UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
WASHINGTON, DC 20549
FORM 8-K
CURRENT REPORT PURSUANT
TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE
SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
Date of report (Date of earliest event reported): September 20, 2013
COMMONWEALTH REIT
(Exact Name of Registrant as Specified in Its Charter)
Maryland
(State or Other Jurisdiction of Incorporation)
1-9317 |
|
04-6558834 |
(Commission File Number) |
|
(IRS Employer Identification No.) |
|
|
|
Two Newton Place, 255 Washington Street, |
|
02458-1634 |
(Address of Principal Executive Offices) |
|
(Zip Code) |
(617) 332-3990
(Registrants Telephone Number, Including Area Code)
Check the appropriate box below if the Form 8-K filing is intended to simultaneously satisfy the filing obligation of the registrant under any of the following provisions:
o Written communications pursuant to Rule 425 under the Securities Act (17 CFR 230.425)
o Soliciting material pursuant to Rule 14a-12 under the Exchange Act (17 CFR 240.14a-12)
o Pre-commencement communications pursuant to Rule 14d-2(b) under the Exchange Act (17 CFR 240.14d-2(b))
o Pre-commencement communications pursuant to Rule 13e-4(c) under the Exchange Act (17 CFR 240.13e-4(c))
In this Current Report on Form 8-K, the terms we, us and our refer to CommonWealth REIT.
Item 1.01. Entry into a Material Definitive Agreement.
On September 20, 2013, we and Reit Management & Research LLC (RMR) agreed to amend our business management agreement to restructure the base business management and incentive fees paid to RMR under the agreement beginning on January 1, 2014 as described in the summary attached hereto as Exhibit 10.1 and incorporated herein by reference. Our Compensation Committee has directed that a definitive revised business management agreement giving effect to this restructuring be provided to it for final approval in connection with the Committees consideration later this year of the renewal of RMRs engagement as our manager. A copy of our press release dated September 23, 2013 announcing this agreement to restructure these fees is attached as Exhibit 99.1 hereto and incorporated herein by reference.
Item 5.03. Amendments to Articles of Incorporation or Bylaws; Change in Fiscal Year.
On September 20, 2013, our Board of Trustees approved an amendment to our Amended and Restated Bylaws (as amended, our Bylaws) to require that shareholder nominations and shareholder proposals of other business for consideration at our 2014 annual meeting of shareholders must be submitted to our secretary in accordance with the requirements of our Bylaws not later than 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time on January 10, 2014 and not earlier than December 11, 2013. If, however, our 2014 annual meeting is called for a date that is more than 30 days earlier or later than May 14, 2014, then a shareholders notice of such a proposal must be so delivered not later than 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time on the tenth day following the earlier of the day on which (1) notice of the date of our 2014 annual meeting is mailed or otherwise made available or (2) public announcement of the date of our 2014 annual meeting is first made by us. Prior to this amendment, our Bylaws required that such nominations and proposals be submitted to our secretary not later than 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time on October 28, 2013 and not earlier than September 28, 2013. The foregoing description of the amendment to our Bylaws is not complete and is subject to and qualified in its entirety by reference to the amendment to our Bylaws, a copy of which is attached as Exhibit 3.1, and which amendment is incorporated herein by reference.
Item 8.01. Other Events.
On September 23, 2013, we also announced our intention to implement certain governance changes and the dismissal with prejudice of the derivative claim in the pending arbitration proceeding with Corvex Management LP and Related Fund Management, LLC, each as further described in the attached press release. Copies of the press release and order dismissing the derivative claim are attached as Exhibit 99.1 and Exhibit 99.2, respectively, to this Current Report on Form 8-K and are incorporated herein by reference.
Item 9.01. Financial Statements and Exhibits.
(d) Exhibits.
3.1 Amendment to Amended and Restated Bylaws dated September 20, 2013
10.1 Overview of Restructuring of Business Management Agreement with Reit Management & Research LLC dated September 20, 2013
99.1 Press Release dated September 23, 2013
99.2 Order Dismissing Derivative Claim With Prejudice dated September 19, 2013
SIGNATURES
Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the registrant has duly caused this report to be signed on its behalf by the undersigned hereunto duly authorized.
