XML 28 R14.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.6.0.2
Note 6 - Employee Benefit Plans
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2016
Notes to Financial Statements  
Disclosure of Compensation Related Costs, Share-based Payments [Text Block]
6.
Employee Benefit Plans
 
Defined Contribution Retirement Plans
– We maintain a defined contribution
401(k)
retirement savings plan covering all salaried and hourly U.S. employees. Participation is voluntary and participants’ contributions are based on their eligible compensation. We match contributions of participants at
50%
of up to
6%
of salary contributed, up to various statutory limits. In
2016
we made matching contributions to the plan of
$0.6
 million. In both
2015
and
2014
we made contributions to the plan of
$0.7
 million.
 
Defined Benefit Retirement Plans
– As a result of the acquisition of Ismeca effective
December
31,
2012,
we took over the Ismeca Europe Semiconductor BVG Pension Plan in Switzerland (“the Swiss Plan”) and the following discussion only relates to the Swiss Plan.
 
Net periodic benefit cost of the Swiss Plan was as follows
:
 
(in thousands)
 
2016
   
2015
   
2014
 
Service cost
  $
868
    $
856
    $
749
 
Interest cost
   
245
     
311
     
491
 
Expected return on assets
   
(147
)    
(193
)    
(343
)
Settlements
   
-
     
235
     
-
 
Net periodic costs
  $
966
    $
1,209
    $
897
 
 
The following table sets forth the projected benefit obligation, the fair value of plan assets, the funded status and the liability we have recorded in our consolidated balance sheet related to the Swiss Plan:
 
(in thousands)
 
2016
   
2015
 
Change in projected benefit obligation:
               
                 
Benefit obligation at beginning of year
  $
(25,483
)   $
(26,027
)
Service cost
   
(868
)    
(856
)
Interest cost
   
(245
)    
(311
)
Actuarial loss
   
(796
)    
(660
)
Participant contributions
   
(719
)    
(672
)
Benefits paid
   
(214
)    
296
 
Plan change
   
-
     
558
 
Settlements
   
-
     
2,199
 
Foreign currency exchange adjustment
   
826
     
(10
)
Benefit obligation at end of year
   
(27,499
)    
(25,483
)
                 
Change in plan assets:
               
                 
Fair value of plan assets at beginning of year
   
14,716
     
15,603
 
Return on assets, net of actuarial loss
   
189
     
277
 
Employer contributions
   
719
     
672
 
Participant contributions
   
719
     
672
 
Benefits paid
   
214
     
(296
)
Settlements
   
-
     
(2,199
)
Foreign currency exchange adjustment
   
(480
)    
(13
)
Fair value of plan assets at end of year
   
16,077
     
14,716
 
Net liability at end of year
  $
(11,422
)   $
(10,767
)
 
At
December
31,
2016
and
December
26,
2015,
the Swiss Plan’s net liability is included in noncurrent accrued retirement benefits. Amounts recognized in accumulated other comprehensive income net of tax related to the Swiss Plan consisted of an unrecognized net actuarial loss totaling
$2.4
million at
December
31,
2016
and
$1.8
million at
December
26,
2015.
 
Weighted-average actuarial assumptions used to determine the projected benefit obligation under the Swiss Plan are as follows
:
 
   
2016
   
2015
 
Discount rate
   
0.7
%    
1.0
%
Compensation increase
   
1.5
%    
1.8
%
 
Weighted-average assumptions used to determine net periodic benefit cost of the Swiss Plan are as follows
:
 
   
2016
   
2015
   
2014
 
Discount rate
   
1.0
%    
1.3
%    
2.3
%
Rate of return on Assets
   
1.0
%    
1.3
%    
2.3
%
Compensation increase
   
1.8
%    
1.8
%    
2.0
%
 
During 
2017
employer and employee contributions to the Swiss Plan are expected to total
$0.7
 million. Estimated benefit payments are expected to be as follows:
2017
-
$0.7
 million;
2018
-
$0.7
 million;
2019
-
$0.8
 million;
2020
-
$1.0
 million;
2021
-
$1.0
 million; and
$5.2
 million thereafter through
2026.
 
As is customary with Swiss pension plans, the assets of the plan are invested in a collective fund with multiple employers. We have no investment authority over the assets of the plan that are held and invested by a Swiss insurance company. Investment holdings are made with respect to Swiss laws and target allocations for plan assets are
71%
debt securities and cash,
14%
real estate investments,
9%
alternative investments and
6%
equity securities. The valuation of the collective fund assets as a whole is a Level
3
measurement; however the individual investments of the fund are generally Level
1
(equity securities), Level
2
(fixed income) and Level
3
(real estate and alternative) investments. We determine the fair value of the plan assets based on information provided by the collective fund, through review of the collective fund’s annual financial statements. See Note
5,
“Financial Instruments Measured at Fair Value” for additional information on the
three
-tier fair value hierarchy.
 
