16. REVISION OF PRIOR PERIOD FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

During the first quarter of 2013, we identified an error in the rate used to calculate interest on certain regulatory assets. Accounting standards allow for the capitalization of all or part of an incurred cost that would otherwise be charged to expense if the regulator provides orders that create probable recovery of past costs through future revenues. Historically we had accrued interest as specified by regulatory order on certain regulatory balances at our authorized rate of return (ROR). This ROR includes both a debt and equity component, which we are allowed to recover from customers in the form of a carrying cost on regulatory deferred account balances. As the equity component of our ROR is not an incurred cost that would otherwise be charged to expense, this portion of the carrying cost should not have been capitalized for financial reporting purposes.

We assessed the materiality of this error on prior period financial statements and concluded it was not material to any prior annual or interim periods; however, the cumulative impact would have been material to the annual and interim periods for 2013, if corrected in 2013. As a result, in accordance with accounting standards, we revised our prior period financial statements as described below to correct this error. The revision had no effect on reported cash flows.

The adjustment impacted years 2003 through 2012 with a cumulative pre-tax decrease over that period of $5.6 million to regulatory assets and other income and expense. The revision decreased net income by $1.1 million and $0.9 million for the years ended December 31, 2012 and 2011, respectively. The cumulative decrease to January 1, 2011 retained earnings was $1.4 million as a result of the revision.

The following table presents the income statement impacts of this revision for the years ended December 31:



	2012							2011
In thousands, except per share data	Reported Balance		Adjust- ment			Adjusted Balance		Reported Balance		Adjust- ment			Adjusted Balance
Other income and expense, net	$	4,936	$	(1,777	)	$	3,159	$	4,523	$	(1,411	)	$	3,112
Income before income taxes	103,959		(1,777		)	102,182		107,280		(1,411		)	105,869
Income tax expense	44,104		(701		)	43,403		43,382		(557		)	42,825
Net Income	59,855		(1,076		)	58,779		63,898		(854		)	63,044
Comprehensive income	58,364		(1,076		)	57,288		62,702		(854		)	61,848
Basic EPS	2.23		(0.04		)	2.19		2.39		(0.03		)	2.36
Diluted EPS	2.22		(0.04		)	2.18		2.39		(0.03		)	2.36

The following table presents the balance sheet impacts of this revision as of December 31:



	2012							2011
In thousands	Reported Balance		Adjustment			Adjusted Balance		Reported Balance		Adjustment			Adjusted Balance
Non-current assets:
Regulatory assets	$	387,888	$	(5,633	)	$	382,255	$	371,392	$	(3,856	)	$	367,536
Total non-current assets	2,535,054		(5,633		)	2,529,421		2,397,885		(3,856		)	2,394,029
Total assets	2,818,753		(5,633		)	2,813,120		2,746,574		(3,856		)	2,742,718
Liabilities and equity:
Deferred credits and other non-current liabilities:
Deferred tax liabilities	$	446,604	$	(2,227	)	$	444,377	$	413,209	$	(1,526	)	$	411,683
Total deferred credits and other non-current liabilities	1,025,584		(2,227		)	1,023,357		975,922		(1,526		)	974,396
Equity:
Retained earnings	385,753		(3,406		)	382,347		373,905		(2,330		)	371,575
Total equity	733,033		(3,406		)	729,627		714,488		(2,330		)	712,158
Total liabilities and equity	2,818,753		(5,633		)	2,813,120		2,746,574		(3,856		)	2,742,718

The following tables present the income statement and balance sheet corrections for the following quarters:



	2012
	First Quarter				Second Quarter				Third Quarter						Fourth Quarter
In thousands, except per share data	Reported Balance		Adjusted Balance		Reported Balance		Adjusted Balance		Reported Balance			Adjusted Balance			Reported Balance		Adjusted Balance
Other income and expense, net	$	1,005	$	472	$	921	$	620	$	1,710		$	1,180		$	1,300	$	887
Income (loss) before income taxes	68,480		67,947		2,296		1,995		(13,594		)	(14,124		)	46,777		46,364
Income tax expense (benefit)	27,873		27,663		887		768		(3,036		)	(3,245		)	18,380		18,217
Net income (loss)	40,607		40,284		1,409		1,227		(10,558		)	(10,879		)	28,397		28,147
Comprehensive income (loss)	40,773		40,450		1,575		1,393		(10,391		)	(10,712		)	26,407		26,157
Basic EPS	1.52		1.50		0.05		0.05		(0.39		)	(0.41		)	1.06		1.05
Diluted EPS	1.51		1.50		0.05		0.05		(0.39		)	(0.41		)	1.05		1.04

Non-current assets:
Regulatory assets	$	368,521	$	364,132	$	366,981	$	362,290	$	367,692		$	362,472		$	387,888	$	382,255
Total non-current assets	2,416,372		2,411,983		2,448,359		2,443,668		2,492,467			2,487,247			2,535,054		2,529,421
Total assets	2,727,262		2,722,873		2,635,141		2,630,450		2,690,368			2,685,148			2,818,753		2,813,120
Liabilities and equity:
Deferred credits and other non-current liabilities:
Deferred tax liabilities	$	438,486	$	436,750	$	440,073	$	438,217	$	430,885		$	428,821		$	446,604	$	444,377
Total deferred credits and other non-current liabilities	999,028		997,292		991,007		989,151		985,729			983,665			1,025,584		1,023,357
Equity:
Retained earnings	402,599		399,946		392,082		389,247		369,584			366,428			385,753		382,347
Total equity	745,971		743,318		737,570		734,735		717,559			714,403			733,033		729,627
Total liabilities and equity	2,727,262		2,722,873		2,635,141		2,630,450		2,690,368			2,685,148			2,818,753		2,813,120



	2011
	First Quarter				Second Quarter				Third Quarter						Fourth Quarter
In thousands, except per share data	Reported Balance		Adjusted Balance		Reported Balance		Adjusted Balance		Reported Balance			Adjusted Balance			Reported Balance		Adjusted Balance
Other income and expense, net	$	1,214	$	1,291	$	1,122	$	779	$	1,781		$	1,426		$	406	$	(384	)
Income (loss) before income taxes	68,627		68,704		3,509		3,166		(14,012		)	(14,367		)	49,156		48,366
Income tax expense (benefit)	27,854		27,884		1,316		1,181		(5,700		)	(5,840		)	19,912		19,600
Net income (loss)	40,773		40,820		2,193		1,985		(8,312		)	(8,527		)	29,244		28,766
Comprehensive income (loss)	40,919		40,966		2,339		2,131		(8,166		)	(8,381		)	27,610		27,132
Basic EPS	1.53		1.53		0.08		0.07		(0.31		)	(0.32		)	1.09		1.08
Diluted EPS	1.53		1.53		0.08		0.07		(0.31		)	(0.32		)	1.09		1.07

Non-current assets:
Regulatory assets	$	345,452	$	343,085	$	326,081	$	323,371	$	328,757		$	325,692		$	371,392	$	367,536
Total non-current assets	2,290,848		2,288,481		2,294,100		2,291,390		2,317,293			2,314,228			2,397,885		2,394,029
Total assets	2,571,553		2,569,186		2,521,994		2,519,284		2,567,840			2,564,775			2,746,574		2,742,718
Liabilities and equity:
Deferred credits and other non-current liabilities:
Deferred tax liabilities	$	396,357	$	395,419	$	398,825	$	397,751	$	394,217		$	393,003		$	413,209	$	411,683
Total deferred credits and other non-current liabilities	873,714		872,776		874,842		873,768		866,927			865,713			975,922		974,396
Equity:
Retained earnings	385,899		384,470		376,489		374,853		356,574			354,723			373,905		371,575
Total equity	723,228		721,799		714,628		712,992		696,605			694,754			714,488		712,158
Total liabilities and equity	2,571,553		2,569,186		2,521,994		2,519,284		2,567,840			2,564,775			2,746,574		2,742,718