CORRESP 1 filename1.htm
VIA EDGAR SUBMISSION

Ms. Cheryl Brown and Mr. Daniel Morris
Division of Corporation Finance
Office of Energy & Transportation
Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street NE
Washington, D.C. 20549
 
August 13, 2024
 
Re:
Piedmont Lithium Inc.

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year ended December 31, 2023

Filed February 29, 2024

File No. 001-38427

Dear Mr. Coleman, Ms. Guobadia and Mr. Hiller,
 
Please find our response to the comments set forth in a letter dated July 16, 2024 (the “Letter”) from the staff (the “Staff”) of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “Commission”) relating to the above-mentioned Annual Report on Form 10-K.  References to the “Company,” “Piedmont,” “we,” “us” and “our” in this letter refer to Piedmont Lithium Inc., unless otherwise indicated.
 
For your convenience, we have restated below in bold the comment from the Letter and supplied our response immediately thereafter.
 
Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year ended December 31, 2023
 
Properties, page 32
 

1.
Please expand your discussion of the Carolina Lithium mineral reserve to include the associated commodity price as required by Item 1304 (d)(1) of Regulation S-K.  Please also provide the commodity price and point of reference along with the summary resource and summary reserve tables as required by Item 1303(b)(3) of Regulation S-K.
 
Response:
 
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment regarding the summary tables and will comply with this comment in its future filings, beginning with the 2024 Form 10-K, by presenting the associated commodity price and point of reference with the summary resource and summary reserve tables in substantially the following form:
 
1

Summary Resources Table
 
The following table provides a summary of our mineral resources, exclusive of reserves as of December 31, 2023.  Where applicable, the amounts represent our attributable portion based on ownership percentages previously noted.  The relevant technical information supporting mineral resources for each material property is included in the “Material Individual Properties” section below.  Relevant technical information supporting mineral resources for our non-material properties is included under the “Authier” and “Ewoyaa” sections below and in the technical report summaries attached as Exhibits 96.4 and 96.2 to this Annual Report.
 

 
Measured Mineral
Resources
   
Indicated Mineral
Resources
   
Measured and
Indicated Mineral
Resources
   
Inferred Mineral
Resources
 
(amounts in millions of metric tons)
 
Amount
   
Grade
(Li2O%)
   
Amount
   
Grade
(Li2O%)
   
Amount
   
Grade
(Li2O%)
   
Amount
   
Grade
(Li2O%)
 
Lithium - Hard Rock:
                                               
North America
                                               
Carolina Lithium (1)
 
   
   
9.96
   
1.14%

 
9.96
   
1.14%

 
15.93
   
1.02%

NAL (2)
 
0.24
   
1.00%

 
2.22
   
1.15%

 
2.47
   
1.14%

 
11.22
   
1.23%

Authier (2)
 
0.08
   
0.80%

 
1.08
   
0.98%

 
1.16
   
0.97%

 
2.16
   
0.98%

West Africa
                     
         
         
Ewoyaa (3)
 
   
   
0.21
   
1.09%

 
0.21
   
1.09%

 
0.17
   
1.07%




(1)
Lithium resources at Carolina Lithium at an effective date of October 20, 2021 were estimated at a spodumene concentrate price of $1,893 per metric ton.

(2)
As of December 31, 2023, we owned 34% of NAL and Authier through ownership in Sayona Mining and our Sayona Quebec joint venture (see “Item 2 Properties—Equity Method Investment Projects”). We are therefore reporting 34% of NAL and Authier’s mineral resources. Lithium resources at NAL at an effective date of December 31, 2022 were estimated at a spodumene concentrate price of $1,273 per metric ton and lithium resources at Authier at effective date of October 6, 2021 were estimated at a spodumene concentrate price of $977 per metric ton.

(3)
As of December 31, 2023, we owned 9% of Ewoyaa through our ownership in Atlantic Lithium. We are therefore reporting 9% of Ewoyaa’s mineral resources. Lithium resources at Ewoyaa at effective date of January 2023 were estimated at a spodumene concentrate price of $1,587 per metric ton.
 
