XML 25 R15.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.24.1.u1
Policyholder Account Balances, Future Policy Benefits and Claims
3 Months Ended
Mar. 31, 2024
Policyholder Account Balance [Abstract]  
Policyholder Account Balances, Future Policy Benefits and Claims Policyholder Account Balances, Future Policy Benefits and Claims
Policyholder account balances, future policy benefits and claims consisted of the following:
March 31, 2024December 31, 2023
(in millions)
Policyholder account balances
Policyholder account balances$29,229 $27,947 
Future policy benefits
Reserve for future policy benefits7,619 7,763 
Deferred profit liability87 81 
Additional liabilities for insurance guarantees1,336 1,321 
Other insurance and annuity liabilities191 213 
Total future policy benefits9,233 9,378 
Policy claims and other policyholders’ funds205 220 
Total policyholder account balances, future policy benefits and claims$38,667 $37,545 
Variable Annuities
Purchasers of variable annuities can select from a variety of investment options and can elect to allocate a portion to a fixed account. A vast majority of the premiums received for variable annuity contracts are held in separate accounts where the assets are held for the exclusive benefit of those contractholders.
Most of the variable annuity contracts issued by the Company contain a guaranteed minimum death benefit (“GMDB”). The Company previously offered contracts with guaranteed minimum accumulation benefit (“GMAB”), guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit (“GMWB”), and guaranteed minimum income benefit (“GMIB”) provisions. See Note 10 for additional information regarding the Company’s variable annuity guarantees. See Note 12 and Note 14 for additional information regarding the Company’s derivative instruments used to hedge risks related to these guarantees.
Structured Variable Annuities
Structured variable annuities provide contractholders the option to allocate a portion of their account value to an indexed account held in a non-insulated separate account with the contractholder’s rate of return, which may be positive or negative, tied to selected indices. The amount allocated by a contractholder to the indexed account creates an embedded derivative which is measured at fair value. The Company hedges the equity and interest rate risk related to the indexed account with freestanding derivative instruments.
Fixed Annuities
Fixed annuities include deferred, payout and fixed deferred indexed annuity contracts. In 2020, the Company discontinued sales of fixed deferred and fixed deferred indexed annuities.
Deferred contracts offer a guaranteed minimum rate of interest and security of the principal invested. Payout contracts guarantee a fixed income payment for life or the term of the contract. Liabilities for fixed annuities in a benefit or payout status are based on future estimated payments using established industry mortality tables and interest rates.
The Company’s fixed index annuity product is a fixed annuity that includes an indexed account. The rate of interest credited above the minimum guarantee for funds allocated to the indexed account is linked to the performance of the specific index for the indexed account (subject to a cap). The amount allocated by a contractholder to the indexed account creates an embedded derivative which is measured at fair value.
See Note 14 for additional information regarding the Company’s derivative instruments used to hedge the risk related to indexed accounts.
Insurance Liabilities
Universal life (“UL”) policies accumulate cash value that increases by a fixed interest rate. Purchasers of variable universal life (“VUL”) can select from a variety of investment options and can elect to allocate a portion of their account balance to a fixed account or a separate account. A vast majority of the premiums received for VUL policies are held in separate accounts where the assets are held for the exclusive benefit of those policyholders.
Indexed universal life (“IUL”) is a UL policy that includes an indexed account. The rate of credited interest for funds allocated by a contractholder to the indexed account is linked to the performance of the specific index for the indexed account (subject to stated account parameters, which include a cap and floor, or a spread). The policyholder may allocate all or a portion of the policy value to a fixed or any available indexed account. The amount allocated by a contractholder to the indexed account creates an embedded derivative which is measured at fair value. The Company hedges the interest credited rate including equity and interest rate risk related to the indexed account with freestanding derivative instruments.
See Note 14 for additional information regarding the Company’s derivative instruments used to hedge the risk related to IUL.
The Company also offers term life insurance as well as disability income (“DI”) insurance products. The Company no longer offers standalone long term care (“LTC”) insurance products and whole life insurance but has in force policies from prior years.
