-----BEGIN PRIVACY-ENHANCED MESSAGE----- Proc-Type: 2001,MIC-CLEAR Originator-Name: webmaster@www.sec.gov Originator-Key-Asymmetric: MFgwCgYEVQgBAQICAf8DSgAwRwJAW2sNKK9AVtBzYZmr6aGjlWyK3XmZv3dTINen TWSM7vrzLADbmYQaionwg5sDW3P6oaM5D3tdezXMm7z1T+B+twIDAQAB MIC-Info: RSA-MD5,RSA, SGk5LtqBYrHEk4M1RvpJdIvutwgGLunHSQbffW6RIxVBYxXpFrGsiKZLwRAyr2T+ AjZtModo6rPsCRqZ4I1dPQ== 0000016099-08-000010.txt : 20080502 0000016099-08-000010.hdr.sgml : 20080502 20080310172442 ACCESSION NUMBER: 0000016099-08-000010 CONFORMED SUBMISSION TYPE: CORRESP PUBLIC DOCUMENT COUNT: 2 FILED AS OF DATE: 20080310 FILER: COMPANY DATA: COMPANY CONFORMED NAME: LUBYS INC CENTRAL INDEX KEY: 0000016099 STANDARD INDUSTRIAL CLASSIFICATION: RETAIL-EATING PLACES [5812] IRS NUMBER: 741335253 STATE OF INCORPORATION: DE FISCAL YEAR END: 0831 FILING VALUES: FORM TYPE: CORRESP BUSINESS ADDRESS: STREET 1: 13111 NORTHWEST FREEWAY STREET 2: SUITE 600 CITY: HOUSTON STATE: TX ZIP: 77040 BUSINESS PHONE: (713) 329 6800 MAIL ADDRESS: STREET 1: 13111 NORTHWEST FREEWAY STREET 2: SUITE 600 CITY: HOUSTON STATE: TX ZIP: 77040 FORMER COMPANY: FORMER CONFORMED NAME: LUBYS CAFETERIAS INC DATE OF NAME CHANGE: 19920703 FORMER COMPANY: FORMER CONFORMED NAME: CAFETERIAS INC DATE OF NAME CHANGE: 19810126 CORRESP 1 filename1.htm correspondence.htm
 

Luby's company logo 
Luby’s, Inc.
13111 Northwest Freeway
Suite 600
Houston, TX 77040
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

 
                                                                                             March 10, 2008
 

 
                                                          Via FedEx Overnight and Via Facsimile
 
 

United States Securities and Exchange Commission
450 Fifth Street N. W.
Washington D.C. 20549
 
 
Attention:              Linda Cvrkel
        Branch Chief
 
 
Ladies and Gentlemen:
 
Set forth below is the response of Luby’s, Inc. (the “Company”) to the comments of the Staff of the Division of Corporation Finance (the “Staff”) of the Securities and Exchange Commission with respect to the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended August 29, 2007, and related matters contained in a letter from the Staff to Mr. K. Scott Gray, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of the Company, dated March 6, 2008.

Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended August 29, 2007

Note 6: Impairment of Long-Lived Assets and Property Held for Sale

1.
We note from your response to our prior comment 5 that the estimated fair value of the property of $.5 million is lower than the carrying amount before the asset was classified as held for sale, adjusted for any depreciation expense that would have been recognized had the asset been continuously classified as held and used of $1.1  million.  However, your response is not clear as to the amount of the previous impairment and the carrying value of the restaurant immediately before the impairment.  Please tell us the carrying value of the asset as of the date immediately before it was impaired and the amount of the depreciation expense you have assumed would have been recognized had the asset been continuously classified as held and used.  Also, tell us how you have calculated that depreciation expense.  Additionally, please tell us the amount and date the original impairment expense was recorded.

RESPONSE: The amount of the original asset impairment expense was $1.9 million, which was the carrying value of the building and equipment assets as of the date immediately before it was originally impaired in August 2001. The amount of building and equipment-related asset depreciation expense we computed would have been recognized had the building assets been continuously classified as held and used was $0.9 million, which would have resulted in a net book value of $1.0 million.  The net book value differs by $0.1 million from that presented in our response letter dated February 19, 2008, as we refined our computation in conjunction with the preparation of our response to the Staff’s comment letter dated March 6, 2008.  Nevertheless, net book value assuming continued depreciation substantially exceeds the estimated fair value of $0.5 million.
 
