The Securities and Exchange Commission has not necessarily reviewed the information in this filing and has not determined if it is accurate and complete.
The reader should not assume that the information is accurate and complete.

UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
FORM 13F

FORM 13F INFORMATION TABLE
OMB APPROVAL
OMB Number: 3235-0006
Estimated average burden
hours per response: 23.8
COLUMN 1 COLUMN 2 COLUMN 3 COLUMN 4 COLUMN 5 COLUMN 6 COLUMN 7 COLUMN 8
VALUE SHRS OR SH/ PUT/ INVESTMENT OTHER VOTING AUTHORITY
NAME OF ISSUER TITLE OF CLASS CUSIP (x$1000) PRN AMT PRN CALL DISCRETION MANAGER SOLE SHARED NONE
Navidea Biopharma COM 63937X103 2 16,755 SH   SOLE   2 0 0
National Holdings 22 Wts *W EXP 01/18/202 636375115 21 48,034 SH   SOLE   21 0 0
Sophiris Bio, Inc. COM NEW 83578Q209 34 40,000 SH   SOLE   34 0 0
Ferroglobe PLC SHS G33856108 35 20,636 SH   SOLE   35 0 0
Compugen Ltd. CL B 001085208 38 10,000 SH   SOLE   38 0 0
Sirius XM Radio Inc. COM 82968B103 56 10,023 SH   SOLE   56 0 0
National Holdings Corporation COM NEW 636375206 102 37,699 SH   SOLE   102 0 0
United Cmnty Finl Corp Ohio COM 909839102 144 15,000 SH   SOLE   144 0 0
Arcos Dorados Holdings SHS CLASS -A - G0457F107 173 23,731 SH   SOLE   173 0 0
iShares Comex Gold Trust ETF ISHARES 464285105 178 13,211 SH   SOLE   178 0 0
Keycorp Inc COM 493267108 180 10,116 SH   SOLE   180 0 0
Cerus Corporation COM 157085101 200 35,613 SH   SOLE   200 0 0
American Electric Power COM 025537101 201 2,287 SH   SOLE   201 0 0
Netflix Inc COM 64110L106 202 550 SH   SOLE   202 0 0
Salesforce.com COM 79466L302 205 1,348 SH   SOLE   205 0 0
Service Now Inc COM 81762P102 206 751 SH   SOLE   206 0 0
iQIYI, Inc. SPONSORED ADS 46267X108 207 10,000 SH   SOLE   207 0 0
iShares Russell 1000 Value Index ETF RUS 1000 VAL ETF 464287598 207 1,625 SH   SOLE   207 0 0
iShares Core MSCI EAFE CORE MSCI EAFE 46432F842 208 3,387 SH   SOLE   208 0 0
SPDR Utilities Select Sec ETF SBI INT-UTILS 81369Y886 208 3,489 SH   SOLE   208 0 0
Guggenheim S&P 500 Pure Value ETF S&P500 PUR VAL 46137V258 208 3,205 SH   SOLE   208 0 0
Verizon Communications COM 92343V104 209 3,661 SH   SOLE   209 0 0
Waste Management Inc Del COM 94106L109 217 1,883 SH   SOLE   217 0 0
iShares Russell 3000 Index ETF RUSSELL 3000 ETF 464287689 224 1,301 SH   SOLE   224 0 0
Canopy Growth Corporation COM 138035100 225 5,572 SH   SOLE   225 0 0
ConocoPhillips COM 20825C104 225 3,685 SH   SOLE   225 0 0
Vanguard Mid Cap ETF MID CAP ETF 922908629 226 1,354 SH   SOLE   226 0 0
SPDR Energy Select Sec ETF ENERGY 81369Y506 227 3,561 SH   SOLE   227 0 0
Nvidia Corp COM 67066G104 230 1,401 SH   SOLE   230 0 0
Vanguard Growth ETF GROWTH ETF 922908736 233 1,426 SH   SOLE   233 0 0
Guardant Health, Inc. COM 40131M109 233 2,700 SH   SOLE   233 0 0
