XML 88 R17.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v2.4.0.6
Pension and Postretirement Benefit Plans
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2011
Pension and Postretirement Benefit Plans

Note 10.  Pension and Postretirement Benefit Plans

 

We sponsor various defined benefit, qualified and nonqualified, pension plans covering eligible employees. Other postretirement benefits (OPEB), including medical and life insurance, are provided for certain employees upon retirement.

 

We also sponsor various defined contribution plans that cover the majority of our employees. Under the terms of the qualified defined contribution retirement plans, employee and employer contributions may be directed into a number of diverse investments. None of these qualified defined contribution plans allow direct investment in our stock.

 

Components of net periodic benefit costs and other amounts recognized in OCI

 

    Pension Benefits
    2011   2010   2009
    U.S.   Non-U.S.   U.S.   Non-U.S.   U.S.   Non-U.S.
Interest cost   $ 92     $ 13     $ 100     $ 17     $ 109     $ 19  
Expected return on plan assets     (104 )     (2 )     (99 )     (5 )     (116 )     (9 )
Service cost             5               5               6  
Amortization of net actuarial loss     20               19                          
Curtailment (gain) loss                                     1       (1 )
Settlement loss             5               2               1  
Termination cost                                     2          
Net periodic benefit cost (credit)     8       21       20       19       (4 )     16  
                                                 
Recognized in OCI:                                                
Amount due to net actuarial (gains) losses     66       (1 )     29       3       285       27  
Prior service cost from                                                
plan amendments                                             (1 )
Amortization of net actuarial                                                
losses in net periodic cost     (20 )     (5 )     (19 )     (2 )                
Total recognized in OCI     46       (6 )     10       1       285       26  
Net recognized in benefit cost and OCI   $ 54     $ 15     $ 30     $ 20     $ 281     $ 42  

 

    OPEB - Non-U.S
    2011   2010   2009
  Interest cost   $ 7     $ 7     $ 6  
  Service cost                     1  
  Curtailment gain                     (2 )
     Net periodic benefit cost     7       7       5  
                         
 Recognized in OCI:                        
  Amount due to net actuarial (gains) losses     7       (1 )     9  
  Total recognized in OCI     7       (1 )     9  
  Net recognized in benefit cost and OCI   $ 14     $ 6     $ 14  

 

Our U.S. pension plans are frozen and no additional service cost is being accrued. The estimated net actuarial loss for the defined benefit pension plans that will be amortized from AOCI into benefit cost in 2012 is $14 for our U.S. plans and a nominal amount for our non-U.S. plans. The year-over-year decrease in amortization of net actuarial losses is primarily due to a change in amortization methods in accordance with our policy from the average remaining service period of active participants to the average remaining life expectancy of inactive participants for one of our U.S. plans as a result of almost all of the plan’s participants being inactive. There is no net actuarial gain or loss related to OPEB plans that will be amortized from AOCI into benefit cost in 2012 for our non-U.S. plans.

 

 

 

Funded status — The following tables provide reconciliations of the changes in benefit obligations, plan assets and funded status and amounts recognized in the consolidated balance sheets.

 

    Pension Benefits        
    2011   2010   OPEB - Non-U.S.
    U.S.   Non-U.S.   U.S.   Non-U.S.   2011   2010
Reconciliation of benefit obligation:                                                
  Obligation at beginning   $ 1,866     $ 325     $ 1,831     $ 351     $ 132     $ 124  
     of period                                                
  Interest cost     92       13       100       17       7       7  
  Service cost             5               5                  
  Actuarial (gain) loss     114       (2 )     94       7       7       (1 )
  Benefit payments     (141 )     (17 )     (159 )     (17 )     (6 )     (6 )
  Settlements, curtailments                                                
     and terminations             (77 )             (33 )                
  Translation adjustments             (4 )             (5 )     (3 )     8  
 Obligation at end of period   $ 1,931     $ 243     $ 1,866     $ 325     $ 137     $ 132  

 

