-----BEGIN PRIVACY-ENHANCED MESSAGE----- Proc-Type: 2001,MIC-CLEAR Originator-Name: webmaster@www.sec.gov Originator-Key-Asymmetric: MFgwCgYEVQgBAQICAf8DSgAwRwJAW2sNKK9AVtBzYZmr6aGjlWyK3XmZv3dTINen TWSM7vrzLADbmYQaionwg5sDW3P6oaM5D3tdezXMm7z1T+B+twIDAQAB MIC-Info: RSA-MD5,RSA, KUMHdHttFQiLOdYAqndK57yJpPTpxNKZ4wcUq1ut1NL7Kt3DXZBQdpTptbBphK2v tYKY62oymdJ7NhqzPAbMlA== 0001104659-06-059189.txt : 20060901 0001104659-06-059189.hdr.sgml : 20060901 20060901160926 ACCESSION NUMBER: 0001104659-06-059189 CONFORMED SUBMISSION TYPE: DEFA14A PUBLIC DOCUMENT COUNT: 3 FILED AS OF DATE: 20060901 DATE AS OF CHANGE: 20060901 EFFECTIVENESS DATE: 20060901 FILER: COMPANY DATA: COMPANY CONFORMED NAME: CORNING NATURAL GAS CORP CENTRAL INDEX KEY: 0000024751 STANDARD INDUSTRIAL CLASSIFICATION: NATURAL GAS TRANSMISSION & DISTRIBUTION [4923] IRS NUMBER: 160397420 STATE OF INCORPORATION: NY FISCAL YEAR END: 0930 FILING VALUES: FORM TYPE: DEFA14A SEC ACT: 1934 Act SEC FILE NUMBER: 000-00643 FILM NUMBER: 061071809 BUSINESS ADDRESS: STREET 1: 330 W WILLIAM ST STREET 2: P O BOX 58 CITY: CORNING STATE: NY ZIP: 14830 BUSINESS PHONE: 6079363755 MAIL ADDRESS: STREET 1: 330 W WILLIAM STREET STREET 2: P O BOX 58 CITY: CORNING STATE: NY ZIP: 14830 DEFA14A 1 a06-19083_1defa14a.htm DEFINITIVE ADDITIONAL PROXY SOLICITING MATERIALS

UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549

SCHEDULE 14A

Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of
the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No.              )

Filed by the Registrant  x

Filed by a Party other than the Registrant  o

Check the appropriate box:

o

Preliminary Proxy Statement

o

Confidential, for Use of the Commission Only (as permitted by Rule 14a-6(e)(2))

o

Definitive Proxy Statement

x

Definitive Additional Materials

o

Soliciting Material Pursuant to §240.14a-12

 

Corning Natural Gas Corporation

(Name of Registrant as Specified In Its Charter)

 

(Name of Person(s) Filing Proxy Statement, if other than the Registrant)

 

Payment of Filing Fee (Check the appropriate box):

x

No fee required.

o

Fee computed on table below per Exchange Act Rules 14a-6(i)(1) and 0-11.

 

(1)

Title of each class of securities to which transaction applies:

 

 

 

 

(2)

Aggregate number of securities to which transaction applies:

 

 

 

 

(3)

Per unit price or other underlying value of transaction computed pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 0-11 (set forth the amount on which the filing fee is calculated and state how it was determined):

 

 

 

 

(4)

Proposed maximum aggregate value of transaction:

 

 

 

 

(5)

Total fee paid:

 

 

 

o

Fee paid previously with preliminary materials.

o

Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule 0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing for which the offsetting fee was paid previously. Identify the previous filing by registration statement number, or the Form or Schedule and the date of its filing.

 

(1)

Amount Previously Paid:

 

 

 

 

(2)

Form, Schedule or Registration Statement No.:

 

 

 

 

(3)

Filing Party:

 

 

 

 

(4)

Date Filed:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 




 

330 West William Street
P.O. Box 58
Corning, New York 14830-0058
607-936-3755
607-962-2844 fax

 

September 1, 2006

Dear Fellow Shareholder:

Recently, you should have received proxy materials from Corning Natural Gas Corporation seeking your vote to approve the proposed merger (the “Merger”) with C&T Enterprises, Inc.  If the Merger is approved by stockholders, C&T will pay each stockholder $16.50 per share owned at the closing, which should occur in October 2006.  The Board of Directors of Corning unanimously recommends that you vote FOR approval of the Merger.

