XML 72 R39.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v2.4.0.6
Income Taxes And Other Taxes
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2012
Income Taxes And Other Taxes [Abstract]  
Income Taxes And Other Taxes

24. INCOME TAXES

Duke Energy and its subsidiaries file income tax returns in the U.S. with federal and various state governmental authorities, and in certain foreign jurisdictions. The taxable income of Duke Energy and its subsidiaries is reflected in Duke Energy's U.S. federal and state income tax returns. These subsidiaries have a tax sharing agreement with Duke Energy where the separate return method is used to allocate tax expenses and benefits to the subsidiaries whose investments or results of operations provide these tax expenses and benefits. The accounting for income taxes essentially represents the income taxes that each of these subsidiaries would incur if it were a separate company filing its own tax return as a C-Corporation.

Components of Income Tax Expense

    Year Ended December 31, 2012
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Current income taxes                     
 Federal $ (46) $ (1) $ (88) $ (48) $ 6 $ 26 $ (27)
 State   35   (25)   2   (6)     11   27
 Foreign   133            
  Total current income taxes   122   (26)   (86)   (54)   6   37  
Deferred income taxes                     
 Federal   513   408   226   162   121   72   (47)
 State   64   77   40   9   21   (9)   (25)
 Foreign   20            
  Total deferred income taxes(a)   597   485   266   171   142   63   (72)
Investment tax credit amortization   (14)   (6)   (8)   (7)   (1)   (2)   (1)
Income tax expense (benefit) from continuing operations(b)   705   453   172   110   147   98   (73)
Tax expense from discontinued operations   24     29        
Total income tax expense (benefit) included in Consolidated Statements of Operations $ 729 $ 453 $ 201 $ 110 $ 147 $ 98 $ (73)
                        
(a)Includes benefits of net operating loss (NOL) carryforwards of $1,127 million at Duke Energy, $245 million at Duke Energy Carolinas, $357 million at Progress Energy, $257 million at Progress Energy Carolinas, $25 million at Progress Energy Florida, $99 million at Duke Energy Ohio and $205 million at Duke Energy Indiana.
(b)Includes uncertain tax benefits relating primarily to certain temporary differences of $27 million at Duke Energy, $11 million at Duke Energy Carolinas, $(42) million at Progress Energy, $(6) million at Progress Energy Carolinas, $(36) million at Progress Energy Florida, $4 million at Duke Energy Ohio and $9 million at Duke Energy Indiana. The offset to these temporary differences are included in deferred income taxes.

    Year Ended December 31, 2011
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Current income taxes                     
 Federal $ (37) $ (122) $ (91) $ (27) $ (60) $ (95) $ 95
 State   21   30   29   21   5   1   42
 Foreign   164            
  Total current income taxes   148   (92)   (62)   (6)   (55)   (94)   137
Deferred income taxes                     
 Federal   526   531   365   262   214   194   (38)
 State   56   40   27   6   22   (2)   (23)
 Foreign   32            
  Total deferred income taxes(a)   614   571   392   268   236   192   (61)
Investment tax credit amortization   (10)   (7)   (7)   (6)   (1)   (2)   (2)
Income tax expense from continuing operations(b)   752   472   323   256   180   96   74
Tax benefit from discontinued operations       (3)        
Total income tax expense included in Consolidated Statements of Operations $ 752 $ 472 $ 320 $ 256 $ 180 $ 96 $ 74
                        
(a)Includes benefits of NOL carryforwards of $274 million at Duke Energy, $79 million at Duke Energy Carolinas, $213 million at Progress Energy, $54 million at Progress Energy Carolinas, $41 million at Progress Energy Florida and $47 million at Duke Energy Ohio.
(b)Includes benefits of uncertain tax benefits relating primarily to certain temporary differences of $43 million at Duke Energy, $43 million at Duke Energy Carolinas, $(3) million at Progress Energy, $(1) million at Progress Energy Carolinas, $(19) million at Progress Energy Florida, $3 million at Duke Energy Ohio and $3 million at Duke Energy Indiana. The offset to these temporary differences are included in deferred income taxes.

