real estate loans of $6.8 billion at December 31, 2015, and $3.8 billion at December 31, 2014, to the Federal Home Loan Bank of San Francisco under its blanket lien pledging program. In addition, the Bank pledged $71.3 million at December 31, 2015, and $127.2 million at December 31, 2014, of its commercial loans to the Federal Reserve Bank’s Discount Window under the Borrower-in-Custody program.


Loans serviced for others as of December 31, 2015, totaled $356.7 million and were comprised of $138.0 million of residential mortgages, $90.9 million of commercial real estate loans, $77.3 million of construction loans, and $50.5 million of commercial loans.


      The Company has entered into transactions with its directors, executive officers, or principal holders of its equity securities, or the associates of such persons (“Related Parties”). Such transactions were made in the ordinary course of business on substantially the same terms and conditions, including interest rates and collateral, as those prevailing at the same time for comparable transactions with customers who are not related parties. In management’s opinion, these transactions did not involve more than normal credit risk or present other unfavorable features. All loans to Related Parties were current as of December 31, 2015. An analysis of the activity with respect to loans to Related Parties for the years indicated is as follows:


   

December 31,

 
   

2015

   

2014

 
   

(In thousands)

 

Balance at beginning of year

  $ 83,812     $ 126,985  

Additional loans made

    54,975       76,610  

Payment received

    (47,167 )     (119,783 )

Balance at end of year

  $ 91,620     $ 83,812  

At December 31, 2015, recorded investment in impaired loans totaled $133.8 million and was comprised of nonaccrual loans, excluding loans held for sale, of $52.1 million and accruing TDR’s of $81.7 million. At December 31, 2014, recorded investment in impaired loans totaled $174.5 million and was comprised of nonaccrual loans, excluding loans held for sale, of $70.2 million and accruing TDR’s of $104.3 million. The average balance of impaired loans was $162.9 million in 2015 and $190.2 million in 2014. We considered all non-accrual loans and troubled debt restructurings ("TDR") to be impaired. Interest recognized on impaired loans totaled $4.0 million in 2015 and $5.3 million in 2014. The Bank recognizes interest income on impaired loans based on its existing method of recognizing interest income on non-accrual loans except accruing TDRs. For impaired loans, the amounts previously charged off represent 22.4% at December 31, 2015, and 17.1% at December 31, 2014, of the contractual balances for impaired loans. The following table presents impaired loans and the related allowance as of the dates indicated:


   

Impaired Loans

 
   

As of December 31, 2015

   

As of December 31, 2014

 
   

Unpaid

Principal

Balance

   

Recorded

Investment

   

Allowance

   

Unpaid

Principal

Balance

   

Recorded

Investment

   

Allowance

 
   

(In thousands)

 
                                                 

With no allocated allowance

                                               

Commercial loans

  $ 15,493     $ 6,721     $ -     $ 19,479     $ 18,452     $ -  

Real estate construction loans

    51,290       22,002       -       32,924       17,025       -  

Commercial mortgage loans

    59,954       54,625       -       77,474       75,172       -  

Residential mortgage and equity lines

    3,233       3,026       -       2,518       2,518       -  

Subtotal

  $ 129,970     $ 86,374     $ -     $ 132,395     $ 113,167     $ -  

With allocated allowance

                                               

Commercial loans

  $ 7,757     $ 6,847     $ 530     $ 7,003     $ 5,037     $ 1,263  

Real estate construction loans

    -       -       -       19,006       8,703       1,077  

Commercial mortgage loans

    28,258       27,152       6,792       38,197       34,022       8,993  

Residential mortgage and equity lines

    14,383       13,437       427       14,019       13,590       465  

Subtotal

  $ 50,398     $ 47,436      $ 7,749     $ 78,225     $ 61,352     $ 11,798  

Total impaired loans

  $ 180,368     $ 133,810     $ 7,749     $ 210,620     $ 174,519     $ 11,798  

The following table presents the average balance and interest income recognized related to impaired loans for the periods indicated:


   

For the year ended December 31,

 
   

2015

   

2014

   

2013

   

2015

   

2014

   

2013

 
   

Average Recorded Investment

   

Interest Income Recognized

 
   

