XML 34 R49.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v2.4.0.8
Employee Benefit Plans (Details) (USD $)
0 Months Ended 12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2007
Oct. 31, 2013
Oct. 31, 2012
Oct. 31, 2011
Defined Benefit Plan Disclosure [Line Items]        
Term Life Insurance Premiums Paid By Employer For Vp And Above   $ 27,000 $ 43,000 $ 56,000
Officers And Director Level Employees   28,000 25,000 24,000
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Noncurrent assets   28,258,000 0  
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Regulatory asset   (246,306,000) (293,104,000)  
Defined Contribution Plans Disclosure [Abstract]        
Current Liability   199,000 160,000  
Noncurrent Liability   3,328,000 2,412,000  
Plan 401 K [Member]
       
Defined Contribution Plans Disclosure [Abstract]        
Employer Contribution to Plan   5,688,000 5,400,000 5,203,000
Defined Contribution Plan, Maximum Annual Contribution Per Employee, Percent   5.00%    
Description Of Defined Contribution Pension And Other Postretirement Plans   We maintain a 401(k) plan that is a profit-sharing plan under Section 401(a) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the Tax Code), which includes qualified cash or deferred arrangements under Tax Code Section 401(k). The 401(k) plan is subject to the provisions of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act. Eligible employees who have completed 30 days of continuous service and have attained age 18 are eligible to participate. Participants may defer a portion of their base salary and cash incentive payments to the plan, and we match a portion of their contributions. Employee contributions vest immediately, and company contributions vest after six months of service. Employees receive a company match of 100% up to the first 5% of eligible pay contributed. Employees may contribute up to 50% of eligible pay to the 401(k) on a pre-tax basis, up to the Tax Code annual contribution and compensation limits. We automatically enroll all eligible non-participating employees in the 401(k) plan at a 2% contribution rate unless the employee chooses not to participate by notifying our record keeper. For employees who are automatically enrolled in the 401(k) plan, we automatically increase their contributions by 1% each year to a maximum of 5% unless the employee chooses to opt out of the automatic increase by contacting our record keeper. If the employee does not make an investment election, employee contributions and matches are automatically invested in a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds. Participants may direct up to 20% of their contributions and company matching contributions as an investment in the Piedmont Stock Fund. Employees may change their contribution rate and investments at any time.    
Standard Eligibility Age For Defined Contribution Plan   18 years    
Service Required For Eligibility In Defined Contribution Plan   30 days    
Employer Match Percentage   100.00%    
Employee Contribution Cap   50.00%    
Employee Contribution Rate At Enrollment   2.00%    
Contribution Annual Automatic Deferral Increase   1.00%    
Employee Contribution Automatic Increase Rate Cap   5.00%    
Investment In Company Stock Cap   20.00%    
Money Purchase Pension Plan [Member]
       
Defined Contribution Plans Disclosure [Abstract]        
Employer Contribution to Plan   700,000    
Employer Contribution Percentage   4.00%    
Description Of Defined Contribution Pension And Other Postretirement Plans   Employees hired or rehired after December 31, 2007 cannot participate in the qualified pension plan but are participants in the Money Purchase Pension (MPP) plan, a defined contribution pension plan that allows the employee to direct the investments and assume the risk of investment returns. A defined contribution plan specifies the amount of the employer’s annual contribution to individual participant accounts established for the retirement benefit. Eligible employees who have completed 30 days of continuous service and have attained age 18 are eligible to participate. Under the MPP plan, we annually deposit a percentage of each participant’s pay into an account of the MPP plan. This contribution equals 4% of the participant’s compensation plus an additional 4% of compensation above the social security wage base up to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) compensation limit. The participant is vested in this plan after three years of service.    
Standard Eligibility Age For Defined Contribution Plan   18 years    
Service Required For Eligibility In Defined Contribution Plan   30 days    
Employer Contribution Percentage Above IRS Limit   4.00%    
Plan Vesting Period Defined Contribution Plan   3 years    
Defined Contribution Plans Estimated Future Employer Contributions In Next Fiscal Year   885,000    
Defined Contribution Restoration Plan [Member]
       