|
COMMONWEALTH REIT | |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
By: |
/s/ John C. Popeo |
|
Name: |
John C. Popeo |
|
Title: |
Treasurer and Chief Financial Officer |
Date: September 26, 2013
Exhibit 3.1
AMENDMENT TO
AMENDED AND RESTATED BYLAWS
OF
COMMONWEALTH REIT
September 20, 2013
The second sentence of the first paragraph of Article II, Section 2.14.1(d) of the Amended and Restated Bylaws of CommonWealth REIT dated as of April 12, 2013 is hereby amended by the addition of the words (A) in the case of the annual meeting held in 2014, not later than 5:00 p.m. (Eastern Time) on January 10, 2014 nor earlier than December 11, 2013, and (B) otherwise, immediately after the phrase principal executive offices of the Trust as shown below:
To be timely, the notice of such shareholder(s) shall set forth all information required under this Section 2.14.1 and shall be delivered to the secretary at the principal executive offices of the Trust (A) in the case of the annual meeting held in 2014, not later than 5:00 p.m. (Eastern Time) on January 10, 2014 nor earlier than December 11, 2013, and (B) otherwise, not later than 5:00 p.m. (Eastern Time) on the 120th day nor earlier than the 150th day prior to the first anniversary of the date of the proxy statement for the preceding years annual meeting; provided, however, that in the event that the annual meeting is called for a date that is more than 30 days earlier or later than the first anniversary of the date of the preceding years annual meeting, notice by such shareholder(s) to be timely shall be so delivered not later than 5:00 p.m. (Eastern Time) on the 10th day following the earlier of the day on which (i) notice of the date of the annual meeting is mailed or otherwise made available or (ii) public announcement of the date of the annual meeting is first made by the Trust.
Exhibit 10.1
Overview of Restructuring of Business Management Agreement with Reit Management & Research LLC (RMR)
CommonWealth REIT (CWH) and RMR have agreed to restructure the fees payable to RMR under the Business Management Agreement as follows:
· The base business management fees paid by CWH to RMR, which are included in CWHs G&A expenses, are currently calculated at the annual rate of approximately 0.5% of the gross historical cost of CWHs real estate assets. Beginning in 2014, these fees will be calculated on the basis of the lower of: (i) gross historical cost of CWHs U.S. real estate assets or (ii) CWHs total market capitalization. Market capitalization will include the market value of CWHs common shares, plus the liquidation preference of preferred shares and the principal amount of debt. The market value of CWHs common shares will be calculated based on the average shares outstanding multiplied by the average closing share price during the period in which the fees are earned.
· Beginning in 2014, 10% of the base business management fees will be paid in common shares of CWH. The amount of CWH common shares granted as part of the base business management fee will be calculated based on the average closing share price during the period in which the fees are earned.
· Annual incentive fees payable by CWH to RMR included in CWHs G&A expenses are currently calculated based upon increases in funds from operations (FFO) per share and are paid in common shares of CWH which vest immediately. Beginning in 2014, the incentive fees which may be earned by RMR will be calculated based upon total returns realized by CWH common shareholders (i.e., share price appreciation plus dividends) in excess of benchmarks. The benchmarks will be set by the Compensation Committee of CWHs Board (which is comprised solely of Independent Trustees) and will be disclosed in CWHs annual meeting proxy statements. Incentive fees will be paid in common shares of CWH which will vest over a multiyear period and will be subject to a claw back in the event of certain material restatements of financial results. The terms of the incentive fee, including among other things, the measurement periods, targets and benchmarks are to be developed and set by the Compensation Committee.
· The annual management fee for foreign assets will be unchanged.
CWHs Compensation Committee has directed that a definitive revised Business Management Agreement giving effect to the above restructuring be provided to it for final approval in connection with the Committees consideration later this year of the renewal of RMRs engagement as CWHs manager.
Exhibit 99.1
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
|
Contact: |
|
Timothy A. Bonang, Vice President, Investor Relations |
|
(617) 796-8222 |
|
www.cwhreit.com |
CommonWealth REIT Announces Restructuring of Management Agreement with RMR and Significant Governance Enhancements
Further Aligning Interests of RMR with CWH Shareholders While Maintaining Low Cost Structure; Increasing Independence of CWH Board; Recommending Annual Election of All Trustees; Terminating Poison Pill
Arbitration Panel Dismisses Corvex/Related Claims for Damages Against CWH Trustees
Newton, MA (September 23, 2013): CommonWealth REIT (NYSE: CWH) today announced the restructuring of its management agreement with Reit Management & Research LLC (RMR) and several significant governance enhancements.
Restructuring of Management Agreement with RMR.
CWH and RMR have agreed to restructure their business management agreement as follows:
· The base business management fees paid by CWH to RMR, which are included in CWHs G&A expenses, are currently calculated at the annual rate of approximately 0.5% of the gross historical cost of CWHs real estate assets. Beginning in 2014, these fees will be calculated on the basis of the lower of: (i) gross historical cost of CWHs real estate assets or (ii) CWHs total market capitalization. Market capitalization will include the market value of CWHs common shares, plus the liquidation preference of preferred shares and the principal amount of debt. The market value of CWHs common shares will be calculated based on the average shares outstanding multiplied by the average closing share price during the period in which the fees are earned. Accordingly, CWHs fees paid to RMR may decline when the market value of CWHs common shares declines.
