EX-99.1 3 dex991.htm UNAUDITED CONDENSED COMBINED PRO FORMA STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS Unaudited condensed combined pro forma statements of operations

Exhibit 99.1

UNAUDITED CONDENSED COMBINED PRO FORMA STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS

VeraSun Energy Corporation and its subsidiaries are collectively referred to as “VeraSun,” the “Company,” “we,” “us” and “our”. The unaudited condensed combined pro forma statements of operations for the year ended December 31, 2007, and the six months ended June 30, 2008, are presented to show how VeraSun might have looked had the acquisition of US BioEnergy Corporation (“US BioEnergy”) occurred on January 1, 2007. On August 17, 2007, VeraSun acquired ASA OpCo Holdings, LLC from ASAlliances Biofuels, LLC (“ASAB”). The unaudited condensed consolidated pro forma statement of operations for VeraSun for the year ended December 31, 2007, combines information from the historical consolidated statement of operations of VeraSun for the year ended December 31, 2007, with the unaudited historical statement of operations of ASAB for the period from January 1, 2007, through August 17, 2007, as if the acquisition had occurred on January 1, 2007. The notes to the unaudited condensed combined pro forma statements of operations describe certain pro forma adjustments to give effect to the acquisition, had it been consummated on the assumed date.

The unaudited condensed combined pro forma statement of operations for the year ended December 31, 2007, combines information from the unaudited condensed consolidated pro forma statement of operations of VeraSun and historical consolidated statement of operations of US BioEnergy for the year ended December 31, 2007. The unaudited condensed combined pro forma statement of operations for the six months ended June 30, 2008, combines information from the historical unaudited condensed consolidated statement of income of VeraSun for the six months ended June 30, 2008 and historical unaudited condensed consolidated statement of earnings of US BioEnergy for the three months ended March 31, 2008.

The unaudited condensed combined pro forma statements of operations were prepared using the purchase method of accounting. The allocation of the purchase price of US BioEnergy as reflected in these condensed combined pro forma statements of operations has been based on the preliminary estimate of the fair values of US BioEnergy’s tangible and intangible assets acquired and liabilities assumed as of April 1, 2008, the completion date of the acquisition.

These pro forma statements of operations are not necessarily indicative of the results of operations that would have occurred had the acquisitions been consummated on the assumed dates. Additionally, future results may vary significantly from the results reflected in the pro forma statements of operations due to changes in future transactions and other factors. These pro forma statements of operations have been derived from, and should be read in conjunction with, our audited consolidated financial statements and the related notes for the year ended December 31, 2007, incorporated by reference to our 2007 Form 10-K, our unaudited condensed consolidated financial statements and the related notes for the six months ended June 30, 2008, included in our second quarter Form 10-Q, the audited consolidated financial statements and the related notes for the year ended December 31, 2007, of US BioEnergy, filed as Exhibit 99.1 to amendment No. 1 to Form 8-K filed on April 11, 2008, which are incorporated by reference into this Form 8-K, and the unaudited condensed consolidated financial statements and the related notes for the three months ended March 31, 2008, of US BioEnergy, filed as Exhibit 99.2 to this Form 8-K.


COMBINED COMPANY

UNAUDITED CONDENSED COMBINED PRO FORMA

STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS

For the Year Ended December 31, 2007

 

     Pro Forma
VeraSun
    Historical
US BioEnergy
    Adjustments     Pro Forma
Combined
 
     (In thousands, except per share data)  

Net sales

   $ 848,281     $ 588,614     $ 19,800 (a)   $ 1,484,554  
         11,600 (b)  
         (23,023) (c)  
         39,282 (d)  

Cost of goods sold

     753,087       517,665       (23,023) (c)     1,330,811  
         39,282 (d)  
         (3,244) (e)  
         32,769 (f)  
         12,428 (g)  
         (4,356) (h)  
         3,732 (i)  
         2,471 (o)  
                                

Gross profit

     95,194       70,949       (12,400 )     153,743  
                                

Startup expenses

     4,961       —         —         4,961  

Selling, general and administrative expenses

     50,559       41,130       (914) (j)     90,775  

Loss on impairment of assets

     —         2,471       (2,471) (o)     —    
                                

Operating income

     39,674       27,348       (9,015 )     58,007  
                                

Other income (expense):