Defined Contribution Plans Disclosure [Abstract]        
Employer Contribution to Plan   434,000 422,000  
Description Of Defined Contribution Pension And Other Postretirement Plans   We have a non-qualified defined contribution restoration plan (DCR plan) for all officers at the vice president level and above where benefits payable under the plan are informally funded annually through a rabbi trust with a bank as the trustee. We contribute 13% of the total cash compensation (base salary, short-term incentive and MVP incentive) that exceeds the IRS compensation limit to the DCR plan account of each covered executive. Participants may not contribute to the DCR plan. Vesting under the DCR plan is five-year cliff vesting, including service prior to adoption of the plan on January 1, 2009, of annual company contributions, and prospective five-year cliff vesting for the one-time opening balances of four Vice Presidents to compensate them for the loss of future benefits under this DCR plan as compared with a terminated SERP. Participants in the DCR plan may provide instructions to us for the deemed investment of their plan accounts. Distribution will occur upon separation of service or death of the participant.    
Employer Contribution Percentage Above IRS Limit   13.00%    
Plan Vesting Period Defined Contribution Plan   5 years    
Vice Presidents Eligible For One Time Contribution New DCR Plan   4    
Voluntary Deferral Plan [Member]
       
Defined Contribution Plans Disclosure [Abstract]        
Employer Contribution to Plan   0    
Deferral Limit As Percentage Of Base Salary   50.00%    
Plan Deferral Limit As Percentage Of Annual Incentive Pay   95.00%    
Distribution Deferral Time Period Minimum In Years   2 years    
Private Equity Funds [Member]
       
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Initial Unfunded Subscription Balance   12,000,000    
Net Asset Value Unfunded Committments   7,400,000    
Qualified Pension [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Disclosure [Line Items]        
Defined Benefit Plans General Information   We have a noncontributory, tax-qualified defined benefit pension plan (qualified pension plan) for our eligible employees. A defined benefit plan specifies the amount of benefit that an eligible participant eventually will receive upon retirement using information about that participant. An employee became eligible on the January 1 or July 1 following either the date on which he or she attained age 30 or attained age 21 and completed 1,000 hours of service during the 12-month period commencing on the employment date. Plan benefits are generally based on credited years of service and the level of compensation during the five consecutive years of the last ten years prior to retirement or termination during which the participant received the highest compensation. Our policy is to fund the plan in an amount not in excess of the amount that is deductible for income tax purposes. The qualified pension plan is closed to employees hired after December 31, 2007. Employees hired prior to January 1, 2008 continue to participate in the qualified pension plan. Employees are vested after five years of service and can be credited with up to a total of 35 years of service. When a vested employee leaves the company, his benefit payment will be calculated as the greater of the accrued benefit as of December 31, 2007 under a specific formula plus the accrued benefit calculated under a second formula for years of service after December 31, 2007, or the benefit for all years of service up to 35 years under the second formula.    
Estimated Future Employee Contributions Next Fiscal Year   20,000,000    
Reconciliation Of Changes In Plan Benefit Obligations And Fair Value Of Assets [Abstract]        
Accumulated Benefit Obligation At Year End   230,175,000 245,361,000  
Change In Benefit Obligation        
Obligation at beginning of year   293,327,000 236,632,000  
Service cost   12,005,000 9,573,000 8,508,000
Interest cost   9,946,000 10,640,000 11,024,000
Actuarial (gain) loss   (24,859,000) 54,852,000  
Participant contributions   0 0  
Administrative expenses   (534,000) (420,000)  
Benefit payments   (17,482,000) (17,950,000)  
Obligation at end of year   272,403,000 293,327,000 236,632,000
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   272,337,000 259,511,000  
Actual return on plan assets   26,340,000 31,196,000  
Employer contributions   20,000,000 0  
Participant contributions   0 0  
Administrative expenses   (534,000) (420,000)  
Benefit payments   (17,482,000) (17,950,000)  
Fair value at end of year   300,661,000 272,337,000 259,511,000
Funded status at year end - (under) over   28,258,000 (20,990,000)  
Noncurrent assets   28,258,000 0  
Current liabilities   0 0  
Noncurrent liabilities   0 (20,990,000)  
Net amount recognized   28,258,000 (20,990,000)  
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Unrecognized transition obligation   0 0  
Unrecognized prior service (cost) credit   17,243,000 19,441,000  
Unrecognized actuarial loss   (96,338,000) (137,633,000)  
Cumulative Employer Contribution In Excess Of Cost   107,353,000 97,202,000  
Horizon For DBPP Long Term Rates Of Return   20 years    
Benefit Obligation Weighted Average Assumptions [Abstract]        
Discount Rate   4.55% 3.51%  
Rate Of Compensation Increase   3.72% 3.76%  
Net Periodic Benefits Cost Weighted Average Assumptions [Abstract]        
Discount Rate   3.51% 4.67% 5.47%
Expected Long Term Rate Of Return On Plan Assets   8.00% 8.00% 8.00%
Rate Of Compensation Increase   3.76% 3.78% 3.87%
Defined Benefit Plan Estimated Future Benefit Payments Abstract        
2014   25,918,000    
2015   16,918,000    
2016   15,169,000    
2017   16,154,000    
2018   18,672,000    
2019 - 2023   106,226,000    
Defined Benefit Plan Net Periodic Benefit Cost Abstract        
Service cost   12,005,000 9,573,000 8,508,000
Interest cost   9,946,000 10,640,000 11,024,000
Expected return on plan assets   (21,105,000) (20,289,000) (20,608,000)
Amortization of transition obligation   0 0 0
Amortization of prior service cost (credit)   (2,198,000) (2,198,000) (2,198,000)
Amortization of net loss   11,202,000 5,966,000 3,547,000
Net periodic benefit (income) cost   9,850,000 3,692,000 273,000
Other Changes In Plan Assets And Benefit Obligatin Recognized Through Regulatory Asset Or Liability [Abstract]        
Prior service cost   0 0 0
Net loss (gain)   (30,094,000) 43,945,000 17,539,000
Amounts Recognized As Component Of Net Periodic Benefit Cost [Abstract]        
Amortization of transition obligation   0 0 0
Amortization of net loss   11,202,000 5,966,000 3,547,000
Amortization of prior service cost (credit)   (2,198,000) (2,198,000) (2,198,000)
Total recognized in regulatory asset (liability)   (39,098,000) 40,177,000 16,190,000
Total Recognized In Net Periodic Benefit Cost And Regulatory Asset (Liability)   (29,248,000) 43,869,000 16,463,000
Estimated Amortization And Expected Refunds [Abstract]        
Amortization of unrecognized prior service cost (credit)   (2,198,000)    
Amortization of unrecognized actuarial loss   7,138,000    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   100.00% 100.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   300,661,000 272,337,000 259,511,000
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   272,337,000 259,511,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   300,661,000 272,337,000 259,511,000
Standard Eligibility Age For Defined Benefit Plan   30 years    
Duration To Complete Service Requirement   12 months    
Maximum Credited Service Period   35 years    
Period Of Compensation For Benefit Calculation   10 years    
Years Of Highest Compensation For Benefit Calculation   5 years    
Plan Vesting Period Defined Benefit Plan   5 years    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Amounts Not Yet Recognized As Component Of Pension Liability [Member]
       