Also, you may receive proxy materials from Richard M. Osborne urging you to vote your shares against the Merger, even though he has offered no viable alternative.  The following is a brief outline of the reasons why the Merger is in the best interests of Corning shareholders and why we believe Mr. Osborne’s opposition is harmful to shareholder interests.

PRICE

·              Mr. Osborne claims that the Merger consideration is inadequate.  Yet, he has not advised the Company why it is inadequate or what an adequate price should be.  How does Mr. Osborne plan to provide better value for stockholders than the near term purchase of your shares for $16.50 per share in cash by C&T?  The Company has been asking him that question for weeks and, according to his representatives, “there is no plan.”

·              In December 2005, Mr. Osborne offered to buy all the shares of Corning for $15.00 per share.  Mr. Osborne withdrew that offer and was invited to offer an improved price, but he did not do so.

·              The $16.50 per share consideration in the Merger is 19% higher than the average price over the last 24 months and is the result of an extensive process carried out by experienced investment bankers.  More than 55 potential buyers or strategic partners were solicited, and the Merger was by far the most beneficial alternative available to the Company.

·              If the Merger were not to close, Corning would have to spend significant dollars on gas supplies and pipe replacement and do so while in the midst of an extremely difficult cash flow situation.  Pursuant to the New York Public Service Commission order approving the Merger, C&T will make substantial investments in infrastructure that could otherwise be required of Corning over the next five years.  Corning will face many other challenges if the Merger is not approved by its stockholders.  These challenges and the significant benefits of the Merger are described at pages 25-27 of the Corning Proxy Statement.

·              An independent “fairness opinion” analysis showed that the Merger price is at the high end of the range of reasonable value.  (See pages 28-33 of the Corning Proxy Statement.)




 

Letter to Shareholders of
Corning Natural Gas Corporation
Page 2 of 3

MANAGEMENT

·              Mr. Osborne lambastes current management.  Obviously, the Board does not share Mr. Osborne’s view.  The robust auction process and subsequent personal payment concessions by Corning management have yielded a share price that is well above the $15.00 Mr. Osborne considered adequate consideration less than nine months ago.

·              In his December 2005 offer for Corning, Mr. Osborne agreed to honor executive management’s employment, severance, and change of control agreements, adopted by the Company in 1999 and modified in 2000.  In fact, since Mr. Barry and Mr. Robinson have agreed to forgo certain payments and have made other personal concessions in connection with the C&T Merger, they would have been better off personally if the Company had accepted Mr. Osborne’s offer.

·              Mr. Osborne creates an impression that management can void the concessions they have made in connection with the Merger.  As described in the Company’s proxy statement, the concessions are contractually binding in the event the Merger closes and they have contributed to the per share merger consideration of $16.50.

·              Mr. Osborne’s complaints about management contradict statements he made to the media before the Merger was announced.  As reported in the August 5, 2006 edition of the Star-Gazette (Corning Bureau), Mr. Osborne said in March 2006 about Corning management:  “It’s been a tough winter for everybody.  A lot of things were out of their control.  I think they are doing a good job for the times.”

MR. OSBORNE’S PRIOR CONDUCT

·              Mr. Osborne has been described as a “corporate raider,” who is known for targeting small companies.  Mr. Osborne’s prior conduct in raiding and/or operating other companies is relevant in judging whether he has the intention or capability of maximizing the value of your shares.

·              GLB Bancorp.   In 1999, Mr. Osborne was Vice Chairman and the largest shareholder of GLB Bancorp, a bank holding company.  In June 1999, the Ohio Department of Commerce rejected GLB’s proposal to merge its subsidiary Great Lakes Bank with Geauga Savings, citing problems with Great Lakes Bank’s “inadequate” management, “poor earnings,” and “weak risk identification system.”  The Department’s decision said that Great Lakes Bank’s “present financial condition is unacceptable, due, at a minimum, to inadequate earnings relative to size and liquidity concerns.”