Summary Reserves Table
 
The following table provides a summary of our mineral reserves as of December 31, 2023.  Where applicable, the amounts represent our attributable portion based on ownership percentages previously noted.  The relevant technical information supporting mineral reserves for each material property is included in the “Material Individual Properties” section below.  Relevant technical information supporting mineral reserves for our non-material properties is included under the “Authier” and “Ewoyaa” sections below and in the technical report summaries attached as Exhibits 96.4 and 96.2 to this Annual Report.
 
2

   
Proven Mineral Reserves
   
Probable Mineral Reserves
   
Total Mineral Reserves
 
(amounts in millions of metric tons)
 
Amount
   
Grade
(Li2O%)
   
Amount
   
Grade
(Li2O%)
   
Amount
   
Grade
(Li2O%)
 
Lithium - Hard Rock:
                                   
North America
                                   
Carolina Lithium (1)
 
   
   
18.26
   
1.10%

 
18.26
   
1.10%

NAL (2)
 
0.11
   
1.43%

 
6.88
   
1.08%

 
7.00
   
1.09%

Authier (2)
 
2.11
   
0.93%

 
1.73
   
1.00%

 
3.84
   
0.96%

West Africa
                     
         
Ewoyaa (3)
 
   
   
2.30
   
1.22%

 
2.30
   
1.22%




(1)
Lithium reserves at Carolina Lithium at an effective date of December 31, 2021 were estimated at a spodumene concentrate price of $1,893 per metric ton.

(2)
As of December 31, 2023, we owned 34% of NAL and Authier through our ownership in Sayona Mining and Sayona Quebec joint venture (see “Item 2 Properties—Equity Method Investment Projects”). We are therefore reporting 34% of NAL and Authier’s mineral reserves. Lithium reserves at NAL at an effective date of December 31, 2023 were estimated at a spodumene concentrate price of $1,352 per metric ton and lithium reserves at Authier at an effective date of December 31, 2023 were estimated at a transfer price of C$120 per metric ton for run-of-mine ore between the Authier Project and NAL.

(3)
As of December 31, 2023, we owned 9% of Ewoyaa through our ownership in Atlantic Lithium. We are therefore reporting 9% of Ewoyaa’s mineral reserves.  Lithium reserves at Ewoyaa at effective date of June 16, 2023 were estimated at a spodumene concentrate price of $1,587 per metric ton.
 
Additionally, the Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment regarding Carolina Lithium’s reserves table and will comply with this comment in future Form 10-K filings, beginning with the 2024 Form 10-K, by presenting the associated commodity price and point of reference with the mineral reserve table for Carolina Lithium in substantially the following form:

Carolina Lithium – Estimate of Mineral Reserves Effective as of December 31, 2021 (undiluted)

Mineral Reserves
Category
Ore
(MT)(1)
Grade
(Li2O%)
Li2O
(metric tons)(2)
LCE
(metric tons)
Cut-Off Grade
(% Li2O)
Metallurgical
Recovery
Concentrator (%)(3)
Proven
0.4
77
Probable
18.26
1.10
200,000
495,000



(1)
Reserves are expressed as tonnages effectively delivered to a run-of-mine pad, prior to the application of losses and recovery factors (i.e., metallurgical recovery as expressed above) incurred during concentration and conversion.  Pricing to support mineral reserve economics is based upon the sale of lithium hydroxide, after the processing of run-of-mine reserves in the Company’s planned spodumene concentrator and lithium hydroxide conversion facilities.  Mineral reserves estimated exclusive of the mineral resources.

(2)
Based on long-term pricing of $1,893 per metric ton of spodumene concentrate.

(3)
Metallurgical recovery of 77 percent for lithium ore is associated with the production of a 6-percent spodumene concentrate.
 
Consolidated Statements of Operations, page F-5
 

2.
We understand from your disclosure on page F-21 that your cost of sales and gross profit measures may not include depreciation.  We generally believe these measures would need to reflect depreciation and amortization that is attributable to cost of sales in accordance with GAAP.  The attributable portion should be included in your cost of sales measure or be presented separately and above your measure of gross  profit, in which case you should also adhere to the labeling conventions described in SAB Topic 11:B.
 
Please also modify your discussion and analysis of the corresponding measures on page 66 to reflect the composition of the measures and to address any material effects of changes in depreciation and amortization on costs of sales.
 