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Regulatory asset   (79,095,000) (118,192,000)  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Minimum [Member]
       
Actual return on plan assets:        
Standard Eligibility Age For Defined Benefit Plan   21 years    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Cash [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   5,722,000 5,346,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   2.00% 2.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   5,722,000 5,346,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   5,722,000 5,346,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Total Fixed Income Securities [Member]
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   38.00% 45.00%  
Target Plan Asset Allocations   45.00%    
Qualified Pension [Member] | US Treasuries [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   24,078,000 17,544,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   8.00% 6.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   24,078,000 17,544,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   24,078,000 17,544,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Long Duration Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   34,041,000 63,565,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   11.00% 23.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   34,041,000 63,565,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   34,041,000 63,565,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Corporate Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   42,701,000 26,368,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   14.00% 10.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   42,701,000 26,368,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   42,701,000 26,368,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | High Yield Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   14,680,000 13,777,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   5.00% 5.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   14,680,000 13,777,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   14,680,000 13,777,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Collateralized Mortgage Backed Securities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,098,000 1,513,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   0.00% 1.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,098,000 1,513,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,098,000 1,513,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Municipals [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 345,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   0.00% 0.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 345,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 345,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Derivatives [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   (11,000) (89,000)  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   0.00% 0.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   (11,000) (89,000)  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   (11,000) (89,000)  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Derivatives [Member] | Maximum [Member]
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Investment Limititation Percentage   10.00%    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Total Equity Securities
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   43.00% 36.00%  
Target Plan Asset Allocations   35.00%    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Large Cap Core Index [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   12,023,000 10,260,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   4.00% 4.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   12,023,000 10,260,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   12,023,000 10,260,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Large Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   16,908,000 10,427,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   6.00% 4.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   16,908,000 10,427,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   16,908,000 10,427,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Large Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   17,823,000 15,252,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   6.00% 6.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   17,823,000 15,252,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   17,823,000 15,252,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Small Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   30,831,000 26,335,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   10.00% 10.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   30,831,000 26,335,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   30,831,000 26,335,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Common Trust Fund International Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   24,460,000    
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Net Asset Value Redemption Notice Period   5 days    
Net Asset Value Redemption Frequency   Daily    
Net Asset Value Redemption Restriction Description   None    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   8.00%    
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   24,460,000    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   24,460,000    
Qualified Pension [Member] | International Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year     14,376,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations     5.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets     14,376,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year     14,376,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Common Trust Fund International Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   18,678,000    
Fair value at end of year   27,270,000    
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Net Asset Value Redemption Notice Period   30 days    
Net Asset Value Redemption Frequency   Monthly    
Net Asset Value Redemption Restriction Description   None    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   9.00% 7.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   27,270,000    
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   18,678,000    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   27,270,000    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Total Real Estate [Member]
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   5.00% 6.00%  
Target Plan Asset Allocations   5.00%    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Global Reit [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   15,042,000 16,252,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   5.00% 6.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   15,042,000 16,252,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   15,042,000 16,252,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Total Other Investments [Member]
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   12.00% 11.00%  
Target Plan Asset Allocations   15.00%    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Hedge Funds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   16,995,000    
Fair value at end of year   18,571,000    
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Net Asset Value Redemption Notice Period   65 days    
Net Asset Value Redemption Frequency   Quarterly    
Net Asset Value Redemption Restriction Description   Redeemed in whole or part but not less than the minimum redemption amount for each currency. Redemption within one year of purchase is subject to 1.5% redemption fee. Redeemed on "first in first out" basis. None of our investment is subject to the redemption fee. Fund's Board of Directors may limit or suspend share redemptions until a further notification ending suspension. No such notification has been received as of October 31, 2013.    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   6.00% 6.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   18,571,000    
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   16,995,000    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   18,571,000    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Private Equity Funds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   3,522,000    
Fair value at end of year   4,659,000    
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Net Asset Value Redemption Frequency   Limited    
Net Asset Value Redemption Restriction Description   Investors have only very limited withdrawal rights for specific legal or regulatory reasons. Any transfer of interest will be subject to approval.    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   2.00% 1.00%  
Target Plan Asset Allocations   5.00%    
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   4,659,000    
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   3,522,000    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   4,659,000    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Private Equity Funds [Member] | Maximum [Member]
       