        

Interest expense

     (33,376 )     (8,609 )     (9,762) (k)     (51,747 )

Interest income

     11,711       6,587       —         18,298  

Equity in net income of unconsolidated subsidiary

     —         2,827       (2,827) (l)     —    

Other income (expense)

     (241 )     880       —         639  
                                
     (21,906 )     1,685       (12,589 )     (32,810 )
                                

Income before income taxes and minority interest

     17,768       29,033       (21,604 )     25,197  

Income tax provision

     4,975       11,706       (7,561 )(m)     9,120  
                                

Income before minority interest

     12,793       17,327       (14,043 )     16,077  

Minority interest in net loss of subsidiary, net of income taxes

     —         79       —         79  
                                

Net income

   $ 12,793     $ 17,406     $ (14,043 )   $ 16,156  
                                

Per share data:

        

Income per common share - basic

   $ 0.14         $ 0.10  

Basic weighted average number of common shares

     94,160         64,789 (n)     158,949  

Income per common share - diluted

   $ 0.13         $ 0.10  

Diluted weighted average number of common and common equivalent shares

     97,737         65,745 (n)     163,482  

See notes to unaudited condensed combined pro forma statements of operations.


VERASUN ENERGY CORPORATION

UNAUDITED CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED PRO FORMA

STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS

For the Year Ended December 31, 2007

 

     Historical           Pro Forma  
     VeraSun     ASAB     Adjustments     VeraSun  
     (In thousands, except per share data)  

Net sales

   $ 848,281     $ —       $ —       $ 848,281  

Cost of goods sold

     752,382       —         705 (a)     753,087  
                                

Gross profit

     95,899       —         (705 )     95,194  

Start-up expenses

     4,961       —         —         4,961  

Selling, general and administrative expenses

     37,519       38,635       (25,595) (b)     50,559  
                                

Operating income (loss)

     53,419       (38,635 )     24,890       39,674  

Other income (expense):

        

Interest expense

     (33,376 )     (3,338 )     3,338 (b)     (33,376 )

Interest income

     16,855       273       (5,417) (c)     11,711  

Other income (expense):

     57       (298 )     —         (241 )
                                

Income (loss) before income taxes

     36,955       (41,998 )     22,811       17,768  

Income tax provision

     10,348       —         (5,373) (d)     4,975  
                                

Net income (loss)

   $ 26,607     $ (41,998 )   $ 28,184     $ 12,793  
                                

Per share data:

        

Income per common share - basic

   $ 0.32         $ 0.14  

Basic weighted average number of common shares

     82,659         11,501 (e)     94,160  

Income per common share - diluted

   $ 0.31         $ 0.13  

Diluted weighted average number of common and common equivalent shares

     86,236         11,501 (e)     97,737  

See notes to unaudited condensed combined pro forma statements of operations.


COMBINED COMPANY

UNAUDITED CONDENSED COMBINED PRO FORMA

STATEMENT OF OPERATIONS

For the Six Months Ended June 30, 2008

 

     Historical           Pro Forma  
     VeraSun     US BioEnergy     Adjustments     Combined  
     (In thousands, except per share data)  

Net sales

   $ 1,531,642     $ 197,155     $ 32 (c)   $ 1,740,527  
         11,698 (d)  

Cost of goods sold

     1,424,570       171,446       32 (c)     1,609,386  
         11,698 (d)  
         (811) (e)  
         2,685 (f)  
         (1,167) (h)  
         933 (i)  
                                

Gross profit

     107,072       25,709       (1,640 )     131,141  
                                

Startup expenses

     6,702       —         —         6,702  

Restructuring charge

     2,004       —         —         2,004  

Selling, general and administrative expenses

     27,682       9,524       (229) (j)     36,977  
                                

Total selling, general and administrative expenses:

     36,388       9,524       (229 )     45,683  

Operating income

     70,684       16,185       (1,411 )     85,458  
                                

Other income (expense):

        

Interest expense

     (26,314 )     (405 )     —   (k)     (26,719 )