    Year Ended December 31, 2010
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Current income taxes                     
 Federal $ (5) $ 3 $ (46) $ 73 $ (44) $ 107 $ (3)
 State   39   (2)   (13)   (8)   (4)   8   16
 Foreign   125            
  Total current income taxes(a)   159   1   (59)   65   (48)   115   13
Deferred income taxes                     
 Federal   639   388   505   238   286   6   123
 State   83   75   100   53   39   12   22
 Foreign   20            
  Total deferred income taxes(b)   742   463   605   291   325   18   145
Investment tax credit amortization   (11)   (7)   (7)   (6)   (1)   (1)   (2)
Income tax expense from continuing operations   890   457   539   350   276   132   156
Tax benefit from discontinued operations   (1)     (9)        
Total income tax expense included in Consolidated Statements of Operations $ 889 $ 457 $ 530 $ 350 $ 276 $ 132 $ 156
                        
(a)Includes uncertain tax benefits relating primarily to certain temporary differences of $(392) million at Duke Energy, $(300) million at Duke Energy Carolinas, $16 million at Progress Energy, $15 million at Progress Energy Carolinas, $1 million at Progress Energy Florida, $(3) million at Duke Energy Ohio and $(7) million at Duke Energy Indiana. The offset to these temporary differences are included in deferred income taxes.
(b)Includes benefits of NOL carryforwards of $37 million at Progress Energy and $9 million at Progress Energy Florida.

Duke Energy Income from Continuing Operations before Income Taxes
           
  Years Ended December 31,
(in millions)201220112010
Domestic $ 1,827 $ 1,780 $ 1,731
Foreign   624   685   479
 Income from continuing operations before income taxes $ 2,451 $ 2,465 $ 2,210

Reconciliation of Income Tax Expense at the U.S. Federal Statutory Tax Rate to the Actual Tax Expense from Continuing Operations (Statutory Rate Reconciliation) 
                         
    Year Ended December 31, 2012 
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana 
Income tax expense, computed at the statutory rate of 35% $ 858 $ 461 $ 185 $ 134 $ 145 $ 96 $ (43) 
 State income tax, net of federal income tax effect   64   34   33   1   14   1   1 
 Tax differential on foreign earnings   (66)             
 AFUDC equity income   (101)   (54)   (37)   (24)   (13)   (2)   (26) 
 Other items, net   (50)   12   (9)   (1)   1   3   (5) 
  Income tax expense from continuing operations $ 705 $ 453 $ 172 $ 110 $ 147 $ 98 $ (73) 
Effective tax rate   28.8%  34.3%  32.7%  28.7%  35.7%  36.0%  59.5%

    Year Ended December 31, 2011 
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana 
Income tax expense, computed at the statutory rate of 35% $ 863 $ 457 $ 319 $ 270 $ 173 $ 102 $ 85 
 State income tax, net of federal income tax effect   50   46   39   18   17   (1)   13 
 Tax differential on foreign earnings   (44)             
 AFUDC equity income   (91)   (59)   (36)   (25)   (11)   (2)   (31) 
 Other items, net   (26)   28   1   (7)   1   (3)   7 
  Income tax expense from continuing operations $ 752 $ 472 $ 323 $ 256 $ 180 $ 96 $ 74 
Effective tax rate   30.5%  36.1%  35.6%  33.2%  36.3%  33.1%  30.6%

    Year Ended December 31, 2010 
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana 
Income tax expense, computed at the statutory rate of 35% $ 774 $ 454 $ 492 $ 333 $ 255 $ (108) $ 155 
 State income tax, net of federal income tax effect   82   48   60   30   23   14   26 
 Tax differential on foreign earnings   (22)             
 Goodwill impairment charges   175           237   
 AFUDC equity income   (82)   (61)   (32)   (22)   (10)   (2)   (20) 
 Other items, net   (37)   16   19   9   8   (9)   (5) 
  Income tax expense from continuing operations $ 890 $ 457 $ 539 $ 350 $ 276 $ 132 $ 156 
Effective tax rate   40.3%  35.3%  38.3%  36.8%  37.9%  (43.0)%  35.5%

Valuation allowances have been established for certain foreign and state net operating loss carryforwards that reduce deferred tax assets to an amount that will be realized on a more-likely-than-not basis. The net change in the total valuation allowance is included in Tax differential on foreign earnings and State income tax, net of federal income tax effect in the above tables.

Net Deferred Income Tax Liability Components
                        
    December 31, 2012
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Deferred credits and other liabilities $ 2,948 $ 194 $ 822 $ 342 $ 333 $ 52 $ 115
Tax credits and NOL carryforwards   3,311   447   1,536   309   91   152   340
Other   408   22   230   82   126   10   27
Valuation allowance   (226)     (77)       (1)  
 Total deferred income tax assets   6,441   663   2,511   733   550   213   482
Investments and other assets   (1,093)   (838)   (112)   (108)   (6)   (25)   (18)
Accelerated depreciation rates   (11,208)   (4,289)   (2,803)   (2,178)   (592)   (1,823)   (1,131)
Regulatory assets and deferred debits   (3,819)   (627)   (1,775)   (465)   (1,318)   (197)   (185)
 Total deferred income tax liabilities   (16,120)   (5,754)   (4,690)   (2,751)   (1,916)   (2,045)   (1,334)
 Net deferred income tax liabilities $ (9,679) $ (5,091) $ (2,179) $ (2,018) $ (1,366) $ (1,832) $ (852)

The following table presents the expiration of tax credits and NOL carryforwards.

