XML 82 R10.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v2.4.0.6
RESTATEMENT OF CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
12 Months Ended
Sep. 30, 2012
RESTATEMENT OF CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS  
RESTATEMENT OF CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

Note 2—Restatement of consolidated financial statements

We have restated our Consolidated Balance Sheets at September 30, 2011, 2010 and 2009 and our Consolidated Statements of Income, Changes in Shareholders' Equity and Cash Flows for the years then ended including the cumulative impact of corrected errors for periods prior to October 1, 2008.

The cumulative adjustments to correct the errors in the consolidated financial statements for all periods prior to October 1, 2008 are recorded as adjustments to retained earnings and accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) at September 30, 2008, as shown in the consolidated statements of changes in shareholders' equity. The cumulative effect of those adjustments increased previously reported retained earnings by $23.0 million and reduced previously reported accumulated other comprehensive income by $0.9 million at September 30, 2008.

The following tables present the summary impacts of the restatement adjustments on the Company's previously reported consolidated retained earnings at September 30, 2008 and consolidated net income for the years ended September 30, 2011, 2010 and 2009 (in thousands):

   

Retained earnings at September 30, 2008—As previously reported

  $ 404,868  

Revenue Recognition Adjustments, net of taxes on revenue recognition adjustments

    25,587  

Other Adjustments

    (2,619 )
       

Retained earnings at September 30, 2008—As restated

  $ 427,836  
   

 

   
 
  For the years ended
September 30,
 
 
  2011
  2010
  2009
 
   

Net Income—As previously reported

  $ 85,078   $ 70,636   $ 55,686  

Revenue Recognition Adjustments, net of taxes on revenue recognition adjustments

    2,321     31     9,900  

Other Adjustments

    (3,495 )   1,427     (2,441 )
       

Net Income—As restated

  $ 83,904   $ 72,094   $ 63,145  
   

In the table above, we have separately identified the impact of errors related to revenue recognition, and the impact related to other individually immaterial errors on net income. Descriptions of the restatement adjustments related to revenue recognition matters follow:

Revenue recognition adjustments

Historically, we recognized sales and profits for development contracts using the cost-to-cost percentage-of-completion method of accounting, modified by a formulary adjustment. Under the cost-to-cost percentage-of-completion method of accounting, sales and profits are based on the ratio of costs incurred to estimated total costs at completion. We have consistently applied a formulary adjustment to the percentage completion calculation for development contracts that had the effect of deferring a portion of the indicated revenue and profits on such contracts until later in the contract performance period. The cost-to-cost percentage-of-completion method as described in ASC 605-35 (formerly SOP 81-1) does not support the practice of using a formulary calculation to defer a portion of the indicated revenue and profits on such contracts. Instead, sales and profits should have been recognized based on the ratio of costs incurred to estimated total costs at completion, without using a formulary adjustment. As such, revenue has been restated for development contracts using the cost-to-cost percentage-of completion-method of accounting to eliminate the formulary adjustment.

We also evaluated the Company's long-standing practice of using the cost-to-cost percentage-of-completion method to recognize revenues for many of its service contracts. Under the accounting literature the cost-to-cost percentage of completion method is acceptable for U.S. government service contracts but not for service contracts with commercial customers other governmental customers, whether domestic or foreign. As such, revenue has been restated for service contracts with non-U.S. government customers to record revenue generally on a straight-line basis. In addition, in some cases our contracts with non-U.S. government customers may also include multiple deliverables, including service deliverables. During the course of our revenue review we noted situations in which we did not historically identify the units of accounting in accordance with the appropriate authoritative guidance. For example, for certain contracts that we entered with a customer prior to the adoption of Accounting Standards Update 2010-13, Multiple-Deliverable Revenue Arrangements (ASU 2010-13), to design and build a system for the customer and to operate and maintain the system for the customer after its delivery, we inappropriately separately accounted for the unit of accounting related to the designing and building of the system and the unit of accounting related to providing services for operating and maintaining the system without having vendor specific objective evidence, which was a requirement for separating units of accounting prior to the adoption of ASU 2010-13. In these cases, in connection with our restatement, we considered the multiple-element revenue recognition guidance in existence at the time that the transaction was entered into or materially modified and revenue was restated to recognize revenue based upon either the individual elements of the arrangement or the combined unit of accounting when the elements were not separable.