Insurance liabilities include accumulation values, incurred but not reported claims, obligations for anticipated future claims, unpaid reported claims and claim adjustment expenses.
The balances of and changes in policyholder account balances were as follows:
Variable AnnuitiesStructured Variable AnnuitiesFixed AnnuitiesFixed Indexed AnnuitiesNon-Life Contingent Payout Annuities
(in millions, except percentages)
Balance at January 1, 2024
$4,173 $10,742 $5,982 $307 $444 
Contract deposits10 955 11 — 30 
Policy charges(3)— — — — 
Surrenders and other benefits(181)(74)(244)(4)(28)
Net transfer from (to) separate account liabilities(7)— — — — 
Variable account index-linked adjustments
— 704 — — — 
Interest credited32 — 52 
Balance at March 31, 2024
$4,024 $12,327 $5,801 $307 $449 
Weighted-average crediting rate3.3 %1.8 %3.6 %2.0 %N/A
Cash surrender value (1)
$3,999 $11,656 $5,794 $278 N/A
Universal Life InsuranceVariable Universal Life InsuranceIndexed Universal Life InsuranceOther Life InsuranceTotal,
All Products
(in millions, except percentages)
Balance at January 1, 2024
$1,474 $1,569 $2,755 $501 $27,947 
Contract deposits29 62 46 — 1,143 
Policy charges(44)(23)(32)— (102)
Surrenders and other benefits(13)(21)(17)(14)(596)
Net transfer from (to) separate account liabilities— (19)— — (26)
Variable account index-linked adjustments
— — — — 704 
Interest credited12 15 37 159 
Balance at March 31, 2024
$1,458 $1,583 $2,789 $491 $29,229 
Weighted-average crediting rate3.6 %3.9 %2.0 %4.0 %
Net amount at risk$8,626 $56,939 $14,215 $139 
Cash surrender value (1)
$1,318 $1,072 $2,315 $319 
Variable AnnuitiesStructured Variable AnnuitiesFixed AnnuitiesFixed Indexed AnnuitiesNon-Life Contingent Payout Annuities
(in millions, except percentages)
Balance at January 1, 2023
$4,752 $6,410 $6,799 $312 $471 
Contract deposits73 3,084 47 — 91 
Policy charges(10)— — — — 
Surrenders and other benefits(759)(156)(1,086)(10)(127)
Net transfer from (to) separate account liabilities(25)— — — — 
Variable account index-linked adjustments
— 1,403 — — — 
Interest credited142 222 
Balance at December 31, 2023
$4,173 $10,742 $5,982 $307 $444 
Weighted-average crediting rate3.3 %1.8 %3.6 %2.0 %N/A
Cash surrender value (1)
$4,146 $10,129 $5,974 $278 N/A
Universal Life InsuranceVariable Universal Life InsuranceIndexed Universal Life InsuranceOther Life InsuranceTotal,
All Products
(in millions, except percentages)
Balance at January 1, 2023
$1,544 $1,520 $2,654 $524 $24,986 
Contract deposits123 272 193 3,884 
Policy charges(176)(94)(121)— (401)
Surrenders and other benefits(69)(78)(53)(44)(2,382)
Net transfer from (to) separate account liabilities— (107)— — (132)
Variable account index-linked adjustments
— — — — 1,403 
Interest credited52 56 82 20 589 
Balance at December 31, 2023
$1,474 $1,569 $2,755 $501 $27,947 
Weighted-average crediting rate3.6 %3.9 %2.0 %4.0 %
Net amount at risk$8,740 $57,291 $14,407 $141 
Cash surrender value (1)
$1,330 $1,065 $2,271 $326 
(1) Cash surrender value represents the amount of the contractholder's account balances distributable at the balance sheet date less certain surrender charges. For variable annuities and VUL, the cash surrender value shown is the proportion of the total cash surrender value related to their fixed account liabilities.
