HILLMAN VALUE FUND
Vote Summary
|
||||||||||||||||
THE KRAFT HEINZ COMPANY
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
500754106
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
KHC
|
Meeting Date
|
12-Sep-2019
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
15-Jul-2019
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1a.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1b.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1c.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1d.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1e.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1f.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1g.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1h.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1i.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1j.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1k.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Health Issues
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Environmental
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
GENERAL MILLS, INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
370334104
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
GIS
|
Meeting Date
|
24-Sep-2019
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
26-Jul-2019
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
LAM RESEARCH CORPORATION
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
512807108
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
LRCX
|
Meeting Date
|
05-Nov-2019
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
06-Sep-2019
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1.
|
Election of Directors
|
Management
|
||||||||||||||
1
|
Sohail U. Ahmed
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
2
|
Timothy M. Archer
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
3
|
Eric K. Brandt
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
4
|
Michael R. Cannon
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
5
|
Youssef A. El-Mansy
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
6
|
Catherine P. Lego
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
7
|
Bethany J. Mayer
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
8
|
Abhijit Y. Talwalkar
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
9
|
Lih Shyng (Rick L) Tsai
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
10
|
Leslie F. Varon
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
MICROSOFT CORPORATION
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
594918104
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
MSFT
|
Meeting Date
|
04-Dec-2019
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
08-Oct-2019
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mtg. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1M.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Gender Pay Equality
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
MEDTRONIC PLC
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
G5960L103
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
MDT
|
Meeting Date
|
06-Dec-2019
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
10-Oct-2019
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
Stock Issuance
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
Eliminate Pre-Emptive Rights
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
Authorize Directors to Repurchase Shares
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
EMERSON ELECTRIC CO.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
291011104
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
EMR
|
Meeting Date
|
04-Feb-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
26-Nov-2019
|
|
||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1.
|
Election of Directors
|
Management
|
||||||||||||||
1
|
M. S. Craighead
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
2
|
D. N. Farr
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
3
|
G. A. Flach
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
4
|
M. S. Levatich
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
Declassify Board
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
BANK OF AMERICA CORPORATION
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
060505104
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
BAC
|
Meeting Date
|
22-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
02-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1M.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1N.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1O.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1P.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1Q.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Create a Non-Discriminatory Sexual Orientation Policy
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
7.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
PFIZER INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
717081103
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
PFE
|
Meeting Date
|
23-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
25-Feb-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1M.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Shareholders be Given Access to Proxy
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Political/Government
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
7.
|
S/H Proposal - Establish Independent Chairman
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
8.
|
S/H Proposal - Gender Pay Gap
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
9.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
AT&T INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
00206R102
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
T
|
Meeting Date
|
24-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
26-Feb-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1M.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Establish Independent Chairman
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
KELLOGG COMPANY
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
487836108
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
K
|
Meeting Date
|
24-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
28-Feb-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
Amend Employee Stock Purchase Plan
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
Declassify Board
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Election of Directors By Majority Vote
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Supermajority vote requirements can act as impediments to takeover proposals and impede shareholders' ability to approve ballot items that are in their interests
|
||||||||||||||||
WELLS FARGO & COMPANY
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
949746101
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
WFC
|
Meeting Date
|
28-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
28-Feb-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Increase Disclosure of Executive Compensation
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Create a Non-Discriminatory Sexual Orientation Policy
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
ANHEUSER-BUSCH INBEV SA
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
03524A108
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
BUD
|
Meeting Date
|
29-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
20-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A
|
Approve Article Amendments
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B
|
Approve Article Amendments
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C
|
Approve Article Amendments
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5
|
Receive Consolidated Financial Statements
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
6
|
Director Removal Without Cause
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
7
|
Director Removal Without Cause
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
8A
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
8B
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
8C
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8D
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8E
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8F
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8G
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8H
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8I
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8J
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8K
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
9
|
Approve Remuneration of Directors and Auditors
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: LTI awards are not performance based; Poor overall compensation disclosure; Poor response to prior year dissent
|
||||||||||||||||
10
|
Miscellaneous Corporate Actions
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
38141G104
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
GS
|
Meeting Date
|
30-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
02-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Shareholder action by written consent enables shareholders to take action on important issues that arise between annual meetings
|
||||||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB COMPANY
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
110122108
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
BMY
|
Meeting Date
|
05-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
16-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Separate Chairman/Coe
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Shareholder action by written consent enables shareholders to take action on important issues that arise between annual meetings
|
||||||||||||||||
VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
92343V104
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
VZ
|
Meeting Date
|
07-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
09-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1a.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1b.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1c.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1d.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1e.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1f.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1g.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1h.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1i.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: A 10% threshold for calling a special meeting is appropriate
|
||||||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Political/Government
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
7.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
8.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
THE KRAFT HEINZ COMPANY
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
500754106
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
KHC
|
Meeting Date
|
07-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
09-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Concerning pay practices
|
||||||||||||||||
3.