3

Response:
 
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and advises the Staff that all revenue is generated through the re-sale of spodumene concentrate from our offtake agreement with Sayona Quebec. Due to the nature of our current operations, which do not yet involve the mining or manufacturing of the product we sell, we have no depreciable assets related to the spodumene concentrate we sell. As described in Note 8—Property, Plant and Mine Development in our consolidated financial statements in our 2024 Form 10-K, depletion of mining interests and mine development assets does not commence until the assets are placed in service. The vast majority of our property, plant and mine development assets as of December 31, 2023 consisted of mining interests and mine development costs associated with Carolina Lithium and construction in process associated with Tennessee Lithium, none of which were placed in service as of December 31, 2023. As such, we have not recorded depletion expense for any of our mining interests or mine development assets as of December 31, 2023. For the year ended December 31, 2023, the Company recognized $241,000 in total depreciation expense, which was recorded to selling, general and administrative expense as all depreciable assets related to corporate assets associated with facilities, equipment, and leasehold improvements.
 
Note 8 - Property, Plant and Mine Development, page F-20
 

3.
We note that you have disclosed various acquisitions without describing the terms governing these transactions or the accounting applied.  For example, on page 35 you refer to an acquisition and earn-in agreement to purchase or earn interests in claims, on page 62 you indicate that you purchased a 132-acre disposal facility, and on page F-24 you indicate that you acquired an investment as part of a spin-out, without such details.
 
Please disclose the material terms of arrangements under which these and other acquisitions occurred, such as the dates of the transactions, duration of any options, earn-in periods, any unresolved or open provisions, the amounts and forms of consideration, milestones or incremental investments required, methodology applied in valuing non-cash components, and any material contingencies or uncertainties.
 
Response:
 
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and advises the Staff that it believes it has disclosed the material terms of such arrangements and related contingencies and uncertainties.
 
The acquisition and earn-in agreement referred to page 35 refers to an agreement between North American Lithium (NAL) and Jourdan Resources, Inc, pursuant to which NAL acquired 20 claims in November of 2022 and has the ability to acquire 51% of an additional 28 claims.  Because the Company had only an approximate 34% indirect interest in NAL, its potential indirect interest in the Jourdan claims is not material to the Company as a whole.
 
With respect to the 132-acre disposal facility, this acquisition is complete, is not material to the Company as a whole, involves no further options, earn-ins, milestones or contingencies, except to the extent the usefulness of this facility depends on the Tennessee Project as a whole, which risks the Company believes are adequately disclosed in its 2024 Form 10-K.
 
4

With respect to the spin-out referred to on page F-24, Atlantic Lithium Limited (“Atlantic Lithium”) conducted a pro rata spin-off of shares in Ricca Resources Limited shares to all of Atlantic Lithium’s shareholders in December of 2021.  The Company, by virtue of its ownership in Atlantic Lithium, received shares in Ricca Resources Limited in proportion to its ownership and without the payment of any consideration and without the Company taking any action.  We estimated the value of such shares at approximately $484,000 as of December 31, 2023, as disclosed in Note 10—Other Assets and Liabilities to our financial statements.  The Company believes that its disclosure in Note 10, in light of the Company’s overall financial position, is sufficient for an understanding of the nature and value of such equity securities.
 
Based on the foregoing, the Company respectfully submits that disclosure of additional details with respect to the arrangements referred to above does not require additional footnote disclosure under GAAP because it is not material to an understanding of the financial statements.
 
Exhibits
 
96.3, page 78
 

4.
We note that the North American Lithium DFS technical report includes a cash flow analysis covering the life-of-mine, having differing assumptions regarding pricing through 2026 and after year 2026, where 50% of sales through 2026 would be based on contractual pricing and no sales beyond that year would be based on contractual pricing.
 
Please explain to us the rational for the change in assumptions and how the assumptions through 2026 and beyond 2026 correlate with the terms of the contractual arrangements that are in place for sales of production.  If these assumptions are not consistent with the contractual arrangements also explain to us how the assessment of economic viability for the mineral reserves would change when using the contractual pricing, and provide the analysis that you performed in formulating your view.
 
Also address the guidance in Item 601(b)(96)(iii)(B)(19) of Regulation S-K, concerning the economic analyses in the technical report summary, which would generally require a cash flow analysis having line items for annual production, price, and revenue.
 
Response:
 
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and advises the Staff that the assumptions in the DFS cash flow analysis change after 2026 to illustrate project economics should a conversion facility be completed on site, with the assumption that concentrate will not be delivered to Piedmont, but instead entirely to the conversion facility beginning in 2027, at market prices.
 