Refer to Note 10 for the net amount at risk for market risk benefits (“MRB”) associated with variable and structured variable annuities. Fixed, fixed indexed, and non-life contingent payout annuities do not have net amount at risk in excess of account value. Net amount at risk for insurance products is calculated as the death benefit amount in excess of applicable account values, host, embedded derivative, and separate account liabilities.
The following tables present the account values of fixed deferred annuities, fixed insurance, and the fixed portion of variable annuities and variable insurance contracts by range of guaranteed minimum interest rates (“GMIRs”) and the range of the difference between rates credited to policyholders and contractholders as of March 31, 2024 and December 31, 2023 and the respective guaranteed minimums, as well as the percentage of account values subject to rate reset in the time period indicated. Rates are reset at management’s discretion, subject to guaranteed minimums.
March 31, 2024
Account Values with Crediting Rates
Range of Guaranteed Minimum Crediting RatesAt Guaranteed Minimum
1-49 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
50-99 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
100-150 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
Greater than 150 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
Total
(in millions, except percentages)
Fixed accounts of variable annuities%1.99%$36 $120 $57 $16 $$231 
%2.99%132 — — — — 132 
%3.99%2,121 — — 2,125 
%5.00%1,480 — — — — 1,480 
Total$3,769 $123 $57 $17 $$3,968 
Fixed accounts of structured variable annuities%1.99%$$22 $$$— $29 
%2.99%11 — — — — 11 
%3.99%— — — — — — 
%5.00%— — — — — — 
Total$12 $22 $$$— $40 
Fixed annuities%1.99%$103 $343 $179 $86 $— $711 
%2.99%31 16 — — — 47 
%3.99%2,697 — — — — 2,697 
%5.00%2,331 — — — — 2,331 
Total$5,162 $359 $179 $86 $— $5,786 
Non-indexed accounts of fixed indexed annuities%1.99%$— $$$14 $— $23 
%2.99%— — — — — — 
%3.99%— — — — — — 
%5.00%— — — — — — 
Total$— $$$14 $— $23 
Universal life insurance%1.99%$— $— $— $— $— $— 
%2.99%50 11 — 65 
%3.99%846 — 854 
%5.00%507 — — — 509 
Total$1,403 $$14 $$$1,428 
Account Values with Crediting Rates
Range of Guaranteed Minimum Crediting RatesAt Guaranteed Minimum
1-49 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
50-99 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
100-150 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
Greater than 150 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
Total
(in millions, except percentages)
Fixed accounts of variable universal life insurance%1.99%$— $$$— $26 $31 
%2.99%12 12 — 33 
%3.99%119 — 131 
%5.00%597 — — — 605 
Total$728 $23 $$$34 $800 
Non-indexed accounts of indexed universal life insurance%1.99%$— $— $$— $— $
%2.99%127 — — — — 127 
%3.99%— — — — — — 
%5.00%— — — — — — 
Total$127 $— $$— $— $129 
Other life insurance%1.99%$— $— $— $— $— $— 
%2.99%— — — — — — 
%3.99%30 — — — — 30 
%5.00%288 — — — — 288 
Total$318 $— $— $— $— $318 
Total%1.99%$140 $488 $253 $118 $28 $1,027 
%2.99%363 31 11 415 
%3.99%5,813 12 — 5,837 
%5.00%5,203 10 — — — 5,213 
Total$11,519 $535 $270 $131 $37 $12,492 
Percentage of total account values that reset in:
Next 12 months100.0 %100.0 %99.5 %100.0 %100.0 %100.0 %
> 12 months to 24 months— — 0.4 — — — 
> 24 months— — 0.1 — — — 
Total100.0 %100.0 %100.0 %100.0 %100.0 %100.0 %
December 31, 2023
Account Values with Crediting Rates
Range of Guaranteed Minimum Crediting RatesAt Guaranteed Minimum
1-49 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
50-99 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
