EX-99.3 4 ex99_3.htm EXHIBIT 99.3
Exhibit 99.3

Carolina Trust BancShares, Inc. and Clover Community Bankshares, Inc.

Unaudited Pro Forma Condensed Combined Balance Sheets As of September 30, 2018
($ in thousands, except share and per share data)

   
Carolina Trust
BancShares, Inc.
   
Clover Community
Bankshares, Inc.
   
Pro Forma
Before
Adjustments
   
Pro Forma
Purchase
Accounting
Adjustments
       
Adjustments for
Merger and
Transactional
Costs
     
Pro Forma
Combined
 
                                           
ASSETS
                                         
Cash and due from banks
 
$
9,000
   
$
6,723
   
$
15,723
   
$
(1,075
)
 
A
 
$
(873
)
A
 
$
13,775
 
Interest-earning deposits in other banks
   
26,416
     
4,073
     
30,489
     
(3,226
)
 
A
   
(2,618
)
A
   
24,645
 
Cash and cash equivalents
   
35,416
     
10,796
     
46,212
     
(4,301
)
       
(3,491
)
A
   
38,420
 
Certificates of deposits
   
1,498
     
4,791
     
6,289
     
-
         
-
       
6,289
 
Securities available for sale, at fair value
   
29,992
     
37,829
     
67,821
     
-
         
-
       
67,821
 
Securities held to maturity
   
-
     
1,000
     
1,000
     
-
         
-
       
1,000
 
Equity securities
   
749
     
-
     
749
     
-
         
-
       
749
 
Nonmarketable equity securities
   
1,050
     
182
     
1,232
     
-
         
-
       
1,232
 
Loans
   
380,746
     
68,736
     
449,482
     
(2,474
)
 
B
   
-
       
447,008
 
Allowance for loan losses
   
(3,925
)
   
(1,332
)
   
(5,257
)
   
1,332
   
C
   
-
       
(3,925
)
Net loans
   
376,821
     
67,404
     
444,225
     
(1,142
)
       
-
       
443,083
 
Accrued interest receivable
   
1,210
     
481
     
1,691
     
-
         
-
       
1,691
 
Bank premises, equipment and software
   
6,154
     
1,916
     
8,070
     
921
   
D
   
-
       
8,991
 
Foreclosed assets
   
1,782
     
960
     
2,742
     
(117
)
 
E
   
-
       
2,625
 
Goodwill
   
-
     
-
     
-
     
4,893
   
F
   
1,074
 
A
   
5,967
 
Other intangible assets
   
47
     
-
     
47
     
3,160
   
G
   
-
       
3,207
 
Bank owned life insurance
   
7,344
     
3,487
     
10,831
     
-
         
-
       
10,831
 
Other assets
   
3,108
     
669
     
3,777
     
(747
)
 
I
   
644
 
A
   
3,674
 
Total Assets
 
$
465,171
   
$
129,515
   
$
594,686
   
$
2,667
       
$
(1,773
)
   
$
595,580
 
                                                       
LIABILITIES AND STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY
Deposits:
                                                     
Noninterest-bearing
 
$
66,796
   
$
32,312
   
$
99,108
   
$
-
       
$
-
     
$
99,108
 
Interest-bearing
   
319,701
     
82,666
     
402,367
     
(46
)
 
H
   
-
       
402,321
 
Total deposits
   
386,497
     
114,978
     
501,475
     
(46
)
       
-
       
501,429
 
Borrowings
   
16,258
     
-
     
16,258
     
-
         
-
       
16,258
 
Notes payable
   
-
     
112
     
112
     
-
         
-
       
112
 
Subordinated notes and debentures
   
9,733
     
-
     
9,733
     
-
         
-
       
9,733
 
Other liabilities
   
3,729
     
1,039
     
4,768
                 
(482
)
A
   
4,286
 
Total liabilities
   
416,217
     
116,129
     
532,346
     
(46
)
       