    Pension Benefits        
    2011   2010   OPEB - Non-U.S.
    U.S.   Non-U.S.   U.S.   Non-U.S.   2011   2010
Reconciliation of fair value of plan assets:                                                
  Fair value at beginning of period   $ 1,456     $ 120     $ 1,401     $ 136     $ —       $ —    
  Actual return on plan assets     152       1       164       9                  
  Employer contributions     30       14       50       18       6       6  
  Benefit payments     (141 )     (17 )     (159 )     (17 )     (6 )     (6 )
  Settlements             (77 )             (33 )                
  Translation adjustments             2               7                  
  Fair value at end of period   $ 1,497     $ 43     $ 1,456     $ 120     $ —       $ —    
                                                 
 Funded status at end of period   $ (434 )   $ (200 )   $ (410 )   $ (205 )   $ (137 )   $ (132 )

 

Amounts recognized in the balance sheet

 

    Pension Benefits        
    2011   2010   OPEB - Non-U.S.
    U.S.   Non-U.S.   U.S.   Non-U.S.   2011   2010
Amounts recognized in the consolidated balance sheet:                                                
  Noncurrent assets   $ —       $ 8     $ —       $ 10     $ —       $ —    
  Current liabilities             (10 )             (10 )     (7 )     (7 )
  Noncurrent liabilities     (434 )     (198 )     (410 )     (205 )     (130 )     (125 )
  Net amount recognized   $ (434 )   $ (200 )   $ (410 )   $ (205 )   $ (137 )   $ (132 )

 

 

 

    Pension Benefits        
    2011   2010   OPEB - Non-U.S.
    U.S.   Non-U.S.   U.S.   Non-U.S.   2011   2010
Amounts recognized in AOCI:                                                
 Net actuarial loss (gain)   $ 443     $ 12     $ 397     $ 18     $ —       $ (7 )
 Prior service cost             6               6                  
 Gross amount recognized     443       18       397       24               (7 )
 Deferred tax benefits             (2 )             (3 )                
 Minority and equity interests             (1 )             (1 )                
 Net amount recognized   $ 443     $ 15     $ 397     $ 20     $ —       $ (7 )

 

During 2011, we made $30 in minimum required contributions to our U.S. pension plans. In January 2012, we made a voluntary contribution to the U.S. pension plans of $150. The $50 contributed to our U.S. pension plans in 2010 was also voluntary.

 

As a result of the closure of several facilities in Canada, we are required to settle the related pension benefit obligations. During the first half of 2011, we settled portions of our Canadian pension benefit obligations by making lump-sum payments or by purchasing non-participating annuity contracts to cover vested benefits. As a result of these actions, we reduced the benefit obligations by $77 and also reduced the fair value of plan assets by $77. The related settlement loss of $5 representing the recognition of a portion of the actuarial loss deferred in AOCI was included in restructuring charges. During principally the fourth quarter of 2010, similar settlement actions resulted in concurrent reductions in benefit obligations and fair value of plan assets by $32 and a related settlement loss of $2 which was included in restructuring charges. Settlement actions completed during the first quarter of 2009 reduced obligations and plan assets by $43 and we recorded the related settlement loss of $1 in cost of sales.

 

In 2009, we recorded a net charge of less than $1 in pension curtailment costs and $2 in postretirement health care curtailment gains related to our workforce reduction actions. These costs were included in restructuring charges. We also announced the anticipated sale of substantially all of the assets of our Structural Products business, which resulted in a termination of pension service. The associated cost of $2 was recorded in other income, net along with other costs associated with the sale.

 

Aggregate funding levels — The following table presents information regarding the aggregate funding levels of our defined benefit pension plans at December 31:

 

    2011   2010
    U.S   Non-U.S   U.S   Non-U.S
Plans with fair value of plan assets in excess of obligations:                                
  Accumulated benefit obligation   $ 16     $ 16     $ 15     $ 90  
  Projected benefit obligation     16       16       15       91  
  Fair value of plan assets     16       24       15       101  
Plans with obligations in excess of fair value of plan assets:                                
  Accumulated benefit obligation     1,915       209       1,851       215  
  Projected benefit obligation     1,915       227       1,851       234  
  Fair value of plan assets     1,481       19       1,441       19  

 

At December 31, 2011, benefit obligations of $189 for certain non-U.S. pension plans and $137 for OPEB benefits are in plans that are not required to be funded.