100-150 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
Greater than 150 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
Total
(in millions, except percentages)
Fixed accounts of variable annuities%1.99%$43 $131 $52 $15 $$243 
%2.99%137 — — — 138 
%3.99%2,214 — — — 2,215 
%5.00%1,514 — — — — 1,514 
Total$3,908 $132 $52 $16 $$4,110 
Account Values with Crediting Rates
Range of Guaranteed Minimum Crediting RatesAt Guaranteed Minimum
1-49 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
50-99 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
100-150 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
Greater than 150 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
Total
(in millions, except percentages)
Fixed accounts of structured variable annuities%1.99%$$18 $$$— $28 
%2.99%11 — — — — 11 
%3.99%— — — — — — 
%5.00%— — — — — — 
Total$12 $18 $$$— $39 
Fixed annuities%1.99%$107 $377 $183 $93 $— $760 
%2.99%36 14 — — 51 
%3.99%2,816 — — — 2,817 
%5.00%2,339 — — — — 2,339 
Total$5,298 $392 $184 $93 $— $5,967 
Non-indexed accounts of fixed indexed annuities%1.99%$— $$$13 $— $22 
%2.99%— — — — — — 
%3.99%— — — — — — 
%5.00%— — — — — — 
Total$— $$$13 $— $22 
Universal life insurance%1.99%$— $— $— $— $— $— 
%2.99%51 — — 63 
%3.99%854 — 863 
%5.00%518 — — — 519 
Total$1,423 $$13 $$— $1,445 
Fixed accounts of variable universal life insurance%1.99%$— $$$— $24 $30 
%2.99%13 12 — 34 
%3.99%122 — 133 
%5.00%607 — — — 613 
Total$742 $22 $$$32 $810 
Non-indexed accounts of indexed universal life insurance%1.99%$— $— $$— $— $
%2.99%128 — — — — 128 
%3.99%— — — — — — 
%5.00%— — — — — — 
Total$128 $— $$— $— $130 
Account Values with Crediting Rates
Range of Guaranteed Minimum Crediting RatesAt Guaranteed Minimum
1-49 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
50-99 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
100-150 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
Greater than 150 bps above Guaranteed Minimum
Total
(in millions, except percentages)
Other life insurance%1.99%$— $— $— $— $— $— 
%2.99%— — — — — — 
%3.99%30 — — — — 30 
%5.00%295 — — — — 295 
Total$325 $— $— $— $— $325 
Total%1.99%$151 $530 $255 $123 $26 $1,085 
%2.99%376 30 10 425 
%3.99%6,036 11 — 6,058 
%5.00%5,273 — — — 5,280 
Total$11,836 $571 $272 $135 $34 $12,848 
Percentage of total account values that reset in:
Next 12 months99.9 %99.5 %99.3 %100.0 %100.0 %99.9 %
> 12 months to 24 months0.1 0.5 0.6 — — 0.1 
> 24 months— — 0.1 — — — 
Total100.0 %100.0 %100.0 %100.0 %100.0 %100.0 %
The following tables summarize the balances of and changes in the liability for future policy benefits:
Life Contingent Payout AnnuitiesTerm and Whole Life Insurance
Disability Income Insurance
Long Term Care InsuranceTotal,
All Products
(in millions, except percentages)
Present Value of Expected Net Premiums:
Balance at January 1, 2024
$— $703 $104 $1,146 $1,953 
Beginning balance at original discount rate— 708 105 1,137 1,950 
Effect of changes in cash flow assumptions— — — — — 
Effect of actual variances from expected experience— (2)(4)(3)(9)
Adjusted beginning of year balance$— $706 $101 $1,134 $1,941 
Issuances60 16 — 78 
Interest accrual— 14 24 
Net premiums collected(60)(18)(2)(37)(117)
Derecognition (lapses)— — — — — 
Ending balance at original discount rate$— $713 $102 $1,111 $1,926 
Effect of changes in discount rate assumptions— (18)(3)(6)(27)
Balance at March 31, 2024
$— $695 $99 $1,105 $1,899 
Present Value of Future Policy Benefits:
Balance at January 1, 2024
$1,164 $1,325 $661 $6,561 $9,711 
Beginning balance at original discount rate1,222 1,291 621 6,507 9,641 
Effect of changes in cash flow assumptions— — — — — 