PowerShares QQQ ETF UNIT SER 1 46090E103 235 1,261 SH   SOLE   235 0 0
Booking Holdings Inc COM 09857L108 238 127 SH   SOLE   238 0 0
iShares S&P SmallCap 600 Index ETF CORE S&P SCP ETF 464287804 239 3,049 SH   SOLE   239 0 0
Workday Inc Cl A CL A 98138H101 247 1,200 SH   SOLE   247 0 0
GS Connect S&P GSCI Enh Commodity TR ETN SP ENHCMD37ETN 38144L852 248 10,796 SH   SOLE   248 0 0
iShares S&P SmallCap 600 Growth Index ETF S&P SML 600 GWT 464287887 250 1,369 SH   SOLE   250 0 0
ProShares Ultra S&P ETF PSHS ULT S&P 500 74347R107 252 2,000 SH   SOLE   252 0 0
Alibaba Group Holding Limited SPONSORED 01609W102 253 1,493 SH   SOLE   253 0 0
Vanguard Emerging Markets Stock ETF FTSE EMR MKT ETF 922042858 257 6,049 SH   SOLE   257 0 0
ALPS Equal Sector Weight ETF EQUAL SEC ETF 00162Q205 260 3,500 SH   SOLE   260 0 0
Celgene Corp COM 151020104 264 2,851 SH   SOLE   264 0 0
Comcast Corp New Cl A CL A 20030N101 268 6,328 SH   SOLE   268 0 0
Guggenheim BulletShrs 2021 Corp Bd ETF BULSHS 2021 CB 46138J700 268 12,657 SH   SOLE   268 0 0
Guggenheim BulletShrs 2022 Corp Bd ETF BULSHS 2022 CB 46138J882 271 12,685 SH   SOLE   271 0 0
M/I Homes, Inc. COM 55305B101 273 9,563 SH   SOLE   273 0 0
Guggenheim BulletShrs 2023 Corp Bd ETF BULSHS 2023 CB 46138J866 274 12,966 SH   SOLE   274 0 0
Schwab US Large Cap Value ETF US LCAP VA ETF 808524409 280 4,995 SH   SOLE   280 0 0
Installed Building Products, Inc COM 45780R101 282 4,770 SH   SOLE   282 0 0
MS India Investment Fund COM 61745C105 294 14,040 SH   SOLE   294 0 0
CVS Caremark Corporation COM 126650100 303 5,558 SH   SOLE   303 0 0
AbbVie Inc. COM 00287Y109 305 4,191 SH   SOLE   305 0 0
3M Company COM 88579Y101 309 1,785 SH   SOLE   309 0 0
First Financial Bancorp COM 320209109 312 12,879 SH   SOLE   312 0 0
SPDR Gold Shares ETF GOLD SHS 78463V107 313 2,350 SH   SOLE   313 0 0
Repligen Corporation COM 759916109 314 3,656 SH   SOLE   314 0 0
Universal Display Corporation COM 91347P105 316 1,682 SH   SOLE   316 0 0
Hewlett Packard Enterprise Comp COM 42824C109 319 21,311 SH   SOLE   319 0 0
Vanguard Small Cap Value ETF SM CP VAL ETF 922908611 319 2,447 SH   SOLE   319 0 0
Abbott Laboratories COM 002824100 325 3,865 SH   SOLE   325 0 0
N V R Corp COM 62944T105 337 100 SH   SOLE   337 0 0
Enterprise Products Partners MLP COM 293792107 337 11,690 SH   SOLE   337 0 0
General Electric COM 369604103 371 35,321 SH   SOLE   371 0 0
Altria Group Inc COM 02209S103 373 7,877 SH   SOLE   373 0 0
PayPal Holdings, Inc. COM 70450Y103 376 3,283 SH   SOLE   376 0 0
Cardinal Health Inc COM 14149Y108 383 8,128 SH   SOLE   383 0 0
Wesbanco Inc COM 950810101 397 10,308 SH   SOLE   397 0 0
iShares M-Star Small Growth Index ETF MRGSTR SM CP GR 464288604 404 1,985 SH   SOLE   404 0 0
Hewlett Packard Company COM 40434L105 409 19,689 SH   SOLE   409 0 0
iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Index ETF MSCI EMG MKT ETF 464287234 415 9,668 SH   SOLE   415 0 0
Kimberly-Clark COM 494368103 417 3,130 SH   SOLE   417 0 0
Davis Select US Equity ETF SELECT US EQTY 23908L207 422 18,010 SH   SOLE   422 0 0
Worthington Industries COM 981811102 426 10,592 SH   SOLE   426 0 0
Mondelez Intl Inc CL A 609207105 429 7,968 SH   SOLE   429 0 0
Public Storage Inc COM 74460D109 443 1,859 SH   SOLE   443 0 0
Macquarie Infrastructure Corp COM 55608B105 451 11,113 SH   SOLE   451 0 0
iShares Russell 2000 Growth Index ETF RUS 2000 GRW ETF 464287648 455 2,263 SH   SOLE   455 0 0
Unilever N V New F N Y SHS NEW 904784709 458 7,549 SH   SOLE   458 0 0
NiSource COM 65473P105 476 16,524 SH   SOLE   476 0 0
Raytheon Co New Cl A COM NEW 755111507 484 2,782 SH   SOLE   484 0 0
Communication Services Sel Sect SPDRETF COMMUNICATION 81369Y852 486 9,876 SH   SOLE   486 0 0
Okta Inc CL A 679295105 494 4,000 SH   SOLE   494 0 0
SPDR Consumer Staples Select Sec ETF SBI CONS STPLS 81369Y308 497 8,557 SH   SOLE   497 0 0
Mastercard Inc CL A 57636Q104 500 1,892 SH   SOLE   500 0 0
Xilinx Inc COM 983919101 511 4,330 SH   SOLE   511 0 0
United Technologies Corp COM 913017109 519 3,989 SH   SOLE   519 0 0
Citigroup Inc COM NEW 172967424 522 7,455 SH   SOLE   522 0 0
Bank of America Corp COM 060505104 528 18,223 SH   SOLE   528 0 0
DTE Energy Co COM 233331107 531 4,153 SH   SOLE   531 0 0
Deutsche X-trackers MSCI EAFE Hedged Eq XTRACK MSCI EAFE 233051200 544 17,216 SH   SOLE   544 0 0
Illumina Inc COM 452327109 571 1,550 SH   SOLE   571 0 0
SPDR Financial Select Sec ETF SBI INT-FINL 81369Y605 576 20,885 SH   SOLE   576 0 0
SPDR Industrial Select Sec ETF SBI INT-INDS 81369Y704 592 7,652 SH   SOLE   592 0 0
Diageo Plc New F 1 ADR Reps 4 Ord SPON ADR NEW 25243Q205 595 3,453 SH   SOLE   595 0 0
Ameritrade Hldg Cp Cl A COM 87236Y108 597 11,950 SH   SOLE   597 0 0
Facebook Inc Class A CL A 30303M102 600 3,108 SH   SOLE   600 0 0
Boeing Co COM 097023105 610 1,675 SH   SOLE   610 0 0
United Healthcare Corp COM 91324P102 623 2,552 SH   SOLE   623 0 0
Charles Schwab Corp COM 808513105 627 15,613 SH   SOLE   627 0 0
SPDR Health Care Select Sec ETF SBI HEALTHCARE 81369Y209 639 6,902 SH   SOLE   639 0 0
iShares MSCI All Country World Mini Vol ETF MIN VOL GBL ETF 464286525 650 7,055 SH   SOLE   650 0 0
SPDR Consumer Disc Select Sec ETF SBI CONS DISCR 81369Y407 688 5,774 SH   SOLE   688 0 0
Axon Enterprise, Inc. COM 05464C101 693 10,800 SH   SOLE   693 0 0
CDW Corporation COM 12514G108 696 6,274 SH   SOLE   696 0 0
Illinois Tool Works Inc COM 452308109 720 4,772 SH   SOLE   720 0 0
Darden Restaurants COM 237194105 721 5,927 SH   SOLE   721 0 0
Alphabet Inc. Cl A CAP STK CL A 02079K305 730 674 SH   SOLE   730 0 0