·              NuMed Home Health Care, Inc.  In 1998 and 1999, Mr. Osborne, through his investment vehicle called Turkey Vulture Fund XIII, fought for control of NuMed Home Health Care, Inc.  Mr. Osborne and NuMed engaged in litigation and, ultimately, the two sides reached a settlement that gave Mr. Osborne a seat on the company’s board.  According to a report published in Crain’s Cleveland Business, in




 

Letter to Shareholders of
Corning Natural Gas Corporation
Page 3 of 3

May 1999 (approximately four months after the settlement), a board member insisted that Mr. Osborne had reneged on a promise to buy 744,680 shares of NuMed for $350,000.  The board member said Mr. Osborne’s inaction deprived NuMed, which watched its stock fall to about 19 cents a share from $1.75 the prior May, of some “badly needed capital.”  On November 1, 2000, NuMed filed for bankruptcy protection.  Mr. Osborne had resigned from the Board, effective one week before the bankruptcy filing.

·              First Union Real Estate Equity and Mortgage Investments.  In 1995, Mr. Osborne, through Turkey Vulture Fund XIII, waged a battle for control of First Union Real Estate Equity and Mortgage Investments.  First Union brought suit against Mr. Osborne and his fund alleging, among other things, that they had engaged in securities fraud.  After protracted litigation, including counterclaims brought by Mr. Osborne, the parties entered into a settlement agreement.  Under the settlement agreement, First Union agreed to purchase from Mr. Osborne’s fund 950,000 shares of First Union’s stock that the fund had acquired.  Also, the agreement prohibited Mr. Osborne from seeking to acquire control of or influence the management of First Union for a period of ten years.

·              If he were to succeed in defeating the C&T Merger, there is no reason to expect that Mr. Osborne will not follow a similar pattern here.  Other than serving as the long-distance Chairman of Energy West, a Montana-based utility, Mr. Osborne appears to have no experience in running a public utility.  It is difficult to determine what value, if any, Mr. Osborne or the people he might propose to put on Corning’s Board could add.

SUMMARY

In summary, Mr. Osborne offers nothing but speculative suggestions that he will provide other stockholders value in excess of the $16.50 per share in cash that C&T has contracted to pay in the next several weeks if the Merger is approved.

Your Board of Directors believes that the Merger with C&T and the $16.50 per share consideration are in the best interests of the Company’s shareholders.  WE RECOMMEND THAT YOU VOTE “FOR” THE MERGER BY COMPLETING AND RETURNING THE WHITE PROXY CARD INCLUDED WITH YOUR PROXY STATEMENT.  If you need additional copies of the proxy card or the proxy statement, please contact S. Gerald Sleve, Secretary of the Company, at (617) 936-3755.

Sincerely,

 

 

 

 

Thomas K. Barry, Chairman of the Board of Directors and Chief Executive Officer

 

 

PLEASE NOTE

This letter is intended to supplement the Corning Proxy Statement previously delivered to you. We strongly urge that you read the Proxy Statement and other documents that provide important information about the Company and the proposed Merger. Such materials are on file and accessible on the website of the Securities and Exchange Commission (www.sec.gov) and the Company’s website (www.corninggas.com) and may be acquired for free from the Company.