(In thousands)

 
       

Commercial loans

  $ 23,960     $ 26,128     $ 27,123     $ 546     $ 878     $ 770  

Real estate construction loans

    22,066       32,439       37,875       261       264       284  

Commercial mortgage loans

    100,118       114,248       138,121       2,708       3,735       4,256  

Residential mortgage and equity lines

    16,801       17,411       18,033       482       462       289  

Subtotal

  $ 162,945     $ 190,226     $ 221,152     $ 3,997     $ 5,339     $ 5,599  

The following is a summary of non-accrual loans as of December 31, 2015, 2014, and 2013 and the related net interest foregone for the years then ended:


   

2015

   

2014

   

2013

 
   

(In thousands)

 

Non-accrual portfolio loans

  $ 52,130     $ 70,163     $ 83,183  

Non-accrual loans held-for-sale

    5,944       973       -  

Total non-accrual loans

  $ 58,074     $ 71,136     $ 83,183  
                         

Contractual interest due

  $ 5,732     $ 6,663     $ 5,851  

Interest recognized

    119       217       22  

Net interest foregone

  $ 5,613     $ 6,446     $ 5,829  

The following tables present the aging of the loan portfolio by type as of December 31, 2015, and December 31, 2014:


   

As of December 31, 2015

 
   

30-59 Days

Past Due

   

60-89 Days

Past Due

   

Greater

than 90

Days Past

Due

   

Non-accrual

Loans

   

Total Past Due

   

Loans Not

Past Due

   

Total

 

 

 

(In thousands)

 
Type of Loans:                                                        

Commercial loans

  $ 8,367     $ 221     $ -     $ 3,545     $ 12,133     $ 2,304,730     $ 2,316,863  

Real estate construction loans

    7,285       -       -       16,306       23,591       417,952       441,543  

Commercial mortgage loans

    2,243       2,223       -       25,231       29,697       5,271,521       5,301,218  

Residential mortgage loans

    4,959       1,038       -       7,048       13,045       2,088,290       2,101,335  

Installment and other loans

    -       -       -       -               2,493       2,493  

Total loans

  $ 22,854     $ 3,482     $ -     $ 52,130     $ 78,466     $ 10,084,986     $ 10,163,452  

   

As of December 31, 2014

 
   

30-59 Days

Past Due

   

60-89 Days

Past Due

   

Greater

than 90

Days Past

Due

   

Non-accrual

Loans

   

Total Past Due

   

Loans Not

Past Due

   

Total

 

 

 

(In thousands)

 
Type of Loans:                                                        

Commercial loans

  $ 11,595     $ 1,238     $ -     $ 6,983     $ 19,816     $ 2,362,677     $ 2,382,493  

Real estate construction loans

    1,416       -       -       19,963       21,379       277,275       298,654  

Commercial mortgage loans

    17,654       3,909       -       35,606       57,169       4,429,274       4,486,443  

Residential mortgage loans

    5,634       732       -       7,611       13,977       1,728,961       1,742,938  

Installment and other loans

    60       -       -       -       60       3,492       3,552  

Total loans

  $ 36,359     $ 5,879     $ -     $ 70,163     $ 112,401     $ 8,801,679     $ 8,914,080  

The determination of the amount of the allowance for credit losses for problem loans is based on management’s current judgment about the credit quality of the loan portfolio and takes into consideration known relevant internal and external factors that affect collectability when determining the appropriate level for the allowance for credit losses. The nature of the process by which the Bank determines the appropriate allowance for credit losses requires the exercise of considerable judgment. This allowance evaluation process is also applied to TDRs since TDRs are considered to be impaired loans.