|
Adopt Omnibus Stock Option Plan
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Supermajority vote requirements can act as impediments to shareholders being able to approve ballot items that are in their interests
|
SIMON PROPERTY GROUP, INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
828806109
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
SPG
|
Meeting Date
|
12-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
16-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1a.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1b.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1c.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1d.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1e.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1f.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1g.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1h.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1i.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1j.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
LABORATORY CORP. OF AMERICA HOLDINGS
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
50540R409
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
LH
|
Meeting Date
|
13-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
25-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: A 10% threshold for calling a special meeting is appropriate
|
||||||||||||||||
COMPASS MINERALS INTERNATIONAL, INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
20451N101
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
CMP
|
Meeting Date
|
14-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
16-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1.
|
Eliminate Supermajority Requirements
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Pay and performance disconnect
|
||||||||||||||||
4.
|
Approve Stock Compensation Plan
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
INTEL CORPORATION
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
458140100
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
INTC
|
Meeting Date
|
14-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
16-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
Amend Employee Stock Purchase Plan
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Create a Non-Discriminatory Sexual Orientation Policy
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
CVS HEALTH CORPORATION
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
126650100
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
CVS
|
Meeting Date
|
14-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
18-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1M.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Concerning pay practices
|
||||||||||||||||
4.
|
Approve Stock Compensation Plan
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
Amend Employee Stock Purchase Plan
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: The Company's 25% ownership threshold is too high to provide shareholders with a meaningful right to action by written consent
|
||||||||||||||||
7.
|
S/H Proposal - Establish Independent Chairman
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
NORDSTROM, INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
655664100
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
JWN
|
Meeting Date
|
20-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
11-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
Amend Stock Compensation Plan
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Minimum equity overhang of all plans, including this proposal, as a percentage of outstanding common stock, is 23.70%.
|
||||||||||||||||
5.
|
Amend Employee Stock Purchase Plan
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
PLAINS ALL AMERICAN PIPELINE, L.P.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
726503105
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
PAA
|
Meeting Date
|
20-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
23-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1.
|
Election of Directors
|
Management
|
||||||||||||||
1
|
Alexandra Pruner
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
2
|
Lawrence Ziemba
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Concerning pay practices
|
MCDONALD'S CORPORATION
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
580135101
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
MCD
|
Meeting Date
|
21-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
23-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Former CEO's equity treatment upon separation
|
||||||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
Amend Omnibus Stock Option Plan
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: A 15% threshold for calling a special meeting is appropriate
|
||||||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Environmental
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
STERICYCLE, INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
858912108
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
SRCL
|
Meeting Date
|
22-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
27-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1a.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1b.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1c.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1d.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1e.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1f.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1g.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1h.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1i.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1j.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1k.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1l.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Amend Employee Stock Purchase Plan
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: A 15% threshold for calling a special meeting is appropriate
|
||||||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Expanding the Company's clawback policy could protect shareholder interests
|
||||||||||||||||
MERCK & CO., INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
58933Y105
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
MRK
|
Meeting Date
|
26-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
27-Mar-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1M.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
EXXON MOBIL CORPORATION
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
30231G102
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
XOM
|
Meeting Date
|
27-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
02-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type |
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Establish Independent Chairman
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Environmental
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
7.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Additional disclosure concerning climate change-related risks is warranted
|
||||||||||||||||
8.
|
S/H Proposal - Political/Government
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
9.
|
S/H Proposal - Political/Government
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
FACEBOOK, INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
30303M102
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
FB
|
Meeting Date
|
27-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
03-Apr-2020
|
|
||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1.