 

 

 
 
The $0.9 million building and equipment-related asset depreciation expense noted above was calculated based on the lesser of the estimated useful life or the related lease term using the straight-line method, which is the same method that was used when the assets were originally placed in service.  The building assets were being depreciated over the term of the ground lease, which will expire in February 2019.  The equipment assets had estimated useful lives of 3 to 10 years. Most of the equipment assets had estimated useful lives of 10 years.
 

*   *   *   *   *


Should you have any additional questions, or wish to clarify any of these matters further, please do not hesitate to contact me.


                                        0;            Very truly yours,                                 
                                                                                         
                                                                                         /s/K.Scott Gray
 
                                                                       K. Scott Gray
                                                                       Senior Vice President and
                                                                       Chief Financial Officer
 
 
 

 



GRAPHIC 2 logo.jpg COMPANY LOGO begin 644 logo.jpg M_]C_X``02D9)1@`!`0$`8`!@``#_X0`\17AI9@``24DJ``@````!`#$!`@`9 M````&@````````!%1$=!4FEZ97(@4V]F='=AH.$A8:'B(F*DI.4E9:7F)F:HJ.DI::G MJ*FJLK.TM;:WN+FZPL/$Q<;'R,G*TM/4U=;7V-G:X>+CY.7FY^CIZO'R\_3U M]O?X^?K_Q``?`0`#`0$!`0$!`0$!`````````0(#!`4&!P@)"@O_Q`"U$0`" M`0($!`,$!P4$!``!`G<``0(#$00%(3$&$D%1!V%Q$R(R@0@40I&AL<$)(S-2 M\!5B7J"@X2%AH>(B8J2DY25EI>8F9JBHZ2EIJ>HJ:JRL[2U MMK>XN;K"P\3%QL?(RKR\_3U]O?X^?K_V@`, M`P$``A$#$0`_`/ZI_P!JK_@MI_P2Y_8I^)VJ?!?]I#]KGP3X&^*V@BR/B+P' MIOAWX@^/M?\`#3:EIEGK.GQ>)+?X>>$/%4>@75YI6H6.H6]GJ\UG>26EW;SB M#RY58_,G_$3G_P`$0/\`H]S3?_#*?M%?_.EK\K?