(482
)
     
531,818
 
Preferred stock
   
-
     
1
     
1
     
(1
)
 
M
   
-
       
-
 
Common stock warrant
   
426
     
-
     
426
     
-
         
-
       
426
 
Common stock
   
17,892
     
9
     
17,901
     
5,301
 
J,
K
   
-
       
23,202
 
Additional paid-in capital
   
25,212
     
2,684
     
27,896
     
8,105
 
J,
K
   
-
       
36,001
 
Retained earnings
   
6,335
     
11,442
     
17,777
     
(11,442
)
 
J
   
(1,291
)
A
   
5,044
 
Accumulated other comprehensive income
   
(911
)
   
(750
)
   
(1,661
)
   
750
   
J
   
-
       
(911
)
Total stockholders’ equity
   
48,954
     
13,386
     
62,340
     
2,713
         
(1,291
)
     
63,762
 
Total Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity
 
$
465,171
   
$
129,515
   
$
594,686
   
$
2,667
       
$
(1,773
)
   
$
595,580
 


Carolina Trust BancShares, Inc. and Clover Community Bankshares, Inc.

 Unaudited Pro Forma Condensed Combined Statements of Operations For the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2018
 ($ in thousands, except per share data)

   
Carolina Trust
BancShares, Inc.
   
Clover Community
Bankshares, Inc.
   
Pro Forma
Before
Adjustments
   
Adjustments
     
Pro Forma
Combined
 
INTEREST INCOME
                               
Interest on investment securities and cash
 
$
984
   
$
940
   
$
1,924
   
$
-
     
$
1,924
 
Interest and fees on loans
   
14,460
     
2,763
     
17,223
     
297
 
B
   
17,520
 
Total interest income
   
15,444
     
3,703
     
19,147
     
297
       
19,444
 
INTEREST EXPENSE
                                         
Interest expense non-maturity deposits
   
500
     
66
     
566
     
-
       
566
 
Interest expense time deposits
   
2,043
     
59
     
2,102
     
8
 
H
   
2,110
 
Interest expense borrowed funds
   
248
     
-
     
248
     
-
       
248
 
Interest expense capital lease
   
10
     
-
     
10
     
-
       
10
 
Interest expense debt
   
16
     
11
     
27
     
-
       
27
 
Interest expense subordinated debt
   
574
     
-
     
574
     
-
       
574
 
Total interest expense
   
3,391
     
136
     
3,527
     
8
       
3,535
 
NET INTEREST INCOME
   
12,053
     
3,567
     
15,620
     
289
       
15,909
 
Loan loss provision
   
415
     
-
     
415
     
-
       
415
 
Net interest income after loan loss provision
   
11,638
     
3,567
     
15,205
     
289
       
15,494
 
                                           
NONINTEREST INCOME
                                         
Service charges on deposit accounts
   
461
     
388
     
849
     
-
       
849
 
Interchange fee income, net
   
165
     
282
     
447
     
-
       
447
 
Gain on sale of investment securities
   
-
     
-
     
-
     
-
       
-
 
Unrealized gain on equity securities
   
123
     
-
     
123
     
-
       
123
 
Other service fees and income
   
321
     
309
     
630
     
-
       
630
 
Total noninterest income
   
1,070
     
979
     
2,049
     
-
       
2,049
 
                                           
NONINTEREST EXPENSE
                                         
Salaries & benefits expense
   
5,496
     
1,962
     
7,458
     
-
       
7,458
 
Occupancy and equipment
   
1,131
     
464
     
1,595
     
17
 
D
   
1,612
 
Data processing expense
   
588
     
162
     
750
     
-
       
750
 
Office supplies expense
   
42
     
87
     
129
     
-
       
129
 
Professional fees
   
328
     
99
     
427
     
-
       
427
 
Advertising and marketing
   
90
     
40
     
130
     
-
       
130
 
Foreclosed asset expense, net
   
453
     
(70
)
   