The Company's historical policy has been to allocate and capitalize general and administrative (G&A) costs on its U.S. government units-of-delivery type contracts, as permitted by SOP 81-1 and the AICPA Audit and Accounting Guide for Federal Government Contractors. During our review of revenue recognition for the issues identified above it was determined that from fiscal 2007 through March of 2012 this policy was inconsistently applied so that G&A costs were not inventoried on certain U.S. government contracts in accordance with the policy. As such, inventory and cost of sales have been restated for these types of contracts with the U.S. government to include G&A costs in inventory until sales are recognized.

Historically the Company has allocated G&A costs to all of its contracts with the U.S. government and with other domestic or foreign governmental agencies. These costs were included in the calculation of percentage completion as well as the measurement of losses on contracts. SOP 81-1 generally does not permit G&A costs to be included as contract costs which are used to measure progress towards completion on percentage-of-completion contracts and to estimate losses, though it does include an exception for government contractors. The Company has historically considered itself to be a government contractor and followed this exception for virtually all of its contracts accounted for on a cost-to-cost percentage-of-completion basis. However, we now recognize that this exception was intended to apply only to contracts with the U.S. federal government and not to contracts with other governmental entities, such as governmental transit agencies and foreign governments. Consequently, for contracts with customers other than the U.S. federal government, revenue is being restated to reflect the impact of excluding general and administrative costs from the calculation of the percentage-of-completion and projected losses on long-term development projects.

We determined the amounts of the revenue recognition adjustments on a contract-by-contract basis and did not calculate or accumulate the errors by type of revenue error because certain errors are interrelated and the adjustments to many contracts were impacted by more than one of the types of revenue recognition error described above. The aggregate impact of these revenue adjustments and the related adjustments made to income tax expense as a result of the revenue recognition adjustments described above are included in the "Revenue Recognition Adjustments" columns in the following tables for the Consolidated Statements of Income.

Other adjustments

In addition to the errors related to revenue recognition described above, we also made adjustments related to other individually immaterial errors including certain corrections that had been previously identified but not recorded because they were not material, individually or in the aggregate, to the Company's consolidated financial statements. These corrections included certain accrued liabilities and reserves and miscellaneous reclassification entries; entries to correct errors in the treatment of return-to-provision income tax reconciliation items; adjustments to various income tax and indirect tax accrual accounts; adjustments to participant compensation used in computing pension liability; and adjustments related to the impact of exchange rates on our U.S. dollar denominated investments held by our wholly-owned subsidiary in the U.K., that has the British pound as its functional currency.

Reclassifications

In the first quarter of fiscal year 2012, we revised our method of categorizing sales and the related cost of sales between products and services. We reconsidered whether certain projects related predominantly to product or service sales. The "Reclassifications" column in the following tables includes the reclassifications of sales and cost of sales for products and services in the consolidated statements of income in order to conform to the current year presentation, and to correct certain errors in classification of cost of sales between products and services. For the year ended September 30, 2011 $13.9 million of costs were erroneously classified as product costs. As such, these costs were reclassified to service costs.

Goodwill impairment assessment date disclosure error

In our consolidated financial statements for the year ended September 30, 2011 and previous years we had disclosed that we evaluated goodwill for potential impairment annually as of June 30, or when circumstances indicate that the carrying value may not be recoverable. However, our annual goodwill impairment evaluation date is July 1 of each year rather than June 30. This was an error in disclosure only and had no impact on our assessment of goodwill impairment, our financial condition, results of operations or cash flows.

The following tables present the impact of the restatement on the our previously issued consolidated balance sheets as of September 30, 2011, 2010 and 2009, and our consolidated statements of income and cash flows for the years then ended:

   
 
  Consolidated balance sheet
September 30, 2011
  Consolidated balance sheet
September 30, 2010
  Consolidated balance sheet
September 30, 2009
 
(in thousands)
  Previously
reported

  Adjustments
  As
restated

  Previously
reported

  Adjustments
  As
restated

  Previously
reported

  Adjustments
  As
restated

 
   

ASSETS

                                                       

Current assets:

                                                       

Cash and cash equivalents

  $ 329,148   $   $ 329,148   $ 295,434   $   $ 295,434   $ 244,074   $   $ 244,074  

Short-term investments

    25,829         25,829     84,081         84,081     8,127         8,127  

Accounts receivable:

                                                       

Trade and other receivables

    20,259         20,259     11,594         11,594     12,833         12,833  

Long-term contracts

    204,120     3,306     207,426     199,353     2,545     201,898     223,186     (477 )   222,709  

Allowance for doubtful accounts

    (395 )       (395 )   (663 )       (663 )   (4,558 )       (4,558 )
       

 

    223,984     3,306     227,290     210,284     2,545     212,829     231,461     (477 )   230,984  

Recoverable income taxes

   
20,725
   
4,192
   
24,917
   
8,320
   
(1,510

)
 
6,810
   
   
249
   
249
 

Inventories

    36,729     1,630     38,359     32,820     7,833     40,653     49,107     8,498     57,605  

Deferred income taxes

    13,778     (4,295 )   9,483     17,825     (3,535 )   14,290     22,132     (1,941 )   20,191  

Prepaid expenses and other current assets

    20,452     628     21,080     25,893     234     26,127     29,957         29,957  
       

Total current assets

    670,645     5,461     676,106     674,657     5,567     680,224     584,858     6,329     591,187  
       

Long-term contract receivables

    23,700         23,700     28,080         28,080     13,400         13,400  

Property, plant and equipment—net

    48,467         48,467     47,469         47,469     48,895         48,895  

Deferred income taxes

    11,318     1,506     12,824     18,570     718     19,288     14,082     422     14,504  

Goodwill

    146,355         146,355     64,142         64,142     59,433         59,433  

Purchased intangibles

    54,139         54,139     26,295         26,295     28,618         28,618  

Other assets

    4,216     717     4,933     5,196     825     6,021     7,029     507     7,536  
       

Total assets

  $ 958,840   $ 7,684   $ 966,524   $ 864,409   $ 7,110   $ 871,519   $ 756,315   $ 7,258   $ 763,573  
       

LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY

                                                       

Current liabilities:

                                                       

Trade accounts payable

  $ 38,870   $ 5,114   $ 43,984   $ 33,638   $ 5,447   $ 39,085   $ 28,626   $ 3,916   $ 32,542  

Customer advances

    183,845     (49,529 )   134,316     139,723     (41,208 )   98,515     123,458     (39,480 )   83,978  

Accrued compensation

    49,513         49,513     48,994         48,994     49,134         49,134  

Other current liabilities

    53,826     3,180     57,006     60,041     1,050     61,091     60,402     (758 )   59,644  

Income taxes payable

    7,902     10,814     18,716     20,107     7,112     27,219     3,491     8,608     12,099  

Current portion of long-term debt

    4,541         4,541     4,545         4,545     4,554         4,554  
       

Total current liabilities

    338,497     (30,421 )   308,076     307,048     (27,599 )   279,449     269,665     (27,714 )   241,951  
       

Long-term debt

    11,377         11,377     15,949         15,949     20,570         20,570  

Accrued pension liability

    38,223     2,943     41,166     37,015     2,840     39,855     32,214     1,548     33,762  

Deferred compendation

    7,884         7,884     8,508         8,508     7,902         7,902  

Income taxes payable

    4,479     7,650     12,129     3,382     6,579     9,961     5,119     5,882     11,001  

Other long-term liabilities

    6,582         6,582     4,748         4,748              

Shareholders' equity:

                                                       

Preferred stock, no par value:

                                                       

Authorized—5,000 shares

                                                       

Issued and outstanding—none

                                     

Common stock, no par value:

                                                       

Authorized—50,000 shares

                                                       

2011 and 2010—Issued 35,682 shares, outstanding—26,736 shares, 2009—Issued 35,677 shares, outstanding—26,732 shares

    12,574         12,574     12,574         12,574     12,530         12,530  

Retained earnings

    598,849     30,711     629,560     521,567     31,885     553,452     455,743     30,427     486,170  

Accumulated other comprehensive loss

    (23,294 )   (3,199 )   (26,493 )   (9,745 )   (6,595 )   (16,340 )   (11,357 )   (2,885 )   (14,242 )

Treasury stock at cost

                                                       

2011 and 2010—8,945 shares

    (36,078 )       (36,078 )   (36,074 )       (36,074 )   (36,071 )       (36,071 )
       

Shareholders' equity attributable to Cubic

    552,051     27,512     579,563     488,322     25,290     513,612     420,845     27,542     448,387  

