EX-23 8 seccommentletter.htm RESPONSE TO SEC COMMENT'S LETTER seccommentletter.htm - Generated by SEC Publisher for SEC Filing

April 13, 2010

Mr. Sonny Oh
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20549

RE: Dreyfus Stock Index Fund, Inc.
  File No: 1933 Act File No. 33-27172
  1940 Act File No. 811-5719
  CIK: 846800

Dear Mr. Oh:

We are responding to the comments that you provided to us by telephone on March 30, 2010 with respect to Post-Effective Amendment No. 26 to the above-referenced Fund’s Registration Statement filed on Form N-1A on February 12, 2010 pursuant to Rule 485(a) under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the “1933 Act”).

I) General
  1) Please confirm that Dreyfus does not currently intend to use a stand-alone summary with
    regard to the fund(s).
    Dreyfus does not currently intend to use a stand-alone summary with regard to the
    fund(s).
  2) Please amend the facing page to provide the date of proposed public offering.
    The facing page will be amended to provide the date of proposed public offering.
  3) Identify each class of shares on the front cover of the prospectus.
    Each class of shares will be identified on the front cover of the prospectus.
  4) Please include a Tandy letter with the filing.
    As requested, a Tandy letter will be provided.

II) Fund Summary Comments:
Portfolio Turnover:
1) Please remove the following sentence: “Policyowners should consult the prospectus of
  the separate account of the participating insurance company or their tax adviser for more
  information regarding their tax consequences.”
 
  As you requested, this sentence will be removed.
 
2) Remove references to taxable accounts.



  As you requested, references to taxable accounts will be removed.
 
3) If the fund’s portfolio turnover rate is in excess of 100%, please add additional risk
  language.
 
  This fund’s portfolio turnover rate is not in excess of 100%, so additional risk language
  will not be added.
 
Investment Strategy:
4) Please add language stating the fund’s policy of investing at least 80% of its assets in
  stocks to the prospectus.
 
  As you requested, the fund’s policy of investing at least 80% of its assets in stocks will be
  added.
 
5) Please amend the Principal Investment Strategy and Principal Risk sections to ensure that
  the strategies and risks correspond.
 
  As requested, we have reviewed the fund’s Principal Investment Strategy section and
  Principal Risk section and, where applicable, amended the disclosure to ensure that the
  strategies and risks correspond.
 
6) Please review and add information regarding the extent to which the fund may invest in
  index futures.
 
  Please be advised that the fund’s investment restrictions do not limit the use of the
  futures; however, the fund generally seeks to meet its objective by investing fully in the
  stocks included in the S&P 500. Index futures are used supplementally as a way of
  managing cash flows.
 
Principal Risks:
7) Describe the risks of investing in S&P 500 stock index futures.
 
  We do not believe that investing in such futures is a principal risk of the fund, and
  accordingly, have not added futures as a principal risk.
 
8) Please ensure that the summary section corresponds to the risk section in the statutory
  prospectus.
 
  As you requested, we will ensure that the Principal Risks section in the summary
  corresponds to the Investment Risks section in the statutory prospectus.
 
9) Please provide additional details on the risks of stock index futures in the statutory
  prospectus.
 
  Upon review, we believe that the current disclosure provides a complete, plain English
  explanation of the risks of futures as they pertain to this fund.
 
Performance:
10) Please change the words “more recent” to “updated” in the last sentence of the first
  paragraph.

2



We respectfully decline to make this change inasmuch as there is no basis for the
comment.
 
11) Add “(reflects no deduction for fees, expenses or taxes)” after “S&P 500® Index” in the
performance table.
 
As you requested, we added “(reflects no deduction for fees, expenses or taxes)” to the
performance table.
 
12) Please explain the reasoning behind using the performance of the fund’s Initial Shares for
Service Shares prior to December 31, 2000.
 
We believe that the method used for calculating the performance data for the Service
Shares is consistent with Rule 482, Form N-1A and Rule 34b-1 and the subsequent
interpretations of the staff regarding these rules. This method will provide investors with
the most meaningful basis for making comparisons among the different classes of the
Fund and other mutual funds. Please see IDS Financial Corp. (December 19, 1994) and
Merrill Lynch Asset Management, Inc. (March 9, 1990).

Portfolio Management:
13) If the fund pays a fee to Mellon Capital Management, please disclose that information in
the Portfolio Management section of the Summary.
 
Please note that Mellon Capital Management acts as index manager pursuant to an index
management agreement between Mellon Capital Management and Dreyfus (not the
fund). The fund pays no fee to Mellon Capital Management.
 
14) Please remove the last sentence of the section: “He also has been employed by Dreyfus
since August 1982.”
 
As you requested, the last sentence of the section has been removed.
 
15) Please remove the Exchange Privilege section.
 
As you requested, we deleted the Exchange Privilege section
 
16) Change “a bank” to “an insurance company” in the Payments to Broker-Dealers and
Other Financial Intermediaries section.
 
As requested, we changed “a bank” to “an insurance company.”
 
17) Please include greater detail in the Purchase and Sale of Fund Shares section.
 
You requested that we have a fuller description under the Purchase and Sale of Fund
Shares. After reviewing the disclosure, we believe that the current description is
satisfactory.
 
III)Fund Details Comments:
1) In the Management section, please add disclosure with respect to the 12b-1 fee as
required by Item 12(b) and 12(c) of Form N-1A.

3



  As you requested, we have added disclosure with respect to the 12b-1 fee as required by
  Item 12(b) and 12(c) of Form N-1A.
 
2) If necessary, please disclose any legal proceedings pursuant to Item 10(a)(3) of Form N-
  1A.
 
  Please be advised that there are no legal proceedings that must be disclosed pursuant to
  Item 10(a)(3) of Form N-1A.
 
3) Remove the second bullet point in the General Policies section: “change or discontinue
  its exchange privilege, or temporarily suspend the privilege during unusual market
  conditions”
 
  As requested, we have deleted the second bullet point under General Policies.

IV) Statement of Additional Information (“SAI”) comments:
1) Please review and update the SAI to reflect the directors’ current ages.

As you requested, the SAI has been updated to reflect the directors’ current ages.

2) Are there any ongoing arrangements to provide portfolio holdings information to third
  parties? If so, please describe those arrangements in the SAI.
 
  At present there are no such ongoing arrangements.

3) Ensure that the SAI includes updated language to comply with the recently adopted proxy
  disclosure enhancements.

Please be advised that the SAI has been updated to comply with the recently adopted
proxy disclosure enhancements.

4) Provide more details on the fund’s proxy voting guidelines.
 
  After further review, we believe that paragraphs five through seven of the Proxy Voting
  Summary are in compliance with Item 17(f) of Form N-1A and provide sufficient
  information regarding how the fund votes its proxies.

5) Please remove the appendix to the SAI.
  As requested, we removed the appendix to the SAI.

As you requested, the Fund acknowledges that:
 
(i) The Fund is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing;
 
(ii) Staff comments or changes in response to staff comments in the filings reviewed by
  the staff do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the
  filing; and

4



(iii) The Fund may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by
the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States.
 
Should you need further information pertaining to this matter, I may be reached at (212) 922-
6795.

Sincerely,
 
/s/ Michael A. Rosenberg
Michael A. Rosenberg,
Vice President and Secretary
Dreyfus Stock Index Fund, Inc.

5