· All of the base business management fees currently paid by CWH to RMR are paid in cash. Beginning in 2014, 10% of the base business management fees will be paid in common shares of CWH. The amount of CWH common shares granted as part of the base business management fee will be calculated based on the average closing share price during the period in which the fees are earned. Accordingly, RMRs common share ownership of CWH is expected to increase over time.
· Annual incentive fees payable by CWH to RMR included in CWHs G&A expenses are currently calculated based upon increases in funds from operations (FFO) per share and are paid in common shares of CWH which vest immediately. Beginning in 2014, the incentive fees which may be earned by RMR will be calculated based upon total returns realized by CWH common shareholders (i.e., share price appreciation plus dividends) in excess of benchmarks. The benchmarks will be set by the Compensation Committee of CWHs Board (which is comprised solely of Independent Trustees) and will be disclosed in CWHs annual meeting proxy statements. Incentive fees will be paid in common shares of CWH which will vest over a multiyear period and will be subject to a claw back in the event of certain material restatements of financial results. Accordingly, the incentive fees payable to RMR are expected to have a direct relationship to total returns realized by CWH common shareholders.
Changing Board of Trustees.
The CWH Board of Trustees intends to increase the size of the CWH Board from its current five members and to increase the ratio of Independent Trustees to total Trustees from the current 60% to at least 75%. The Nominating & Governance Committee of CWHs Board (which is comprised solely of Independent Trustees) has retained the services of the executive search firm Korn / Ferry International to help identify potential Independent Trustee candidates. The CWH Board also anticipates that the Independent Trustees of the expanded Board will designate a Lead Independent Trustee soon after the new Trustees join the Board.
Recommending Annual Election of All Trustees.
The CWH Board of Trustees has determined to recommend to shareholders that CWHs Declaration of Trust be amended to permit the annual election of all Trustees. CWHs Trustees currently serve staggered, three year terms. The proposed amendment to CWHs Declaration of Trust will be presented to CWHs shareholders at CWHs next annual shareholders meeting following resolution of the pending disputes with Corvex Management LP, Related Fund Management, LLC and certain of their affiliates (Corvex/Related). If this amendment is approved by CWHs shareholders, all Trustees will thereafter be elected for one year terms.
Terminating Poison Pill.
The CWH Board of Trustees has determined to accelerate the expiration of CWHs shareholders rights plan (the poison pill), which currently expires on October 17, 2014, to a date soon after resolution of the pending disputes with Corvex/Related.
Arbitration Panel Dismisses Corvex/Related Claims for Damages Against CWH Trustees.
Among the various claims asserted by Corvex/Related in the pending arbitration proceedings were claims for money damages against CWHs Trustees for breaches of fiduciary duty by employing RMR. After the expert reports were exchanged which evaluated the quality and costs of RMRs historical services to CWH, and at the request of Corvex/Related, the Arbitration Panel ordered that these claims be dismissed with prejudice. An evidentiary hearing before the Arbitration Panel regarding remaining matters currently in the dispute between Corvex/Related and CWH is scheduled to begin on October 7, 2013.
Other Matters.
In order to implement certain changes announced today and to provide shareholders additional time to consider these matters, and considering the current schedule of the Corvex/Related arbitration proceedings, the CWH Board has amended CWHs Bylaws so that the 30 day period during which qualified shareholders may present Trustee nominations and proposals of other business for consideration at CWHs 2014 Annual Meeting will now commence on December 11, 2013 and will end at 5:00 p.m. (Eastern Time) on January 10, 2014 (rather than commencing on September 28, 2013 and ending on October 28, 2013, as previously required).
CWHs Independent Trustees issued the following joint statement regarding todays announcements:
During the past several weeks, the Board and management of CWH have had numerous conversations with shareholders. Historically, CWHs Board and management have focused on providing high quality management services to CWH at or below average costs. Nonetheless, a persistent theme of our recent conversations with shareholders has been that CWH should further align RMRs financial incentives with the returns realized by shareholders and enhance its governance. The changes announced today are intended to address these concerns, while allowing CWH shareholders to continue receiving high quality management services at or below average costs.
None of the changes announced today affect the business plan that CWH has been implementing over the last several years, which includes focusing the Companys portfolio towards high quality office buildings in central business district (CBD) locations and divesting non-core suburban properties. The Board and management continue to execute this business plan and believe it will result in enhanced value for all CWH shareholders.
CommonWealth REIT is a real estate investment trust (REIT) that primarily owns office properties located throughout the United States. CWH is headquartered in Newton, MA.