383
     
-
       
383
 
Directors fees and expenses
   
191
     
58
     
249
     
-
       
249
 
Core deposit intangible amortization expense
   
26
     
-
     
26
     
407
 
G
   
433
 
Merger expense
   
480
     
172
     
652
     
-
       
652
 
Other operating expense
   
1,218
     
581
     
1,799
     
-
       
1,799
 
Total noninterest expense
   
10,043
     
3,555
     
13,598
     
424
       
14,022
 
INCOME BEFORE INCOME TAXES
   
2,665
     
991
     
3,656
     
(135
)
     
3,521
 
Income tax expense
   
659
     
185
     
844
     
(32
)
L
   
812
 
NET INCOME
 
$
2,006
   
$
806
   
$
2,812
   
$
(103
)
   
$
2,709
 
                                           
NET INCOME PER COMMON SHARE
                                         
Basic
 
$
0.33
   
$
0.93
                     
$
0.31
 
Diluted
 
$
0.32
   
$
0.83
                     
$
0.31
 
Weighted average common shares outstanding
   
6,118,461
     
863,776
             
1,791,539
       
8,773,776
 
Weighted average diluted common shares outstanding
   
6,211,670
     
976,901
             
1,678,414
       
8,866,985
 


Carolina Trust BancShares, Inc. and Clover Community Bankshares, Inc.

 Unaudited Pro Forma Condensed Combined Statements of Operations For the Twelve Months Ended December 31, 2017
 ($ in thousands, except per share data)

   
Carolina Trust
BancShares, Inc.
   
Clover Community
Bankshares, Inc.
   
