ped_corresp
June 4,
2021
John
Cannarella
Division
of Corporation Finance
Office
of Energy &
Transportation
United
States Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F
Street, N.E.
Washington,
D.C. 20549-3561
Form
10-K for the Fiscal Year ended December 31, 2020
Filed
March 23, 2021
File
No. 001-35922
Ladies
and Gentlemen:
Set
forth below are the responses of PEDEVCO CORP. (the
“Company,”
“PEDEVCO,”
“we,”
“us” or
“our”), to
comments received from the staff of the division of Corporation
Finance (the “Staff”) of the
Securities and Exchange Commission (the “Commission”)
by letter dated May 20, 2021, with respect to the Company’s
Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31,
2020 (the “Form
10-K”).
For
your convenience, each response is prefaced by the exact text of
the Staff’s corresponding comment in bold text. All
references to page numbers and captions correspond to the Form 10-K
unless otherwise specified.
Financial Statements
Note 6 - Oil and Gas Properties, page 84
1.
We note that you filed a current report on February 1, 2021 to
explain that you expected to recognize an impairment charge in the
fourth quarter of 2020, ranging from $73.6 million to $85.9
million, based on 60% to 70% of the estimated discounted value of
your reserves as of the end of the preceding fiscal year, which you
indicated was $122.7 million. However, you have reported an
impairment charge of just $19.3 million for 2020. Tell us how your
view of the need for impairment was established on the date of
issuing the press release mentioned above, and how your view
evolved from that point until filing your report on March 23, 2021.
Please describe all of the key underlying assumptions, and explain
how they changed during this period.
RESPONSE:
We acknowledge the Staff’s comment. When
providing the disclosure in the Current Report on Form 8-K filed on
February 1, 2021 (the “Form
8-K”), PEDEVCO was
primarily intending to convey and quantify an expected decrease in
PV-10, rather than the actual dollar amount of an impairment
charge.
In
the Form 8-K, PEDEVCO stated:
“Based on preliminary assessments applying
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) mandated pricing and
reserves methodologies, the Company believes that, due primarily to
the material decrease in oil and gas pricing in 2020, coupled with
the Company’s cessation of development in 2020 due to such
low pricing, the Company will be required to take a one-time oil
and gas asset impairment charge
in the range of 60% to 70% of the estimated discounted value of its
reserves (PV-10) as calculated the year prior as of December 31,
2019, which was $122.7 million.
. . . [T]he Company notes that it is not reducing the magnitude of
oil and gas reserves it holds – rather,
only the year-end value as
calculated in accordance with SEC-mandated pricing and reserves
methodologies…”
Accordingly,
PEDEVCO was primarily intending to convey that it would report a
PV-10 as of December 31, 2020 at approximately 60% to 70% of the
PV-10 of $122.7 million reported as of December 31, 2019, rather
than any particular dollar amount of an impairment
charge.
Ultimately,
PEDEVCO reported a PV-10 of $58.2 million, which is calculated as
approximately 47% of the PV-10 reported as of December 31, 2019,
and an impairment charge of $19.3 million. As stated in the Form
8-K, the Company noted that the estimate was preliminary and the
final amounts would be reported in its Form 10-K.
The difference between the preliminary estimate
and the final reduction in PV-10 (as well as the difference in the
actual amount of the impairment charge) was as a result of
variables for which PEDEVCO was unable to determine with reasonable
certainty until the final reserve report was completed. These
variables included undiscounted cash flows, PV-10 discounted cash
flows, and depreciation, depletion, and amortization
(“DD&A”),
and the corresponding carrying amount of oil and gas properties.
Once the final reserve report was provided, PEDEVCO used the
reserve report to determine the DD&A amount for its oil and gas
properties at December 31, 2020. The calculated DD&A amount was
then applied as a reduction to the carrying value of
PEDEVCO’s oil and gas properties. The net carrying value was
then compared to the undiscounted cash flows value per the reserve
report to determine if an impairment expense was necessary. The
undiscounted net cash flows for our New Mexico properties exceeded
the carrying value of those assets; therefore, no impairment was
deemed necessary. However, the undiscounted net cash flows, per the
reserve report, for our Colorado properties were less than the
carrying value of those assets, and an impairment expense was
deemed necessary. The corresponding impairment charge was
calculated based on the PV-10 amount less the net carrying value of
the assets.
If
PEDEVCO makes a similar disclosure in the future, it will expand
its disclosure to include assumptions about underlying
variables.
2.
Please submit for review the development plans that you had adopted
for the proved reserves as of December 31, 2020, including the
development projections and details concerning the availability of
capital relative to your development plans, as provided to your
auditor and referenced in the report on page 75, as well as the
evidence demonstrating your financial backing and development
success, as provided to your third party engineer and referenced in
the report at Exhibit 99.1.