WARNING CONCERNING FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS
THIS PRESS RELEASE CONTAINS STATEMENTS THAT CONSTITUTE FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE PRIVATE SECURITIES LITIGATION REFORM ACT OF 1995 AND OTHER SECURITIES LAWS. ALSO, WHENEVER CWH USES WORDS SUCH AS BELIEVE, EXPECT, ANTICIPATE, INTEND, PLAN, ESTIMATE OR SIMILAR EXPRESSIONS, CWH IS MAKING FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS. THESE FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS ARE BASED UPON CWHS PRESENT INTENT, BELIEFS AND EXPECTATIONS, BUT FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS ARE NOT GUARANTEED TO OCCUR AND MAY NOT OCCUR. ACTUAL RESULTS MAY DIFFER MATERIALLY FROM THOSE CONTAINED IN OR IMPLIED BY THESE FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS AS A RESULT OF VARIOUS FACTORS. FOR EXAMPLE:
· THIS PRESS RELEASE STATES THAT FUTURE INCENTIVE FEES PAYABLE TO RMR ARE EXPECTED TO HAVE A DIRECT RELATIONSHIP TO TOTAL RETURNS REALIZED BY CWH
COMMON SHAREHOLDERS. AN IMPLICATION OF THIS STATEMENT MAY BE THAT SHAREHOLDERS WILL RECEIVE INCREASED TOTAL RETURNS. IN FACT, FUTURE TOTAL RETURNS REALIZED BY SHAREHOLDERS WILL BE IMPACTED BY MANY FACTORS, INCLUDING SOME BEYOND CWHS AND RMRS CONTROL. FOR EXAMPLE, THE TOTAL RETURNS REALIZED BY SHAREHOLDERS ARE DEPENDENT UPON THE CHANGES IN THE TRADING PRICE OF CWH SHARES WHICH MAY REFLECT CHANGES IN INTEREST RATES, THE EXPECTATION OF FUTURE INTEREST RATE CHANGES OR OTHER GENERAL MARKET CONDITIONS. ACCORDINGLY, THERE CAN BE NO ASSURANCE THAT THE CHANGES IN THE METHOD OF CALCULATING THE INCENTIVE FEES PAID BY CWH TO RMR WILL INCREASE THE TOTAL RETURNS REALIZED BY CWH COMMON SHAREHOLDERS.
· THIS PRESS RELEASE IMPLIES THAT CWHS HISTORICAL AND FUTURE G&A COSTS HAVE BEEN, AND WILL BE, AT OR BELOW THE AVERAGE OF SUCH COSTS AMONG ITS PEER GROUP. CALCULATING THE RELATIVE COSTS OF G&A SERVICES CAN BE DONE IN MANY DIFFERENT WAYS; FOR EXAMPLE, IN ACTUAL DOLLAR AMOUNTS, AS A PERCENTAGE OF ASSETS VALUED AT COST OR BOOK VALUES, AS A PERCENTAGE OF BOOK OR MARKET EQUITY VALUES, AS A PERCENTAGE OF REVENUES, OR OTHERWISE. CWH BELIEVES THAT ITS STATEMENTS ARE BASED UPON CUSTOMARY CALCULATIONS USED IN THE REIT INDUSTRY TO COMPARE G&A COSTS BASED ON FINANCIAL STATEMENT METRICS. HOWEVER, DEPENDING UPON HOW RELATIVE G&A COSTS ARE CALCULATED, IT MAY BE POSSIBLE TO ARGUE THAT CWHS HISTORICAL AND FUTURE G&A COSTS ARE NOT, AND WILL NOT BE, AT OR BELOW AVERAGE.
· THIS PRESS RELEASE STATES THAT THE CWH BOARD OF TRUSTEES PLANS TO INCREASE THE SIZE OF THE BOARD AND TO INCREASE THE RATIO OF INDEPENDENT TRUSTEES TO TOTAL TRUSTEES FROM THE CURRENT 60% TO AT LEAST 75%. BECAUSE OF THE UNCERTAINTIES CREATED BY THE EFFORTS OF CORVEX/RELATED TO REMOVE THE ENTIRE CWH BOARD AND THE ASSOCIATED LITIGATION AND ARBITRATION IN WHICH THE CWH TRUSTEES ARE NOW ENGAGED, CHANGES IN THE CURRENT BOARD MAY NOT BE POSSIBLE OR PRACTICAL UNTIL RESOLUTION OF THE PENDING DISPUTES WITH CORVEX/RELATED. AS A RESULT, IT MAY TAKE A PROLONGED PERIOD OF TIME TO IMPLEMENT SOME OR ALL OF THESE CHANGES TO THE CWH BOARD.