Pro Forma
Before
Adjustments
   
Adjustments
     
Pro Forma
Combined
 
INTEREST INCOME
                               
Interest on investment securities and cash
 
$
915
   
$
1,125
   
$
2,040
   
$
-
     
$
2,040
 
Interest and fees on loans
   
16,534
     
3,971
     
20,505
     
440
 
B
   
20,945
 
Total interest income
   
17,449
     
5,096
     
22,545
     
440
       
22,985
 
INTEREST EXPENSE
                                         
Interest expense non-maturity deposits
   
442
     
82
     
524
     
-
       
524
 
Interest expense time deposits
   
2,039
     
76
     
2,115
     
36
 
H
   
2,151
 
Interest expense borrowed funds
   
222
     
12
     
234
     
-
       
234
 
Interest expense capital lease
   
17
     
-
     
17
     
-
       
17
 
Interest expense debt
   
-
     
31
     
31
     
-
       
31
 
Interest expense subordinated debt
   
759
     
-
     
759
     
-
       
759
 
Total interest expense
   
3,479
     
201
     
3,680
     
36
       
3,716
 
NET INTEREST INCOME
   
13,970
     
4,895
     
18,865
     
404
       
19,269
 
Loan loss provision
   
704
     
-
     
704
               
704
 
Net interest income after loan loss provision
   
13,266
     
4,895
     
18,161
     
404
       
18,565
 
                                           
NONINTEREST INCOME
                                         
Service charges on deposit accounts
   
487
     
566
     
1,053
     
-
       
1,053
 
Interchange fee income, net
   
139
     
348
     
487
     
-
       
487
 
Gain on sale of investment securities
   
-
     
52
     
52
     
-
       
52
 
Other service fees and income
   
407
     
421
     
828
               
828
 
Total noninterest income
   
1,033
     
1,387
     
2,420
     
-
       
2,420
 
                                           
NONINTEREST EXPENSE
                                         
Salaries & benefits expense
   
7,071
     
2,642
     
9,713
     
-
       
9,713
 
Occupancy and equipment
   
1,444
     
618
     
2,062
     
23
 
D
   
2,085
 
Data processing expense
   
948
     
275
     
1,223
     
-
       
1,223
 
Office supplies expense
   
81
     
113
     
194
     
-
       
194
 
Professional fees
   
473
     
155
     
628
     
-
       
628
 
Advertising and marketing
   
132
     
53
     
185
     
-
       
185
 
Foreclosed asset expense, net
   
281
     
6
     
287
     
-
       
287
 
Directors fees and expenses
   
256
     
77
     
333
     
-
       
333
 
Core deposit intangible amortization expense
   
44
     
-
     
44
     
598
 
G
   
642
 
Other operating expense
   
1,571
     
766
     
2,337
     
-
       
2,337
 
Total noninterest expense
   
12,301
     
4,705
     
17,006
     
621
       
17,627
 
INCOME BEFORE INCOME TAXES
   
1,998
     
1,577
     
3,575
     
(217
)
     
3,358
 
Income tax expense
   
1,594
     
564
     
2,158
     
(51
)
L
   
2,107
 
NET INCOME
   
404
     
1,013
     
1,417
     
(166
)
     
1,251
 
Preferred stock dividends
   
-
     
36
     
36
     
(36
)
M
   
-
 
NET INCOME AVAILABLE TO COMMON STOCKHOLDERS
 
$
404
   
$
977
   
$
1,381
   
$
(130
)
   
$
1,251
 
                                           
NET INCOME PER COMMON SHARE
                                         
Basic
 
$
0.09
   
$
1.13
                     
$
0.17
 
Diluted
 
$
0.09
   
$
1.00
                     
$
0.17
 
Weighted average common shares outstanding
   
4,655,369
     
863,776
             
1,791,539
       
7,310,684
 
Weighted average diluted common shares outstanding
   
4,737,874
     
976,901
             
1,678,414
       
7,393,189
 
                                           
Cash dividends per common share
 
$
-
   
$
0.30
                     
$
0.04
 


Notes to Pro Forma Condensed Combined Financial Statements

Note 1. Basis of Presentation

The unaudited pro forma condensed combined financial information has been prepared using the acquisition method of accounting.  Balance sheet data is presented as of September 30, 2018 and assumes the merger involving Carolina Trust BancShares, Inc. (“Carolina Trust”) and Clover Community Bankshares, Inc. (“Clover”) was completed on that date.  Income statement data is presented to give effect to the merger as if it had occurred on January 1, 2017.  The unaudited pro forma condensed combined financial information is presented for illustrative purposes only and is not necessarily indicative of the results of operations or financial position had the merger been consummated at the beginning of the period presented, nor is it indicative of the results of operations in future periods or the future financial position of the combined entities.  Certain historical financial information has been reclassified to conform to current presentation.  The merger, which was completed on January 1, 2019, provided that the merger consideration to be paid by Carolina Trust will consist of a mixture of Carolina Trust common stock and cash, with 195,380 shares, or 20% of Clover’s common stock outstanding on the merger date converted to the per share cash consideration of $22.00 and the balance of Clover’s stock  converted into Carolina Trust common stock at the 2.7181 stock exchange ratio.  Each of the 113,125 shares of Clover preferred stock converted to one share of Clover common stock prior to the exchange of Clover common stock for the merger consideration.

The unaudited pro forma condensed combined financial information includes preliminary estimated adjustments to record assets and liabilities of Clover at their respective fair values and represents Carolina Trust management’s estimates based on available information. The pro forma adjustments included herein are subject to updates as additional information becomes available and as additional analyses are performed. The final allocation of the purchase price will be determined after completion of thorough analyses to determine the fair value of Clover’s tangible and identifiable intangible assets and liabilities as of the merger date. Increases or decreases in the estimated fair values of the net assets, commitments, executory contracts and other items of Clover as compared with the information shown in the unaudited pro forma condensed combined financial information may change the amount of the purchase price allocated to goodwill and other assets and liabilities and may impact the statement of income due to adjustments in yield and/or amortization of the adjusted assets or liabilities.