 

 

 

Fair value of pension plan assets

 

        Fair Value Measurements at December 31, 2011
        U.S.   Non-U.S.
        Quoted   Significant       Significant    
        Prices in   Other   Significant   Other   Significant
        Active   Observable   Unobservable   Observable   Unobservable
        Markets   Inputs   Inputs   Inputs   Inputs
Asset Category   Total   (Level 1)   (Level 2)   (Level 3)   (Level 2)   (Level 3)
 Equity securities:                                                
 U.S. all cap (a)   $ 56     $ 56     $ —       $ —       $ —       $ —    
 U.S. large cap     114       114                                  
 U.S. small cap     35       35                                  
 EAFE composite     127       127                                  
 Emerging markets     52       52                                  
 Fixed income securities:                                                
 U.S. core bonds (b)     163               163                          
 Corporate bonds     501               501                          
 U.S. Treasury strips     265               265                          
 Non-U.S. government                                                
 securities     24                               24          
 Emerging market debt     44               44                          
 Alternative Investments:                                                
 Hedge fund of funds (c)     73                       73                  
 Insurance contracts (d)     10                                       10  
 Real estate     42                       42                  
 Other     6                       1       5          
 Cash and cash equivalents     28               24               4          
 Total   $ 1,540     $ 384     $ 997     $ 116     $ 33     $ 10  

 

        Fair Value Measurements at December 31, 2010
        U.S.   Non-U.S.
        Quoted   Significant       Significant    
        Prices in   Other   Significant   Other   Significant
        Active   Observable   Unobservable   Observable   Unobservable
        Markets   Inputs   Inputs   Inputs   Inputs
Asset Category   Total   (Level 1)   (Level 2)   (Level 3)   (Level 2)   (Level 3)
 Equity securities:                                                
 U.S. all cap (a)   $ 66     $ 66     $ —       $ —       $ —       $ —    
 U.S. large cap     115       115                                  
 U.S. small cap     35       35                                  
 EAFE composite     160       160                                  
 Emerging markets     65       65                                  
 Fixed income securities:                                                
 U.S. core bonds (b)     112               112                          
 Corporate bonds     467               463               4          
 U.S. Treasury strips     219               219                          
 Non-U.S. government                                                
 securities     91                               91          
 Emerging market debt     41               41                          
 Alternative Investments:                                                
 Hedge fund of funds (c)     78                       78                  
 Insurance contracts (d)     10                                       10  
 Real estate     19                       19                  
 Other     5                       1       4          
 Cash and cash equivalents     93               82               11          
 Total   $ 1,576     $ 441     $ 917     $ 98     $ 110     $ 10  

 


Notes:

(a)

This category comprises a combination of small-, mid- and large-cap equity stocks that are allocated at the investment manager’s discretion.

(b)

This category represents a combination of investment grade corporate bonds, sovereign bonds, Yankee bonds, asset backed securities and U.S. government bonds.

(c)

This category includes fund managers that invest in a well-diversified group of hedge funds where strategies include, but are not limited to, event driven, relative value, long/short market neutral, multistrategy and global macro.

(d)

This category comprises contracts placed with insurance companies where the underlying assets are invested in fixed interest securities.