As Piedmont believes that our offtake agreement and its commercial terms would survive the construction of a conversion facility, whereby Piedmont would still have the right to purchase spodumene concentrate at a ceiling price of $900 per metric ton on an SC-6 basis; however, with the obligation to then deliver (sell) this concentrate to the conversion facility at market prices, the DFS cash flow analysis assumptions do run counter to the provisions of the offtake agreement.
 
5

The DFS cash flow analysis is most representative of a scenario where Piedmont and Sayona Quebec reach a commercial agreement to renegotiate the ownership structure of Sayona Quebec, whereby Piedmont contributes the value of our offtake agreement potentially in exchange for a larger stake in the Sayona Quebec joint venture.  In such scenario, no spodumene concentrate would be delivered to Piedmont before being delivered to the conversion facility.
 
To the extent such scenario does not come to fruition, and our offtake agreement is enforced on a life-of-mine basis, the economic viability for the mineral reserves would not change, as evidenced by the following economic analysis:
 
6

Calendar Year
               
2021
   
2022
   
2023
   
2024
   
2025
   
2026
   
2027
   
2028
   
2029
   
2030
   
2031
   
2032
   
2033
   
2034
   
2035
   
2036
   
2037
   
2038
   
2039
   
2040
   
2041
   
2042
 
Summary of Key Production & Financial Metrics
Millions
 
Total
   
US$
                                                                                                                                     

           
0.75
                                                                                                                                     

                                                                                                                                                   
Net Revenue
C$ mil
   
6,147
     
4,610
     
-
     
-
     
553
     
918
     
402
     
343
     
343
     
270
     
262
     
252
     
244
     
235
     
223
     
261
     
221
     
221
     
221
     
262
     
221
     
262
     
222
     
209
 

                                                                                                                                                                                                 
Net Revenue per Ton
CAD$ / ton of Spodumene
                   
-
     
-
     
3,686
     
3,826
     
1,913
     
1,635
     
1,633
     
1,503
     
1,453
     
1,402
     
1,354
     
1,306
     
1,241
     
1,245
     
1,230
     
1,230
     
1,230
     
1,246
     
1,230
     
1,246
     
1,231
     
1,224
 
Net Revenue per Ton
USD$ / ton of Spodumene
                   
-
     
-
     
2,765
     
2,869
     
1,434
     
1,226
     
1,225
     
1,127
     
1,090
     
1,052
     
1,016
     
979
     
931
     
934
     
923
     
923
     
923
     
935
     
923
     
935
     
923
     
918
 

                                                                                                                                                                                                 
Sales
ton of Spodumene
   
3,800,781
             
-
     
-
     
150,000
     
240,000
     
210,000
     
210,000
     
210,000
     
180,000
     
180,000
     
180,000
     
180,000
     
180,000
     
180,000
     
210,000
     
180,000
     
180,000
     
180,000
     
210,000
     
180,000
     
210,000
     
180,000
     
170,781
 

                                                                                                                                                                                                 
Operating Costs
C$ mil
   
3,935
     
2,951
     
-
     
-
     
138
     
185
     
221
     
234
     
229
     
195
     
219
     
217
     
214
     
186
     
195
     
229
     
185
     
193
     
184
     
195
     
177
     
194
     
169
     
177
 

                                                                                                                                                                                                 

                                                                                                                                                                                                 
Gross Profit - Ebitda
C$ mil
   
2,212
     
1,659
     
-
     
-
     
415
     
733
     
181
     
109
     
114
     
76
     
43
     
36
     
30
     
49
     
29
     
33
     
36
     
28
     
38
     
67
     
44
     
68
     
53
     
32
 

                                                                                                                                                                                                 
Gross Profit Margin
%
   
36
%
   
36
%
   
-
     
-
     
75
%
   
80
%
   
45
%
   
32
%
   
33
%
   
28
%
   
16
%
   
14
%
   
12
%
   
21
%
   
13
%
   
13
%
   
16
%
   
13
%
   
17
%
   
26
%
   
20
%
   
26
%
   
24
%
   
15
%

                                                                                                                                                                                                 
Depreciation
C$ mil
   
372
     
279
     
-
     
-
     
18
     
34
     
36
     
33
     
36
     
37
     
30
     
24
     
20
     
16
     
14
     
13
     
12
     
10
     
9
     
8
     
7
     
6
     
5
     
4
 

                                                                                                                                                                                                 
EBIT
C$ mil
   
1,841
     
1,381
     
-
     
-
     
397
     
699
     
145
     
76
     
78
     
38
     
13
     
12
     
10
     
33
     
14
     
20
     
24
     
18
     
29
     
59
     
38
     
62
     
47
     
28
 
 
                                                                                                                                                                                                 