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Net Asset Value Liquidating Investment Remaining Period   12 years    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Private Equity Funds [Member] | Minimum [Member]
       
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Net Asset Value Liquidating Investment Remaining Period   10 years    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Commodities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   11,871,000    
Fair value at end of year   10,765,000    
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Net Asset Value Redemption Notice Period   35 days    
Net Asset Value Redemption Frequency   Monthly    
Net Asset Value Redemption Restriction Description   Redemption within one year of purchase is subject to 1% redemption fee. None of our investment is subject to the redemption fee. If 95% or more of the balance is requested, 95% of the balance will be paid within 30 days. Any outstanding balance or interest owed will be paid after the annual audit is complete.    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   4.00% 4.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   10,765,000    
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   11,871,000    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   10,765,000    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Total Investments [Member]
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   100.00% 100.00%  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   112,879,000 112,022,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   37.00% 41.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   112,879,000 112,022,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   112,879,000 112,022,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Cash [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   5,566,000 5,346,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   5,566,000 5,346,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   5,566,000 5,346,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | US Treasuries [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Long Duration Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Corporate Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | High Yield Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   14,680,000 13,777,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   14,680,000 13,777,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   14,680,000 13,777,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Collateralized Mortgage Backed Securities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Municipals [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Derivatives [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   6,000 (3,000)  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   6,000 (3,000)  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   6,000 (3,000)  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Large Cap Core Index [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   12,023,000 10,260,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   12,023,000 10,260,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   12,023,000 10,260,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Large Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   16,908,000 10,427,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   16,908,000 10,427,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   16,908,000 10,427,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Large Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   17,823,000 15,252,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   17,823,000 15,252,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   17,823,000 15,252,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Small Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   30,831,000 26,335,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   30,831,000 26,335,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   30,831,000 26,335,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Common Trust Fund International Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | International Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year     14,376,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets     14,376,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year     14,376,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Common Trust Fund International Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Global Reit [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   15,042,000 16,252,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   15,042,000 16,252,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   15,042,000 16,252,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Hedge Funds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Private Equity Funds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Commodities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   183,123,000 156,793,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   61.00% 58.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   183,123,000 156,793,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   183,123,000 156,793,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Cash [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   156,000 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   156,000 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   156,000 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | US Treasuries [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   24,078,000 17,544,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   24,078,000 17,544,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   24,078,000 17,544,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Long Duration Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   34,041,000 63,565,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   34,041,000 63,565,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   34,041,000 63,565,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Corporate Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   42,701,000 26,368,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   42,701,000 26,368,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   42,701,000 26,368,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | High Yield Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Collateralized Mortgage Backed Securities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,098,000 1,513,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,098,000 1,513,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,098,000 1,513,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Municipals [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 345,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 345,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 345,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Derivatives [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   (17,000) (86,000)  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   (17,000) (86,000)  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   (17,000) (86,000)  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Core Index [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Small Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Common Trust Fund International Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   24,460,000    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   24,460,000    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   24,460,000    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | International Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year     0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets     0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year     0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Common Trust Fund International Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   27,270,000 18,678,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   27,270,000 18,678,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   27,270,000 18,678,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Global Reit [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Hedge Funds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   18,571,000 16,995,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   18,571,000 16,995,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   18,571,000 16,995,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Private Equity Funds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Commodities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   10,765,000 11,871,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   10,765,000 11,871,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   10,765,000 11,871,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   3,522,000 16,604,000  