· THIS PRESS RELEASE STATES THAT, AFTER THE RESOLUTION OF THE PENDING DISPUTES WITH CORVEX/RELATED, CWHS BOARD HAS DETERMINED TO RECOMMEND TO SHAREHOLDERS THAT CWHS DECLARATION OF TRUST BE AMENDED TO PROVIDE THAT ALL TRUSTEES BE ELECTED TO SERVE FOR ONE YEAR TERMS. THIS AMENDMENT MAY NOT BE APPROVED BY CWHS SHAREHOLDERS. ALSO, ALTHOUGH CWHS BOARD HAS NO CURRENT INTENTION TO DO SO, CWHS BOARD MAY DETERMINE IN THE FUTURE NOT TO PROCEED WITH A PROPOSAL TO SHAREHOLDERS TO PROVIDE THAT ALL TRUSTEES BE ELECTED TO SERVE FOR ONE YEAR TERMS.
· THIS PRESS RELEASE STATES THAT CWHS BOARD INTENDS TO ACCELERATE THE EXPIRATION OF CWHS SHAREHOLDERS RIGHTS PLAN (THE POISON PILL) AFTER THE RESOLUTION OF THE PENDING DISPUTES WITH CORVEX/RELATED. UNDER APPLICABLE LAW, THE CWH BOARD HAS THE POWER TO CREATE, AMEND, EXTEND OR TERMINATE A SHAREHOLDERS RIGHTS PLAN. ALTHOUGH CWHS BOARD HAS NO CURRENT INTENTION TO DO SO, CWHS BOARD MAY DETERMINE IN THE FUTURE NOT TO ACCELERATE THE EXPIRATION OF THE PLAN OR TO ADOPT A NEW SHAREHOLDERS RIGHTS PLAN AFTER THE CURRENT PLAN EXPIRES.
· THIS PRESS RELEASE STATES THAT AFTER THE EXPERT REPORTS WERE EXCHANGED WHICH EVALUATED THE QUALITY AND COSTS OF THE RMR SERVICES TO CWH, AND AT THE REQUEST OF CORVEX/RELATED, THE ARBITRATION PANEL HEARING THE DISPUTES BETWEEN CORVEX/RELATED AND CWHS TRUSTEES ORDERED CLAIMS BY CORVEX/RELATED FOR MONEY DAMAGES FOR BREACHES OF FIDUCIARY DUTY AGAINST CWHS TRUSTEES BE DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE. AN IMPLICATION OF THESE STATEMENTS MAY BE THAT OTHER CLAIMS IN THE PENDING ARBITRATION WILL BE DECIDED IN FAVOR OF CWH AND THE CWH TRUSTEES. DISCOVERY AND OTHER ACTIVITIES DURING LITIGATION AND ARBITRATION PROCEEDINGS SOMETIMES PRODUCE UNEXPECTED RESULTS. CWH CANNOT PROVIDE ANY ASSURANCES REGARDING THE OUTCOME OF THE PENDING ARBITRATION PROCEEDINGS. ALSO, OTHER SHAREHOLDERS HAVE BROUGHT LITIGATION AGAINST THE CWH TRUSTEES, WHICH LITIGATION REMAINS PENDING IN SEVERAL COURTS AND IN ARBITRATION PROCEEDINGS; CWH CAN PROVIDE NO ASSURANCES REGARDING THE OUTCOME OF THESE OTHER SIMILAR LITIGATIONS AND ARBITRATIONS.
· THIS PRESS RELEASE STATES THAT THE CWH BOARD AND MANAGEMENT ARE CONTINUING TO IMPLEMENT THE BUSINESS PLAN OF FOCUSING THE COMPANYS PORTFOLIO TOWARD HIGH QUALITY OFFICE BUILDINGS IN CENTRAL BUSINESS DISTRICT LOCATIONS AND DIVESTING NON-CORE SUBURBAN PROPERTIES, AND THAT THE CWH BOARD AND MANAGEMENT BELIEVE THIS BUSINESS PLAN WILL RESULT IN ENHANCED VALUE FOR ALL CWH SHAREHOLDERS. THE SUCCESS OF CWHS BUSINESS PLAN DEPENDS UPON MANY FACTORS, INCLUDING SOME FACTORS BEYOND CWHS CONTROL. CWHS ABILITY TO ACQUIRE PROPERTIES IN CENTRAL BUSINESS DISTRICT LOCATIONS DEPENDS UPON CWHS ABILITY TO LOCATE SUCH PROPERTIES WHICH MAY BE AVAILABLE FOR SALE, TO NEGOTIATE ACCEPTABLE PURCHASE PRICES AND FINANCING TERMS; CWHS ABILITY TO DIVEST NON-CORE SUBURBAN PROPERTIES DEPENDS UPON CWHS ABILITY TO IDENTIFY BUYERS FOR SUCH PROPERTIES ON ACCEPTABLE TERMS; AND THE BUYING AND SELLING OF PROPERTIES NECESSARY TO IMPLEMENT CWHS BUSINESS PLAN DEPENDS UPON ACTIONS BY THIRD PARTY SELLERS AND BUYERS WHO ARE BEYOND CWHS CONTROL. ALSO, THE VALUE REALIZED BY CWH SHAREHOLDERS WILL DEPEND UPON OTHER FACTORS IN ADDITION TO THE SUCCESSFUL IMPLEMENTATION OF CWHS BUSINESS PLAN, INCLUDING MARKET CONDITIONS AFFECTING ALL REITS, SUCH AS MARKET EXPECTATIONS FOR INTEREST RATE CHANGES. ACCORDINGLY, CWH CAN PROVIDE NO ASSURANCE THAT IT WILL BE ABLE TO SUCCESSFULLY IMPLEMENT ITS BUSINESS PLAN OR THAT DOING SO WILL ENHANCE SHAREHOLDER VALUE.