We maintain other defined benefit plans for employees located outside the U.S. for which the majority of the obligations and net periodic benefit cost were determined to be immaterial for all periods presented.
 
Retiree Medical Benefits
– We provide post-retirement health benefits to certain executives and directors under a noncontributory plan. The net periodic benefit cost was
$0.1
 million in both
2016
and
2015
compared to a net periodic benefit income of
$0.1
 million in
2014.
We fund benefits as costs are incurred and as a result there are no plan assets.
 
The weighted average discount rate used in determining the accumulated post-retirement benefit obligation was
3.9%
in
2016,
4.2%
in
2015
and
3.8%
in
2014.
The annual rates of increase of the cost of health benefits was assumed to be
7.7%
in
2017.
This rate was then assumed to decrease
0.3%
per year to
4.9%
in
2026
and remain level thereafter. A
one
percent increase (decrease) in health care cost trend rates would increase (decrease) the
2016
net periodic benefit cost by approximately
$18,000
($14,000)
and the accumulated post-retirement benefit obligation as of
December
31,
2016,
by approximately
$338,000
($283,000).
 
Contributions to the post-retirement health benefit plan are expected to total
$0.1
million in 
2017.
Estimated benefit payments are expected to be as follows:
2017
-
$0.1
million;
2018
-
$0.1
million;
2019
-
$0.1
million;
2020
-
$0.1
million;
2021
-
$0.1
million and
$0.7
million thereafter through
2026.
 
The following table sets forth the post-retirement benefit obligation, funded status and the liability we have recorded in our consolidated balance sheets
:
 
(in thousands)
 
2016
   
2015
 
Accumulated benefit obligation at beginning of year
  $
2,649
    $
2,428
 
Interest cost
   
109
     
90
 
Actuarial (gain) loss
   
(185
)    
187
 
Benefits paid
   
(83
)    
(56
)
Accumulated benefit obligation at end of year
   
2,490
     
2,649
 
Plan assets at end of year
   
-
     
-
 
Funded status
  $
(2,490
)   $
(2,649
)
 
Deferred Compensation
– The Cohu, Inc. Deferred Compensation Plan allows certain of our officers to defer a portion of their current compensation. We have purchased life insurance policies on the participants with Cohu as the named beneficiary. Participant contributions, distributions and investment earnings and losses are accumulated in a separate account for each participant. At
December
31,
2016,
the payroll liability to participants, included in accrued compensation and benefits in the consolidated balance sheet, was approximately
$2.4
 million and the cash surrender value of the related life insurance policies included in other current assets was approximately
$2.2
 million. At
December
26,
2015,
the liability totaled
$2.6
 million and the corresponding assets were
$2.3
 million.
 
Employee Stock Purchase Plan
– The Cohu, Inc.
1997
Employee Stock Purchase Plan (“the Plan”) provides for the issuance of a maximum of
2,650,000
shares of our common stock. Under the Plan, eligible employees
may
purchase shares of common stock through payroll deductions. The price paid for the common stock is equal to
85%
of the fair market value of our common stock on specified dates. During the last
three
years we issued shares under the Plan as follows:
2016
-
110,579;
2015
-
122,528
and
2014
-
138,831.
At
December
31,
2016,
there were
700,484
 shares reserved for issuance under the Plan.
 
Stock Options
– At
December
31,
2016,
a total of
1,853,509
 shares were available for future equity grants under the Cohu, Inc.
2005
Equity Incentive Plan (“the
2005
Plan”). Under the
2005
Plan stock options
may
be granted to employees, consultants and outside directors to purchase a fixed number of shares of our common stock at prices not less than
100%
of the fair market value at the date of grant. Options generally vest and become exercisable after
one
year or in
four
annual increments beginning
one
year after the grant date and expire
ten
years from the grant date. We have historically issued new shares of Cohu common stock upon share option exercise.
 
Stock option activity under our share-based compensation plans was as follows:
 
   
2016
   
2015
   
2014
 
           
Wt. Avg.
           
Wt. Avg.
           
Wt. Avg.
 
(in thousands, except per share data)
 
Shares
   
Ex. Price
   
Shares
   
Ex. Price
   
Shares
   
Ex. Price
 
Outstanding, beginning of year
   
1,965
    $
11.25
     
2,435
    $
11.67
     
3,086
    $
11.93
 
Granted
   
-
    $
-
     
10
    $
10.98
     
10
    $
12.58
 
Exercised
   
(101
)   $
7.89
     
(175
)   $
8.65
     
(237
)   $
8.43
 
Cancelled
   
(223
)   $
16.19
     
(305
)   $
16.07
     
(424
)   $
15.37
 
Outstanding, end of year
   
1,641
    $
10.79
     
1,965
    $
11.25
     
2,435
    $
11.67
 
                                                 
Options exercisable at year end
   
1,537
    $
10.85
     
1,673
    $
11.47
     
1,901
    $
12.08
 
 
The aggregate intrinsic value of options exercised was
$0.5
 million in
2016
and
$0.7
million in both
2015
and
2014.
At
December
31,
2016,
the aggregate intrinsic value of options outstanding, vested and expected to vest and exercisable was
$5.6
 million.
 