^"UG_``:[_"3]I'Q1^US_ M`,%"/A!^T)XT^&OQ3U3P7X]^.7BCX3:]X3L/&W@/QAXS\'>!WU>\LM#UR+6- M"\2^#4\83>'YVNWGC\86NGZIJS3:;IUMIMM%I1_S1T4NZHOWG95&>!EB`,GZ MF@#_`&OOV0/^"R?_``32_;R^(ES\(_V6?VJO!WQ'^)T&E7FMP>!+S0/'?@+Q M+J^EZ='Y^I7?AS3OB+X5\)R^)AIEONN]2@\/_P!I76GV400V<4LZ?IQ7 M\E/_``1@_P"#83X1_L`?&#X*_MP?$;]H+Q7\:?CAX9\`RZQX7\(:1X6T_P`$ M_#7P3XM^(O@:XT#Q!>&X.K>(/$/C8:/H7B37='T2YN9O#=G-)=#6;O1C/%:V MMM_6M0`4444`%%?C3_P72\??\%-?AS^Q!F-,_VT?BGX7\8>#=?OM!\3 M^$O%?PE^#.E:UH/B'0;^2QU;0?$6A:I\*+>]L-1TZ_M9['5-+U"WAN+>>*:V MN8D=70`'^PI17@_[+'Q`\1_%G]F+]G'XJ>,9;.?Q=\2_@/\`"#X@>*IM/M%L M+";Q'XR^'WA[Q'KDMC8HSI96*`"BBB@#AOB;\ M3/`'P9^'GC3XL?%3Q;HG@/X;_#KPUJ_C#QOXR\1WB6&B>&_#6@V4NH:KJVHW M3YV06MK#(_EQK)<3R;+>VAFN)8HG_&_PG\?O^"J__!0/2Q\3/V1-"^!W[!7[ M)WB(QW?PE^+7[57PU\8?&3]IOXT^$YE+Z9\3M&_9_P!(\7?#SPC\)O`?B>!D MU'PI8_$;Q3J_C;6M%?3];N-"T.TU2&(:7_!9RT7XJ:E_P39_8^\1QW$OPA_: MU_X*#_#+PU\=-/!']F^,_AI\'?!?COX]O\,=;0Y$VC^._%GPZ\+P:I;,K+=: M5I=_;$H90X_;2**."..&&-(8842***)%CCBCC4)'''&@"HB*`J(H"JH````% M`'XD>(O$7_!:K]CC2IOB3XZU+]FW_@IU\'_#L+ZM\1_!/P>^$/B']E?]K'3O M#MJDEQK&K?"+0+OXC_$WX3_%74M&L(I[RW^'^IWG@WQ'XJN(X=)T'6/[0NXH MZ_4']F3]I?X,_M@?`[P!^T3\`/%]MXV^%OQ(TEM3T'5XX)[&_L[FTNI]-UOP M[XBT>[6/4/#_`(J\,:U:7^@^)O#^I0PZAH^M:?>6-S&'AW-[S7XH?L!:5!\% M?^"G?_!7C]F?P8HL?A!?ZO\`LJ_MC>&?"EDBIHW@KXF?M+^!_'>B?&V'3[>, M+#IR^./%'PCTWQ[/80+'#_:6LZK>QQ(UW(T@!^U]%%%`'SA^V/>P:9^R'^U3 MJ5SO^S:?^S?\<;VX\I=\GD6GPQ\43R^6F5WOY<;;%W#>-6`(Y!()''/IS7^Y?_P`%!-8M_#_[!G[:^N78!M=)_9+_ M`&B]0N`9HK<&&U^$/C"63,TQ$40VJ?WDA"+U/%?X=7@B2*'QGX1EG>.."+Q/ MH$DTDI58HXDU6T:1Y&;Y5C1`6HV[7>F/X@\#_``XU[Q/HGV^T1HVN=/\`[0TRV-W;J\9EMA)&'3=N'^?W M_P`&Q_\`P5I_X*&_M!_\%4],^!_[0?[4?Q0^.OPS^.'@#XLZWXI\+_%+7[CQ M1IVA^(O!GA"]\7Z%KO@&UNL6_@2:&YT@Z5<:3X7BTOP[=Z/J%Q#>)K37Y(O.TV*R.\G]LCQEDDD_M,^("6<$__``1X:6>1HI=._::^!UU:Q[TC\ZY?3_'%@\+HXW2; M;6\N9O+CQ(K0B0_NXY`0#\O/^#3K_@J%^WO^V-^V9^T!\&?VI?VEO'_QU^'^ ME?LUZA\1]$TOXA3:=J][H7B[1?B9\//#EMJ&D:PMA;ZG:07&D>*M7MK_`$\W M,EC=.;.X:!9[2.0_RH?\%UX(+?