GRAPHIC 2 g190831dai001.gif GRAPHIC begin 644 g190831dai001.gif M1TE&.#EA$@$Y`'<`,2'^&E-O9G1W87)E.B!-:6-R;W-O9G0@3V9F:6-E`"'Y M!`$`````+``````1`3@`AP````````0$!!(2$AH:&@X.#@$!`1T='186%@4% M!145%1$1$1D9&0@("`D)"1,3$QP<'`,#`Q`0$`H*"A\?'QL;&Q04%`L+"P\/ M#PP,#!X>'A@8&!<7%P8&!@T-#0("`@<'!RVYN;G]_?W-S'AYJ:FI^?GY>7EYZ> MGH*"@IV=G82$A(:&AHJ*BHN+BYRWMZ^OK[R\O+V]O;&QL:BHJ*ZNKJ2DI+"P ML+*RLJ6EI;6UM:.CH[N[N[:VMKBXN*FIJ;JZNKZ^OJRLK*>GI[2TM*JJJK^_ MOZ*BHM/3T\K*RL+"PMO;V]K:VM'1T MWM34U,#`P,?'Q^KJZNGIZ>3DY.7EY>#@X/?W]^?GY_;V]O'Q\?[^_OS\_//S M\_3T]./CX_W]_>SL[/KZ^NWM[?7U]?GY^>;FYO+R\O#P\.CHZ.OKZ_CX^/O[ M^^'AX>+BXN[N[N_O[____P$"`PC_`/T)'$BPH,&#"!,J7,BPH<.'$"-*G$BQ MHL6+&#-JW,BQH\>/($.*'$FRI,F3*%.J7,FRIN MG#ASX,Z%(VN6;#AT_M()5*?.W[IQ"]FQP]B.G3AW!<\%$_:NX#!XHN)=/">. MG3R&Q`J1.8)$P-`D2I:4,53LHCH10^.I&T&4Z``S\SR.`D.@M.O2!8H8BTB* MQ.O;``6*43<$O#1%$3)=1$R1,TRT)\!`$/+SCSO7(LCM?1,R\]!U[(* MID-1@;#"`X%C6VD4T*)0(Q(+V2E!CP:`\4!5O-990N928G!"1*QA]MEFCX'$ M&&B?/<1!H/R&ET!$3#O0*+A%`Y%^`?3_ZU&U`>B=4:X!S''SC>_="NU03!-T MCQ6N51`*0I5(_,10?EL\U-8$7>%:!,<@9"X60S&"T)R('T0!;BX/9.88!$5P M6PJD#O5U1[('\(Q&=`RUGD`X(X[;(P9%VWA!Z!SAF@.V&/1O`$D4E,50EGC+ M>4%)N&8!,08U^+%`,0Q%[D%."F^0/;_M/E#V`4@R4#2X%>;0#4/EZ]&>]F.4 M>^8X8W$!!@#$P`4"L``,2*!`N2L-#H8R@RG@XR#&4\@U`$>4#&"#((2+'D%> M,)1+%$0#FU.(.-Y4FFP0A%),JMS`#.*.$11!"C",H0QA6`V&XH:*?#$`YRA(R8:BA7Q0I!4I&@I_!D*?%3;D'J7!P`,3$BT/ M-F0:GBM-!7)AB:&EA`&Y@RX9@(I)#@1U!EC%%AV2B M-+^#X%`>]I!K+`$W821($#I8D"VXLB';@.)MWC@0)KA&!C9CR"Q"2?\401KD M&;@AIS%?8X>!9.`V$8G'; MT1C&(JK`@=<0KR"5#,!$GH&LH6Q@&^(,@(DB$HL%ND:#`^%;)JPG$638M#1, M&@@N<`,&0B2B$(,`!"4BT"D\HN!!(9K` MIO""L,F"1-62O2K-VQ`FT(A@HSA$P4)!Y'D=,VKMD4U=TD'RT-4`<,&1"#G% M;9!@U]<,9`ZW@>E$&'0C!%#"(:>@8'TZ,(:R&N0 M"U>0/853((N,4$5R4;.$!$.-]=G`(>27$,'_OJ82`X$$421`QZ',RA^$N$WH M+,*(,5C@-UL8@BXHHHPY\.