Fair value at end of year   4,659,000 3,522,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   2.00% 1.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   4,659,000 3,522,000  
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   3,522,000 16,604,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Relating to assets still held at the reporting date   116,000 13,000  
Relating to assets sold during the period   61,000 145,000  
Purchases, sales and settlements (net)   960,000 1,439,000  
Transfer in/out of Level 3   0 (14,679,000)  
Fair value at end of year   4,659,000 3,522,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Cash [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | US Treasuries [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Long Duration Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Corporate Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | High Yield Bonds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Collateralized Mortgage Backed Securities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Municipals [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Derivatives [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Core Index [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Small Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Common Trust Fund International Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0    
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | International Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year     0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets     0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year     0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Common Trust Fund International Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Global Reit [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Hedge Funds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   0 6,207,000  
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   0 6,207,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Relating to assets still held at the reporting date   0 0  
Relating to assets sold during the period   0 0  
Purchases, sales and settlements (net)   0 0  
Transfer in/out of Level 3   0 (6,207,000)  
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Private Equity Funds [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   3,522,000 1,925,000  
Fair value at end of year   4,659,000 3,522,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   4,659,000 3,522,000  
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   3,522,000 1,925,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Relating to assets still held at the reporting date   116,000 13,000  
Relating to assets sold during the period   61,000 145,000  
Purchases, sales and settlements (net)   960,000 1,439,000  
Transfer in/out of Level 3   0 0  
Fair value at end of year   4,659,000 3,522,000  
Qualified Pension [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Commodities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   0 8,472,000  
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   0 8,472,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Relating to assets still held at the reporting date   0 0  
Relating to assets sold during the period   0 0  
Purchases, sales and settlements (net)   0 0  
Transfer in/out of Level 3   0 (8,472,000)  
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Non Qualified Pension [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Disclosure [Line Items]        
Estimated Future Employee Contributions Next Fiscal Year   444,000    
Reconciliation Of Changes In Plan Benefit Obligations And Fair Value Of Assets [Abstract]        
Accumulated Benefit Obligation At Year End   4,736,000 5,569,000  
Change In Benefit Obligation        
Obligation at beginning of year   5,569,000 5,219,000  
Service cost   0 39,000 45,000
Interest cost   157,000 203,000 209,000
Actuarial (gain) loss   (540,000) 629,000  
Participant contributions   0 0  
Administrative expenses   0 0  
Benefit payments   (450,000) (521,000)  
Obligation at end of year   4,736,000 5,569,000 5,219,000
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets   0 0  
Employer contributions   450,000 521,000  
Participant contributions   0 0  
Administrative expenses   0 0  
Benefit payments   (450,000) (521,000)  
Fair value at end of year   0 0 0
Funded status at year end - (under) over   (4,736,000) (5,569,000)  
Noncurrent assets   0 0  
Current liabilities   (445,000) (502,000)  
Noncurrent liabilities   (4,291,000) (5,067,000)  
Net amount recognized   (4,736,000) (5,569,000)  
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Unrecognized transition obligation   0 0  
Unrecognized prior service (cost) credit   (196,000) (277,000)  
Unrecognized actuarial loss   (820,000) (1,521,000)  
Cumulative Employer Contribution In Excess Of Cost   (3,720,000) (3,771,000)  
Benefit Obligation Weighted Average Assumptions [Abstract]        
Discount Rate   3.98% 2.95%  
Net Periodic Benefits Cost Weighted Average Assumptions [Abstract]        
Discount Rate   2.95% 4.10% 4.37%
Defined Benefit Plan Estimated Future Benefit Payments Abstract        
2014   444,000    
2015   458,000    
2016   434,000    
2017   410,000    
2018   383,000    
2019 - 2023   1,890,000    
Defined Benefit Plan Net Periodic Benefit Cost Abstract        
Service cost   0 39,000 45,000
Interest cost   157,000 203,000 209,000
Expected return on plan assets   0 0 0
Amortization of transition obligation   0 0 0
Amortization of prior service cost (credit)   81,000 81,000 20,000
Amortization of net loss   161,000 49,000 41,000
Net periodic benefit (income) cost   399,000 372,000 315,000
Other Changes In Plan Assets And Benefit Obligatin Recognized Through Regulatory Asset Or Liability [Abstract]        
Prior service cost   0 0 290,000
Net loss (gain)   (540,000) 629,000 130,000
Amounts Recognized As Component Of Net Periodic Benefit Cost [Abstract]        
Amortization of transition obligation   0 0 0
Amortization of net loss   161,000 49,000 41,000
Amortization of prior service cost (credit)   81,000 81,000 20,000
Total recognized in regulatory asset (liability)   (782,000) 499,000 359,000
Total Recognized In Net Periodic Benefit Cost And Regulatory Asset (Liability)   (383,000) 871,000 674,000
Estimated Amortization And Expected Refunds [Abstract]        
Amortization of unrecognized prior service cost (credit)   81,000    
Amortization of unrecognized actuarial loss   47,000    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0 0
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0 0
Non Qualified Pension [Member] | Amounts Not Yet Recognized As Component Of Pension Liability [Member]
       