    December 31, 2012
(in millions) AmountExpiration year
Investment Tax Credits $ 391 2029-2032
Alternative Minimum Tax Credits   1,033 Indefinite
Federal NOL carryforwards   1,604 2031-2032
State NOL carryforwards(a)   166 2013-2032
Foreign NOL carryforwards(b)   117 2015-2032; Indefinite
 Total tax credits and NOL carryforwards $ 3,311  
        
(a)A valuation allowance of $121 million has been recorded on the state NOL carryforwards and state capital loss carryforwards, as presented in the Net Deferred Income Tax Liability Components table.
(b)A valuation allowance of $105 million has been recorded on the foreign NOL carryforwards, as presented in the Net Deferred Income Tax Liability Components table.

    December 31, 2011
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Deferred credits and other liabilities $ 790 $ 228 $ 900 $ 441 $ 513 $ 68 $ 92
Tax credits and NOL carryforwards   930   199   1,163   57   42     95
Regulatory liabilities and deferred credits       375   142   198    
Investments and other assets             3  
Other   137   18   522   168   101   31   5
Valuation allowance   (144)     (71)        
 Total deferred income tax assets   1,713   445   2,889   808   854   102   192
Investments and other assets   (809)   (720)     (103)   (56)     (2)
Accelerated depreciation rates   (6,989)   (3,576)   (3,098)   (1,908)   (1,180)   (1,706)   (968)
Regulatory assets and deferred debits   (1,219)   (658)   (1,271)   (541)   (685)   (216)   (136)
Other       (315)   (17)   (120)    
 Total deferred income tax liabilities   (9,017)   (4,954)   (4,684)   (2,569)   (2,041)   (1,922)   (1,106)
 Net deferred income tax liabilities $ (7,304) $ (4,509) $ (1,795) $ (1,761) $ (1,187) $ (1,820) $ (914)

Classification of Deferred Tax Assets (Liabilities) in the Consolidated Balance Sheets
                        
    December 31, 2012
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Current deferred tax assets, included in Other within Current Assets $ 732 $ 90 $ 359 $ 144 $ 152 $ 21 $ 1
Non-current deferred tax assets, included in Other within Investments and Other Assets   85     20        
Current deferred tax liabilities, included in Other within Current Liabilities   (6)            
Non-current deferred tax liabilities, included in Other within Deferred Credits and Other Liabilities   (10,490)   (5,181)   (2,558)   (2,162)   (1,518)   (1,853)   (853)
 Net deferred income tax liabilities $ (9,679) $ (5,091) $ (2,179) $ (2,018) $ (1,366) $ (1,832) $ (852)

    December 31, 2011
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Current deferred tax assets, included in Other within Current Assets $ 210 $ 46 $ 371 $ 142 $ 138 $ 33 $ 13
Non-current deferred tax assets, included in Other within Investments and Other Assets   67     27        
Non-current deferred tax liabilities, included in Other within Deferred Credits and Other Liabilities   (7,581)   (4,555)   (2,193)   (1,903)   (1,325)   (1,853)   (927)
 Net deferred income tax liabilities $ (7,304) $ (4,509) $ (1,795) $ (1,761) $ (1,187) $ (1,820) $ (914)

Deferred income taxes and foreign withholding taxes have not been provided on undistributed earnings of Duke Energy's foreign subsidiaries when such amounts are deemed to be indefinitely reinvested. The cumulative undistributed earnings as of December 31, 2012 on which Duke Energy has not provided deferred income taxes and foreign withholding taxes is $2 billion. The amount of unrecognized deferred tax liability related to these undistributed earnings is estimated at between $275 million and $350 million.