Interest Expense
C$ mil
   
6
     
4
     
-
     
-
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
     
0
 
Mine Closure Cost
C$ mil
   
35
     
26
     
-
     
-
     
17
     
9
     
9
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
 

                                                                                                                                                                                                 
EBT
C$ mil
   
1,800
     
1,350
     
-
     
-
     
379
     
690
     
136
     
76
     
78
     
38
     
13
     
11
     
10
     
32
     
14
     
20
     
24
     
18
     
29
     
59
     
37
     
61
     
47
     
28
 

                                                                                                                                                                                                 
Income Tax
C$ mil
   
559
     
419
     
-
     
-
     
106
     
189
     
96
     
21
     
17
     
13
     
5
     
3
     
4
     
6
     
7
     
6
     
6
     
6
     
9
     
13
     
14
     
15
     
15
     
8
 

                                                                                                                                                                                                 
Net Income
C$ mil
   
1,241
     
931
     
-
     
-
     
274
     
501
     
40
     
55
     
61
     
26
     
8
     
8
     
6
     
26
     
7
     
13
     
18
     
11
     
20
     
46
     
23
     
47
     
32
     
19
 
                                                                                                                                                                                                   
Cash Flow (USD, millions)
 
                                                                                                                                                                                               
Ebitda
     
2,212
     
1,659
                     
415
     
733
     
181
     
109
     
114
     
76
     
43
     
36
     
30
     
49
     
29
     
33
     
36
     
28
     
38
     
67
     
44
     
68
     
53
     
32
 
Working Capital changes
     
(1
)
   
(1
)
                   
(31
)
   
(1
)
   
12
     
1
     
8
     
(18
)
   
8
     
2
     
1
     
(9
)
   
(3
)
   
28
     
(4
)
   
4
     
(10
)
   
6
     
(7
)
   
2
     
(5
)
   
14
 
Capex
     
(352
)
   
(264
)
                   
(84
)
   
(64
)
   
(40
)
   
(12
)
   
(76
)
   
(10
)
   
(0
)
   
(10
)
   
(3
)
   
(8
)
   
(7
)
   
(8
)
   
(11
)
   
(0
)
   
(4
)
   
(5
)
   
(3
)
   
(5
)
   
(0
)
   
-
 
Pre-Tax Cash Flow
     
1,859
     
1,394
                     
300
     
667
     
152
     
98
     
45
     
48
     
51
     
28
     
29
     
32
     
19
     
52
     
21
     
32
     
24
     
68
     
34
     
65
     
47
     
46
 
Cash Taxes
     
(561
)
   
(421
)
                   
(106
)
   
(189
)
   
(96
)
   
(21
)
   
(17
)
   
(13
)
   
(5
)
   
(4
)
   
(4
)
   
(6
)
   
(7
)
   
(6
)
   
(6
)
   
(6
)
   
(9
)
   
(13
)
   
(14
)
   
(15
)
   
(15
)
   
(8
)
Post-Tax Cash Flow
 
   
1,298
     
974
                     
194
     
479
     
56
     
77
     
28
     
35
     
45
     
24
     
24
     
26
     
12
     
46
     
16
     
26
     
15
     
55
     
20
     
50
     
32
     
38
 

7

Additionally, the Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment regarding the guidance in Item 601(b)(96)(iii)(B)(19) of Regulation S-K and will comply with this comment in future Form 10-K filings, beginning with the 2024 Form 10-K, by including additional line items in the cash flow analysis of the North American Lithium DFS technical report summary, in substantially the form as seen above.
 
 
Sincerely,
   
 
/s/ Bruce Czachor
 
 
Bruce Czachor
 
Executive Vice President and Chief Legal Officer and Secretary

Via E-mail:
cc:
Michael White, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer

Eric Scarazzo, Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP


8