1. | We note from your response letter dated July 23, 2018 that you received a one-time payment related to a provision of your co-brand agreement, and that you allocated this type of revenue across your performance obligations. You then describe how you defer this revenue allocated to MileagePlus award miles, but recognize up front revenue allocated to the other three performance obligation categories. Please revise this disclosure to include a policy disclosure related to this type of payment. |
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission September 5, 2018 Page 2 |
2. | On page 17 of this Form 10-Q, you indicate that under ASC 606, you identified four separately identifiable performance obligation categories in your co-brand agreement with Chase Bank, and determined revenue recognition patterns based on satisfaction of those performance obligations. We note that travel-related revenue, such as revenue from MileagePlus miles awarded, bag fees, and seat upgrades is deferred and recognized in passenger revenue at the time of travel. In contrast, advertising, lounge pass revenue, and marketing revenue is recorded in other operating revenue based on various factors, such as when the lounge pass is used, or customer use pattern of the credit card over the term of the co-brand agreement. Your response to comment 2 in your letter dated July 23, 2018 indicates the $50 million relates to a cash payment received under a provision of the co-brand agreement and, similar to other consideration received under the co-brand agreement, you allocated the payment across the performance obligations identified in the co-brand agreement based on fixed percentages. The amounts related to MileagePlus miles awarded were deferred, while the $50 million allocated to marketing, advertising, and certain other travel related benefits was recognized on receipt. This recognition pattern appears to be consistent with the policy set forth in your Form 10-K, prior to adoption of ASC 606. Please tell us why you believe your recognition pattern in the first quarter complies with your recognition policy for such revenue under ASC 606. |
cc: | David Vitale, Chairman, Audit Committee |
Oscar Munoz, Chief Executive Officer | |
Gerry Laderman, Executive Vice President Finance and Chief Financial Officer | |
Brett J. Hart, Executive Vice President, Chief Administrative Officer and General Counsel | |
Darren J. Ludwig, Partner, Ernst & Young LLP | |
Douglas Urbanciz, Partner, Ernst & Young LLP |
'!A8VME="!B96=I
M;CTB[[N_(B!I9#TB5S5-,$UP0V5H:4AZ V5[MMU/8[C:2V][$VEXY$9'0^C(P#*?D0#U(\%Q!=0QW%K.DENXJK*0RL/
M4,"01\P>E%[2]/=>]^Z]U[W[KW1,OEU_,&^(7P8PE-EODKW1MO8N2R=#+D-O
M;'IQ5[C[&W131R24ZSX'8NWZ?([BJ)61F UTD$..BEXEJ([$@=\D^VG.WN
M%<-#RIL,MQ$C:7E-$@C/&CS.50-3.@$N1\*GH/;]S7L'+,8DWC<4B=A54RTC
M?Z5%JU*XU4"@\2.J)=_?\*P?B#A\E4TG7/QU^06^:&!ECBRNX:C8.PX*U@Y6
M66FI8-P[QK4I= #1F9(I7O9HX_>1&V_ /0&NO
M>GE:SNKFTEL-P,D4C(2$AI525-*S@TJ,5 ^SJ[SXI?)38OS!^/G6?R3ZTQ.[
M,'L;M7$5^:V]BM]4.'QF[*.EQV>RVWIX\S0X#.[FP]/4-6X>5D$%?4*8F4E@
MQ*KC_P Y 0V\BO-8R EX?#9G@CG_5 1D4TU$ED-OO/+^[:MZDM;+;
M-[F\![:UE97@DD0B.X4UHKZ@%D>/L-0Q' ,<_OW_A/5_+L[AW=UK-T+W5\U
MOE'LK=^;VOO:KWSU_F.[=W/V#@JV6#)1Y"G[DK>O^K*_)4^3IWE.3P.(J?(
M9H9)@(_9O;;=]YGW/V.RW5>8[#8.4+B!)(A%,MK'X+@%=)M1-2 18;9G1F7V]'%(BD^*/+P
M#4-*%R1[!TGW?^38KAY^ +72:C50
M5H#05P8K[Z;,)9$EV6X\(,0&5D:H!-#1M%*BAI7%>.,FOZR_X4U?RONP76FW
M;FN[NEUF8PR2=G=25&6I+-Z"SMU#F^U9# ]_JT8.G]2CZ>P9NWW3?=S; 7LH
M-OOR,_H7(4_]G*6^?S^SH]LO>7DN[-)Y+FW_ .:D51_U2:7I+]J?)/X@_.[Y
MY?RNMG?%'?G679.WNN.R^Z?DUW!N79F,AQE9L/#=,]7O_<"/=T.0Q>&S>&I<
M]O#=GCA2ICCC$D9 C8>
M3?=W^L?-MC.D.[[7_>9/\ -UMS?R[/B]N+
MX7?##HSXQ[LW'@]W;BZIPNY,;E-Q[:@KZ;"96?.[ZW3NU9Z"#)Q0UT:)#GUC
M?R*"9$8CBWO"KW/YNM>?.>^8>;;*UD@M;R1&5'(+J$ACCH2M1Q2HIY$=3SRE
MLLO+O+NV;-/,LDT"L"RUH=3LV*Y_%UJI?\*FOG1_>??G7/P*V)F->&Z[&/[:
M[R%'/Z*G?&;QDJ=<[/K?&R.#MO:>2FR]1"VN&5LS1/Q+3<9B_= ]O/I-NW3W
M&W]>ZU6UI4<(D;]>4?Z>11&IP1X4@X/U"'O9S-XUU:
Z/-.^VZMB9C
M,X'>^Q8:YL5V!M#*[?RL^#R\6X-C9N+';IH*.FRU-) E::4T-2RW@FE4AC@]
MS)R+S;RC'9S\P;%/;V=PBO%,1JAD5U#J4E35&25()75K7\2@XZR VOF'9=Z:
M>/;=PCDGB8JZ5HZ%3I.I#1@ <5II/D3T1_J#H'HS>N^?F+_+R^0'5FQ>T>L>
MOM_8WY'=&[6WSMZ@R$6&Z:^54NY-SY"CV<]0AR&!.P>^L!O7'T=9C)J>;'X]
MZ&&-XM*#W(&]\R