`W'@A"(O31D#PLXK$7^4,:[A`'%YAJ$X"X!T9V M(0$:%$0<@I`%/0H"CTOP0F86H44`KK@0;L3"$BCH@A$ND((>^$`/F2C'0\[J MFGT,I`=$68*SB-(&@2`MFAP1;TCD(8YS6-8G$U$,ABOBF]?0R!\?(`IR9D"4 M@OHCEJ[QPH97S&*7%*@T%1+(.N3HCV\.!5C^T&%I0-OB'OM8)&=XC3D$@@^B M,$!S`8C"0"'\XR8[62,A_G+%=D34>Q7Y*'( M1R!="P"2^.J:,X/Y_\UP5@@_#.L/+C>0,+Q88+,0Q*.<`@&.(?&NOG"XH&E)B'4I>)=$"E_KBF06RDVH%@`@,%4H`6"%(#7?KC%OBV M6`8VY;Z":",`.?K@)!SR`0RL4PF_5(%!>A$`+[U*(?O2`A\"P+&!Z",`>O\0 M0P#@H$@7J"$`G2"(0IG@G]\*A`\&0,8O`B"U@3C+$(CMN1D-D@EQW:$.M.WS MD`="A`Q4HY1P\7D`'&#,73`$JT,IC\J5/)!%(X%FI9G;1!@``OS,8JT$P<`6 M-G`07G"=(#DP-!W,6Z0A]Z(#!H'!&2)@$!%,AR%Y\*5``F$0-)0@`%$?B`>0 MXX\5+*0$8A!(-;@WD`DPS3/$#F>,;!-"QV)U.80."?`/?%)CIS5A@ MA#L2K_0`(!`%C^X"P#D0VR-V?ZH0`&$0+! M,&<'\0/]9C%E=7H#`0@*.&L!$WW]MQ"^($=01!`CT`-=0!0>@!$!``T=6`PA M4%I!(`T!8#H%07T&$0-E(!"9,``%`0%$X`0!$('^P`=`$`Y`L#(#X0.,MQ`& M0#R&4#(%,0L!8`UUP'O^$`QF(H71$7$&<5>S1Q`;0`>L(`&D0!!V-@OT5"0# M@0H<0!#6H%+P4Q"8!`;.T0L&`8%92!#"D'"*4'T"$0XJ-019@`-NQA#J<#F` M$@`[94S=\'L9$0"CX`\'_Y4'T3$"-0`#,480,E@012!XGD`"T4%=>%`%T>$" M"(`"O`<#?]`06=`%%I-_+U`#H-%9_K`$GV!,KG801-`"`I%>!.$%:R`0O``$ MT0%31:!Q`S%C""$`DU0!9T`0!B@0'>`=`[$&(V`(@"`#?E00*1!4JT@0$\!G M?1:!?#A0WB`1OF`#!&!/`G&'`7`"#;>(;81Q`^$'G&A,0B<0FD",!%$/*R`FA""50"'LQ$/``#0.1#SYX"5G0 M5@H1"^V(4LL%56%9$,J2$/#`#PM1DOY0BP(X$4TI:(B9F(JYF(S9F([YF)`9 MF9(YF919F99YF9B9F9JYF9S9F9[YF:`9FJ+9F0(VFJ9YFJB9FJJYFJS9FJ[Y )FK`9FY49$``[ ` end GRAPHIC 3 g190831dai002.jpg GRAPHIC begin 644 g190831dai002.jpg M_]C_X``02D9)1@`!`0$`8`!@``#_VP!#``@&!@<&!0@'!P<)"0@*#!0-#`L+ M#!D2$P\4'1H?'AT:'!P@)"XG("(L(QP<*#7J#A(6&AXB)BI*3E)66EYB9FJ*CI*6FIZBI MJK*SM+6VM[BYNL+#Q,7&Q\C)RM+3U-76U]C9VN'BX^3EYN?HZ>KQ\O/T]?;W M^/GZ_]H`"`$!```_`/>IKF"W3?/-'$OJ[!1^M9W_``E&@>9Y?]MZ=O\`[OVE M,_SJ.]\5Z%8PI++JMJWF-LB2*02/(W]U57)8^PJK;?V[K-Y#^4^+-14[>2T4&P>^-E+ MX2U2^U*UO5O)(+D6MRT$5[`NU+I0`=P&3@@DJ<$C(.*Z*BD)`')K/AU>TN=6 MOM-B=C-9(C3MM^1-X)`SZX&2/0CUJCX;UZ7Q!-J5S';JNEQ7'DV5P");70+=V<>?