Interest income

     1,548       763       —         2,311  

Equity in net income of unconsolidated subsidiary

     —         618       (618) (l)     —    

Other income (expense)

     714       (6,202 )     —         (5,488 )
                                
     (24,052 )     (5,226 )     (618 )     (29,896 )
                                

Income before income taxes and minority interest

     46,632       10,959       (2,029 )     55,562  

Income tax provision

     15,175       6,204       (761) (m)     20,618  
                                

Income before minority interest

     31,457       4,755       (1,268 )     34,944  

Minority interest in net loss of subsidiary

     6       7       —         13  
                                

Net income

   $ 31,463     $ 4,762     $ (1,268 )   $ 34,957  
                                

Per share data:

        

Income per common share - basic

   $ 0.25         $ 0.22  

Basic weighted average number of common shares

     124,836         32,395 (n)     157,231  

Income per common share - diluted

   $ 0.25         $ 0.22  

Diluted weighted average number of common and common equivalent shares

     127,350         32,873 (n)     160,223  

See notes to unaudited condensed combined pro forma statements of operations.


VERASUN ENERGY CORPORATION

NOTES TO UNAUDITED CONDENSED COMBINED

PRO FORMA STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS

Purchase Price

These unaudited condensed combined pro forma statements of operations reflect a preliminary allocation of the purchase price as if the acquisition had been completed on January 1, 2007. The preliminary allocations are subject to change based on finalization of the fair values of the tangible and intangible assets acquired and liabilities assumed. The relevant tangible assets consist mainly of US BioEnergy’s property, plant and equipment. Identifiable intangible assets include favorable and unfavorable contracts related to US BioEnergy’s business such as ethanol sales contracts, corn purchase contracts, customer relationships and lease agreements. The purchase price of $756.9 million has been calculated as follows:

 

Number of shares of US BioEnergy common stock outstanding at the closing date of the merger (in thousands)

     79,986   

Exchange ratio

     0.81   
         

Shares of VeraSun issued (in thousands)

     64,789   

Multiplied by VeraSun’s weighted average stock price for the period two business days before and three business days after the November 29, 2007 announcement of acquisition

   $ 11.36    $ 736,001  

Fair value of VeraSun’s stock options issued in exchange for US BioEnergy’s stock options outstanding as of the close date of the acquisition (1)

        14,664  

Other, including VeraSun’s transaction (registering and issuing) costs

        7,296  

Less: Cost of registering equity securities

        (1,063 )
           

Purchase price

      $ 756,898  
           

The preliminary allocation of the purchase price based on the estimated fair values of US BioEnergy’s assets and liabilities assumed in the acquisition are as follows (in thousands):

 

Assets acquired:

  

Cash

   $ 51,339

Other current assets

     142,917

Property, plant and equipment

     1,069,350

Intangible assets

     55,694

Goodwill (2)

     101,773

Other non-current assets

     6,571
      

Total assets acquired

     1,427,644
      

Liabilities assumed:

  

Current liabilities, excluding current maturities on long-term debt

     85,055

Long – term debt

     460,979

Deferred tax liability

     101,411

Other long – term liabilities

     19,387

Minority interest in consolidated subsidiaries

     3,914
      

Total liabilities assumed

     670,746
      

Net assets acquired

   $ 756,898
      

 

(1) The fair value of VeraSun’s options issued in exchange for US BioEnergy’s stock options was determined using the Black-Scholes option pricing model with the following assumptions: dividend yield of 0.0%; expected volatility of 65%; risk-free rate of 3.0%; and an expected life of 6.9 years.


VERASUN ENERGY CORPORATION

NOTES TO UNAUDITED CONDENSED COMBINED

PRO FORMA STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS

 

(2) The excess of purchase price over the estimated fair value of identifiable net assets acquired has been classified as goodwill. The major factors that contribute to goodwill include the expected future profitability of US BioEnergy, the market position of US BioEnergy, its existing facilities and plants under construction given their geographic locations, and its successful track record of plant completions and start-ups.