Information about stock options outstanding at
December
31,
2016
is as follows
(options in thousands)
:
 
         
Options Outstanding
   
Options Exercisable
 
                 
Approximate
                         
                 
Wt. Avg.
                         
Range of
   
Number
   
Remaining
   
Wt. Avg.
   
Number
   
Wt. Avg.
 
Exercise Prices
   
Outstanding
   
Life (in years)
   
Ex. Price
   
Exercisable
   
Ex. Price
 
$7.32
-
$10.58
     
1,089
     
4.4
    $
8.92
     
1,002
    $
8.87
 
$10.59
-
$15.50
     
466
     
3.2
    $
14.08
     
449
    $
14.20
 
$15.51
-
$20.73
     
86
     
3.2
    $
16.55
     
86
    $
16.55
 
 
 
 
     
1,641
     
4.0
    $
10.79
     
1,537
    $
10.85
 
 
Restricted Stock Units
– Under our equity incentive plans, restricted stock units
may
be granted to employees, consultants and outside directors. Restricted stock units vest over a
one
-year,
two
-year or a
four
-year period from the date of grant. Prior to vesting, restricted stock units do not have dividend equivalent rights, do not have voting rights and the shares underlying the restricted stock units are not considered issued and outstanding. New shares of our common stock will be issued on the date the restricted stock units vest net of the statutory tax withholding requirements to be paid by us on behalf of our employees. As a result, the actual number of shares issued will be fewer than the actual number of RSUs outstanding at
December
31,
2016.
 
Restricted stock unit activity under our share-based compensation plans was as follows
:
 
   
2016
   
2015
   
2014
 
           
Wt. Avg.
           
Wt. Avg.
           
Wt. Avg.
 
(in thousands, except per share data)
 
Units
   
Fair Value
   
Units
   
Fair Value
   
Units
   
Fair Value
 
Outstanding, beginning of year
   
1,078
    $
9.93
     
1,026
    $
9.54
     
887
    $
9.46
 
Granted
   
471
    $
11.25
     
482
    $
10.54
     
497
    $
10.07
 
Released
   
(409
)   $
9.90
     
(339
)   $
9.63
     
(315
)   $
10.16
 
Cancelled
   
(57
)   $
10.25
     
(91
)   $
9.82
     
(43
)   $
9.41
 
Outstanding, end of year
   
1,083
    $
10.50
     
1,078
    $
9.93
     
1,026
    $
9.54
 
 
Equity-Based Performance Stock Units
We grant performance stock units (“PSUs”) to certain senior executives as a part of our long-term equity compensation program. The performance criteria for the PSUs granted in
2016
and
2015
is based on a combination of the Company’s annualized Total Shareholder Return (“TSR”) for the performance period and the relative performance of the Company’s TSR compared with the annualized TSR of certain peer companies for the performance period. The PSU awards granted in
2014
had a
one
-year performance period after which the number of shares of our common stock earned, if any, was determined, subject to certain adjustments resulting from the performance of our TSR relative to a pre-selected comparator group over the
two
-year period following the date of grant. The number of shares of common stock that will ultimately be issued to settle PSUs granted over the last
three
years is as follows:
 
Year Granted   Range of Awards     Performance Criteria Period (in years)  
2016
 
25%
-
200%
     
3
 
2015
 
25%
-
200%
     
2
 
2014
 
0%
-
150%
     
2
 
 
PSUs granted in
2016
vest
100%
on the
third
anniversary of their grant and PSUs granted in
2015
and
2014
vest
50%
on the
second
and
third
anniversary of their grant, respectively.
 
We estimated the fair value of the PSUs using a Monte Carlo simulation model on the date of grant. Compensation expense is recognized over the derived service period. New shares of our common stock will be issued on the date the PSUs vest net of the minimum statutory tax withholding requirements to be paid by us on behalf of our employees. As a result, the actual number of shares issued will be fewer than the actual number PSUs outstanding at
December
31,
2016.
 
PSU activity under our share-based compensation plans was as follows
:
 
   
2016
   
2015
   
2014
 
           
Wt. Avg.
           
Wt. Avg.
           
Wt. Avg.
 