At December 31, 2015, accruing TDRs were $81.7 million and non-accrual TDRs were $39.9 million compared to accruing TDRs of $104.3 million and non-accrual TDRs of $41.6 million at December 31, 2014. The Company has allocated specific reserves of $5.4 million to non-accrual TDRs and $2.0 million to accruing TDRs at December 31, 2015, and $6.5 million to accruing TDRs and $4.9 million to non-accrual TDRs at December 31, 2014. The following table presents TDRs that were modified during 2015, their specific reserve at December 31, 2015, and charge-offs during 2015:


   

No. of

Contracts

   

Pre-Modification

Outstanding Recorded

Investment

   

Post-Modification

Outstanding Recorded

Investment

   

Specific Reserve

   

Charge-offs

 
   

(Dollars in thousands)

 
                                         

Commercial loans

    3     $ 1,181     $ 1,181     $ 2     $ -  

Commercial mortgage loans

    20       17,204       17,204       708       -  

Residential mortgage and equity lines

    5       1,521       1,374       42       148  

Total

    28     $ 19,906     $ 19,759     $ 752     $ 148  

The following table presents TDRs that were modified during 2014, their specific reserve at December 31, 2014, and charge-offs during 2014:


   

No. of

Contracts

   

Pre-Modification

Outstanding Recorded

Investment

   

Post-Modification

Outstanding Recorded

Investment

   

Specific Reserve

   

Charge-offs

 
   

(Dollars in thousands)

 
                                         

Commercial loans

    4     $ 10,539     $ 10,539     $ 21     $ -  

Commercial mortgage loans

    3       11,817       11,817       5,550       -  

Residential mortgage and equity lines

    7       2,715       2,715       29       -  

Total

    14     $ 25,071     $ 25,071     $ 5,600     $ -  

The following table presents TDRs that were modified during 2013, their specific reserve at December 31, 2013, and charge-offs during 2013:


   

No. of

Contracts

   

Pre-Modification

Outstanding Recorded

Investment

   

Post-Modification

Outstanding Recorded

Investment

   

Specific Reserve

   

Charge-off

 
   

(Dollars in thousands)

 
                                         

Commercial loans

    9     $ 12,026     $ 10,860     $ 550     $ 1,166  

Commercial mortgage loans

    5       13,090       13,090       329       -  

Residential mortgage and equity lines

    11       3,736       3,658       103       78  

Total

    25     $ 28,852     $ 27,608     $ 982     $ 1,244  

A summary of TDRs by type of concession and by type of loans as of December 31, 2015, and December 31, 2014, are shown below:


   

December 31, 2015

 

Accruing TDRs

 

Payment

Deferral

   

Rate

Reduction

   

Rate Reduction

and Payment

Deferral

   

Total

 
                                 

Commercial loans

  $ 8,298     $ -     $ 1,726     $ 10,024  

Real estate construction loans

    -       -       5,696       5,696  

Commercial mortgage loans

    16,701       6,045       33,800       56,546  

Residential mortgage loans

    5,201       999       3,214       9,414  

Total accruing TDRs

  $ 30,200     $ 7,044     $ 44,436     $ 81,680  

    December 31, 2015  
                   

Non-accrual TDRs

 

Payment

Deferral

   

Rate Reduction

and Payment

Deferral

   

Total

 
                         

Commercial loans

  $ 1,033     $ 90     $ 1,123  

Real estate construction loans

    9,981       5,825       15,806  

Commercial mortgage loans

    1,544       20,362       21,906  

Residential mortgage loans

    388       700       1,088  

Total non-accrual TDRs

  $ 12,946     $ 26,977     $ 39,923  

   

December 31, 2014

 

Accruing TDRs

 

Payment

Deferral

   

Rate

Reduction

   

Rate Reduction

and Forgiveness

of Principal

   

Rate Reduction

and Payment

Deferral

   

Total

 
                                         

Commercial loans

  $ 11,572     $ -     $ -     $ 4,934     $ 16,506  

Real estate construction loans

    5,765       -       -       -       5,765  

Commercial mortgage loans

    20,543       26,694       -       26,351       73,588  

Residential mortgage loans

    3,316       -       410       4,771       8,497  

Total accruing TDRs

  $ 41,196     $ 26,694     $ 410     $ 36,056     $ 104,356  

    December 31, 2014  

Non-accrual TDRs

 

Payment

Deferral

   

Rate

Reduction

   

Rate Reduction

and Payment

Deferral

   

Total

 
                                 