<^47CME;!;'3)[9/`[D\`$U9T"XU*YT> MVGUB"&VOY5WR6\1)$6>0N3U(&,^^:U*****XW5_!4]WXAGUFWN+">65440ZG M:&X2$*,?N_F&W/4\'FI!X2U&[1$U#5;>&,=8]-L4A_`.VXC\,5;M?`WABRMV MBBT2S)8EGD>,-(S'J2YY)]\UR^NVVB6,]G;6\%]:&ZG$=O#83R)<7))Y*KN^ M6,`9+'MTQUJ+4=-L-*DFTC1-7O-+M+;]YJFH27A,=NK?PY;.Z5AZGY003V%= M/9^%-,TG3DMH-6U."SBCRB_;V55434UOX5T&XB29D?4$;YE>XNGG5O MS8@UO0K'$@BA5%C0!0B``+[8'2I-U4=6U)=,L#/L\R1G6**,=7=CA0/\]`:S M?&/B1/"WANXU'R6GN0I6WMT!)EDP3C`YP`"2>P!KG/#?A/4-4T2(ZU?PFQO# M]JG@LG+?;7?DM++QN4\810!C`R<5W\4$=M"D4,:1Q1J%1$&`H'0`>E96K:M* M+A=*TP))J=265WX+UMTOY%U:\OI/,MM9NY&WQ16<;Y[ABTDTA[^I)]!T'8"MH,&`(Y M!&12[O:C-&:,TM%5=0@:YL+B!)9X6>,@20,%D4^JDY`->=^&O!6OZ9I>KZP\ MD2^*]2^2"6\F,_V.+(`4OSN/5C@8)P.E5KSX5WL=IHT%M>Q:E-#>&ZO9M4=B MK'DY6->#\QR0>3@`G'%5X/AYXAO+G5]=\3FVUK6"?)TZTDG*6RIN^\ZCC;T. MSG..>32:=\-M=TS4;5(=2NOL6G6\K%HKCR_M:''<6H M0I&RLL5LC;OE<2'+L-NH"(HXUVPVP(YV`\DGN MQY],#BH8-&NY_&=YJ^HF-[6&!;?3H@<[`PS*S#'WB<#Z"JWA_3M:T#P[?6,% MK:LT-[*=.A>8A1;M)E0Q`.,`M@8[`5TUS))%9S211&65(V98Q_$0.!^-&O!C:KK8:.^EC-YJ3ORYE/)7\.%4#V`JG>VZ0>!]:Q*N=BQC<8[90"3N0+\V`6+ M=^W1ZUXQDU+QAIUI<7DNEV%HZWDUDJL;F<8S$C*.=@Z`9;D@">X\=^(5N M_$-Y%H6I;K.'R[33W@/EJ`-S3RR=.E)@>E+1BC`]*,"C%&!2'I7,Z^AO_$N M@Z7)_P`>9:2\E7M(T6W8I'<;FW?\!%=(Q41DN5"@$DMTQ[UR7A)(M0UOQ#K< M`#V%W=QK:,5^5_*C"-(OL6R,CKMKJ_LMN+DW/D1"F>M8FO:[/;7 M<.CZ3"ESJ]RA94?_`%=O'T,LI'1>P'5CP.Y&!9>&['2_&6DVZ+Y]Z4GU"\NF M15:5P!&O`^ZHWMA1P,5W^*,"BBBBBBBBBBBBBLW5]%M=:@CCN3+')"_F0SP2 M%)86Z95ATX)!['O64G@R*91'JFKZKJD(.?(NIP(V]F5`NX>QR*Z..)(8UCC1 M4C0!551@`#H`.U9GB#6AH]@KQ0FXO9W$-I;`X,TIZ#V`Y)/8`TSP_H9TBVED MN)1<:E=MYM[=8YD?T'HBCA1V'XU5L@)_B'JTS`[K;3[:%?HS2,?Y#\JZ2BBB MBBBBBBBBBBBBBD8A5)8@*!DD]JYO1(O[:U63Q',"8=I@TU&'W8L_-)]7(_[Y M`]372`8%<_I=G>P^,]?O)XB+6XCM5MWR/FVJ^X?@370T4444444444444445 M2U2R&IZ?+9/(T<4WR2%>I3^)<]LC(S[U:B18HUCC4*B`*JJ,``=`*?28&:6B #O__9 ` end
-----END PRIVACY-ENHANCED MESSAGE-----