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Regulatory asset   (1,016,000) (1,798,000)  
Other Benefits [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Disclosure [Line Items]        
Defined Benefit Plans General Information   We provide certain postretirement health care and life insurance benefits to eligible retirees. The liability associated with such benefits is funded in irrevocable trust funds that can only be used to pay the benefits. Employees are first eligible to retire and receive these benefits at age 55 with ten or more years of service after the age of 45. Employees who met this requirement in 1993 or who retired prior to 1993 are in a “grandfathered” group for whom we pay the full cost of the retiree’s coverage. Retirees not in the grandfathered group have a portion of the cost of retiree coverage paid by us, subject to certain annual contribution limits. Retirees are responsible for the full cost of dependent coverage. Effective January 1, 2008, new employees have to complete ten years of service after age 50 to be eligible for benefits, and no benefits are provided to those employees after age 65 when they are automatically eligible for Medicare benefits to cover health costs. Our OPEB plan includes a defined dollar benefit to pay the premiums for Medicare Part D. Employees who meet the eligibility requirements to retire also receive a life insurance benefit. For employees who retire after July 1, 2005, this benefit is $15,000. The life insurance amount for employees who retired prior to this date was calculated as a percentage of their basic life insurance prior to retirement.    
Estimated Future Employee Contributions Next Fiscal Year   1,500,000    
Change In Benefit Obligation        
Obligation at beginning of year   34,830,000 31,900,000  
Service cost   1,327,000 1,387,000 1,398,000
Interest cost   1,130,000 1,347,000 1,495,000
Actuarial (gain) loss   (1,094,000) 2,630,000  
Participant contributions   641,000 788,000  
Administrative expenses   0 0  
Benefit payments   (3,156,000) (3,222,000)  
Obligation at end of year   33,678,000 34,830,000 31,900,000
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   23,663,000 22,045,000  
Actual return on plan assets   2,848,000 1,972,000  
Employer contributions   1,965,000 2,080,000  
Participant contributions   641,000 788,000  
Administrative expenses   0 0  
Benefit payments   (3,156,000) (3,222,000)  
Fair value at end of year   25,961,000 23,663,000 22,045,000
Funded status at year end - (under) over   (7,717,000) (11,167,000)  
Noncurrent assets   0 0  
Current liabilities   0 0  
Noncurrent liabilities   (7,717,000) (11,167,000)  
Net amount recognized   (7,717,000) (11,167,000)  
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Unrecognized transition obligation   0 (667,000)  
Unrecognized prior service (cost) credit   0 0  
Unrecognized actuarial loss   (354,000) (2,633,000)  
Cumulative Employer Contribution In Excess Of Cost   (7,363,000) (7,867,000)  
Benefit Obligation Weighted Average Assumptions [Abstract]        
Discount Rate   4.44% 3.34%  
Net Periodic Benefits Cost Weighted Average Assumptions [Abstract]        
Discount Rate   3.34% 4.36% 4.85%
Expected Long Term Rate Of Return On Plan Assets   8.00% 8.00% 8.00%
Defined Benefit Plan Estimated Future Benefit Payments Abstract        
2014   2,140,000    
2015   2,262,000    
2016   2,322,000    
2017   2,417,000    
2018   2,507,000    
2019 - 2023   13,640,000    
Assumed Health Care Cost Rate Trends Abstract        
Health Care Cost Trend Rate Assumed For Next Fiscal Year   7.40% 7.50%  
Ultimate Health Care Cost Trend Rate   5.00% 5.00%  
Year That Rate Reaches Ultimate Trend Rate   2027 2027  
Effect Of Health Care Cost Trend Rate Assumptions [Abstract]        
Effect of One Percentage Point Increase on Service and Interest Cost Components   21,000    
Effect of One Percentage Point Decrease on Service and Interest Cost Components   27,000    
Effect Of One Percentage Point Increase on Postretirement Benefit Obligation   690,000    
Effect of One Percentage Point Decrease on Postretirement Benefit Obligation   699,000    
Defined Benefit Plan Net Periodic Benefit Cost Abstract        
Service cost   1,327,000 1,387,000 1,398,000
Interest cost   1,130,000 1,347,000 1,495,000
Expected return on plan assets   (1,663,000) (1,551,000) (1,534,000)
Amortization of transition obligation   667,000 667,000 667,000
Amortization of prior service cost (credit)   0 0 0
Amortization of net loss   0 0 0
Net periodic benefit (income) cost   1,461,000 1,850,000 2,026,000
Other Changes In Plan Assets And Benefit Obligatin Recognized Through Regulatory Asset Or Liability [Abstract]        
Prior service cost   0 0 0
Net loss (gain)   (2,278,000) 2,209,000 415,000
Amounts Recognized As Component Of Net Periodic Benefit Cost [Abstract]        
Amortization of transition obligation   667,000 667,000 667,000
Amortization of net loss   0 0 0
Amortization of prior service cost (credit)   0 0 0
Total recognized in regulatory asset (liability)   (2,945,000) 1,542,000 (252,000)
Total Recognized In Net Periodic Benefit Cost And Regulatory Asset (Liability)   (1,484,000) 3,392,000 1,774,000
Estimated Amortization And Expected Refunds [Abstract]        
Amortization of unrecognized prior service cost (credit)   0    
Amortization of unrecognized actuarial loss   0    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   100.00% 100.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   25,961,000 23,663,000 22,045,000
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   23,663,000 22,045,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   25,961,000 23,663,000 22,045,000
Standard Eligibility Age For Defined Benefit Plan 45 years 50 years    
Service Required For Eligibility In Defined Benefit Plan 10 years 10 years    
Plan Vesting Period Defined Benefit Plan   65 years    
Benefits Provided After Employee Is Eligible for Medicare Benefits   0    
Term Life Insurance Per Individual Benefit Provided By Employer   15,000    
Other Benefits [Member] | Amounts Not Yet Recognized As Component Of Pension Liability [Member]
       