Commercial loans

  $ 1,423     $ 860     $ 1,269     $ 3,552  

Real estate construction loans

    -       -       19,462       19,462  

Commercial mortgage loans

    15,917       -       973       16,890  

Residential mortgage loans

    1,026       -       688       1,714  

Total non-accrual TDRs

  $ 18,366     $ 860     $ 22,392     $ 41,618  

Troubled debt restructurings on accrual status totaled $81.7 million at December 31, 2015, and were comprised of 59 loans, a decrease of $22.7 million, compared to 60 loans totaling $104.4 million at December 31, 2014. TDRs at December 31, 2015, were comprised of 15 non-farm non-residential commercial mortgage loans of $44.9 million, six commercial loans of $10.0 million, 32 single family residential mortgage loans of $9.4 million, one multi-family residential commercial mortgage loan of $6.0 million, four single family residential commercial mortgage loans of $5.7 million, and one construction loan of $5.7 million. We expect that the troubled debt restructuring loans on accruing status as of December 31, 2015, which are all performing in accordance with their restructured terms, will continue to comply with the restructured terms because of the reduced principal or interest payments on these loans. The comparable TDRs at December 31, 2014, were comprised of nine commercial loans of $16.5 million, three hotel loans of $15.7 million, 31 single family residential loans of $13.6 million, two industrial and manufactural use building loans of $12.2 million, two land loans for residential purpose of $10.2 million, four commercial condos loans of $10.1 million, three retail shopping and commercial use building loans of $9.0 million, one multi-family residential loan of $6.1 million, one shopping center construction loan of $5.8 million, three office buildings loans of $3.5 million, and one warehouse loan of $1.6 million. The activity within our TDR loans for 2015, 2014, and 2013 are shown below:


Accruing TDRs

 

2015

   

2014

   

2013

 
   

(In thousands)

 

Beginning balance

  $ 104,356     $ 117,597     $ 144,695  

New restructurings

    17,752       23,740       21,382  

Restructured loans restored to accrual status

    723       962       6,851  

Charge-offs

    (104 )     -       (78 )

Payments

    (30,858 )     (13,256 )     (52,362 )

Restructured loans placed on non-accrual

    (10,189 )     (24,687 )     (2,891 )

Ending balance

  $ 81,680     $ 104,356     $ 117,597  

Non-accrual TDRs

 

2015

   

2014

   

2013

 
   

(In thousands)

 

Beginning balance

  $ 41,618     $ 38,769     $ 47,731  

New restructurings

    2,006       1,331       6,226  

Restructured loans placed on non-accrual

    10,189       24,687       2,891  

Charge-offs

    (3,246 )     (8,937 )     (2,124 )

Payments

    (9,921 )     (11,710 )     (4,295 )

Foreclosures

    -       (1,560 )     (4,809 )

Restructured loans restored to accrual status

    (723 )     (962 )     (6,851 )

Ending balance

  $ 39,923     $ 41,618     $ 38,769  

A loan is considered to be in payment default once it is 60 to 90 days contractually past due under the modified terms.  There were no loans modified as TDRs during the previous twelve months that subsequently defaulted as of December 31, 2015. 


Under the Company’s internal underwriting policy, an evaluation is performed of the probability that the borrower will be in payment default on any of its debt in the foreseeable future without the modification in order to determine whether a borrower is experiencing financial difficulty. As of December 31, 2015, there were no commitments to lend additional funds to those borrowers whose loans have been restructured, were considered impaired, or were on non-accrual status.


As part of the on-going monitoring of the credit quality of our loan portfolio, the Company utilizes a risk grading matrix to assign a risk grade to each loan. Loans are risk rated based on analysis of the current state of the borrower’s credit quality. The analysis of credit quality includes a review of all sources of repayment, the borrower’s current financial and liquidity status and all other relevant information. The risk rating categories can be generally described by the following grouping for non-homogeneous loans:


 

Pass/Watch – These loans range from minimal credit risk to lower than average, but still acceptable, credit risk.

     
  Special Mention  Borrower is fundamentally sound and the loan is currently protected but adverse trends are apparent that, if not corrected, may affect ability to repay. Primary source of loan repayment remains viable but there is increasing reliance on collateral or guarantor support.

 

Substandard  These loans are inadequately protected by current sound worth, paying capacity or pledged collateral. Well-defined weaknesses exist that could jeopardize repayment of debt. Loss may not be imminent, but if weaknesses are not corrected, there is a good possibility of some loss.