Noncontrolling interest in variable interest entity

    (253 )       (253 )   (563 )       (563 )            
       

Total shareholders' equity

    551,798     27,512     579,310     487,759     25,290     513,049     420,845     27,542     448,387  
       

Total liabilities and shareholders' equity

  $ 958,840   $ 7,684   $ 966,524   $ 864,409   $ 7,110   $ 871,519   $ 756,315   $ 7,258   $ 763,573  
   

   
 
  Consolidated statement of income
Year ended September 30, 2011
  Consolidated statement of income
Year ended September 30, 2010
  Consolidated statement of income
Year ended September 30, 2009
 
(amounts in thousands,
except per share data)

  Previously
reported

  Revenue
recognition
adjustments

  Other
adjustments

  Reclassifications
  As
restated

  Previously
reported

  Revenue
recognition
adjustments

  Other
adjustments

  Reclassifications
  As
restated

  Previously
reported

  Revenue
recognition
adjustments

  Other
adjustments

  Reclassifications
  As
restated

 
   

Net sales:

                                                                                           

Products

  $ 618,924   $ (10,844 ) $ 1,357   $ (8,504 ) $ 600,933   $ 636,739   $ 239   $ 147   $ (29,369 ) $ 607,756   $ 526,879   $ (7,505 ) $ (992 ) $ (10,215 ) $ 508,167  

Services

    666,279     19,215     650     8,504     694,648     557,450     1,971     1,646     29,369     590,436     489,778     21,549     (3,785 )   10,215     517,757  
       

 

    1,285,203     8,371     2,007         1,295,581     1,194,189     2,210     1,793         1,198,192     1,016,657     14,044     (4,777 )       1,025,924  

Costs and expenses:

                                                                                           

Products

    437,992     4,164     1,047     (24,924 )   418,279     457,651     678     (90 )   (27,822 )   430,417     394,478     (2,004 )   (839 )   (13,583 )   378,052  

Services

    539,973     1,195     646     22,248     564,062     484,343     1,306         25,365     511,014     411,038     1,850     (2,139 )   7,543     418,292  

Selling, general and administrative

    154,962         2,153     2,676     159,791     120,848         1,001     2,457     124,306     111,828         1,240     6,040     119,108  

Research and development

    25,260                 25,260     18,976                 18,976     8,173                 8,173  

Amortization of purchased intangibles

    14,681                 14,681     6,846                 6,846     6,432                 6,432  
       

 

    1,172,868     5,359     3,846         1,182,073     1,088,664     1,984     911         1,091,559     931,949     (154 )   (1,738 )       930,057  
       

Operating income

    112,335     3,012     (1,839 )       113,508     105,525     226     882         106,633     84,708     14,198     (3,039 )       95,867  

Other income (expense):

                                                                                           

Interest and dividend income

    2,568                 2,568     1,590                 1,590     1,664                 1,664  

Interest expense

    (1,461 )               (1,461 )   (1,755 )               (1,755 )   (2,031 )               (2,031 )

Other income (expense)—net

    4,205     (171 )   (2,372 )       1,662     561     (95 )   3,171         3,637     899     (20 )   (218 )       661  
       

Income before income taxes

    117,647     2,841     (4,211 )       116,277     105,921     131     4,053         110,105     85,240     14,178     (3,257 )       96,161  

Income taxes

    32,569     520     (716 )       32,373     35,285     100     2,626         38,011     29,554     4,278     (816 )       33,016  
       

Net income

    85,078     2,321     (3,495 )       83,904     70,636     31     1,427         72,094     55,686     9,900     (2,441 )       63,145  

Less noncontrolling interest in income of VIE

    310                 310                                          
       

Net income attributable to Cubic

  $ 84,768   $ 2,321   $ (3,495 ) $   $ 83,594   $ 70,636   $ 31   $ 1,427   $   $ 72,094   $ 55,686   $ 9,900   $ (2,441 ) $   $ 63,145  
       

Basic and diluted net income per common share

  $ 3.17   $ 0.09   $ (0.13 ) $   $ 3.13   $ 2.64   $   $ 0.06   $   $ 2.70   $ 2.08   $ 0.37   $ (0.09 ) $   $ 2.36  
       

