CORRESP 1 filename1.htm Correspondence Letter

LOGO

December 18, 2007

United States Securities and Exchange Commission

100 F Street, N.E.

Washington, D.C. 20549

Attention: Gary R. Todd, Reviewing Accountant

Gentlemen:

 

Re: Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2006
     Forms 10-Q for fiscal 2007
     File No. 1-10109

In response to your request for additional information related to the errors in our cash flow statements, by quarter, we provide the following information with respect to the overstatement of depreciation and amortization, and resulting overstatement of operating cash flows and equal overstatement of additions to property, plant & equipment and investing cash flows for each of the periods (amounts in millions):

 

     2007     2006     2005     2004  

Q1

   $ (4.9 )   $ (2.9 )   $ (3.1 )   $ (2.7 )

Q2

       (3.9 )     (3.0 )     (2.7 )

Q3

       (4.3 )     (2.6 )     (2.8 )

Q4

       (4.9 )     (2.6 )     (3.1 )

Total

     $ (15.9 )   $ (11.2 )   $ (11.3 )

The errors resulted from inadvertent incorrect summarization of eliminating entries for the depreciation impact of profit in operating type leases, which is eliminated in consolidation. As we have disclosed in our Form 10Q for the second quarter 2007, we corrected the errors in 2007, including the amounts reported within that 10Q related to 2006. Our third quarter 2007 10Q also reflects the corrected amounts for 2007 and 2006.

Following is a summary of the errors related to 2006, which have been reflected in our second and third quarter 10Qs filed in 2007.


U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission

Attn: Gary R. Todd

December 18, 2007

Page 2

 

     Q1 2006     Q2 2006     Q3 2006  

Cash Flow Impact

   Per
Reported
   Per
Restated
    Error     Per
Reported
   Per
Restated
    Error     Per
Reported
   Per
Restated
    Error  

Operating activities

   56.2    53.3     (2.9 )   128.0    124.1     (3.9 )   39.9    35.6     (4.3 )

% of Net Cash Flow from Operating Activities

      5.4 %        3.1 %        12.0 %  

Additions to Property, Plant, and Equipment

   65.0    62.1     (2.9 )   75.8    71.9     (3.9 )   77.6    73.3     (4.3 )

% of Additions

      4.7 %        5.4 %        5.8 %  

Investing activities

   69.2    66.3     (2.9 )   87.1    83.2     (3.9 )   35.8    31.5     (4.3 )

% of Net Cash Flow from Investing Activities

      4.4 %        4.6 %        13.5 %  

Following is a summary of the impact of the error for the first three quarters in 2005 and 2004:

 

     Q1 2005     Q1 2004  

Cash Flow Impact

   Per
Reported
   Per
Restated
    Error     Per
Reported
   Per
Restated
    Error  

Operating activities

   100.2    97.1     (3.1 )   48.6    45.9     (2.7 )

% of Net Cash Flow from Operating Activities

      3.2 %        5.8 %  

Additions to Property, Plant, and Equipment

   38.4    35.3     (3.1 )   29.2    26.5     (2.7 )

% of Additions

      8.8 %        10.0 %  

Investing activities

   42.4    39.3     (3.1 )   32.7    30.0     (2.7 )

% of Net Cash Flow from Investing Activities

      7.9 %        8.9 %  

 

     Q2 2005     Q2 2004  

Cash Flow Impact

   Per
Reported
   Per
Restated
    Error     Per
Reported
   Per
Restated
    Error  

Operating activities

   46.0    43.0     (3.0 )   7.1    4.4     (2.7 )

% of Net Cash Flow from Operating Activities

      6.9 %        60.2 %  

Additions to Property, Plant, and Equipment

   49.9    46.9     (3.0 )   40.5    37.8     (2.7 )

% of Additions

      6.3 %        7.1 %  

Investing activities

   150.6    147.6     (3.0 )   43.3    40.6     (2.7 )

% of Net Cash Flow from Investing Activities

      2.0 %        6.6 %  


U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission

Attn: Gary R. Todd

December 18, 2007

Page 3

 

     Q3 2005     Q3 2004  

Cash Flow Impact

   Per
Reported
   Per
Restated
    Error     Per
Reported
   Per
Restated
    Error  

Operating activities

   131.7    129.1     (2.6 )   75.8    73.0     (2.8 )

% of Net Cash Flow from Operating Activities

      2.0 %        3.9 %  

Additions to Property, Plant, and Equipment

   67.4    64.8     (2.6 )   36.9    34.1     (2.8 )

% of Additions

      4.0 %        8.3 %  

Investing activities

   68.7    66.1     (2.6 )   38.9    36.1     (2.8 )

% of Net Cash Flow from Investing Activities

      3.9 %        7.9 %  

The error in the second quarter 2004 amounted to 60% of the cash flow from operating activities because the cash flow for the quarter was unusually low. The magnitude of the error in the quarter is consistent with the error in other quarters. The trend in cash flow quarter to quarter is not affected. Furthermore, free cash flow, a measure used by our analysts and investors, is not affected by the error. As a result, we believe the errors are not material and do not require restatement.

We would be pleased to discuss these errors in a conference call. Please contact me at (714) 773-6626 with any questions regarding the above or to arrange a conference call.

Sincerely,

BECKMAN COULTER, INC.

 

/s/ Carolyn D. Beaver
Carolyn D. Beaver
Corporate Vice President, Controller
Chief Accounting Officer

 

cc: Mr. Charles P. Slacik, Beckman Coulter, Inc.