FOR THESE REASONS, AMONG OTHERS, INVESTORS ARE CAUTIONED NOT TO PLACE UNDUE RELIANCE UPON ANY FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS IN THIS PRESS RELEASE.
EXCEPT AS REQUIRED BY LAW, CWH DOES NOT INTEND TO UNDERTAKE ANY OBLIGATION TO UPDATE ANY FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENT IN THIS PRESS RELEASE AS A RESULT OF FUTURE EVENTS, NEW INFORMATION WHICH MAY COME TO CWHS ATTENTION OR OTHERWISE.
(end)
Exhibit 99.2
IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BETWEEN
|
) | |
COMMONWEALTH REIT, et al., |
) | |
|
) | |
Claimants and Counterclaim Respondents, |
) | |
|
) | |
REIT MANAGEMENT & RESEARCH LLC. |
) | |
|
) | |
Claimant, |
) |
AAA No. 11-512-Y-276-13 |
|
) | |
v. |
) | |
|
) | |
CORVEX MANAGEMENT LP, et al., |
) | |
|
) | |
Respondents and Counterclaimants. |
) |
ORDER DISMISSING DERIVATIVE CLAIM WITH PREJUDICE
The Panel has considered the letter dated September 16, 2013 from counsel for Respondents Corvex Management LP and Related Fund Management LLC (hereafter Respondents) requesting dismissal of Count VIII of Respondents Counterclaim entitled Breach of Fiduciary Duty (Self Dealing and Entrenchment) which is pled as a derivative claim on behalf of CommonWealth REIT, as well as all of the subsequent related submissions of the parties, including the request of the individual Claimants (the Trustees) that the dismissal be with prejudice and the agreement of Respondents that Count VIII be dismissed with prejudice as to them.
It is therefore Ordered that Count VIII of Respondents Counterclaims hereby is dismissed in its entirety with prejudice as to Corvex Management LP and Related Fund Management LLC.
This dismissal is without prejudice as to derivative claims that have been or may be asserted by other Commonwealth REIT stockholders.
Dated: September 19, 2013 |
/s/ Henry J. Silberberg |
|
Henry J. Silberberg, Panel Chair |
|
|
Dated: September 19, 2013 |
/s/ Adrian M. Overstreet |
|
Adrian M. Overstreet, Arbitrator |
|
|
Dated: September 19, 2013 |
/s/ William B. Chandler, III |
|
William B. Chandler, III, Arbitrator |