Effect of actual variances from expected experience(2)(2)(6)(6)(16)
Adjusted beginning of year balance$1,220 $1,289 $615 $6,501 $9,625 
Issuances60 16 — 78 
Interest accrual14 18 81 122 
Benefit payments(39)(34)(10)(104)(187)
Derecognition (lapses)— — — — — 
Ending balance at original discount rate$1,255 $1,289 $616 $6,478 $9,638 
Effect of changes in discount rate assumptions(75)26 (83)(126)
Balance at March 31, 2024
$1,180 $1,295 $642 $6,395 $9,512 
Adjustment due to reserve flooring$— $$— $— $
Net liability for future policy benefits$1,180 $606 $543 $5,290 $7,619 
Less: reinsurance recoverable845 428 21 2,675 3,969 
Net liability for future policy benefits, after reinsurance recoverable$335 $178 $522 $2,615 $3,650 
Discounted expected future gross premiums$— $1,713 $879 $1,279 $3,871 
Expected future gross premiums$— $2,909 $1,250 $1,740 $5,899 
Expected future benefit payments$1,786 $2,163 $1,054 $10,741 $15,744 
Weighted average interest accretion rate4.4 %6.3 %6.3 %5.1 %
Weighted average discount rate5.2 %5.3 %5.4 %5.4 %
Weighted average duration of liability (in years)7788
Life Contingent Payout AnnuitiesTerm and Whole Life Insurance
Disability Income Insurance
Long Term Care InsuranceTotal,
All Products
(in millions, except percentages)
Present Value of Expected Net Premiums:
Balance at January 1, 2023
$— $686 $134 $1,207 $2,027 
Beginning balance at original discount rate— 708 137 1,220 2,065 
Effect of changes in cash flow assumptions— (19)(19)19 (19)
Effect of actual variances from expected experience— (2)(18)(3)(23)
Adjusted beginning of year balance$— $687 $100 $1,236 $2,023 
Issuances177 55 12 — 244 
Interest accrual36 59 101 
Net premiums collected(178)(70)(12)(158)(418)
Derecognition (lapses)— — — — — 
Ending balance at original discount rate$— $708 $105 $1,137 $1,950 
Effect of changes in discount rate assumptions— (5)(1)
Balance at December 31, 2023
$— $703 $104 $1,146 $1,953 
Present Value of Future Policy Benefits:
Balance at January 1, 2023
$1,065 $1,319 $696 $6,439 $9,519 
Beginning balance at original discount rate1,155 1,313 669 6,569 9,706 
Effect of changes in cash flow assumptions— (18)(25)(34)
Effect of actual variances from expected experience(10)(1)(29)(35)
Adjusted beginning of year balance$1,145 $1,294 $615 $6,583 $9,637 
Issuances177 56 11 — 244 
Interest accrual50 73 37 329 489 
Benefit payments(150)(132)(42)(405)(729)
Derecognition (lapses)— — — — — 
Ending balance at original discount rate$1,222 $1,291 $621 $6,507 $9,641 
Effect of changes in discount rate assumptions(58)34 40 54 70 
Balance at December 31, 2023
$1,164 $1,325 $661 $6,561 $9,711 
Adjustment due to reserve flooring$— $$— $— $
Net liability for future policy benefits$1,164 $627 $557 $5,415 $7,763 
Less: reinsurance recoverable880 440 22 2,738 4,080 
Net liability for future policy benefits, after reinsurance recoverable$284 $187 $535 $2,677 $3,683 
Discounted expected future gross premiums$— $1,764 $904 $1,325 $3,993 
Expected future gross premiums$— $2,938 $1,269 $1,786 $5,993 
Expected future benefit payments$1,726 $2,166 $1,068 $10,850 $15,810 
Weighted average interest accretion rate4.2 %6.2 %6.1 %5.0 %
Weighted average discount rate4.9 %5.1 %5.1 %5.1 %
Weighted average duration of liability (in years)7788
Impacts of the annual review of policy benefit reserves assumptions are reflected within the effect of changes in cash flow assumptions in the disaggregated rollforwards above. The annual review of policy benefit reserves assumptions in the third quarter of 2023 resulted in a net decrease in future policy benefit reserves, primarily due to updates to LTC premium rate increase assumptions.
