XML 36 R46.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.19.3
Note 3 - Rate and Regulatory Matters (Details Textual)
1 Months Ended 2 Months Ended 3 Months Ended 9 Months Ended 12 Months Ended
Nov. 01, 2019
Aug. 30, 2019
USD ($)
Jun. 28, 2019
USD ($)
Jun. 24, 2019
USD ($)
Jun. 16, 2019
USD ($)
Jun. 11, 2019
USD ($)
May 30, 2019
USD ($)
Apr. 01, 2019
USD ($)
Dec. 01, 2018
Oct. 16, 2018
Sep. 26, 2018
USD ($)
Apr. 20, 2018
USD ($)
Mar. 23, 2018
USD ($)
Mar. 22, 2018
USD ($)
Nov. 16, 2016
USD ($)
Sep. 28, 2016
May 25, 2016
Feb. 12, 2015
Nov. 06, 2014
Nov. 12, 2013
Jun. 30, 2016
Dec. 22, 2015
Sep. 30, 2019
USD ($)
Mar. 31, 2019
USD ($)
Sep. 30, 2019
USD ($)
Dec. 31, 2018
USD ($)
Dec. 31, 2017
Oct. 24, 2019
USD ($)
Mar. 01, 2018
USD ($)
Dec. 20, 2017
USD ($)
Nov. 02, 2017
USD ($)
May 01, 2017
Dec. 31, 2016
USD ($)
Effective Income Tax Rate Reconciliation, at Federal Statutory Income Tax Rate, Percent                                                   21.00% 35.00%            
Regulatory Liabilities, Total                                             $ 245,092,000   $ 245,092,000 $ 227,207,000              
Minnesota1 [Member]                                                                  
Effect of Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, Refund to Customers                                             11,500,000                    
NORTH DAKOTA                                                                  
Accrued Refund Liabilities Resulting from Tax Rate Reduction                                               $ 800,000                  
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission [Member]                                                                  
Accrued Refund Liabilities Resulting from Tax Rate Reduction                                             200,000   200,000                
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | Federal Energy Regulatory Commission [Member]                                                                  
Current Return on Equity Used in Transmission Rates                               10.32%       12.38%   10.32%                      
Proposed Reduced Return on Equity Used in Transmission Rates                                   8.67%   9.15% 9.70%                        
Additional Incentive Basis Point                                     0.50%                            
Expected Percentage of Return on Equity                   10.41%           10.82%                                  
Regulatory Liabilities, Total                                             1,600,000   1,600,000               $ 2,700,000
Contract with Customer, Refund Liability, Total                                             1,600,000   1,600,000                
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | Federal Energy Regulatory Commission [Member] | Maximum [Member]                                                                  
Proposed Reduced Return on Equity Used in Transmission Rates                   13.08%                                              
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | Minnesota Public Utilities Commission [Member] | The 2016 General Rate Case [Member]                                                                  
Percentage of Allowed Rate of Return on Rate Base                                                               7.5056%  
Percentage of Allowed Rate of Return on Equity                                                               9.41%  
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | Minnesota Public Utilities Commission [Member] | Conservation Improvement Program [Member]                                                                  
Utility Incentive Percentage in Next Rolling Twelve Months                                 13.50%                                
Utility Incentive Percentage in Next Rolling Year Two                                 12.00%                                
Utility Incentive Percentage in Next Rolling Year Three                                 10.00%                                
Assumed Savings of Utility                                 1.70%                                
Financial Incentive, Maximum Percentage of Spending, Year One                                 40.00%                                
Financial Incentive, Maximum Percentage of Spending, Year Two                                 35.00%                                
Financial Incentive, Maximum Percentage of Spending, Year Three                                 30.00%                                
Expected Rate of Financial Incentive Reduction                                 50.00%                                
Financial Incentives Recognized During Period               $ 3,000,000.0                                                  
Financial Incentive Offered to MPUC       $ 4,000,000.0                                                          
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | Minnesota Public Utilities Commission [Member] | Conservation Improvement Program [Member] | Subsequent Event [Member]                                                                  
Financial Incentive Request Approved                                                       $ 3,000,000.0          
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | Minnesota1 [Member]                                                                  
Environmental Cost Recovery Rider Rate                 0.00%                                                
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | Minnesota1 [Member] | Transmission Cost Recovery Rider [Member]                                                                  
Loss Contingency, Estimate of Possible Loss                                             2,600,000   2,600,000                
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | North Dakota Public Service Commission [Member] | The 2010 General Rate Case [Member]                                                                  
Percentage of Allowed Rate of Return on Rate Base                                                             7.97%    
Percentage of Allowed Rate of Return on Equity                                                             10.30%    
General Rate Revenue Increase Requested                                                           $ 12,800,000 $ 13,100,000    
Percentage of Increase in Base Rate Revenue Requested                                                             8.72%    