,?,IP10*Q-129'KTJJ^IVD=KUU57>V6<(AP6E@:,$Y((!8# M/(-!7+*U[%^BD)`ZG%1QW$4LLL4;AGA8+(!_"2`A."/SH& MDV6:*0D#J0*B2ZADN9;=7S)"%+C'3.Q)13(YDEA29&^1P"">.#3B0.I`H$+129&<9 MYHR,XS0`M%48=7LY[5;I6<1/,(49D(WL3@$>HSWJ[D9`SUH&XM;BT4F1SR.. MM5+K4[:TN8K=_,>652P6.,OA00,G'09(H!)O1%RBHY)DCVYW' %'?#32>6@`SEL$X_(&@+,FHJ-95=Y$&X&,@$E2`20#P>_6DBN89C( M(Y`WE/Y;^S<<@D#]#0"3;LBQ14,%W#<-*L M3Y,,AB?C&&`!Q[]:FH!JP456EU"U@EFBFE$;0P^<^X8`3GG/X&I89DGA29,[ M74,-PP0",\@]*`LUJ245#;W4-TKM"VX([1DXQ\RG!_6J8U_3C=O;&5U*EU\Q MHV$;,@)8!L8)`!S]#Z4#4)/9&E13(I4FC22-LJZAE/J#T-,DNH8IX87?YYR0 M@`SG`R:!69-15._U2VTXQ+,)7>8D(D,32,<#)X4&I[>=;F!)E61%<9`D0HP^ MH/(H#E=KDM%0RW4,,T,3OAYV*H/4@$G]!4N1G&>?2@+"T4F1ZBC(SC/-`A:* M**`"N7U'3M5O-4;4E5!';W$*10-'ERBN"S!MV!GGL>%%=1107";@[HY?5]/U M*?Q#]LM86!VI:K+D?(C*^]_P)7\0*RH]%OTBL[86$D8C:-D94#%`TI9_F)^4 M@8'`R:[VB@VCB)))6.,&FS0S:;;(A2ZU&*47QW?.J,RNQ/TY0>FZH3I>I-): MJUBZ,CQR!EC!V`R%W^8GY2,XP!D_2NU$,0G,XB02LNTOM&XCTSZ5)0/ZS+L< M6-%N8%MY'LII$:*(WJ)RTQ9V9E//.T[>/0D5=CTJX/A&/3UMY('N;@&5`PW1 M(TNX\^RUT]%!+Q$G]]SC;W2+Z%Y=RW5XHNEWRNHF:6'82B[20,*['(^AJ&32 M]46:T0VLK/:^3MD"!B$'SGY\\'/RX`Y&,Y%=Q10-8F2Z'+W]C<1:)HUIY%VP MA=7G-ICS$(0]/^!D5'<6DUQ/8$6-_-;.:$2J2`L*GRI3*Q=R2?E(&W!YR!75P:W92N$>9 M(7:9XHUD8`R%6VDCVR,58GOK2VGB@GN8XY9CB-&8`M]*"W7J+2QCZ]876H7R MI'$YA\@1%U.,;Y4W_DB'\ZH_V/?) QM_M"F MXC>6VB:5XE8;L`9Z?YZBD6ZU7^4Y1M"O8;4/;VDD):,F98QN)5Y]Q0#/.U5Q MCT)'>I!H-W/:R"2VD($)^SHP"B-I)>2%!PI55!]LUT/]OV/VF*V\U/-92TJ[ MQ^X`7<=WIZ5.NK:<\<3K>P%9VVQG>/G.<8'OR*8.M5[%30;;[%IDS?9##-)/ M-(Z%<%B7./KQBL>31;M]+@C>U=Y+;39&5<_\O#D$]^2,'\ZW]8U.72[99X[) M[I2P5@DBJ020!UZY)IUKJEO.ZP2R10W?1K?S59E/)QQWP,T$*:6YS-[9W MESYDITNY9"ZK;Q2*!8PH#KGY02S_-G*D`UH0Z9(FAZTD=F\5S<22E5_B?` MPF&[Y`'/J36K/KFEVZ,SWT/RQ&;`<9*@9R/PIUKJ]A=>4J7,8EEB$HB+C<%( MST^E`W4J M=E+?VD$\4$US%'+-_JT9@"WTK$B\86]S? MFUMH%E^=@&\]!E58+G!]6/`[]:!TZE6WNK8S[S2)HY'CATN1XC ]`E7J+HZ3=BW,A ML7N)KB>:21FC$C<<1*02``1SD\`^]0PZ5J$0+#3[@WT04K HM+'-:/H][;ZW$)DE`MF)\WRU"F,)M5`^ F?QXH%[6IS 6%E5XHW!8%F"C]304JU316,/3M,NH-7L1-9S M.T,:*TLF"$`4D%7!XY;:4YSP:=J%E=RZG<2+8RR7"S>9'/\`P^2(\;`<]VR" MOOFMVRU6UO;59UD5`TGEA689SG`'X\$?6F-K$"7TULX"+!_K)'<*`-NXGGTR M/SH)]I/F;MK8R;O2UM=&T>Q_LY[BVMW5KB*%0>B'MGG+D?K6;;:1JL-W;B:& M8M"(WB*HK")%&XH')R#G*D8Y&.W3I)/$6F1R6H^UQ&.YW[9=XV@K@$'WRPJ1 M-:LO.>*69(66 8P`SC\3CZT#52HEL