Please clarify as appropriate how you have established a reasonable
expectation that financing will be available to develop all of the
proved reserves that you booked in 2018 by 2023, as required under
Rule 4-10(a)(26) of Regulation S-X, considering the estimated
future development costs of $141 million reported on page 97,
budgeted capital expenditures for 2021 of $28.2 million reported on
page 14, and the remaining $112.8 million in capital expenditures
required during 2022 and 2023.
Given the definition of reasonable certainty in Rule 4-10(a)(24) of
Regulation S-X, tell us the probability that you would assign to
the likelihood of obtaining the needed financing and proceeding
with development as scheduled, and explain how you have considered
your five-year cumulative average rate of development being about
2%, rather than 20%, in formulating your view. Tell us how your
rationale for the current outlook differs from each of the past
five years, why your current development plans would be more
reliable than in the past, and describe any enhancements in your
ability to adhere to the plans.
RESPONSE:
We
acknowledge the Staff’s comment. Jones Walker LLP, our
outside counsel, has submitted under separate cover on electronic
media pursuant to a confidential treatment request under Rule 83
promulgated by the Commission, the development plans that we had
adopted for the proved reserves as of December 31, 2020, as
provided to our auditor and referenced in its report, and our full
year end December 31, 2020 reserves report prepared by Cawley,
Gillespie & Associates, our third party engineer. We have been
informed by our third party engineer that, in preparing its report,
it relied upon the development plan provided to our auditors and
other materials provided by PEDEVCO, information in our public
filings, our historical fundraising ability, and statements from
officers of PEDEVCO, rather than a single document evidencing
financing availability and development success. We have provided
the same materials provided to our third party engineer under the
separate cover letter and on electronic media.
PEDEVCO
believes that it has complied with Rules 4-10(a)(24) and
4-10(a)(26) by having a reasonable expectation that financing will
be available to develop all of the proved reserved within five
years of their initial booking.
We
maintain a five-year development plan that is updated and approved
annually and reviewed quarterly by our executive team and our
independent outside reserve engineering consultant with input from
our internal engineering and professional staff. During the annual
review of our development plan, if we determine, based upon
information that was not known when we made our final investment
decision, that a proved location is not reasonably certain to be
drilled within five years of initial booking, we remove that
location from our proved reserves. Our year end proved reserve
estimates are prepared by our independent reserve engineering firm,
Cawley, Gillespie & Associates. Cawley reviews the technical
merits, including financial, engineering and geological, of all
proved reserves in our development plan in connection with the
preparation of its reserve report to ensure compliance with the
Commission’s rules and regulations regarding proved
undeveloped reserve bookings.
In order to develop our proved reserves within
five years of their initial booking in 2018, we initially expected
costs of $200.4 million to develop 86 wells (excluding two water
facility upgrades) (the “2018
Wells”), as well as other
investments in proved developed non-producing assets to make them
productive.
In
2018 and 2019, we focused on delineating the New Mexico assets,
refining our development plan and planning full scale development
through 2023. In 2018 and 2019, we drilled nine of the 2018 Wells
in our development plan, making capital expenditures of $30.0
million in 2018 and $42.9 million in 2019.
In
2020, the COVID-19 pandemic substantially halted all development
efforts, although we made capital expenditures of $5.9
million.
At
the end of 2020, we revised our development plan to account for,
among other things, results of our delineation efforts and
technical work that provided us with updated type curves,
geological information and offset well performance. We also took
into account pricing changes and focused on wells with the highest
remaining oil in place.
Our revised development plan reduced the number of
2018 Wells planned to be developed to 33, all of which are planned
to be completed by 2023 (within five years of initial booking of
the 2018 Wells). Furthermore, at the end of 2019, we booked proved
undeveloped reserves associated with ten new wells (the
“2019
Wells”), which were
booked based on updated geological work and offset performance, all
of which are planned to be completed by 2024 (within five years of
initial booking of the 2019 Wells).
Under
our revised development plan, as reflected in the reserve report,
as of December 31, 2020 we plan to spend $131.4 million through
2024 to develop 43 wells (excluding two water facility upgrades),
all within five years of their respective initial
booking.
As reflected in PEDEVCO's reserve report and
consistent with its development plan, giving effect to offsetting
revenue (and deducting production taxes, ad valorem taxes,
operating expense and other costs and expenses), PEDEVCO’s
development plan results in cash used in the aggregate of
approximately $15.0 million through 2024. In addition to
development costs, PEDEVCO expects approximately $4.0 million
annually in general and administrative expenses
(“G&A”)
through 2024.