\`X+!_\%$([>&."-OVF_'T[)$BQJT]U<6] MS9S\TDTDDC$LQ)_<3_@RAL+J;_@HA^TSJ4:*;2Q_8ZUJUN7 M+J'6;4/C+\)'M56,_,X=;&Y+,.$VJ&Y=:_"[_@N1J(U3_@KW_P`%$KH0F`)^ MU+\3+'87#DG2]5_LPR[@%P)S9F<+CY!($)8KN(!]C:G\5?\`@Y&^*_[)7AO] MK71O&_[=6@?L$/AQJ M?A#4O$?AK1+#0]FN?$'_`(1[6K7R["^U36O$#0VMU?''QTOAV\^*_A'XIW_B'2GD\&:CK'BA4 M\._$"]\=^&5U_P`+_#6^\;Q76KZ-\3]3\)I>ZGJNB7+VFF_Z(GP!M/@Y;?\` M!-3X-V6G)HQ^`%MYG,^^.>-I#< M%M\A/^,9^QU%>S_MF_LLP>&%O9-1E_:=^"$7AY+,-_:+WK_%7PPNE+:B,[OM MK3F`0[#GSRNTYQ0!^AGQ1_X+,?\`!:;J.CW&DV[V3QL0\*QQ+;2VLD%Q9M):2P2/^ MYO['?[47_!SK\?/^"3_[3G[27PJ^*?B[Q_X)A\6^#=9^&WQ/\5KX'N_CWJ'@ M3X>W/C>W^/W'EP)#X+\(6:,;F[`D_*K_@G1_P7#/[(7_!&7_@H M1^PAJ.M:Q;?%WQQO7]D^\CMKZ[MK/2OCRMAX#^/.FQ:DD,UGX)=9D@<7,1$@`W_@GE_P`%4O\`@H;^V5^T/\-_V>/BM\=O'?[0 M'QKG^+?PU^.?[$6I_$O'B+2?!'[6/P0O]9U[0/#6OSZ=:6U[H/PI^.OPSUGX MG?!7XDZO$&TWPI!XN\/^.=7%KX?\(:O<)_I-?L5?\%&?V?\`]M2SUCPIX?O[ M_P"%G[2WPY2/3OCW^R/\5HU\*?'WX(^++<>5JVD^(_!VHBUO-=\.Q72LVA_$ M'PO%JG@[Q)IDUE?V.IQS7$EC;?Q7_P#!EE^PK:^*OB;^T+_P4*\9:09K/X66 MB?L_?!6ZN(\P+XV\7Z9;:]\5M>M-R@IJ&@>";GPMX;M[A'*/8^/]=MR"Z$I^ MF7P]_:M_9;T'_@I!^TA^UO\`\%(=:^)WB/\`X*/?L[_'#XM_LZ_L+?L$_"WX M.>+-;^(OA;X`3M>:9\.O%7PI\->"-`23X^^*/CIX0UO4=;NOB?XR\6W'@+PY M9:C>V]F/"D%K%A>&=!LA)J.O:_J.FZ/IT,U[>P1-_ MF.?\%#/^"SO_``4*_9>^/?[3GAOX=:E=?LO?M$?MC^)OA_\`M"?M':U;6D%] M\9?A7\/]5^'FB?\`#*O[+6EZSK%G/;>"V^%/P!O_``MX@^(.HZ+I]OXHN/BA M\1/&.D1:GHUKH<]OJ?\`^$O MB&S^(7[+'_!.72=<@\6V/A7QK92--X8^.?[7_BJQ8>'OB1\9]!A9+SP1\,]" MMY_A_P#"2\F>YEOO$?BLZA!-4U.RN/&=GJGP MY\/Z7<:QX,L9E\$/V<-#_`."C MG@;XS?M@^,?V?KCP==?%BU\5:I\=/!_QCL)_AY91W>HW_B_5_@;XJ\7>+]3N M?#-O96=WJ%Z+[X?RM8:7#+J%Q:VEE"UQ%_0=_P`&CO\`P49_;2_;BNOVZ/#/ M[6?QU\7?':T^'"]4\;BRNM7\,ZAX^G^)]GXFTS3=0LK.R6W\/Z@GA M;1Y[+P^(QIVD365P^CV]E%=WDQZMX7U*POXY_] M(2>*?Y_[X/\`@TH_;Z^#'[37P?\`V@O@C8?LW_`[]G[]H[X=:KX8\??$WQ%\ M"?`&E?#WP]\?_"_B`ZAHNC>.]:T'2H_LND>*O"NJ6MUH^N:+I3V?@^V37].U M'PAH>@PZKJND60!^,'_!?<_\'#/Q1_;0_:G^"FA>#?VVO%G[%WB3Q#>Z+\+/ M!G[.7P^^(.K_``1\8?!B]TG2AI=AK]U\+M$NX/%5_J%HV/&^F>-+^_N%\1R: MW8?8K?3%@LT_FA'_``2S_P""F8((_P""?'