Public Utilities, Interim Rate Requirement, Decrease in Amount                                                         $ 4,500,000        
Public Utilities, Interim Rate Requirement, Amount                                                         $ 8,300,000        
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | North Dakota Public Service Commission [Member] | The 2017 General Rate Case [Member]                                                                  
Percentage of Allowed Rate of Return on Equity                         10.30%                                        
Public Utilities, Requested Rate Increase (Decrease), Amount                     $ 4,600,000   $ 7,100,000 $ 13,100,000                                      
Public Utilities, Requested Rate Increase (Decrease), Percentage                     3.10%   4.80%                                        
General Rate Revenue Increase Requested, Decrease                         $ 6,000,000.0                                        
General Rate Revenue Increase Requested, Decrease, Amount Related to Tax Reform                         4,800,000                                        
General Rate Revenue Increase Requested, Decrease, Amount Related to Updates Other Than Tax Reform                         $ 1,200,000                                        
Percentage of Requested Allowed Rate of Return on Equity                     9.77%                                            
Equity to Total Capitalization Ratio Basis for Return on Equity                     52.50%                                            
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | North Dakota 1 [Member] | Subsequent Event [Member]                                                                  
Environmental Cost Recovery Rider Rate 0.00%                                                                
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | North Dakota 1 [Member] | Transmission Cost Recovery Rider [Member] | The 2019 Annual Update [Member]                                                                  
Annual Revenue Requesting Recovery   $ 5,700,000                                                              
Number of New Projects Included in Request for Recovery   7                                                              
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | South Dakota Public Utilities Commission [Member] | The 2018 General Rate Case [Member]                                                                  
Percentage of Allowed Rate of Return on Equity             8.75%                                                    
Public Utilities, Requested Rate Increase (Decrease), Amount                       $ 3,300,000                                          
Increase in Annual Non-fuel Rates Requested, Step One, Percentage                       10.10%                                          
Increase in Annual Non-fuel Rates Requested, Step Two, Percentage                       1.70%                                          
Contract with Customer, Liability, Revenue Recognized             $ 2,200,000                                 $ 1,000,000.0                  
Understated Amount of OTP's Electric Transmission Plant in Service     $ 44,000,000                                                            
Annual Revenue Requirement Shortfall Resulted from Understatement     341,000                                                            
Increase in Non-fuel Annual Revenue Resulted from Increased in General Rate Case     $ 2,600,000                                                            
Increase in Non-fuel Annual Revenue Resulted from Increased in General Rate Case, Percentage     7.70%                                                            
Non-fuel Annual Revenue Increased, Perecenage of Adjusted Requsted Annual Revenue     69.00%                                                            
Adjusted Requested Annual Revenue Increased, Amount     $ 3,700,000                                                            
Adjusted Requested Annual Revenue Increased, Percentage     11.10%                                                            
Authorized Return of Equity     8.75%                                                            
Percentage of Excess Weather-normalized Revenue, Refund to Customer     50.00%                                                            
Maximum ROE, Input for Refund to Customer     9.50%                                                            
Percentage of Any Earnings Above Maximum ROE     100.00%                                                            
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | Big Stone South - Ellendale MVP [Member] | Federal Energy Regulatory Commission [Member]                                                                  
Current Project Cost                                                 $ 106,000,000                
Expanded Capacity of Projects                                                 345                
Extended Distance of Transmission Line                                                 162                
Percentage of Assets of Project                                                 100.00%                
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | Astoria Station Project [Member]                                                                  
Expanded Capacity of Projects (MW)                                                 245                
Current Project Capitalized Cost                                                 $ 36,800,000                
Expected Project Cost                                             158,000,000   158,000,000                
Otter Tail Power Company [Member] | Merricourt Project [Member] | EDF [Member]                                                                  
Expanded Capacity of Projects (MW)                             150                                    
Expected Project Cost                                             $ 258,000,000   258,000,000                
Asset Purchase Agreement, Purchase Price         $ 37,700,000 $ 37,700,000                 $ 34,700,000                                    
Turnkey Engineering, Procurement and Construction Services Agreement, Costs                             $ 200,500,000                                    
Current Project Cost                                                 $ 54,800,000