PEDEVCO believes that it has a reasonable
certainty, within the meaning of Rule 4-10(a)(24) of Regulation
S-X, of obtaining the financing and proceeding with development as
scheduled. PEDEVCO has a large portion of these funds currently
available through cash on hand ($19.2 million of the estimated
$31.0 million of development costs and G&A through 2024).
PEDEVCO believes it will be able to supplement cash on hand as
needed with asset sales, private and public offerings, credit
availability and financial support from SK Energy LLC, our majority
shareholder (“SK
Energy”).1 Each these financing sources, and the basis of
their availability, are discussed below:
●
Cash on
Hand: As of March 31, 2021,
PEDEVCO had cash on hand of $18.5 million, and, as of the date of
this letter has approximately $19.2 million currently on hand which
can be used for development purposes. Accordingly, a significant
portion ($19.2 million) of the expected $15.0 million (or $31.0
million including G&A) needed prior to 2024 is presently
available.
●
Asset
Sales: PEDEVCO has disposed of
assets in the ordinary course of business, the proceeds of which
can be used to fund development. For example, in March of 2019,
PEDEVCO received $1.2 million in cash proceeds from the sale of
certain oil and gas properties located in Colorado. Additionally,
in March 2021, PEDEVCO received $1.9 million in cash proceeds from
the sale of certain oil and gas assets located in
Colorado.
●
Private and
Public Securities Offerings:
PEDEVCO has demonstrated an ability to successfully engage in
private and public offerings of securities to raise proceeds. For
example, in May 2019 PEDEVCO raised $3.0 million through the
private issuance of common stock, in September 2019 PEDEVCO raised
$12.0 million through the private issuance of common stock, and in
February 2021 PEDEVCO raised $9.0 million through a public offering
of common stock.
______________
1 The future development costs of $141 million noted
by the Staff (rather than the immediately preceding amounts)
represent the discounted investment costs associated with our
proved reserves from 2021 through 2039, as reflected in the report
of our third party reserve engineer. This amount includes
expenditures beyond that necessary to develop our proved reserves,
such as plugging and abandonment costs, costs for rod pump
installations (expected in 2024 and 2025), and water facility
upgrades (expected in 2028).
●
Credit
Availability: While PEDEVCO
does not currently have a term loan or credit facility,
PEDEVCO’s assets are unencumbered, and as such, believes it
would be able to obtain a term loan or credit facility on
commercially reasonable terms. From time to time, members of
PEDEVCO’s management consult with financial institutions and
lenders regarding credit availability. While PEDEVCO has ultimately
determined not to seek financing at this time due to availability
of other financing sources, it believes it would be able to obtain
a reserve based credit facility or term loan that could be used for
development purposes with borrowing availability in the range of
$20 million to $30 million based on PEDEVCO’s current
producing asset base.
●
SK
Energy: SK Energy has a history
of financially sponsoring PEDEVCO. In June 2018, with the
assistance of SK Energy, PEDEVCO consummated a transformative debt
restructuring and management change wherein PEDEVCO satisfied
approximately $78.3 million in outstanding liabilities in exchange
for a $7.7 million convertible note investment made by SK
Energy. In connection with the
restructuring, SK Energy acquired over 50% ownership of PEDEVCO
through the purchase of Series A Preferred Stock held by a
creditor, which subsequently converted to common stock. SK Energy
subsequently converted the $7.7 million convertible note into
additional common stock in March 2019.
Subsequent
to the June 2018 debt restructuring and change in control, in
August 2018, PEDEVCO acquired its New Mexico assets for a cash
purchase price of $21.3 million, which was financed through the
issuance of $23.6 million in convertible notes (including $22.0
million purchased by SK Energy). In March 2019, all $23.6 million
of the convertible notes converted into common stock.
In
October 2018, PEDEVCO borrowed an additional $7.0 million from SK
Energy through the issuance of a convertible note, which was
converted into common stock in February 2019.
In
January 2019, PEDEVCO borrowed an additional $15.0 million from SK
Energy through the issuance of a convertible note, all of which was
converted into common stock in February 2019.
In
May 2019, PEDEVCO raised $15.0 million through the issuance of
common stock to SK Energy.
In
September 2019, PEDEVCO raised $13.0 million through the issuance
of common stock to SK Energy.
Accordingly,
PEDEVCO believes that cash on hand, supplemented as needed with
proceeds from asset sales, private and public offerings, credit
availability and financial sponsorship from SK Energy will be
sufficient to finance the future development of our proved reserves
in compliance with Rule 4-10(a)(26) of Regulation S-X. Moreover,
PEDEVCO calculates that the probability it would obtain needed
financing and proceed with the development of all of the proved
reserves that it booked within five years of their initial booking
is greater than 90%.