[:X((((_9@^-0((Y!!'@O((/(( MZ5_N"T4`?X__`(CU3_@YA\7_``KU'X(^*-!_X*[^(/A3K'A1O`NK^"=6^'_[ M35]I.K>#GLETV;PUJAG\//=ZCH]UIJ_V=>V5Y=317NGM)97:S6LLD3_I'_P: MZ?\`!.G]N[X1_P#!5[X>_&?XP?LD?M`_!WX6_#SX7_&!?%'C;XM_"SQE\--# MM[KQ;X%U;POX>TS3KKQIH^BC6]6U'5]1A1-,T@7EW#9Q7>H7$<5I:R2U_INT M4`?Y#W_!97_@AU^V]^QK^V'\:_$?@7X#_%7XP_LX_$/XD^+/B+\)/BW\*O!7 MB+QYI5CX<\8Z[JGB2R\)^-#X4T[4;OPCXP\(?:)M$U!-:MM-M=7_`+.CUW1) M9]/OX1%@>(?@?_P<4_\`!2;]G:#POX]^'G[=7[0OP`_9^2P\4:-X>^)>B:]8 MQ2ZC9V(\/Z=>>%].\9P:%XL^,GBO2]&U:Z@M8]&3QQXBTO2+O4Y(4MX+JZ,_ M^P!10!_CD?L3_#7_`(+U?\$Z/B1XC^*?[(7[)W[;GPG\;>*_"T_@?Q1?#]C? MQKXQLM;\-2:C9ZL=+O=(\;_"OQ)I#+#JNG65_;W4%I%>0SVR^5)O%OB[Q3^SK\2?#O_"0 M^,?%6I27NJ:QK.KZEX1T'POH5O`9K:3QAI>A>%]8U6RU?PE;W6AQ^)?&_CY?".G^$=&U:U:[GK_38K\* M/^#CG]B[XS_MT?\`!+#XP?"K]G_3=1\3?%+P;XJ\"_&70_`&DNXU'XD67P^U M"ZEU_P`':=;JP&HZQ+H.IZCKOA[1]LDNL^(]"TC2[-#?W=HR@'S]XK_;W_X) MF_\`!Q?^S!^U]_P3Q_9Z^*MY??%KQ)\(]9U[P/H'Q/\``^N>`=2D\3>%;RUU MGP#\2?"`UNW`UC2?"?Q`L/"]SXEM;.>W\0V>B7LHO])ATZ]GD'^45JW@?Q9H MGCC4OAMJ&A:A%XYTCQ7>>![[PRD#S:K'XLL-7DT&YT)+:$.\NH)K$3Z>L$09 MY+D"-`Q(S]D?L)?MM?'K_@EE^U/_`,-!_"WP1X2'QK\$^%_B%\/(=`^,WA?Q M'<6WA/4/&.B7/AK5;Z\\-VFM>%-4M_$>AQS2B"SU2X-JLAGMM1TZX20HG[?_ M`/!M[_P31^-7_!1?_@HCHO[=_P`/[ZS\:^,[?2[>32-'T71SHFI26-UK^D6U MP`?Z&G_!*']B;1/^">W[`/[-_P"R_8:?:6GB?PCX#T[7?BM>VT<8DUSXQ>,H MU\2_$O5+BX0L]XD7B;4+S1M)FF>22'P]I&C6"L(+.%$_0%M(TE]4CUQ]+TYM M:BLVTZ+6&LK9M4CT]I3.UC'J!B-VEFTS-,ULLP@,K&0H7)-:-%`!7^6!_P`% MG?V*/^"F=K_P7P_:#^*W[+GP%_:.\4_$._\`'_@#]H3X"_$OX0^!O%GB6.+2 M_#?@/PA>'KG2[VZ"Q:GHS:%]BN8KFTMKO_4_ MHH`_R//V_O\`@IO_`,%K_P#@HA\'?#O[%_[5O[-6M:H^B>+]'UMH]#_8Z\9> M&/C-KOBSP\+JTM3,PTJZ.E7[_`&MW_9G_`+4^-O[6?C;P;\-+?X)>+=)\1ZIXQ\%_`_PR MFH>)Y4\3:)X3E^W^#?''Q:\3W=A%I%KKBS3>#-+\%B?Q-IUC>:]+86'^@S10 M`4444`%%%%`!1110`4444`%%%%`'^=/_`,',G_*3?X%?]C!IG_J+K7]U'["_ ?_)HOP#_[$&P_]*KRBB@#ZPHHHH`****`"BBB@#__V3\_ ` end
-----END PRIVACY-ENHANCED MESSAGE-----