In the ASA Acquisition (signed on July 22, 2007), the ASAB shareholders received consideration consisting of approximately 13.8 million shares of VeraSun stock (valued at the time at $194.3 million) and $250 million of cash. ASAB’s business consisted of three facilities in Linden, Indiana, Albion, Nebraska, and Bloomingburg, Ohio in different stages of completion with an estimated production capacity of approximately 330 MMGY, of which 110 MMGY came online after the signing of the transaction, but before it closed. The allocation of this purchase price resulted in goodwill of $158.9 million, representing the excess of purchase price over the estimated fair value of identifiable net assets. The major factors that contributed to goodwill included the expected future profitability of ASAB’s facilities which reflected the spreads between commodities prices for corn and ethanol prevailing at the time, the comparative ease of integrating a less mature business without management functions (which were not acquired), the geographic locations of ASAB’s facilities, and the significant contribution to VeraSun’s production capacity compared to pre-acquisition levels, which helped establish VeraSun’s strategic position as a consolidator in a highly fractured industry.

The smaller amount of goodwill recorded in the acquisition of US BioEnergy reflects developments in the industry in the interim and differences in the transaction structures. In particular, over the course of 2007, the spread between corn and ethanol prices narrowed significantly, which contributed to a fall in the stock prices of VeraSun and US BioEnergy as well as other ethanol companies. The closing prices of VeraSun’s and US BioEnergy’s stock as of July 20, 2007 (the last trading day before the signing of the ASA Acquisition) and November 28, 2007 (the last trading day before the signing of acquisition agreement with US BioEnergy) fell from $13.72 and $10.59 to $10.64 and $8.03, respectively. Structurally, the transactions differ in that the transaction with US BioEnergy involves a merger of equals with consideration consisting entirely of VeraSun stock (other than cash to be paid in lieu of fractional shares). As a result, US BioEnergy shareholders can continue to participate in the development of the combined company to a significantly larger extent than the shareholders of ASAB who only received a portion of their consideration in stock.

Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 142, “Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets” requires that goodwill be tested for impairment at the reporting unit level on an annual basis and between annual tests if an event occurs or circumstances change that would more likely than not reduce the fair value of the reporting unit below its carrying value. The Company performed an interim impairment test of its goodwill, identifiable intangible assets and all its long-lived assets as of April 1, 2008, due to events and changes in circumstances that indicated an impairment might have occurred. The major factor deemed by management to have constituted an impairment triggering event was the sustained decrease in the Company stock price relative to the book value of the Company coupled with a significant issuance of common stock, pursuant to the acquisition of US BioEnergy.

The Company estimated the fair value of the enterprise utilizing several fair value measurement techniques, including two market estimates and one income estimate, and using relevant data available through and as of April 1, 2008. Under the market approaches, the fair value of the enterprise was estimated based upon the fair value of invested capital for VeraSun, as well as a separate comparison to revenue and earnings before interest, taxes, deprecation, and amortization, “EBITDA,” multiples for similar publicly traded companies in the renewable energy industry. The fair value estimates using both market approaches included a control premium similar to those observed for historical renewable energy company market transactions. Under the income approach, the fair value of the enterprise was estimated based upon the present value of estimated future cash flows for VeraSun. The income approach is dependent on a number of critical management assumptions including estimates of ethanol and distiller sales price, corn and natural gas cost, appropriate discount rates and other relevant assumptions.

Taking into consideration a weight of the two market estimates and the income estimate the indicated fair value of the enterprise was more than its carrying value, and therefore, the Company was not required to perform step two of the SFAS 142 goodwill impairment testing methodology.

Due to extreme corn and crude oil price volatility, tight credit markets, the volatility of the Company’s stock price and the resulting decline in its market capitalization and, the uncertain economic environment, as well as other uncertainties, the Company can provide no assurance that a material impairment charge to goodwill, intangible assets and all long lived assets will not occur in a future period. The Company will continue to monitor circumstances and events in future periods to determine whether additional interim asset impairment testing is warranted.


VERASUN ENERGY CORPORATION

NOTES TO UNAUDITED CONDENSED COMBINED

PRO FORMA STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS

Pro Forma Statements of Operations adjustments related to the Combined Company US Bio Energy acquisition

 

(a) Represents an adjustment to revenue for unfavorable ethanol sales contracts acquired, upon delivery of the contracted ethanol.