PEDEVCO
has considered its historical rate of development in formulating
its development plan, and is aware that its estimated development
rate for the remainder of 2021, 2022, 2023 and 2024 is higher than
its historical rate. PEDEVCO acquired its New Mexico asset in late
August 2018 and promptly commenced analysis for future development
on this new asset base. In 2018 and 2019, PEDEVCO focused on
delineating the New Mexico asset by drilling and completing nine
horizontal wells, refining its development plan and planning full
scale development through 2023. Accordingly, 2018 and 2019 saw a
lower development rate as PEDEVCO was seeking to better define the
asset and identify well sites for full development. In 2020, the
COVID-19 pandemic substantially halted all development efforts,
resulting in a lower development rate. PEDEVCO resumed development
efforts in late 2020 and early 2021, and is currently ramping up to
resume full field development commencing in late 2021 through 2024.
Accordingly, due to the circumstances above, PEDEVCO believes that
the rate of development over the remainder of 2021, as well as
2022, 2023 and 2024, will exceed historical rates.
3.
If you are able to support the requisite level of confidence,
explain how you propose to clarify the disclosures on pages 70 and
96, which appear to emphasize uncertainty as to whether you will
complete your development plans as scheduled, i.e. stating that you
"may choose to delay or extend the drilling program and associated
capital expenditures" if market conditions are not conducive,
indicating that you plan to convert the remaining undeveloped
reserves by 2025, rather than 2023, and the qualifier "...provided
that we are able to obtain adequate funding and capital over the
time period."
If your proved undeveloped reserves do not fully meet the
prescribed definitions referenced above, as well as Rule
4-10(a)(31) of Regulation S-X, please submit the revisions that
would be necessary to conform with these requirements, and address
the implications for impairment testing under FASB ASC 360-10-35-34
and FASB ASC 932-360-35.
To the extent that you are able to support the continued disclosure
of proved undeveloped reserves, you should also disclose the extent
of these reserves that are scheduled for development in each of the
next three years, along with the associated capital expenditures
for each period. We believe that you would need to describe the
reasons for any material deviations from your development plans in
subsequent reports, and address the implications for impairment
testing and reporting proved reserves.
RESPONSE:
We acknowledge the Staff’s
comment. These disclosures were
intended to reflect uncertainty about possible future changes in
circumstances and not uncertainty about drilling plans or adherence
to the definitions in Rule 4-10(a) of Regulation S-X. In future
filings, we will remove the language regarding uncertainty, and
will clarify that the proved undeveloped reserves are scheduled to
be developed within five years of their initial booking.
Furthermore, we confirm that at December 31, 2020, there were no
proved reserves scheduled for development beyond five years from
initial booking.
PEDEVCO
has not historically provided forward looking guidance on the
specific amount of reserves that are scheduled for development in
each upcoming year, nor has PEDEVCO provided specific dollar
amounts of capital expenditures by year, as we may increase or
decrease the actual amount of capital expenditures and development
pace from period to period (but not beyond five years from initial
booking) due to a variety of factors, such as commodity pricing and
development results.
In
future filings, PEDEVCO proposes to disclose the timeline
associated with development of its proved undeveloped reserves, and
the aggregate capital expenditures associated with that period, in
the following format:
“We expect to spend an aggregate of
$
developing proved undeveloped reserves through December 31,
[2024] 2. All proved
undeveloped reserves are scheduled to be developed within five
years of initial booking. We expect to fund these development costs
with cash from operations and cash on hand, supplemented as needed
by proceeds from asset sales, private and public offerings, credit
availability and financial sponsorship from SK
Energy.”
In the event there are any material deviations
from our development plans, we will describe the reasons for the
deviations and the implications for impairment testing and
reporting of proved reserves.
*
*
*
*
*
If
you have any questions concerning our response, please contact me
at (713) 221-1768.
|
|
|
Very
truly yours,
|
|
PEDEVCO
Corp.
|
|
|
By:
|
|
/s/
Paul Pinkston
|
Name:
|
|
Paul
Pinkston
|
Title:
|
|
Principal
Financial Officer
|
cc:
Karl Hiller (U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission)
Doug Schick
(PEDEVCO Corp.)
Clark Moore
(PEDEVCO Corp.)
Arvind
Krishna (PEDEVCO Corp.)
Audit
Committee of PEDEVCO Corp.
Todd
Brooker (Cawley, Gillespie &
Associates)
David
Grossman (Marcum LLP)
David
Dyer (Marcum LLP)
Clint
Smith (Jones Walker LLP)
______________
2 Date to reflect three-year period going
forward.