The balances of and changes in additional liabilities related to insurance guarantees were as follows:
Universal Life InsuranceVariable Universal Life InsuranceOther Life InsuranceTotal,
All Products
(in millions, except percentages)
Balance at January 1, 2024
$1,225 $81 $15 $1,321 
Interest accrual— 10 
Benefit accrual33 36 
Benefit payments(13)(3)(1)(17)
Effect of actual variances from expected experience(3)— — (3)
Impact of change in net unrealized (gains) losses on securities(9)— (2)(11)
Balance at March 31, 2024
$1,242 $81 $13 $1,336 
Weighted average interest accretion rate3.0 %7.1 %3.9 %
Weighted average discount rate3.2 %7.1 %4.0 %
Weighted average duration of reserves (in years)1086
Universal Life InsuranceVariable Universal Life InsuranceOther Life InsuranceTotal,
All Products
(in millions, except percentages)
Balance at January 1, 2023
$1,100 $74 $12 $1,186 
Interest accrual35 41 
Benefit accrual128 138 
Benefit payments(50)(18)(4)(72)
Effect of actual variances from expected experience(13)11 (2)(4)
Impact of change in net unrealized (gains) losses on securities25 32 
Balance at December 31, 2023
$1,225 $81 $15 $1,321 
Weighted average interest accretion rate3.0 %6.9 %4.0 %
Weighted average discount rate3.2 %7.1 %4.0 %
Weighted average duration of reserves (in years)1086
The amount of revenue and interest recognized in the Statements of Operations was as follows:
Three Months Ended March 31,
2024
Gross PremiumsInterest Expense
(in millions)
Life contingent payout annuities$66 $14 
Term and whole life insurance42 
Disability income insurance
30 
Long term care insurance44 67 
Total$182 $98 
Year Ended December 31,
2023
Gross PremiumsInterest Expense
(in millions)
Life contingent payout annuities$196 $49 
Term and whole life insurance169 37 
Disability income insurance
124 32 
Long term care insurance185 270 
Total$674 $388 
The following tables summarize the balances of and changes in unearned revenue:
Universal Life InsuranceVariable Universal Life InsuranceIndexed Universal Life InsuranceTotal,
All Products
(in millions)
Balance at January 1, 2024
$27 $196 $266 $489 
Deferral of revenue— 16 13 29 
Amortization— (4)(5)(9)
Balance at March 31, 2024
$27 $208 $274 $509 
Balance at January 1, 2023
$27 $150 $233 $410 
Deferral of revenue59 52 112 
Amortization(1)(13)(19)(33)
Balance at December 31, 2023
$27 $196 $266 $489 
Market Risk Benefits
Market risk benefits are contracts or contract features that both provide protection to the contractholder from other-than-nominal capital market risk and expose the Company to other-than-nominal capital market risk. Most of the variable annuity contracts issued by the Company contain a GMDB provision. The Company previously offered contracts containing GMWB, GMAB, or GMIB provisions.
The GMDB provisions provide a specified minimum return upon death of the contractholder. The death benefit payable is the greater of (i) the contract value less any purchase payment credits subject to recapture less a pro-rata portion of any rider fees, or (ii) the GMDB provisions specified in the contract. The Company has the following primary GMDB provisions:
Return of premium — provides purchase payments minus adjusted partial surrenders.
Reset — provides that the value resets to the account value at specified contract anniversary intervals minus adjusted partial surrenders. This provision was often provided in combination with the return of premium provision and is no longer offered.