Changes to Unrecognized Tax Benefits
                        
    Year Ended December 31, 2012
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Unrecognized tax benefits — January 1 $ 385 $ 260 $ 173 $ 73 $ 80 $ 32 $ 24
Acquisitions   128            
Unrecognized tax benefits increases (decreases)                     
 Gross increases — tax positions in prior periods   29   12   23   10   12   2   6
 Gross decreases — tax positions in prior periods   (4)     (72)   (19)   (52)    
 Gross increases — current period tax positions   28   15   8   4   4   4   4
 Gross decreases — current period tax positions   (9)   (5)   (1)   (1)     (2)   (2)
 Settlements   (13)   (11)          
 Statute   (4)            
 Total changes   155   11   (42)   (6)   (36)   4   8
Unrecognized tax benefits — December 31 $ 540 $ 271 $ 131 $ 67 $ 44 $ 36 $ 32

    Year Ended December 31, 2011
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Unrecognized tax benefits — January 1 $ 342 $ 217 $ 176 $ 74 $ 99 $ 29 $ 21
Unrecognized tax benefits increases (decreases)                     
 Gross increases — tax positions in prior periods   49   42   88   19   66   4   3
 Gross decreases — tax positions in prior periods   (18)   (8)   (24)   (14)   (21)   (5)   (3)
 Gross increases — current period tax positions   16   9   9   8   1   4   3
 Gross decreases — current period tax positions       (8)   (4)   (4)    
 Settlements   (4)     (68)   (10)   (61)    
 Total changes   43   43   (3)   (1)   (19)   3   3
Unrecognized tax benefits — December 31 $ 385 $ 260 $ 173 $ 73 $ 80 $ 32 $ 24

    Year Ended December 31, 2010
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Unrecognized tax benefits — January 1 $ 664 $ 517 $ 160 $ 59 $ 98 $ 32 $ 28
Unrecognized tax benefits increases (decreases)                     
 Gross increases — tax positions in prior periods   36   14   10   8   2   15   7
 Gross decreases — tax positions in prior periods   (43)   (7)   (4)   (2)   (1)   (21)   (13)
 Gross increases — current period tax positions   5   3   14   10   3   1   1
 Gross decreases — current period tax positions       (4)   (1)   (3)    
 Settlements   (320)   (310)         2   (2)
 Total changes   (322)   (300)   16   15   1   (3)   (7)
Unrecognized tax benefits — December 31 $ 342 $ 217 $ 176 $ 74 $ 99 $ 29 $ 21

The following table includes information regarding the Duke Energy Registrants' unrecognized tax benefits(a).

  December 31, 2012
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Amount that if recognized, would affect the effective tax rate or regulatory liability(b) $ 131 $ 113 $ 8 $ 1 $ 1 $ $ 1
Amount that if recognized, would be recorded as a component of discontinued operations   11     3        
                       
(a)It is reasonably possible that Duke Energy and Duke Energy Carolinas will reflect an approximate $65 million reduction in unrecognized tax benefits within the next 12 months due to expected settlements. All other Duke Energy Registrants do not anticipate a material increase or decrease in unrecognized tax benefits within the next 12 months.
(b)Duke Energy, Duke Energy Carolinas, Progress Energy, Progress Energy Carolinas and Progress Energy Florida are unable to estimate the specific amounts that would affect the effective tax rate or regulatory liability.

The following tables include interest and penalties recognized in the Consolidated Statements of Operations and the Consolidated Balance Sheets:

  As of and For the Year Ended December 31, 2012
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Net interest income recognized related to income taxes $ 10 $ 9 $ $ $ $ $ 2
Net interest expense recognized related to income taxes       2     2    
Interest receivable related to income taxes      7          
Interest payable related to income taxes   7     17   8   9   3   1

  As of and For the Year Ended December 31, 2011
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Net interest income recognized related to income taxes $ 12 $ 5 $ 24 $ 6 $ 22 $ $
Net interest expense recognized related to income taxes             1   1
Interest receivable related to income taxes   8   5          
Interest payable related to income taxes       21   8   7   3   3

  Year Ended December 31, 2010
(in millions)Duke EnergyDuke Energy CarolinasProgress EnergyProgress Energy CarolinasProgress Energy FloridaDuke Energy OhioDuke Energy Indiana
Net interest income recognized related to income taxes $ 26 $ 18 $ $ $ $ 4 $ 5
Net interest expense recognized related to income taxes       9   4   5    

Duke Energy, Duke Energy Carolinas, Duke Energy Ohio and Duke Energy Indiana are no longer subject to U.S. federal examination for years before 2004. The years 2004 and 2005 are in Appeals, waiting for approval from the Joint Committee. The 2006-2007 years are also in Appeals, waiting for the prior cycle to close. The IRS is currently auditing the federal income tax returns for years 2008 through 2011.

Progress Energy, Progress Energy Carolinas and Progress Energy Florida are no longer subject to U.S. federal examination for years before 2007. The IRS has examined years 2007 through 2009 and examination has been completed.

With few exceptions, Duke Energy and its subsidiaries are no longer subject to state, local or non-U.S. income tax examinations by tax authorities for years before 2004.