 

 

 

    2011   2010
    U.S.   Non-U.S.   U.S.   Non-U.S.
Reconciliation of Level 3 Assets   Hedge fund of funds   Real Estate and Other   Insurance contract   Hedge fund of funds   Real Estate and Other   Insurance contract
Fair value at beginning of period   $ 78     $ 20     $ 10     $ 109     $ 2     $ 9  
Unrealized gains (losses) relating to                                                
Assets sold during the period                             (36 )                
Assets still held at the reporting date     (5 )     4               5               1  
Purchases             19                       18          
Fair value at end of period   $ 73     $ 43     $ 10     $ 78     $ 20     $ 10  

 

Investment policy — Target asset allocations of U.S. pension plans are established through an investment policy, which is updated periodically and reviewed by an Investment Committee, comprised of certain company officers and directors. The investment policy allows for a flexible asset allocation mix which is intended to provide appropriate diversification to lessen market volatility while assuming a reasonable level of economic risk.

 

Our policy recognizes that properly managing the relationship between pension assets and pension liabilities serves to mitigate the impact of market volatility on our funding levels. The investment policy permits plan assets to be invested in a number of diverse categories, including a Growth Portfolio, an Immunizing Portfolio and a Liquidity Portfolio. These three sub-portfolios are intended to balance the generation of incremental returns with the management of overall risk.

 

The Growth Portfolio is invested in a diversified pool of assets in order to generate an incremental return with an acceptable level of risk. The Immunizing Portfolio is a hedging portfolio that may be comprised of fixed income securities and overlay positions. This portfolio is designed to offset changes in the value of the pension liability due to changes in interest rates. The Liquidity Portfolio is a cash portfolio designed to meet short-term liquidity needs and reduce the plans’ overall risk.

 

The allocations among portfolios may be adjusted to meet changing objectives and constraints. We expect that as the funded status of the plan changes, we will increase or decrease the size of the Growth Portfolio in order to manage the risk of losses in the plan. As of December 31, 2011, the Growth Portfolio (U.S. and non-U.S. equities, core and high-yield fixed income, as well as hedge fund of funds, real estate and emerging market debt) comprises 47% of total assets, the Immunizing Portfolio (long duration U.S. Treasury strips and corporate bonds) comprises 52% and the Liquidity Portfolio (cash and short-term securities) comprises 1%. The Growth Portfolio is currently limited to not less than 40.5% nor more than 55.5% of total assets, the Immunizing Portfolio is currently limited to not less than 44.5% nor more than 59.5% and the Liquidity Portfolio is currently limited to no more than 11.5%.  

 

 

 

Significant assumptions — The significant weighted average assumptions used in the measurement of pension benefit obligations at December 31 of each year and the net periodic benefit cost for each year are as follows:

 

    2011   2010   2009
    U.S.   Non-U.S.   U.S.   Non-U.S.   U.S.   Non-U.S.
Pension benefit obligations:                                                
  Discount rate     4.57 %     4.98 %     5.23 %     4.87 %     5.79 %     5.36 %
Net periodic benefit cost:                                                
  Discount rate     5.23 %     4.87 %     5.79 %     5.36 %     6.44 %     5.80 %
  Rate of compensation increase      N/A       3.21 %      N/A       3.19 %      N/A       3.21 %
  Expected return on plan assets     7.50 %     4.09 %     7.50 %     4.12 %     7.50 %     6.03 %

 

The pension plan discount rate assumptions are evaluated annually in consultation with our outside actuarial advisors. Long-term interest rates on high quality corporate debt instruments are used to determine the discount rate. For our largest plans, discount rates are developed using a discounted bond portfolio analysis, with appropriate consideration given to defined benefit payment terms and duration of the liabilities.

 

The expected rate of return on plan assets was selected on the basis of our long-term view of return and risk assumptions for major asset classes. We define long-term as forecasts that span at least the next ten years. Our long-term outlook is influenced by a combination of return expectations by individual asset class, actual historical experience and our diversified investment strategy. We consult with and consider the opinions of financial professionals in developing appropriate capital market assumptions. Return projections are also validated using a simulation model that incorporates yield curves, credit spreads and risk premiums to project long-term prospective returns. The appropriateness of the expected rate of return is assessed on an annual basis and revised if necessary. We have a high percentage of total assets in fixed income securities since the benefit accruals are frozen for all of our U.S. pension plans. Based on this assessment, we have reduced the expected return on assets for 2012 to 7.00% for our U.S. plans.