Average number of common shares outstanding

    26,736                 26,736     26,735                 26,735     26,731                 26,731  
   

   
 
  Consolidated statement
of cash flows
September 30, 2011
  Consolidated statement
of cash flows
September 30, 2010
  Consolidated statement
of cash flows
September 30, 2009
 
(in thousands)
  Previously
reported

  Adjustments
  As
restated

  Previously
reported

  Adjustments
  As
restated

  Previously
reported

  Adjustments
  As
restated

 
   

Operating Activities:

                                                       

Net income

  $ 85,078   $ (1,174 ) $ 83,904   $ 70,636   $ 1,458   $ 72,094   $ 55,686   $ 7,459   $ 63,145  

Adjustments to reconcile net income to net cash provided by operating activities:

                                                       

Depreciation and amortization

    22,341         22,341     14,469         14,469     15,586         15,586  

Deferred income taxes

    4,048     (1,536 )   2,512     (164 )   1,294     1,130     3,346     1,974     5,320  

Provision for doubtful accounts

                (3,889 )       (3,889 )   3,038         3,038  

Changes in operating assets and liabilities net of effects from acquisitions:

                                                       

Accounts receivable

    4,219     (653 )   3,566     28,565     (3,340 )   25,225     36,211     4,866     41,077  

Inventories

    (3,760 )   6,202     2,442     16,638     666     17,304     (4,275 )   (3,459 )   (7,734 )

Prepaid expenses and other current assets

    5,516     (394 )   5,122     4,401     (234 )   4,167     5,141     610     5,751  

Accounts payable and other current liabilities

    (3,387 )   1,840     (1,547 )   (27,498 )   3,357     (24,141 )   14,175     908     15,083  

Customer advances

    45,517     (8,374 )   37,143     20,672     (2,210 )   18,462     48,663     (14,044 )   34,619  

Income taxes

    (24,205 )   492     (23,713 )   (14,614 )   986     (13,628 )   (2,890 )   2,215     (675 )

Other items—net

    (2,779 )   103     (2,676 )   2,507     1,292     3,799     1,352     262     1,614  
       

NET CASH PROVIDED BY OPERATING ACTIVITIES

    132,588     (3,494 )   129,094     111,723     3,269     114,992     176,033     791     176,824  
       

Investing Activities:

                                                       

Acquisition of businesses, net of cash acquired

    (126,825 )       (126,825 )   (8,250 )       (8,250 )   (19,965 )       (19,965 )

Consolidation of variable interest entity

                38,264         38,264              

Proceeds from sales or maturities of short-term investments

    58,252         58,252     82,992         82,992              

Purchases of short-term investments

                (158,946 )       (158,946 )   (8,127 )       (8,127 )

Purchases of property, plant and equipment

    (8,728 )       (8,728 )   (6,878 )       (6,878 )   (5,332 )       (5,332 )

Other items

                            41         41  
       

NET CASH USED IN INVESTING ACTIVITIES

    (77,301 )       (77,301 )   (52,818 )       (52,818 )   (33,383 )       (33,383 )
       

Financing Activities:

                                                       

Principal payments on long-term debt

    (4,555 )       (4,555 )   (4,541 )       (4,541 )   (5,970 )       (5,970 )

Proceeds from issuance of common stock

                44         44     45         45  

Purchases of treasury stock

    (4 )       (4 )   (3 )       (3 )            

Dividends paid to shareholders

    (7,486 )       (7,486 )   (4,812 )       (4,812 )   (4,811 )       (4,811 )
       

NET CASH USED IN FINANCING ACTIVITIES

    (12,045 )       (12,045 )   (9,312 )       (9,312 )   (10,736 )       (10,736 )
       

Effect of exchange rates on cash

   
(9,528

)
 
3,494
   
(6,034

)
 
1,767
   
(3,269

)
 
(1,502

)
 
(536

)
 
(791

)
 
(1,327

)
       

NET INCREASE IN CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS

   
33,714
   
   
33,714
   
51,360
   
   
51,360
   
131,378
   
   
131,378
 

Cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the year

   
295,434
   
   
295,434
   
244,074
   
   
244,074
   
112,696
   
   
112,696
 
       

CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT THE END OF THE YEAR

 
$

329,148
 
$

 
$

329,148
 
$

295,434
 
$

 
$

295,434
 
$

244,074
 
$

 
$

244,074