 

Doubtful – The possibility of loss is extremely high, but due to identifiable and important pending events (which may strengthen the loan) a loss classification is deferred until the situation is better defined.


 

Loss – These loans are considered uncollectible and of such little value that to continue to carry the loans as an active asset is no longer warranted.


The following tables present loan portfolio by risk rating as of December 31, 2015, and as of December 31, 2014:


   

As of December 31, 2015

 
   

Pass/Watch

   

Special Mention

   

Substandard

   

Doubtful

   

Total

 
    (In Thousands)  

Commercial loans

  $ 2,143,270     $ 110,338     $ 61,297     $ 1,958     $ 2,316,863  

Real estate construction loans

    413,765       5,776       21,502       500       441,543  

Commercial mortgage loans

    5,018,199       155,553       118,196       9,270       5,301,218  

Residential mortgage and equity lines

    2,091,434       399       9,502       -       2,101,335  

Installment and other loans

    2,493       -       -       -       2,493  
                                         

Total gross loans

  $ 9,669,161     $ 272,066     $ 210,497     $ 11,728     $ 10,163,452  
                                         

Loans held for sale

  $ 732     $ -     $ 5,944     $ -     $ 6,676  

   

As of December 31, 2014

 
   

Pass/Watch

   

Special Mention

   

Substandard

   

Doubtful

   

Total

 
    (In Thousands)  

Commercial loans

  $ 2,260,474     $ 47,619     $ 72,561     $ 1,839     $ 2,382,493  

Real estate construction loans

    272,927       -       25,227       500       298,654  

Commercial mortgage loans

    4,213,453       105,970       167,020       -       4,486,443  

Residential mortgage and equity lines

    1,733,248       -       9,690       -       1,742,938  

Installment and other loans

    3,552       -       -       -       3,552  
                                         

Total gross loans

  $ 8,483,654     $ 153,589     $ 274,498     $ 2,339     $ 8,914,080  
                                         

Loans held for sale

  $ -     $ -     $ 973     $ -     $ 973  

The allowance for loan losses and the reserve for off-balance sheet credit commitments are significant estimates that can and do change based on management’s process in analyzing the loan portfolio and on management’s assumptions about specific borrowers, underlying collateral, and applicable economic and environmental conditions, among other factors.


The following table presents the balance in the allowance for loan losses by portfolio segment and based on impairment method as of December 31, 2015, and as of December 31, 2014.


   

Commercial

Loans

   

Real Estate

Construction

Loans

   

Commercial

Mortgage

Loans

   

Residential

Mortgage

and Equity Lines

   

Consumer

and Other

   

Total

 
   

(In thousands)

 

December 31, 2015

                                               

Loans individually evaluated for impairment

                                               

Allowance

  $ 530     $ -     $ 6,792     $ 427     $ -     $ 7,749  

Balance

  $ 13,568     $ 22,002     $ 81,776     $ 16,464     $ -     $ 133,810  
                                                 

Loans collectively evaluated for impairment

                                               

Allowance

  $ 55,669     $ 22,170     $ 42,648     $ 10,718     $ 9     $ 131,214  

Balance

  $ 2,303,295     $ 419,541     $ 5,219,442     $ 2,084,871     $ 2,493     $ 10,029,642  
                                                 

Total allowance

  $ 56,199     $ 22,170     $ 49,440     $ 11,145     $ 9     $ 138,963  

Total balance

  $ 2,316,863     $ 441,543     $ 5,301,218     $ 2,101,335     $ 2,493     $ 10,163,452  
                                                 

December 31, 2014

                                               

Loans individually evaluated for impairment

                                               

Allowance

  $ 1,263     $ 1,077     $ 8,993     $ 465     $ -     $ 11,798  

Balance

  $ 23,489     $ 25,728     $ 109,194     $ 16,108     $ -     $ 174,519  
                                                 

Loans collectively evaluated for impairment

                                               

Allowance

  $ 46,238     $ 26,575     $ 65,680     $ 11,113     $ 16     $ 149,622  

Balance

  $ 2,359,004     $ 272,926     $ 4,377,249     $ 1,726,830     $ 3,552     $ 8,739,561  
                                                 

Total allowance

  $ 47,501     $ 27,652     $ 74,673     $ 11,578     $ 16     $ 161,420  

Total balance

  $ 2,382,493     $ 298,654     $ 4,486,443     $ 1,742,938     $ 3,552     $ 8,914,080  

The following table details activity in the allowance for loan losses by portfolio segment for the years ended December 31, 2015 and 2014. Allocation of a portion of the allowance to one category of loans does not preclude its availability to absorb losses in other categories.