F:?'H5^IB=;9EG58E21L`Q@-)(1P>`#L7'X5T6H:U!I]]:V;[ M2\X9V+2!1'&O5CFIUU73W2%UO82LYVQ?./G.<$#UY-`W6JVO;\AE.[:-C@Y.,X_+ MF@EUIN+TW.9NM&O+V6^EFM78L)/(#-P&>0*&'/4(BGVS56?1KQ\*EC*BSO/E M5B5L2M(<.23\N$QAN>]=A-J=C;VJ74UW"D#_`'9&<8;Z'O4-WKNF622&:]A# M1Q&8H'&XKC.0*"HUJFR1S5[HMX%6Y:VEF>:> HNAB:WIT\T5I:V-NRPQPLHV\!- MVU!^2LY_"LS^RI;B\/FZ3*8GNXWD:506'SEB#SAU!`PV.`<5T5QX@TV"V-PM MU%*BS)"Y1P0I8XR?;O\`A3CK5LUTD$1657C202B10NUBV"#GGA"?PH"-2I&- MK'+6^E:BL9EN;:YD`*+>((U4W&7RW0Y<#'7C@D>U:D.GSP>%1"MG+'YMR99K M93E_*,N2HYY^7C&>G%:_]N:5]F-P-1MS$I"EQ(,`GH/T-1KKUE+=R6T,J2-$ MR*[>8H`W*6R#GG`&:`E4J2^SMJ<])H=UB:2.&TD%K)),(88XU M=58[55CDC;P"0W;)[FMK5]*GU&2SM 8,+GD#'?@9S]*BL/$NG:A/'%',J--$DD0=@"^[=P!ZX7]:!N=5V M=MOU.<72=7N'A:ZMY8Y+D&3"(K""1I69SN)^4A=F#SG&*FM=&U9]7B\^.1;5 MI)8W)?@0I('3OU #^"U3O[#4KB]DGMH+D1"U,<>^3#M,%XD(]<,R@_P![GTKKZ*"8UW%)6V.. MN-%2ZCD-MHTL,"6\S10R'[TI"JIVYX.`3^O6H+O2]5EO9&CM91(BRQ^8$`W# MR_+3YR ,9-7M4T_4+C5H[BVCAVJJCS&?JH))5E((/."",$']=RB@T=:3= MSEV\/7T,,"P>7B&&")E1]C-M+,Y#8."6*G/7@]*AB\+7BZ=<+*T;W#K'R)3E ML2M(XWD9&2<9]AFNNHH']8F 2TPD;G(QQA"1WR0*ZBB@/;S.1D\-ZC/"8Y$@40(ZQL MDI#3%IED;)Q\N0H'?DFK5EI%W878OY(5EF(;"&4N0SNH)W$=D5>?K7244`Z\ MFK%'4[.6]6U1"H2.Y263)ZJISQ^(%9,NC:C"$FM$MVN&FN97+.5`:3(1NG.% MXQ7244$1J2BK(Y&7P]J:PRV\$=N$^S>7GS.)2$"*<$?*X&1N'4=O1UQX8OKF M6\0N$CE:66-_/;&YTV@;0.,`D$\\8Q7644&GUB9@6FB7(TG48G/D7%Y'Y:YF M,NP!=JY;`]3T'2FV^C74VJP7UU!!"D;`B!&W!=B%4YP,G+L?8`5T-%!/MI:^ M9A7VE7MQJ4Y18C!=&$M*S?-&(SNV@8YR>ASQDU57PY>F*)&DB4A(59@3D%6= MV(X_OLOY5T]%`*M)*R.4DT35'M[)EM[>*2R`C1(9RC,`A7<7QZDG&.A/>M31 M-';2A<$A"[+&B$$GY50#&3S][]U$*D<$,EUD7!)WCRTVJ`,=-V3G/3-=710/V M\KWZG+Z?X YS,'AR[CC<2-`7D>' Q-=/10 M'MY .XXE( MG90@\QG(P!\V0P'48(KK:*!_6)F+J^E7-[>?:(Q&ZQ1QA(W;&\B4.RGC@$*H MINF:/<0ZJVHW:Q!G61@B'/EL[#(!Q_=1>>YS6Y101[67+RG*:EH&JW][.V]- MADD9"9B%.8RB?(!U&>2 #3=J110O&JB7R]C%0$.0"=H&00,=15(Z!J$6G7&G M16]J\1.Y)7?YV^55VCCY<*",\\8]ZZNB@F-:221CZO8WD]S%/:1PR'[/+!ME M;`C+[?GZ'.,$$>])8:))9Z3>V@D59KG>%E'4#:$0GZ`"MFB@GVDN7E.7_L?5 M//MKP6EJ#;F)1;"4[2L:N`=V.NY\CC@**IW7ANZMK&5YYH]B1DED5CSL(Z`9 MV[I)/PKM**#18B29QD=EJFJI/?VT<4/VB5]HCE,8XC5$;=MR5X?H!G([5+_P MB]\;,VO[D*A+*2Y._P#=(B@\<#`8'ZUUU%`_K$NB.:;1+^XNKB^D2"*66*7R MX@V1&Y143G'H&R??%6[S3;N(6#6,4,QM(7A"2MM`)4`/T/3!&/0FMJB@S]M+ M3R,.RT6YL=(O[9)$::6/RX6)P,+$J+GTY!/XU5;PY 21"2&R41(= MJ#.."WD6&(QJ@F8,Y:0.SAL? M*?E4CKR*T-)L-3L[IYKE()&ECC1G5\$8+EL@#D_,.>,GTK