|
Election of Directors
|
Management
|
||||||||||||||
1
|
Peggy Alford
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
2
|
Marc L. Andreessen
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
3
|
Andrew W. Houston
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
4
|
Nancy Killefer
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
5
|
Robert M. Kimmitt
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
6
|
Sheryl K. Sandberg
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
7
|
Peter A. Thiel
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
8
|
Tracey T. Travis
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
9
|
Mark Zuckerberg
|
For
|
For
|
|||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Miscellaneous Compensation Plans
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Allowing one vote per share generally operates as a safeguard for common shareholders
|
||||||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Establish Independent Chairman
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Election of Directors By Majority Vote
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Majority voting increases board accountability and performance
|
||||||||||||||||
7.
|
S/H Proposal - Political/Government
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Additional disclosure concerning how the Company is managing political advertising is warranted
|
||||||||||||||||
8.
|
S/H Proposal - Human Rights Related
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Adoption of proposal would promote board independence and enhanced oversight of human rights
|
||||||||||||||||
9.
|
S/H Proposal - Human Rights Related
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Additional reporting concerning human rights-related oversight is warranted
|
||||||||||||||||
10.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Increased disclosure will provide shareholders assurance that the Company is managing associated risks as it grows its encrypted messaging services
|
||||||||||||||||
11.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Increased disclosure would allow shareholders to fully understand the steps the Company is taking to ensure equitable compensation
|
DUPONT DE NEMOURS INC
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
26614N102
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
DD
|
Meeting Date
|
27-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
06-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
Approve Stock Compensation Plan
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: A 10% threshold for calling a special meeting is appropriate
|
||||||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
AMAZON.COM, INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
023135106
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
AMZN
|
Meeting Date
|
27-May-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
02-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item |
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
4.
|
Approve Charter Amendment
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: A 20% special meeting threshold as proposed in Proposal 14 is preferable to 25%
|
||||||||||||||||
5.
|
S/H Proposal - Adopt Conservation Policy
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
6.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: An assessment of the Company's customer due diligence could benefit shareholders
|
||||||||||||||||
7.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Additional disclosure on the financial and operational risks associated with the use of Rekognition would benefit shareholders
|
||||||||||||||||
8.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Additional disclosure on the Company's efforts to address hate speech and the sale of offensive products is warranted
|
||||||||||||||||
9.
|
S/H Proposal - Establish Independent Chairman
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
10.
|
S/H Proposal - Create a Non-Discriminatory Sexual Orientation Policy
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
11.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
12.
|
S/H Proposal - Create a Non-Discriminatory Sexual Orientation Policy
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
13.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Production of requested report would give shareholders critical information concerning the Company's management of diversity-related issues
|
||||||||||||||||
14.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
For
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
Comments: A 20% special meeting threshold is preferable to the 25% proposed by the Company
|
||||||||||||||||
15.
|
S/H Proposal - Corporate Governance
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
||||||||||||
16.
|
S/H Proposal - Political/Government
|
Shareholder
|
Against
|
Against
|
BIOGEN INC.
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
09062X103
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
BIIB
|
Meeting Date
|
03-Jun-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
06-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1D.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1E.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1F.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1G.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1H.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1I.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1J.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1K.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1L.
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
2.
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
3.
|
14A Executive Compensation
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
ANHEUSER-BUSCH INBEV SA
|
||||||||||||||||
Security
|
03524A108
|
Meeting Type
|
Annual
|
|||||||||||||
Ticker Symbol
|
BUD
|
Meeting Date
|
03-Jun-2020
|
|||||||||||||
Record Date
|
27-Apr-2020
|
|||||||||||||||
Item
|
Proposal
|
Type
|
Vote
|
Mgt. Rec
|
||||||||||||
1A
|
Approve Article Amendments
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1B
|
Approve Article Amendments
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
1C
|
Approve Article Amendments
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
5
|
Ratify Appointment of Independent Auditors
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
6
|
Director Removal Without Cause
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
7
|
Miscellaneous Corporate Actions
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
8A
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
8B
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
||||||||||||
8C
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8D
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8E
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8F
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8G
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8H
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8I
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8J
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
8K
|
Election of Directors (Majority Voting)
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: Board is not majority independent.
|
||||||||||||||||
9
|
Approve Remuneration of Directors and Auditors
|
Management
|
Against
|
For
|
||||||||||||
Comments: LTI awards are not performance based; Poor overall compensation disclosure; Poor response to prior year dissent
|
||||||||||||||||
10
|
Miscellaneous Corporate Actions
|
Management
|
For
|
For
|
Hillman Capital Management Investment Trust
|
|
/s/ Mark A. Hillman
|
|
By:
|
Mark A. Hillman
President and Principal Executive Officer
|
Date:
|
July 29, 2020
|