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Regulatory asset   (354,000) (3,300,000)  
Other Benefits [Member] | Cash [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   926,000    
Fair value at end of year   982,000    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   4.00% 4.00%  
Target Plan Asset Allocations   3.00%    
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   982,000    
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   926,000    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   982,000    
Other Benefits [Member] | Total Fixed Income Securities [Member]
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   46.00% 46.00%  
Target Plan Asset Allocations   45.00%    
Other Benefits [Member] | US Treasuries [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   2,582,000 2,345,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   10.00% 10.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   2,582,000 2,345,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   2,582,000 2,345,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Corporate Bonds [Member]
       
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Investment Maturity Date   within 10 years    
Other Benefits [Member] | Corporate Bonds Other Fixed Income Securities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   9,232,000 8,474,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   36.00% 36.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   9,232,000 8,474,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   9,232,000 8,474,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | High Yield Bonds [Member]
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Target Plan Asset Allocations   5.00%    
Other Benefits [Member] | Total Equity Securities
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   45.00% 45.00%  
Target Plan Asset Allocations   47.00%    
Other Benefits [Member] | Large Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,327,000 1,221,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   5.00% 5.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,327,000 1,221,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,327,000 1,221,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Large Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,352,000 1,149,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   5.00% 5.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,352,000 1,149,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,352,000 1,149,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Small Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,331,000 1,177,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   5.00% 5.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,331,000 1,177,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,331,000 1,177,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Small Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,313,000 1,155,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   5.00% 5.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,313,000 1,155,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,313,000 1,155,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Large Cap Index [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   2,384,000 2,148,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   9.00% 9.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   2,384,000 2,148,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   2,384,000 2,148,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | International Blend [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   4,206,000 3,907,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   16.00% 16.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   4,206,000 3,907,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   4,206,000 3,907,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Total Real Estate [Member]
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   5.00% 5.00%  
Other Benefits [Member] | Global Reit [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   1,161,000    
Fair value at end of year   1,252,000    
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   5.00% 5.00%  
Target Plan Asset Allocations   5.00%    
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,252,000    
Reconciliation Of Plan Assets Classified As Level 3 Roll Forward        
Fair value at beginning of year   1,161,000    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,252,000    
Other Benefits [Member] | Total Investments [Member]
       