Note 2. Accounting Policies and Financial Statement Classifications

The accounting policies of both Carolina Trust and Clover have been reviewed and management has determined that there are no material additional conforming adjustments or financial statement reclassifications needed. There are currently no material transactions between Carolina Trust and Clover in relation to the unaudited pro forma condensed combined financial information.

Note 3. Merger Related Charges

The estimated transaction costs related to the merger are approximately $3.0 million ($2.4 million net of tax). This cost is included in the unaudited Pro Forma Condensed Combined Balance Sheets. These estimated transaction costs are still being developed and will continue to be refined over the next several months, and will include assessing personnel, benefit plans, premises, equipment, and service contracts to determine where Carolina Trust and Clover may take advantage of redundancies. These costs will be recorded as non-interest expense as incurred. The pro forma presentation of the merger-related charges is in the following table (dollars in thousands).

   
Carolina Trust
   
Clover
   
Total
 
Professional fees
 
$
120
   
$
253
   
$
373
 
Employee benefit expenses
   
1,149
     
537
   
1,686
 
Data processing
   
355
     
474
   
829
 
Other noninterest expense
   
50
     
70
   
120
 
Total noninterest expense
   
1,674
     
1,334
     
3,008
 
Tax benefit
   
383
     
260
   
643
 
Net merger related expenses
 
$
1,291
   
$
1,074
   
$
2,365
 


Note 4. Purchase Accounting Allocation

The unaudited pro forma condensed combined financial information reflects the issuance of 2,123,858 shares of Carolina Trust common stock totaling approximately $16.1 million plus cash of approximately $4.3 million. The merger will be accounted for using the acquisition method of accounting; accordingly Carolina Trust’s cost to acquire Clover will be allocated to the assets (including identifiable intangible assets) and liabilities of Carolina Trust at their respective fair values as of the merger date. Accordingly, the pro forma purchase price was preliminarily allocated to the assets acquired and the liabilities assumed based on their estimated fair values as summarized in the following table (dollars in thousands).

Common equity capital of Clover as of September 30, 2018(1)
       
$
13,386
 
Estimated Clover related expenses, net of tax
         
(1,074
)
Common equity capital of Clover as of September 30, 2018, adjusted
         
12,312
 
Less estimated fair value adjustments:
             
Allowance for loan losses
 
$
1,332
         
Loan fair value
   
(2,474
)
       
Loans, net
   
(1,142
)
       
Other real estate owned
   
(117
)
       
Premises and equipment
   
921
         
Core deposit intangible
   
3,160
         
Time deposits
   
46
         
Deferred tax adjustments related to the items above
   
(674
)
       
Deferred tax adjustment related BOLI policies acquired
   
(73
)
       
Total fair value adjustments
           
2,121
 
Net assets (Equity capital less fair value adjustments)
           
14,433
 
Total consideration paid to Clover shareholders(2)
           
20,400
 
Goodwill
         
$
5,967
 

(1) Note:  Stockholders’ equity reported here includes preferred equity of $1 that will convert to common equity prior to the share exchange.

(2) Note:  The purchase price is based on total consideration of $20.4 million.  This includes the issuance of approximately $16.1 million in stock consideration, or 2,123,858 shares of Carolina Trust common stock with a value of $7.58 per share (based on Carolina Trust’s closing stock price on December 31, 2018, the last trading day as of the merger date.

Note 5. Pro Forma Adjustments

The following pro forma adjustments have been reflected in the unaudited pro forma condensed combined financial information. All adjustments are based on current assumptions and valuations which are subject to change.


A
Cash was adjusted to reflect payment of estimated merger-related expenses of $2.7 million, which includes $1.2 million for Clover and $1.5 million for Carolina Trust.  Additional merger-related expenses of $0.3 million are expected to be accrued, which includes $0.1 million for Clover and $0.2 million for Carolina Trust.  The impact of these cash and accrued expenses would be offset partially by $0.6 million in tax benefits.  The expenses, net of tax, incurred by Clover would reduce the net assets acquired by Carolina Trust by an estimated $1.1 million, which would result in an increase to goodwill.  The expenses, net of tax, incurred by Carolina Trust would reduce retained earnings by $1.3 million.