 

The significant weighted average assumptions used in the measurement of OPEB obligations at December 31 of each year and the net periodic benefit cost for each year are as follows:

 

    2011   2010   2009
    Non-U.S.   Non-U.S.   Non-U.S.
OPEB benefit obligations:                        
  Discount rate     4.18 %     5.11 %     5.79 %
Net periodic benefit cost:                        
  Discount rate     5.11 %     5.79 %     6.33 %
  Initial health care costs trend rate     6.70 %     7.00 %     7.98 %
  Ultimate health care costs trend rate     5.02 %     5.02 %     5.03 %
  Year ultimate reached     2018       2015       2015  

 

The discount rate selection process was similar to the process used for the pension plans. Assumed health care cost trend rates have a significant effect on the health care obligation. To determine the trend rates, consideration is given to the plan design, recent experience and health care economics.

 

A one-percentage-point change in assumed health care cost trend rates would have the following effects for 2011:

 

    1% Point   1% Point
    Increase   Decrease
  Effect on total of service and interest cost components   $ 1     $ (1 )
  Effect on OPEB obligations     14       (12 )

 

 

 

Estimated future benefit payments and contributions — Expected benefit payments by our pension and OPEB plans for each of the next five years and for the period 2017 through 2021 are as follows:

 

    Pension Benefits   OPEB
Year   U.S.   Non-U.S.   Non-U.S.
  2012   $ 140     $ 13     $ 7  
  2013     135       13       7  
  2014     132       13       7  
  2015     130       13       8  
  2016     126       14       8  
  2017 to 2021     597       82       39  
 Total   $ 1,260     $ 148     $ 76  

 

Pension benefits are funded through deposits with trustees that satisfy, at a minimum, the applicable funding regulations. OPEB benefits are funded as they become due. Projected contributions to be made during 2012 to the defined benefit pension plans are $13 for our non-U.S. plans and $212 for our U.S. plans, inclusive of a voluntary contribution of $150 in January 2012.

 

Multiemployer pension plans

 

We participate in the Steelworkers Pension Trust (SPT) multiemployer pension plan which provides pension benefits to substantially all of our U.S. union-represented employees. We also have a small participation in the IAM National Pension Fund. Benefit levels are set by trustees who manage the plans. Contributions are made in accordance with our collective bargaining agreements and rates are generally based on hours worked. The SPT agreement expires May 31, 2014. The trustees of the SPT have provided us with the latest data available for the plan year ending December 31, 2011. As of that date, the plan is not fully funded. We could be held liable to the plan for our, as well as other employers’ obligations due to our participation in the plan. Contribution rates could increase if the plan is required to adopt a funding improvement plan or a rehabilitation plan, if the performance of plan assets do not meet expectations, or as a result of future collectively-bargained wage and benefit agreements. If we choose to stop participating in the plan, we may be required to pay the plan an amount based on the underfunded status of the plan, referred to as a withdrawal liability.

 

The Pension Protection Act (PPA) defines a zone status for each plan. Plans in the green zone are at least 80% funded, plans in the yellow zone are at least 65% funded, and plans in the red zone are generally less than 65% funded. The SPT plan has utilized extended amortization provisions to amortize its losses from 2008. The plan recertified its zone status after using the extended amortization provisions as allowed by law. The SPT plan has not implemented a funding improvement or rehabilitation plan, nor are such plans pending. Our contributions to the SPT have not exceeded more than 5% of the total contributions to the plan. The sale of substantially all of our Structural Products business to Metalsa in March 2010 impacted our contributions in 2010. The increased levels of overtime impacted our contributions in 2011.

 

    Employer
Identification
  PPA   Funding Plan                
Pension   Number /   Zone Status   Pending /   Contributions by Dana   Surcharge
Fund   Plan Number   2011   2010   Implemented   2011   2010   2009   Imposed
                                                                 
 SPT     23-6648508 / 499       Green       Green       No     $ 9     $ 8     $ 9       No