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   100.00% 100.00%  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   25,961,000 23,663,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   100.00% 100.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   25,961,000 23,663,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   25,961,000 23,663,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Cash [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   982,000 926,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   982,000 926,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   982,000 926,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | US Treasuries [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   2,582,000 2,345,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   2,582,000 2,345,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   2,582,000 2,345,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Corporate Bonds Other Fixed Income Securities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   9,232,000 8,474,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   9,232,000 8,474,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   9,232,000 8,474,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Large Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,327,000 1,221,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,327,000 1,221,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,327,000 1,221,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Large Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,352,000 1,149,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,352,000 1,149,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,352,000 1,149,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Small Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,331,000 1,177,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,331,000 1,177,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,331,000 1,177,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Small Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,313,000 1,155,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,313,000 1,155,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,313,000 1,155,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Large Cap Index [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   2,384,000 2,148,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   2,384,000 2,148,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   2,384,000 2,148,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | International Blend [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   4,206,000 3,907,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   4,206,000 3,907,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   4,206,000 3,907,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Quoted Prices In Active Markets [Member] | Global Reit [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   1,252,000 1,161,000  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   1,252,000 1,161,000  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   1,252,000 1,161,000  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   0.00% 0.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Cash [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | US Treasuries [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Corporate Bonds Other Fixed Income Securities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Small Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Small Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Index [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | International Blend [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Other Observable Inputs [Member] | Global Reit [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Weighted Average Asset Allocations   0.00% 0.00%  
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Cash [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | US Treasuries [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Corporate Bonds Other Fixed Income Securities [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Small Cap Value [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Small Cap Growth [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Large Cap Index [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | International Blend [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Other Benefits [Member] | Significant Unobservable Inputs [Member] | Global Reit [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Change In Fair Value Of Plan Assets Roll Forward        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
Plan Assets Fair Value Hierarchy [Abstract]        
Defined Benefit Plan Fair Value Of Plan Assets   0 0  
Actual return on plan assets:        
Fair value at end of year   0 0  
NCNG SERP [Member]
       
Net Periodic Benefits Cost Weighted Average Assumptions [Abstract]        
Discount Rate   3.89%    
Directors SERP [Member]
       
Net Periodic Benefits Cost Weighted Average Assumptions [Abstract]        
Discount Rate   4.09%    
Piedmont SERP [Member]
       
Net Periodic Benefits Cost Weighted Average Assumptions [Abstract]        
Discount Rate   3.31%    
Pension [Member]
       
Amounts Not Yet Recognized as a Component of Cost and Recognized in a Deferred Regulatory Account        
Defined Benefit Plan Measurement Date   31-Oct    
Defined Benefit Plan Actuarial Gains And Losses Amortization Corridor   5 years    
Gains And Losses Amortized In Excess Of Percentage   10.00%    
Defined Benefit Pension Plan Funding Target   100.00%    
Supplemental Executive Retirement Plans [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Disclosure [Line Items]        
Defined Benefit Plans General Information   We have pension liabilities related to supplemental executive retirement plans (SERPs) for certain former employees, non-employee directors or surviving spouses. There are no assets related to these SERPs, and no additional benefits accrue to the participants. Payments to the participants are made from operating funds during the year.    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Assets for Participant Benefits   0    
Officers and Director-Level Employees Life Insurance [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Disclosure [Line Items]        
Defined Benefit Plans General Information   We also provide a term life insurance benefit equal to $200,000 to all officers and director-level employees for which we bear the cost of the policies.    
Actual return on plan assets:        
Term Life Insurance Per Individual Benefit Provided By Employer   $ 200,000    
Certain Officers Vice President And Above Life Insurance [Member]
       
Defined Benefit Plan Disclosure [Line Items]        
Defined Benefit Plans General Information   We provide term life insurance policies for certain officers at the vice president level and above who were former participants in a terminated SERP; the level of the insurance benefit is dependent upon the level of the benefit provided under the terminated SERP. These life insurance policies are owned exclusively by each officer. Premiums on these policies are paid and expensed.