EX-99.23 (C) 5 mva1_71119ex23c.txt OPINION AND CONSENT OF BRIAN A. GIANTONIO EXHIBIT 23.(c) CONSENT OF BRIAN A. GIANTONIO, ESQ. To Whom It May Concern: As Counsel to the Registrant, I am familiar with the Market Value Adjustment ("MVA") investment options that are offered under the variable annuity contracts (the "Contracts") and registered on Form S-1. In connection with this opinion, I have reviewed the Registration Statement and the provisions of federal income tax laws relevant to the issuance of Contracts with the MVA investment options. Based upon this review, I am of the opinion that each of the Contracts, when issued with the MVA investment options will have been validly and legally issued. I hereby consent to the reference to my name under the caption "Legal Matters" in the Prospectus contained in this Registration Statement on Form S-1(Post-Effective Amendment POS AM) filed by Separate Account MVA1 with the Securities and Exchange Commission under the Securities Act of 1933. Very truly yours, Dated: April 19, 2005 /s/ Brian A. Giantonio ---------------------- Brian A. Giantonio, Vice President, Tax and ERISA Counsel PHL Variable Insurance Company