   

Commercial

Loans

   

Real Estate

Construction

Loans

   

Commercial

Mortgage

Loans

   

Residential

Mortgage

and Equity Lines

   

Installment

and Other

Loans

   

Total

 
   

(In thousands)

 

2014 Beginning Balance

  $ 65,103     $ 11,999     $ 84,753     $ 12,005     $ 29     $ 173,889  
                                                 

Provision/(reversal) for possible loan losses

    (22,244 )     19,853       (8,197 )     (558 )     (26 )     (11,172 )
                                                 

Charge-offs

    (7,875 )     (6,747 )     (7,458 )     (155 )     -       (22,235 )

Recoveries

    12,517       2,547       5,575       286       13       20,938  

Net Recoveries/(Charge-offs

    4,642       (4,200 )     (1,883 )     131       13       (1,297 )
                                                 

2014 Ending Balance

  $ 47,501     $ 27,652     $ 74,673     $ 11,578     $ 16     $ 161,420  

Reserve to impaired loans

  $ 1,263     $ 1,077     $ 8,993     $ 465     $ -     $ 11,798  

Reserve to non-impaired loans

  $ 46,238     $ 26,575     $ 65,680     $ 11,113     $ 16     $ 149,622  

Reserve for off-balance sheet credit commitments

  $ 923     $ 728     $ 259     $ 39     $ -     $ 1,949  
                                                 

2015 Beginning Balance

  $ 47,501     $ 27,652     $ 74,673     $ 11,578     $ 16     $ 161,420  
                                                 

Provision/(reversal) for possible loan losses

    20,505       (5,684 )     (26,035 )     (179 )     (7 )     (11,400 )
                                                 

Charge-offs

    (16,426 )     -       (3,716 )     (285 )     -       (20,427 )

Recoveries

    4,619       202       4,518       31       -       9,370  

Net (Charge-offs)/Recoveries

    (11,807 )     202       802       (254 )     -       (11,057 )
                                                 

2015 Ending Balance

  $ 56,199     $ 22,170     $ 49,440     $ 11,145     $ 9     $ 138,963  

Reserve to impaired loans

  $ 530     $ -     $ 6,792     $ 427     $ -     $ 7,749  

Reserve to non-impaired loans

  $ 55,669     $ 22,170     $ 42,648     $ 10,718     $ 9     $ 131,214  

Reserve for off-balance sheet credit commitments

  $ 810     $ 526     $ 158     $ -     $ -     $ 1,494  

An analysis of the activity in the allowance for credit losses for the years ended December 31, 2015, 2014, and 2013 is as follows:


   

December 31,

 
   

2015

   

2014

   

2013

 

 

 

(In thousands)

 
Allowance for Loan Losses                        

Balance at beginning of year

  $ 161,420     $ 173,889     $ 183,322  

Reversal for credit losses

    (11,400 )     (10,800 )     (3,000 )

Transfers to reserve for off-balance sheet credit commitments

    -       (372 )     -  

Loans charged off

    (20,427 )     (22,235 )     (20,442 )

Recoveries of charged off loans

    9,370       20,938       14,009  

Balance at end of year

  $ 138,963     $ 161,420     $ 173,889  

Reserve for Off-balance Sheet Credit Commitments

                       

Balance at beginning of year

  $ 1,949     $ 1,363     $ 1,363  

(Reversal)/provision for credit losses and transfers

    (455 )     586       -  

Balance at end of year

  $ 1,494     $ 1,949     $ 1,363  

Residential mortgage loans in process of formal foreclosure proceedings were $2.0 million at December 31, 2015, compared to $2.3 million at December 31, 2014.