 

(b) Represents an adjustment to revenue for unfavorable distillers sales contracts acquired, upon delivery of the contracted distillers grains.

 

(c) Represents an income statement reclassification of US BioEnergy’s mark-to-market income (loss) on ethanol hedges to be consistent with VeraSun’s presentation policies.

 

(d) Represents an income statement reclassification to record US BioEnergy’s freight costs as cost of goods sold versus netting with net sales to be consistent with VeraSun’s presentation policies.

 

(e) Reflects the reduction in depreciation expense associated with recording US BioEnergy’s property and equipment at its preliminary estimated fair value based upon a 19 year average economic life.

 

(f) Represents an adjustment to cost of goods sold for favorable corn purchase contracts acquired.

 

(g) Represents an adjustment to cost of goods sold for the fair value adjustment of corn inventories acquired.

 

(h) Reflects an adjustment to cost of goods sold for unfavorable rail car contracts.

 

(i) Reflects the amortization related to the finite-lived identifiable intangible assets related to the US BioEnergy acquisition.

 

(j) Reflects the elimination of the CEO salary of US BioEnergy. The CEO of US BioEnergy did not transition to VeraSun but became a non-executive director of VeraSun upon completion of the transaction. It is not anticipated that any additional employees will be hired to carry out any of the duties previously performed by US BioEnergy’s CEO.

 

(k) Represents amortized debt discount on the fair value adjustment to debt for 2007. No adjustment to interest expense is required for 2008 for the fair value adjustment to debt as the increased interest cost increases the amount of capitalized interest on construction in progress.

 

(l) Reflects the elimination of US BioEnergy’s share of net income in Provista Renewable Fuels Marketing, LLC (“Provista”). On March 31, 2008, US BioEnergy and CHS Inc. (“CHS”) executed a Purchase Agreement, whereby US BioEnergy sold all of its fifty-percent membership interest in Provista to CHS, effective on April 1, 2008.

 

(m) Reflects the tax effect of the pro forma adjustments based on the estimated effective rate of 37.5% for 2008 and 35% for 2007.

 

(n) Reflects the issuance of 64,789,000 shares of common stock as consideration paid for US BioEnergy and the dilutive effect of stock options.

 

(o) Reflects the reclassification of loss on impairment of an asset to cost of goods sold, to be consistent with VeraSun’s presentation policy.


VERASUN ENERGY CORPORATION

NOTES TO UNAUDITED CONDENSED COMBINED

PRO FORMA STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS

Pro Forma Statements of Operations adjustments for VeraSun Energy Corporation related to ASA acquisition

 

(a) Reflects the amortization related to the finite-lived identifiable intangible assets related to the ASA acquisition.

 

(b) Reflects the elimination of non-recurring ASAB level expenses directly related to the acquisition. On August 17, 2007, VeraSun purchased all of the equity interests in ASA Holdings from ASAB. ASA Holdings owns three biorefineries, which were substantially all of the key operating assets of ASAB. On August 17, 2007, employees at the ASAB level were terminated with the exception of six employees who were temporarily retained to address transitional issues and terminated employment on February 17, 2008. All of the functions provided by ASAB were absorbed by VeraSun’s existing organization without adding additional employees. The pro forma adjustments for the year ended December 31, 2007 include $11.3 million of severance costs, $7.4 million of transactional costs (primarily investment banking fees), and $6.9 million of expense related to the write-off of deferred financing fees associated with the ASAB debt (not assumed). Interest expense was eliminated entirely as it related to ASAB debt that was not assumed. Interest expense related to ASA Holdings’ facilities under construction was capitalized as part of construction costs.

 

(c) Reflects the reduction of interest income related to cash consideration for the purchase of ASA Holdings. Interest income is calculated at 4% per annum.

 

(d) Reflects the income tax effect of the results of operations of the acquired entity and the pro forma adjustments at an estimated effective tax rate of 28.0% for 2007.

 

(e) Reflects the issuance of 13,801,284 shares of common stock as part of the consideration paid for ASA Holdings.