(in thousands, except per share data)
 
Units
   
Fair Value
   
Units
   
Fair Value
   
Units
   
Fair Value
 
Outstanding, beginning of year
   
376
    $
10.80
     
334
    $
10.49
     
238
    $
9.32
 
Granted
   
222
    $
11.38
     
156
    $
10.69
     
208
    $
11.34
 
Released
   
(172
)   $
11.27
     
(38
)   $
9.52
     
(38
)   $
9.52
 
Cancelled
   
(23
)   $
8.75
     
(76
)   $
9.86
     
(74
)   $
9.59
 
Outstanding, end of year
   
403
    $
11.04
     
376
    $
10.80
     
334
    $
10.49
 
 
Share-based Compensation
– We estimate the fair value of each share-based award on the grant date using the Black-Scholes and the Monte Carlo simulation valuation models. Option valuation models require the input of highly subjective assumptions and changes in the assumptions used can materially affect the grant date fair value of an award. These assumptions for the Black-Scholes model include the risk-free rate of interest, expected dividend yield, expected volatility, and the expected life of the award. The risk-free rate of interest is based on the U.S. Treasury rates appropriate for the expected term of the award as of the grant date. Expected dividends are based primarily on historical factors related to our common stock. Expected volatility is based on historic weekly stock price observations of our common stock during the period immediately preceding the share-based award grant that is equal in length to the award’s expected term. We believe that historical volatility is the best estimate of future volatility. Expected life of the award is based on historical option exercise data. The Monte Carlo simulation model incorporates assumptions for the risk-free interest rate, Cohu and the selected peer group price volatility, the correlation between Cohu and the selected index, and dividend yields. Share-based compensation expense related to restricted stock unit awards is calculated based on the market price of our common stock on the date of grant, reduced by the present value of dividends expected to be paid on our common stock prior to vesting of the restricted stock unit.
 
The following weighted average assumptions were used to value share-based awards granted:
 
Employee Stock Purchase Plan
 
2016
   
2015
   
2014
 
Dividend yield
   
2.0
%
   
2.2
%    
2.4
%
Expected volatility
   
31.2
%
   
35.3
%    
35.3
%
Risk-free interest rate
   
0.3
%
   
0.1
%    
0.1
%
Expected term (years)
   
0.5
 
   
0.5
     
0.5
 
Weighted-average grant date fair value per share
  $
2.82
 
  $
2.71
    $
2.52
 
                         
Employee Stock Options
   
2016
 (1)
   
2015
     
2014
 
Dividend yield
   
N/A
 
   
2.1
%    
2.0
%
Expected volatility
   
N/A
 
   
39.1
%    
42.5
%
Risk-free interest rate
   
N/A
 
   
1.6
%    
1.9
%
Expected term (years)
   
N/A
 
   
5.9
     
5.9
 
Weighted-average grant date fair value per share
   
N/A
 
  $
3.46
    $
4.39
 
                         
Restricted Stock Units
 
2016
 
 
2015
   
2014
 
Dividend yield
   
2.0
%
   
2.1
%    
2.2
%
                         
Performance Stock Units
 
2016
 
 
2015
   
2014
 
Dividend yield
   
2.0
%
   
2.1
%    
2.2
%
 
 
(1)
There were no employee stock options granted in
2016.
 
Reported share-based compensation is classified in the Consolidated Financial Statements as follows
:
 
(in thousands)
 
2016
   
2015
   
2014
 
Cost of sales
  $
398
    $
566
    $
491
 
Research and development
   
1,292
     
1,092
     
1,858
 
Selling, general and administrative
   
5,453
     
5,097
     
4,039
 
Share-based compensation of continuing operations
   
7,143
     
6,755
     
6,388
 
Discontinued operations
   
-
     
138
     
388
 
Income tax benefit
   
(269
)    
(249
)    
(204
)
Total share-based compensation, net of tax
  $
6,874
    $
6,644
    $
6,572
 
 
We elected to early adopt ASU
2016
-
09
in the
fourth
quarter of
2016,
which among other items, provides an accounting policy election to account for forfeitures as they occur, rather than based on an estimate of expected forfeitures. We elected to account for forfeitures as they occur and therefore, share-based compensation expense for the year ended
December
31,
2016
has been calculated based on actual forfeitures in our consolidated statement of income, rather than our previous approach where the expense was net of estimated forfeitures determined at the grant date. The net cumulative effect of this change was recognized as a
$0.2
 million increase to paid-in capital and a decrease to retained earnings as of
December
27,
2015.
Share-based compensation expense for the years ended
December
26,
2015
and
December
27,
2014
was recorded net of estimated forfeitures.
 
At
December
31,
2016,
we had approximately
$0.1
 million of pre-tax unrecognized compensation cost related to unvested stock options which is expected to be recognized over a weighted-average period of approximately
0.5
 years.
 
At
December
31,
2016,
we had approximately
$9.3
 million of pre-tax unrecognized compensation cost related to unvested restricted stock units and performance stock units which is expected to be recognized over a weighted-average period of approximately
2.3
 years.