Ratchet — provides that the value ratchets up to the maximum account value at specified anniversary intervals, plus subsequent purchase payments less adjusted partial surrenders.
The variable annuity contracts with GMWB riders typically have account values that are based on an underlying portfolio of mutual funds, the values of which fluctuate based on fund performance. At contract issue, the guaranteed amount is equal to the amount deposited but the guarantee may be increased annually to the account value (a “step-up”) in the case of favorable market performance or by a benefit credit if the contract includes this provision.
The Company has GMWB riders in force, which contain one or more of the following provisions:
Withdrawals at a specified rate per year until the amount withdrawn is equal to the guaranteed amount.
Withdrawals at a specified rate per year for the life of the contractholder (“GMWB for life”).
Withdrawals at a specified rate per year for joint contractholders while either is alive.
Withdrawals based on performance of the contract.
Withdrawals based on the age withdrawals begin.
Credits are applied annually for a specified number of years to increase the guaranteed amount as long as withdrawals have not been taken.
Variable annuity contractholders age 79 or younger at contract issue could obtain a principal-back guarantee by purchasing the optional GMAB rider for an additional charge. The GMAB rider guarantees that, regardless of market performance at the end of the 10-year waiting period, the contract value will be no less than the original investment or a specified percentage of the highest anniversary value, adjusted for withdrawals. If the contract value is less than the guarantee at the end of the 10-year period, a lump sum will be added to the contract value to make the contract value equal to the guarantee value.
Individual variable annuity contracts may have both a death benefit and a living benefit. Net amount at risk is quantified for each benefit and a composite net amount at risk is calculated using the greater of the death benefit or living benefit for each individual contract. The net amount at risk for GMDB and GMAB is defined as the current guaranteed benefit amount in excess of the current contract value. The net amount at risk for GMIB is defined as the greater of the present value of the minimum guaranteed annuity payments less the current contract value or zero. The net amount at risk for GMWB is defined as the greater of the present value of the minimum guaranteed withdrawal payments less the current contract value or zero.
The following tables summarize the balances of and changes in market risk benefits:
Three Months Ended March 31,
2024
2023
(in millions, except age)
Balance at beginning of period$335 $1,103 
Issuances
Interest accrual and time decay(10)(26)
Reserve increase from attributed fees collected184 189 
Reserve release for benefit payments and derecognition(4)(9)
Effect of changes in interest rates and bond markets(527)504 
Effect of changes in equity markets and subaccount performance(730)(392)
Effect of changes in equity index volatility39 (43)
Actual policyholder behavior different from expected behavior31 
Effect of changes in the instrument-specific credit risk on market risk benefits48 (204)
Balance at end of period$(629)$1,133 
Reconciliation of the gross balances in an asset or liability position:
Asset position$1,964 $990 
Liability position(1,335)(2,123)
Net asset (liability) position$629 $(1,133)
Guaranteed benefit amount in excess of current account balances (net amount at risk):
Death benefits$578 $1,956 
Living benefits$2,233 $2,836 
Composite (greater of)$2,735 $4,596 
Weighted average attained age of contractholders6968
Changes in unrealized (gains) losses in net income relating to liabilities held at end of period $(1,202)$59 
Changes in unrealized (gains) losses in other comprehensive income relating to liabilities held at end of period $48 $(204)
Year Ended December 31,
2023
(in millions, except age)
Balance at beginning of period$1,103 
Issuances17 
Interest accrual and time decay(53)
Reserve increase from attributed fees collected788 
Reserve release for benefit payments and derecognition(35)
Effect of changes in interest rates and bond markets(367)
Effect of changes in equity markets and subaccount performance(1,267)
Effect of changes in equity index volatility(67)
Actual policyholder behavior different from expected behavior
Effect of changes in other future expected assumptions128 
Effect of changes in the instrument-specific credit risk on market risk benefits83 
Balance at end of period$335 
Reconciliation of the gross balances in an asset or liability position:
Asset position$1,427 
Liability position(1,762)
Net asset (liability) position$(335)
Guaranteed benefit amount in excess of current account balances (net amount at risk):
Death benefits$913 
Living benefits$2,513 
Composite (greater of)$3,308 
Weighted average attained age of contractholders69
Changes in unrealized (gains) losses in net income relating to liabilities held at end of period $(1,551)
Changes in unrealized (gains) losses in other comprehensive income relating to liabilities held at end of period$84 
The following tables provide a summary of the significant inputs and assumptions used in the fair value measurements developed by the Company or reasonably available to the Company of market risk benefits:
March 31, 2024
Fair ValueValuation TechniqueSignificant Inputs and AssumptionsRangeWeighted
 Average
(in millions)
Market risk benefits$(629)Discounted cash flow
Utilization of guaranteed withdrawals (1)
0.0%48.0%11.6%
Surrender rate (2)
0.3%75.0%3.6%
Market volatility (3)
0.0%25.2%10.5%
Nonperformance risk (4)
75 bps75 bps
Mortality rate (5)
0.0%41.6%1.6%
December 31, 2023
Fair ValueValuation TechniqueSignificant Inputs and AssumptionsRangeWeighted
 Average
(in millions)
Market risk benefits$335 Discounted cash flow
Utilization of guaranteed withdrawals (1)
0.0%48.0%11.6%
Surrender rate (2)
0.3%75.0%3.7%
Market volatility (3)
0.0%25.2%10.6%
Nonperformance risk (4)
85 bps85 bps
Mortality rate (5)
0.0%41.6%1.6%
(1) The utilization of guaranteed withdrawals represents the percentage of contractholders that will begin withdrawing in any given year. The weighted average utilization rate represents the average assumption, weighted based on the benefit base. The calculation excludes policies that have already started taking withdrawals.
(2) The weighted average surrender rate represents the average assumption weighted based on the account value of each contract.
(3) Market volatility represents the implied volatility of each contractholder’s mix of funds. The weighted average market volatility represents the average volatility across all contracts, weighted by the size of the guaranteed benefit.
(4) The nonperformance risk is the spread added to the U.S. Treasury curve.
(5) The weighted average mortality rate represents the average assumption weighted based on the account value of each contract.
Changes to Significant Inputs and Assumptions:
During the year ended December 31, 2023, the Company updated inputs and assumptions based on management’s review of experience studies. These updates resulted in the following notable changes in the fair value estimates of market risk benefits calculations:
Year ended December 31, 2023
Updates to utilization of guaranteed withdrawals assumptions resulted in a decrease to pre-tax income of $18 million.
Updates to surrender assumptions resulted in a decrease to pre-tax income of $110 million.
Refer to the rollforward of market risk benefits for the impacts of changes to interest rate, equity market, volatility and nonperformance risk assumptions.
Uncertainty of Fair Value Measurements
Significant increases (decreases) in utilization and volatility used in the fair value measurement of market risk benefits in isolation would have resulted in a significantly higher (lower) liability value.
Significant increases (decreases) in nonperformance risk and surrender assumptions used in the fair value measurement of market risk benefits in isolation would have resulted in a significantly lower (higher) liability value.
Significant increases (decreases) in mortality assumptions used in the fair value measurement of the death benefit portion of market risk benefits in isolation would have resulted in a significantly higher (lower) liability value whereas significant increases (decreases) in mortality rates used in the fair value measurement of the life contingent portion of market risk benefits in isolation would have resulted in a significantly lower (higher) liability value.
Surrender assumptions, utilization assumptions and mortality assumptions vary with the type of base product, type of rider, duration of the policy, age of the contractholder, calendar year of the projection, previous withdrawal history, and the relationship between the value of the guaranteed benefit and the contract accumulation value.
Determination of Fair Value
The Company values market risk benefits using internal valuation models. These models include observable capital market assumptions and significant unobservable inputs related to implied volatility, contractholder behavior assumptions that include margins for risk, and the Company’s nonperformance risk. These measurements are classified as Level 3.