Cash was adjusted for Clover’s payment of accrued supplemental executive retirement plan expenses of $0.8 million, which would reduce other liabilities.

Based on the 976,901 outstanding shares of Clover common stock and preferred stock, Carolina Trust expects to pay aggregate cash consideration of $4.3 million, which reflects the $22.00 per share cash consideration payable pursuant to the merger agreement for 20% of the outstanding shares of Clover common stock at merger consummation.


B
Carolina Trust identified $2.5 million in net preliminary estimated fair value adjustments to Clover’s loan portfolio.  This $2.5 million decrease to the fair value of loans reflects Carolina Trust’s estimates related to credit quality totaling $1.7 million, estimates related to market interest rates and liquidity totaling $0.7 million and adjustments to eliminate deferred fees and costs totaling $0.1 million.  The fair value adjustment will be accreted using the level yield methodology over the 2.9 year weighted average life of the acquired loan portfolio.  The accretions would increase interest income for the nine months ended September 30, 2018 and the year ended December 31, 2017 by approximately $0.3 million and $0.4 million, respectively.


C
Clover’s existing allowance for loan losses of $1.3 million was eliminated in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles.



D
Premises and equipment were adjusted higher by $0.9 million to reflect estimated fair value for real property, with the allocation being $0.6 million to land and $0.3 million to buildings.  The adjustment to buildings would be depreciated over an estimated life of 15 years, resulting in depreciation expense of $17,000 for the nine months ended September 30, 2018 and $23,000 for the year ended December 31, 2017.


E
Foreclosed properties were adjusted by $0.1 million based on Carolina Trust’s estimates of adjustments to the market value of these assets.


F
The estimated amount of goodwill arising from pro forma purchase accounting adjustments is $4.8 million, in addition to the goodwill adjustment discussed with merger and transaction costs in paragraph 5.A above.  The final allocation of purchase price will be determined after the merger is completed and all purchase accounting adjustments are finalized, which may change the amount allocated to goodwill.


G
Other intangible assets were adjusted to reflect a core deposit intangible of $3.2 million.  A core deposit intangible arises from a financial institution having a funding base derived from stable customer relationships.  These customer relationships provide a cost benefit to the acquiring institution since the associated customer deposits are typically at lower interest rates and can be expected to be retained on a long-term basis.  This core deposit intangible reflects Carolina Trust management’s estimate of the market premium associated with these core deposits.  The accelerated amortization period is estimated at nine years, resulting in expense of approximately $407,000 for the nine months ended September 30, 2018 and $598,000 for the year ended December 31, 2017.


H
Time deposits were adjusted lower by less than $0.1 million for fair value adjustments based on slightly higher current market rates for similar products. This adjustment will be amortized as an increase to interest expense over the 5 year maturity period of the time deposits under the effective yield method.


I
Other liabilities were adjusted higher by $0.7 million for the estimated deferred tax liability arising from the fair value adjustments and based on an estimated combined federal and state tax rate of 23.5%.


J
Clover’s historical stockholders’ equity was eliminated as a result of the merger when Clover stockholders’ shares were exchanged for a combination of cash and Carolina Trust common stock.


K
The Carolina Trust stock exchanged for Clover stock was 2,123,858 shares, $2.50 par value per share, at market price of $7.58, the closing stock price as of December 31, 2018, the last trading day prior to the closing of the merger.  Fractional shares were paid in cash at the 20 day average closing stock price prior to the merger date which was $7.6305 per share.


L
The tax effect of the adjustments on the pro forma statement of operations is calculated based on an estimated combined federal and state income tax rate of 23.5%


M
The Clover preferred stock and preferred dividend is eliminated as an adjustment because the preferred stock was converted to Clover common stock prior to exchanging Clover common stock for Carolina Trust common stock.