Air Products & Chemicals Inc COM 009158AR7 732 3,233 SH   SOLE   732 0 0
Omnicom Group Inc COM 681919106 733 8,946 SH   SOLE   733 0 0
Occidental Petroleum COM 674599105 743 14,771 SH   SOLE   743 0 0
iPath Bloomberg Commodity Index Total Return ETN DJUBS CMDT ETN36 06738C778 744 33,458 SH   SOLE   744 0 0
Exxon Mobil Corporation COM 30231G102 751 9,794 SH   SOLE   751 0 0
iShares High Dividend Equity ETF CORE HIGH DV ETF 46429B663 756 8,000 SH   SOLE   756 0 0
Dominion Resources Va COM 25746U109 756 9,782 SH   SOLE   756 0 0
Square Inc CL A 852234103 762 10,501 SH   SOLE   762 0 0
BlackRock Inc COM 09247X101 762 1,624 SH   SOLE   762 0 0
Costco Whsl Corp New COM 22160K105 764 2,891 SH   SOLE   764 0 0
Cavco Industries, Inc. COM 149568107 764 4,851 SH   SOLE   764 0 0
Cummins Inc COM 231021106 778 4,539 SH   SOLE   778 0 0
TJX Companies Inc. COM 872540109 788 14,905 SH   SOLE   788 0 0
Lockheed Martin Corp COM 539830109 798 2,194 SH   SOLE   798 0 0
Intuit Inc COM 461202103 804 3,078 SH   SOLE   804 0 0
iShares Barclays TIPS Bond ETF TIPS BD ETF 464287176 808 6,997 SH   SOLE   808 0 0
Baxter International COM 071813BF5 813 9,926 SH   SOLE   813 0 0
Schwab US Aggregate Bond ETF US AGGREGATE B 808524839 813 15,345 SH   SOLE   813 0 0
Texas Instruments Inc COM 882508104 815 7,101 SH   SOLE   815 0 0
American Tower Corp Cl A COM 03027X100 819 4,004 SH   SOLE   819 0 0
Phillips 66 Common Stock COM 718546104 824 8,806 SH   SOLE   824 0 0
First Defiance Financial COM 32006W106 864 30,254 SH   SOLE   864 0 0
iShares Russell 1000 Growth Index ETF RUS 1000 GRW ETF 464287614 962 6,112 SH   SOLE   962 0 0
Mettler-Toledo International Inc COM 592688105 963 1,147 SH   SOLE   963 0 0
Oracle Sys Corp COM 68389X105 967 16,968 SH   SOLE   967 0 0
Gilead Science COM 375558103 970 14,361 SH   SOLE   970 0 0
First Merchants Corp COM 320817109 975 25,726 SH   SOLE   975 0 0
PowerShares FTSE RAFI US 1000 ETF FTSE RAFI 1000 46137V613 994 8,520 SH   SOLE   994 0 0
Home Depot Inc COM 437076102 997 4,793 SH   SOLE   997 0 0
International Business Machines COM 459200101 1,000 7,250 SH   SOLE   1,000 0 0
SPDR Technology Select Sec ETF TECHNOLOGY 81369Y803 1,033 13,238 SH   SOLE   1,033 0 0
HCA Inc COM 40412C101 1,042 7,710 SH   SOLE   1,042 0 0
Amgen Inc COM 031162100 1,060 5,753 SH   SOLE   1,060 0 0
Visa Inc. COM CL A 92826C839 1,090 6,282 SH   SOLE   1,090 0 0
iShares Core MSCI Emerging Mkt ETF CORE MSCI EMKT 46434G103 1,100 21,384 SH   SOLE   1,100 0 0
PepsiCo Inc COM 713448108 1,103 8,414 SH   SOLE   1,103 0 0
Guggenheim S&P 500 Pure Growth ETF S&P500 PUR GWT 46137V266 1,121 9,386 SH   SOLE   1,121 0 0
Wells Fargo & Co New COM 949746101 1,122 23,704 SH   SOLE   1,122 0 0
Sarepta Therapeutics COM 803607100 1,124 7,400 SH   SOLE   1,124 0 0
Ohio Valley Banc COM 677719106 1,209 31,350 SH   SOLE   1,209 0 0